SOLVER7 Study. Nothing Else.
Chapter 8 Examples Q13

Do the following two statements mean the same thing\(?\)
(i) The population of this state in \(1991\) is \(165\%\) of that in \(1961.\)
(ii) The population of this state has increased by \(65\%\) from \(1961\) to \(1991.\)

CBSE Class 8 Maths · Fractions In Disguise

Solution

👶 Simple Explanation

Simple Explanation

Imagine you have 100 chocolates. Someone gives you 65 more chocolates. Now you have 165 chocolates total. That is the same as saying you have 165 out of every 100, or \( 165\% \) of what you started with. So saying 'increased by \( 65\% \)' and saying 'is \( 165\% \) of the original' are just two ways of describing the same pile of chocolates. Both statements point to the exact same amount.

Answer: Yes, the two statements mean the same thing, because increasing a quantity by \( 65\% \) makes it \( 100\% + 65\% = 165\% \) of the original.

📖 Comparing Percentage Statements

Detailed Explanation

In percentage problems, we must read the wording very carefully. Saying a quantity is \( 165\% \) OF an old value means the new value equals the whole old value plus something extra. Saying a quantity INCREASED BY \( 65\% \) means we add \( 65\% \) of the old value on top of the original \( 100\% \). If we start with any base value and call it \( 100\% \), then increasing it by \( 65\% \) gives \( 100\% + 65\% = 165\% \). So both statements describe the same final amount, just in two different ways.

Formula Used

\[ \text{New value as percent} = 100\% + (\text{percent increase}) \]

Solution

  1. Step 1: Treat the population in 1961 as the base value and call it \( 100\% \). This is our starting point for comparison.
  2. Step 2: Read statement (i): the 1991 population is \( 165\% \) of the 1961 population. So the new value equals \( 165\% \) of the base value.
  3. Step 3: Read statement (ii): the population increased by \( 65\% \) from 1961 to 1991. An increase means we add the extra part to the original whole.
  4. Step 4: Convert the increase into a total percentage. Starting from the base \( 100\% \) and adding an increase of \( 65\% \) gives \[ 100\% + 65\% = 165\% \]
  5. Step 5: Compare the two results. Statement (i) gives \( 165\% \) of the 1961 value, and statement (ii) also gives \( 165\% \) of the 1961 value. Both point to the same final amount.

Final Answer

Yes, the two statements mean the same thing, because increasing a quantity by \( 65\% \) makes it \( 100\% + 65\% = 165\% \) of the original.

Common Mistake

A common mistake is to think 'increased by \( 65\% \)' means the new value is only \( 65\% \) of the old value. Students forget to add the original \( 100\% \), so they wrongly conclude the two statements are different.

🪜 Step-by-step Solution

Step-by-step Solution

  1. Step 1: Assign the 1961 population as the base and label it \( 100\% \). — Reason: Treating the starting value as \( 100\% \) gives us a reference point so both statements can be compared on the same scale.
  2. Step 2: Examine Statement (i): the 1991 population is \( 165\% \) of the 1961 population. This directly tells us the new value is \( 165\% \) of the base. — Reason: The phrase '165% of' means we take the old value and express the new value as that fraction of it.
  3. Step 3: Examine Statement (ii): the population increased by \( 65\% \) from 1961 to 1991. An increase means the original whole is still there, and the extra part is added on top. — Reason: The word 'increased by' tells us \( 65\% \) is only the extra portion; the original \( 100\% \) must also be counted.
  4. Step 4: Convert Statement (ii) into a total percentage by adding the increase to the original base: \[ 100\% + 65\% = 165\% \] — Reason: Since the base is \( 100\% \) and we add \( 65\% \) on top, the combined result gives the new value as a percentage of the original.
  5. Step 5: Compare the two results: Statement (i) gives \( 165\% \) of the 1961 value, and Statement (ii) also gives \( 165\% \) of the 1961 value. Both expressions point to the identical final amount. — Reason: Since both statements produce the same percentage of the original, they are equivalent in meaning.

Final Answer

Yes, the two statements mean the same thing, because increasing a quantity by \( 65\% \) makes it \( 100\% + 65\% = 165\% \) of the original.

Common Mistake

One common mistake: Students forget that 'increased by 65%' still includes the original 100%, and they treat the new value as just 65% of the old value instead of 165%.

✍️ Exam-ready Answer

Exam-ready Answer

  1. Step 1: Statement (i): 1991 population = \( 165\% \) of 1961 population.
  2. Step 2: Statement (ii): population increased by \( 65\% \), so total = \[ 100\% + 65\% = 165\% \]
  3. Step 3: Both statements give \( 165\% \) of the 1961 value. The two statements are equivalent.

Answer: Yes, the two statements mean the same thing, because increasing a quantity by \( 65\% \) makes it \( 100\% + 65\% = 165\% \) of the original.

➕ More Examples

More Examples

Example 1

Question: Do the following two statements mean the same thing? (i) The number of students enrolled in a school in 2020 is 240% of the number enrolled in 2000. (ii) The number of students enrolled in the school has increased by 240% from 2000 to 2020. Justify your answer.

Solution: Let the number of students enrolled in 2000 be S. Statement (i) says the enrollment in 2020 is 240% of S. So the enrollment in 2020 is: \[ \frac{240}{100} \times S = 2.4S \] The increase in enrollment = New enrollment - Original enrollment: \[ 2.4S - S = 1.4S \] Percentage increase: \[ \frac{1.4S}{S} \times 100 = 140\% \] So Statement (i) means the enrollment increased by 140%. Statement (ii) says the enrollment increased by 240%. If the increase is 240%, the new enrollment would be: \[ S + \frac{240}{100} \times S = S + 2.4S = 3.4S \] This is 340% of the original enrollment. Since Statement (i) corresponds to a 140% increase, while Statement (ii) corresponds to a 240% increase, the two statements do NOT mean the same thing.

Answer: No, the two statements do not mean the same thing. Statement (i) implies a 140% increase, whereas Statement (ii) implies a 240% increase.

Example 2

Question: Do the following two statements mean the same thing? (i) The monthly salary of a worker in 2023 has increased by 75% compared to his salary in 2015. (ii) The monthly salary of the worker in 2023 is 175% of his salary in 2015. Justify your answer.

Solution: Let the monthly salary of the worker in 2015 be W. Statement (i) says the salary increased by 75%. So the increase in salary is: \[ \frac{75}{100} \times W = 0.75W \] The salary in 2023 as per Statement (i): \[ W + 0.75W = 1.75W \] Expressing this as a percentage of the 2015 salary: \[ \frac{1.75W}{W} \times 100 = 175\% \] So Statement (i) says the 2023 salary is 175% of the 2015 salary. Statement (ii) directly says the 2023 salary is 175% of the 2015 salary: \[ \frac{175}{100} \times W = 1.75W \] The increase as per Statement (ii): \[ 1.75W - W = 0.75W \] Percentage increase: \[ \frac{0.75W}{W} \times 100 = 75\% \] Both statements describe exactly the same situation: a 75% increase, making the new salary 175% of the original.

Answer: Yes, both statements mean the same thing. A 75% increase means the new salary is 175% of the original, and 175% of the original means the salary increased by 75%.

🎯 Try a Similar Question

Try a Similar Question

Question: Do the following two statements mean the same thing? Give a reason for your answer. (i) The number of students enrolled in a school in 2020 is 240% of that in 2000. (ii) The number of students enrolled in the school has increased by 140% from 2000 to 2020.

Solution

  1. Step 1: Interpret Statement (i): Statement (i) says the enrollment in 2020 is 240% of the enrollment in 2000. If the enrollment in 2000 is taken as the base (100%), then the enrollment in 2020 equals \( 240\% \) of the original.
  2. Step 2: Interpret Statement (ii): Statement (ii) says the enrollment has increased by 140% from 2000 to 2020. An increase of \( 140\% \) on top of the original \( 100\% \) gives a new value of \[ 100\% + 140\% = 240\% \] of the original.
  3. Step 3: Verify with a numerical example: Let the enrollment in 2000 be 500 students. According to Statement (i), enrollment in 2020 \( = 240\% \) of 500 \[ = \frac{240}{100} \times 500 = 1200 \] According to Statement (ii), increase \( = 140\% \) of 500 \[ = \frac{140}{100} \times 500 = 700 \] So the new enrollment \( = 500 + 700 = 1200 \). Both statements give the same result of 1200 students.
  4. Step 4: Conclusion: Since increasing a quantity by \( 140\% \) always makes the new value \( 100\% + 140\% = 240\% \) of the original, the two statements mean the same thing.

Answer: No, wait — they DO mean the same thing. An increase of \( 140\% \) over the original gives \( 100\% + 140\% = 240\% \) of the original, which is exactly what Statement (i) says. So both statements convey identical information.

Everything you get with Solver7

More questions in Fractions In Disguise