SOLVER7 Study. Nothing Else.
Chapter 8 Examples Q4

Madhu and Madhav each ate biscuits of a different variety. Madhu’s biscuits had \(25\%\) sugar, while Madhav’s had \(35\%\) sugar. Can you tell who ate more sugar\(?\)

CBSE Class 8 Maths · Fractions In Disguise

Solution

👶 Simple Explanation

Simple Explanation

Think of juice concentrate. One bottle might be stronger, but if you pour only a tiny bit, you still get less juice than a weak bottle poured fully. Percentage tells us only how sugary each biscuit type is, not how much was eaten. Madhu's biscuits had less sugar per 100 grams, but maybe she ate a huge packet. Madhav's biscuits were sweeter, but maybe he ate just a few. Without knowing the actual weight of biscuits each person ate, we simply cannot say who ate more sugar overall.

Answer: No, we cannot tell who ate more sugar. The percentages only tell us the concentration of sugar in each variety. To know the actual amount of sugar eaten, we also need to know how much biscuit each person ate, which is not given.

📖 Comparing Sugar in Two Biscuits Using Percentage

Detailed Explanation

A percentage tells us how much of something there is out of every 100 parts. When we say Madhu's biscuits had \( 25\% \) sugar, it means for every 100 grams of biscuit, 25 grams is sugar. Similarly, Madhav's \( 35\% \) sugar means 35 grams of sugar in every 100 grams of biscuit. But the actual amount of sugar eaten depends on TWO things: the percentage of sugar AND the total weight of biscuits eaten. Since we are not told how many grams of biscuits each person ate, we only know the concentration of sugar, not the actual amount. So a higher percentage does not automatically mean more sugar was eaten.

Formula Used

\( \text{Amount of sugar} = \text{percentage} \times \text{total weight of biscuits} \), where \( x\% = \frac{x}{100} \)

Solution

  1. Step 1: Understand what the percentages mean. Madhu's biscuits contain \( 25\% = \frac{25}{100} \) sugar, and Madhav's biscuits contain \( 35\% = \frac{35}{100} \) sugar. This is the fraction of sugar in each biscuit, not the actual amount eaten.
  2. Step 2: Recall the formula for the actual amount of sugar. \[ \text{Sugar eaten} = \frac{\text{percentage}}{100} \times \text{weight of biscuits eaten} \] This shows we need the weight of biscuits to find the real amount of sugar.
  3. Step 3: Check the given information. The question tells us only the percentage of sugar in each variety. It does NOT tell us how many grams of biscuits Madhu ate or how many grams Madhav ate. Without the weights, we cannot calculate the actual sugar amounts.
  4. Step 4: See it with an example. Suppose Madhu ate 200 g of biscuits and Madhav ate only 100 g. Then Madhu's sugar is \( \frac{25}{100} \times 200 = 50 \) g, while Madhav's sugar is \( \frac{35}{100} \times 100 = 35 \) g. Here Madhu ate MORE sugar even though her biscuits had a lower percentage. So the answer changes depending on the amounts eaten.
  5. Step 5: Conclude. Since the total weight of biscuits eaten by each person is unknown, we cannot decide who ate more sugar. A higher percentage alone does not guarantee more sugar.

Final Answer

No, we cannot tell who ate more sugar. The percentages only tell us the concentration of sugar in each variety. To know the actual amount of sugar eaten, we also need to know how much biscuit each person ate, which is not given.

Common Mistake

A common mistake is to conclude straight away that Madhav ate more sugar just because his biscuits had \( 35\% \) sugar. This ignores that the actual sugar depends on the total weight of biscuits eaten, which is not given.

🪜 Step-by-step Solution

Step-by-step Solution

  1. Step 1: Identify what the percentages actually represent. Madhu's biscuits have \( 25\% \) sugar, meaning \( \frac{25}{100} \) of every 100 g is sugar. Madhav's biscuits have \( 35\% \) sugar, meaning \( \frac{35}{100} \) of every 100 g is sugar. — Reason: Understanding what a percentage means helps us see it is a rate (sugar per 100 g), not an actual quantity of sugar.
  2. Step 2: Write the formula for the actual amount of sugar eaten. \[ \text{Sugar eaten} = \frac{\text{Percentage}}{100} \times \text{Weight of biscuits eaten} \] — Reason: This formula shows that two pieces of information are always needed — the percentage and the total weight of biscuits eaten — before we can find the real quantity of sugar.
  3. Step 3: Apply the formula to Madhu. If Madhu ate \( W_1 \) grams of biscuits, then \[ \text{Madhu's sugar} = \frac{25}{100} \times W_1 \] — Reason: We set up Madhu's sugar in terms of an unknown weight \( W_1 \), since the problem does not give us this value.
  4. Step 4: Apply the formula to Madhav. If Madhav ate \( W_2 \) grams of biscuits, then \[ \text{Madhav's sugar} = \frac{35}{100} \times W_2 \] — Reason: Similarly, Madhav's actual sugar depends on his unknown weight \( W_2 \), which the problem does not provide.
  5. Step 5: Check what information is missing. The problem gives us only the percentages (\( 25\% \) and \( 35\% \)), but neither \( W_1 \) nor \( W_2 \) is given. — Reason: Without the weights, both expressions remain unknown, so no comparison is possible.
  6. Step 6: Consider a quick example to confirm. Suppose Madhu ate 200 g of biscuits and Madhav ate only 50 g. Then Madhu's sugar \( = \frac{25}{100} \times 200 = 50 \) g, and Madhav's sugar \( = \frac{35}{100} \times 50 = 17.5 \) g. Madhu ate more sugar despite having the lower percentage. — Reason: This example shows that a higher percentage does not guarantee a larger actual amount of sugar eaten; the weight of biscuits matters just as much.
  7. Step 7: Draw the conclusion. Since the weights \( W_1 \) and \( W_2 \) are both unknown, the expressions \( \frac{25}{100} \times W_1 \) and \( \frac{35}{100} \times W_2 \) cannot be evaluated or compared. — Reason: Any comparison would require actual numbers for both weights, and the problem simply does not provide them.

Final Answer

No, we cannot tell who ate more sugar. The percentages only tell us the concentration of sugar in each variety. To know the actual amount of sugar eaten, we also need to know how much biscuit each person ate, which is not given.

Common Mistake

One common mistake: Students assume that a higher sugar percentage (35% vs 25%) automatically means more sugar was eaten. This ignores the fact that the actual sugar quantity also depends on the total weight of biscuits consumed — if the person with the lower percentage ate a much larger quantity of biscuits, they could have eaten more sugar overall.

✍️ Exam-ready Answer

Exam-ready Answer

  1. Step 1: Madhu's biscuits: \( 25\% = \frac{25}{100} \) sugar per 100 g; Madhav's biscuits: \( 35\% = \frac{35}{100} \) sugar per 100 g.
  2. Step 2: Actual sugar eaten depends on both the percentage and the total weight of biscuits consumed by each person.
  3. Step 3: Weight of biscuits eaten by Madhu and Madhav: not given. Without weights, actual sugar amounts cannot be calculated.

Answer: No, we cannot tell who ate more sugar. The percentages only tell us the concentration of sugar in each variety. To know the actual amount of sugar eaten, we also need to know how much biscuit each person ate, which is not given.

➕ More Examples

More Examples

Example 1

Question: Riya and Rohan each bought a bag of trail mix. Riya's bag weighed 400 g and contained 30% nuts. Rohan's bag weighed 250 g and contained 48% nuts. Who actually had more nuts in their bag?

Solution: We find the actual weight of nuts in each bag. For Riya: her bag is 400 g with 30% nuts. Nuts in Riya's bag = \(\frac{30}{100} \times 400\) \[= \frac{30 \times 400}{100} = \frac{12000}{100} = 120 \text{ g}\] For Rohan: his bag is 250 g with 48% nuts. Nuts in Rohan's bag = \(\frac{48}{100} \times 250\) \[= \frac{48 \times 250}{100} = \frac{12000}{100} = 120 \text{ g}\] Both have exactly 120 g of nuts. So the actual weight of nuts in both bags is equal, even though the percentages are different.

Answer: Both Riya and Rohan have the same amount of nuts: 120 g each.

Example 2

Question: A school organised a sports day. Class 8A has 40 students, of whom 45% participated in at least one event. Class 8B has 60 students, of whom 35% participated in at least one event. Which class had more students who participated?

Solution: We calculate the actual number of participating students in each class. For Class 8A: 40 students, 45% participated. Participants from 8A = \(\frac{45}{100} \times 40\) \[= \frac{45 \times 40}{100} = \frac{1800}{100} = 18 \text{ students}\] For Class 8B: 60 students, 35% participated. Participants from 8B = \(\frac{35}{100} \times 60\) \[= \frac{35 \times 60}{100} = \frac{2100}{100} = 21 \text{ students}\] Comparing: 8A had 18 participants and 8B had 21 participants. Since \(21 > 18\), Class 8B had more participating students.

Answer: Class 8B had more participants: 21 students, compared to 18 students from Class 8A.

🎯 Try a Similar Question

Try a Similar Question

Question: Priya and Preet each drank a glass of juice of a different brand. Priya's juice contained \( 40\% \) real fruit content, while Preet's juice contained \( 55\% \) real fruit content. Priya drank 300 mL of her juice, while Preet drank 180 mL of his juice. Who consumed more actual fruit content?

Solution

  1. Step 1: Identify the given information: Priya's juice: \( 40\% \) fruit content, volume = 300 mL. Preet's juice: \( 55\% \) fruit content, volume = 180 mL. Here, both the percentage and the total quantity are given, so we can find the actual fruit content for each person.
  2. Step 2: Calculate the actual fruit content consumed by Priya: Actual fruit content consumed by Priya is \( \frac{40}{100} \times 300 \) mL. Calculating: \( \frac{40}{100} \times 300 = 0.40 \times 300 = 120 \) mL.
  3. Step 3: Calculate the actual fruit content consumed by Preet: Actual fruit content consumed by Preet is \( \frac{55}{100} \times 180 \) mL. Calculating: \( \frac{55}{100} \times 180 = 0.55 \times 180 = 99 \) mL.
  4. Step 4: Compare the two amounts: Priya consumed 120 mL of actual fruit content and Preet consumed 99 mL. Since \( 120 > 99 \), Priya consumed more actual fruit content, even though Preet's juice had a higher percentage of fruit content.
  5. Step 5: State the conclusion: Priya consumed more actual fruit content (120 mL) compared to Preet (99 mL). This shows that a higher percentage does not always mean a greater actual amount — the total quantity also matters.

Answer: Priya consumed more actual fruit content: 120 mL compared to Preet's 99 mL. Even though Preet's juice had a higher percentage of fruit (\( 55\% \) vs \( 40\% \)), Priya drank a larger volume of juice, resulting in a greater actual amount of fruit content.

Everything you get with Solver7

More questions in Fractions In Disguise