Detailed Explanation
The key idea is that percentages are always taken on different base amounts, so a 50% profit and a 50% discount are NOT taken on the same number. Surbhi first buys at the cost price (CP). She adds 50% profit to this CP to fix her marked price (MP). Later, she gives a 50% discount on the MARKED PRICE, not on the cost price. Because the marked price is larger than the cost price, taking 50% off the marked price removes more money than the 50% she had added earlier. So the selling price ends up below the cost price, which means she actually makes a loss.
Formula Used
\( \text{Marked Price} = \text{CP} + (\text{Profit}\% \text{ of CP}) \) and \( \text{Selling Price} = \text{MP} - (\text{Discount}\% \text{ of MP}) \)
Solution
- Step 1: Take a convenient cost price to test the claim. Let the cost price of a product be \( \text{CP} = 100 \) rupees. Using \( 100 \) makes percentage calculations easy.
- Step 2: Add the 50% profit margin to the cost price to get the marked price. Profit \( = 50\% \text{ of } 100 = \frac{50}{100} \times 100 = 50 \). So the marked price is \[ \text{MP} = 100 + 50 = 150. \]
- Step 3: Now apply the 50% discount. Notice the discount is taken on the marked price \( 150 \), NOT on the cost price \( 100 \). Discount \( = 50\% \text{ of } 150 = \frac{50}{100} \times 150 = 75 \).
- Step 4: Find the selling price after discount. \[ \text{SP} = 150 - 75 = 75. \]
- Step 5: Compare the selling price with the cost price. Here \( \text{SP} = 75 \) but \( \text{CP} = 100 \). Since \( 75 < 100 \), she sells below cost, so there is a loss. Loss \( = 100 - 75 = 25 \).
- Step 6: Express the loss as a percentage of the cost price. \[ \text{Loss}\% = \frac{25}{100} \times 100 = 25\%. \] This same 25% loss will happen for every product, whatever its cost price is.
Final Answer
No, Surbhi is not correct. A 50% profit followed by a 50% discount does not cancel out because the discount is taken on the larger marked price. She actually suffers a loss of 25% on the cost price.
Common Mistake
Students often assume a 50% profit and a 50% discount cancel each other. They forget that the profit is calculated on the cost price while the discount is calculated on the (larger) marked price, so the two 50% amounts are not equal.