SOLVER7 Study. Nothing Else.
Chapter 8 Examples Q23(i)

After Surbhi bought cookware from the wholesaler, she kept a profit margin of \(50\%\) on all the products. To clear off the remaining stock, she thought she would offer a \(50\%\) discount and come out without any loss.
Do you think she didn’t make any loss\(?\)

CBSE Class 8 Maths · Fractions In Disguise

Solution

👶 Simple Explanation

Simple Explanation

Imagine a shopkeeper buys a toy for 100 rupees. She raises the price to 150 rupees to make a profit. Now she gives a 50% discount, but on 150 rupees, not 100. Half of 150 is 75, so she sells it for just 75 rupees. She actually loses money! Adding 50% and removing 50% only cancel out when they are taken on the same number. Here they are not, so they do not cancel.

Answer: No, Surbhi is not correct. A 50% profit followed by a 50% discount does not cancel out because the discount is taken on the larger marked price. She actually suffers a loss of 25% on the cost price.

📖 Does a 50% Discount Cancel a 50% Profit Margin?

Detailed Explanation

The key idea is that percentages are always taken on different base amounts, so a 50% profit and a 50% discount are NOT taken on the same number. Surbhi first buys at the cost price (CP). She adds 50% profit to this CP to fix her marked price (MP). Later, she gives a 50% discount on the MARKED PRICE, not on the cost price. Because the marked price is larger than the cost price, taking 50% off the marked price removes more money than the 50% she had added earlier. So the selling price ends up below the cost price, which means she actually makes a loss.

Formula Used

\( \text{Marked Price} = \text{CP} + (\text{Profit}\% \text{ of CP}) \) and \( \text{Selling Price} = \text{MP} - (\text{Discount}\% \text{ of MP}) \)

Solution

  1. Step 1: Take a convenient cost price to test the claim. Let the cost price of a product be \( \text{CP} = 100 \) rupees. Using \( 100 \) makes percentage calculations easy.
  2. Step 2: Add the 50% profit margin to the cost price to get the marked price. Profit \( = 50\% \text{ of } 100 = \frac{50}{100} \times 100 = 50 \). So the marked price is \[ \text{MP} = 100 + 50 = 150. \]
  3. Step 3: Now apply the 50% discount. Notice the discount is taken on the marked price \( 150 \), NOT on the cost price \( 100 \). Discount \( = 50\% \text{ of } 150 = \frac{50}{100} \times 150 = 75 \).
  4. Step 4: Find the selling price after discount. \[ \text{SP} = 150 - 75 = 75. \]
  5. Step 5: Compare the selling price with the cost price. Here \( \text{SP} = 75 \) but \( \text{CP} = 100 \). Since \( 75 < 100 \), she sells below cost, so there is a loss. Loss \( = 100 - 75 = 25 \).
  6. Step 6: Express the loss as a percentage of the cost price. \[ \text{Loss}\% = \frac{25}{100} \times 100 = 25\%. \] This same 25% loss will happen for every product, whatever its cost price is.

Final Answer

No, Surbhi is not correct. A 50% profit followed by a 50% discount does not cancel out because the discount is taken on the larger marked price. She actually suffers a loss of 25% on the cost price.

Common Mistake

Students often assume a 50% profit and a 50% discount cancel each other. They forget that the profit is calculated on the cost price while the discount is calculated on the (larger) marked price, so the two 50% amounts are not equal.

🪜 Step-by-step Solution

Step-by-step Solution

  1. Step 1: Assume a convenient cost price to test Surbhi's claim. Let \( \text{CP} = \text{Rs. } 100 \). — Reason: Choosing \( 100 \) as the cost price makes percentage calculations straightforward and easy to track.
  2. Step 2: Calculate the 50% profit on the cost price. Profit \( = \frac{50}{100} \times 100 = 50 \). So the Marked Price is \[ \text{MP} = 100 + 50 = 150. \] — Reason: Surbhi marks her price by adding profit on the cost price, so the base here is CP = 100.
  3. Step 3: Calculate the 50% discount on the Marked Price, NOT on the Cost Price. Discount \( = \frac{50}{100} \times 150 = 75 \). — Reason: A discount is always applied to the Marked Price; the base has now changed to MP = 150, which is larger than 100.
  4. Step 4: Find the actual Selling Price after deducting the discount. \[ \text{SP} = 150 - 75 = 75. \] — Reason: The amount the customer pays is what remains after the discount is subtracted from the Marked Price.
  5. Step 5: Compare the Selling Price with the Cost Price to determine profit or loss. Since \( \text{SP} = 75 \) and \( \text{CP} = 100 \), we have \( \text{SP} < \text{CP} \), so Surbhi incurs a loss. Loss \( = 100 - 75 = 25 \). — Reason: Whenever SP is less than CP, the seller makes a loss, not a profit or a break-even.
  6. Step 6: Calculate the loss percentage on the cost price. \[ \text{Loss}\% = \frac{\text{Loss}}{\text{CP}} \times 100 = \frac{25}{100} \times 100 = 25\%. \] — Reason: Loss percentage is always measured relative to the Cost Price, confirming the extent of Surbhi's actual loss.

Final Answer

No, Surbhi is not correct. A 50% profit followed by a 50% discount does not cancel out because the discount is taken on the larger marked price. She actually suffers a loss of 25% on the cost price.

Common Mistake

One common mistake: Students assume that a 50% profit and a 50% discount cancel each other because the numbers are equal — they forget that the profit is calculated on the smaller Cost Price while the discount is calculated on the larger Marked Price, so the two percentages represent different amounts of money.

✍️ Exam-ready Answer

Exam-ready Answer

  1. Step 1: Let \( \text{CP} = 100 \). Then \( \text{MP} = 100 + 50\% \text{ of } 100 = 150 \).
  2. Step 2: Discount \( = 50\% \text{ of } 150 = 75 \), so \( \text{SP} = 150 - 75 = 75 \).
  3. Step 3: Since \( \text{SP} = 75 < \text{CP} = 100 \), there is a loss. \[\text{Loss}\% = \frac{100 - 75}{100} \times 100 = 25\%\]

Answer: No, Surbhi is not correct. A 50% profit followed by a 50% discount does not cancel out because the discount is taken on the larger marked price. She actually suffers a loss of 25% on the cost price.

➕ More Examples

More Examples

Example 1

Question: Ramesh bought electronic gadgets from a manufacturer. He marked up the price by 40% to set the selling price. Later, to clear old stock, he offered a 40% discount on the marked price. Did Ramesh make a profit, a loss, or did he break even? If not break-even, find the percentage profit or loss.

Solution: Let the Cost Price (CP) of the gadgets be \( \text{Rs } 100 \). Step 1: Find the Marked Price (MP) after a 40% markup. Markup amount \( = 40\% \) of \( 100 \) \[ = \frac{40}{100} \times 100 = 40 \] So, Marked Price \( = 100 + 40 = \text{Rs } 140 \). Step 2: Find the Selling Price (SP) after a 40% discount on the Marked Price. Discount amount \( = 40\% \) of \( 140 \) \[ = \frac{40}{100} \times 140 = 56 \] So, Selling Price \( = 140 - 56 = \text{Rs } 84 \). Step 3: Compare SP with CP. Since SP \( = \text{Rs } 84 < \text{Rs } 100 = \) CP, Ramesh made a loss. Loss \( = 100 - 84 = \text{Rs } 16 \). Step 4: Calculate the percentage loss. \[ \text{Loss\%} = \frac{\text{Loss}}{\text{CP}} \times 100 = \frac{16}{100} \times 100 = 16\% \] So Ramesh did NOT break even; he actually incurred a loss of 16%.

Answer: Ramesh made a loss of 16%, not a break-even.

Example 2

Question: Priya runs a clothing store. She bought kurtas at a certain cost price and marked them up by 60% to set the display price. During a sale, she offered a 60% discount on the display price, thinking she would recover exactly her cost. Did she recover her cost? Find the actual percentage profit or loss.

Solution: Let the Cost Price (CP) of each kurta be \( \text{Rs } 100 \). Step 1: Find the Marked Price (MP) after a 60% markup. Markup amount \( = 60\% \) of \( 100 \) \[ = \frac{60}{100} \times 100 = 60 \] So, Marked Price \( = 100 + 60 = \text{Rs } 160 \). Step 2: Find the Selling Price (SP) after a 60% discount on the Marked Price. Discount amount \( = 60\% \) of \( 160 \) \[ = \frac{60}{100} \times 160 = 96 \] So, Selling Price \( = 160 - 96 = \text{Rs } 64 \). Step 3: Compare SP with CP. Since SP \( = \text{Rs } 64 < \text{Rs } 100 = \) CP, Priya made a loss. Loss \( = 100 - 64 = \text{Rs } 36 \). Step 4: Calculate the percentage loss. \[ \text{Loss\%} = \frac{\text{Loss}}{\text{CP}} \times 100 = \frac{36}{100} \times 100 = 36\% \] So Priya did NOT recover her cost; she suffered a loss of 36%. Note: The general formula for net result when the same rate \( r\% \) is used for both markup and discount is: \[ \text{Net Loss\%} = \left(\frac{r}{10}\right)^2 \% \] For \( r = 60 \): Net Loss \( = \left(\frac{60}{10}\right)^2 = 36\% \), which matches.

Answer: Priya made a loss of 36%, not a break-even.

🎯 Try a Similar Question

Try a Similar Question

Question: Rajan, a furniture dealer, buys chairs from a manufacturer. He marks up the price of each chair by 40% above the cost price. Later, to clear his stock quickly, he offers a 40% discount on the marked price. Rajan claims he will neither gain nor lose any money. Is Rajan correct? Justify with a calculation, and find the actual profit or loss percentage.

Solution

  1. Step 1: Assume a convenient Cost Price: Let the cost price (CP) of one chair be Rs. 100.
  2. Step 2: Calculate the Marked Price after 40% markup: A markup of 40% means the marked price (MP) is 40% more than the CP. Marked Price = CP + 40% of CP \[ MP = 100 + \frac{40}{100} \times 100 \] \[ MP = 100 + 40 = 140 \] So the Marked Price is Rs. 140.
  3. Step 3: Calculate the Selling Price after 40% discount: A discount of 40% is applied on the Marked Price of Rs. 140, not on the Cost Price. Discount = 40% of MP \[ \text{Discount} = \frac{40}{100} \times 140 \] \[ \text{Discount} = 56 \] Selling Price = MP - Discount \[ SP = 140 - 56 = 84 \]
  4. Step 4: Compare SP with CP: The Cost Price is Rs. 100 and the Selling Price is Rs. 84. Since SP is less than CP, Rajan has made a loss. Loss = CP - SP \[ \text{Loss} = 100 - 84 = 16 \]
  5. Step 5: Calculate Loss Percentage: \[ \text{Loss \%} = \frac{\text{Loss}}{\text{CP}} \times 100 \] \[ \text{Loss \%} = \frac{16}{100} \times 100 = 16\% \] We can also verify using the formula: Loss % = \( \frac{(40)^2}{100} = \frac{1600}{100} = 16\% \).
  6. Step 6: Conclusion: Rajan is NOT correct. Even though the markup percentage and the discount percentage are both 40%, the discount is applied on the higher marked price (Rs. 140), resulting in a larger deduction than the original markup in rupee terms. Therefore, Rajan actually suffers a loss of 16% on the cost price.

Answer: No, Rajan is not correct. A 40% markup followed by a 40% discount does not cancel out. Rajan actually suffers a loss of 16% on the cost price, because the discount is applied on the larger marked price, making the rupee deduction greater than the rupee markup.

Everything you get with Solver7

More questions in Fractions In Disguise