Detailed Explanation
When a shopkeeper adds a profit margin, she fixes the Marked Price (MP) above the Cost Price (CP). A discount is a reduction given on this Marked Price, not on the Cost Price. This is the key idea students often miss: the profit percent and the discount percent are calculated on different amounts. The profit is calculated on the CP, but the discount is calculated on the MP. So a 50% profit and a 50% discount do NOT cancel out. To sell at 'no profit or loss', the final selling price after discount must equal the Cost Price. We first express the Marked Price in terms of the Cost Price, then find what discount on that Marked Price brings the price back down to the Cost Price.
Formula Used
\( \text{MP} = \text{CP} \times \left(1 + \frac{\text{Profit}\%}{100}\right) \) and \( \text{Discount}\% = \frac{\text{MP} - \text{SP}}{\text{MP}} \times 100 \)
Solution
- Step 1: Let the Cost Price be a convenient number. Take \( \text{CP} = 100 \). This makes the percentages easy to handle.
- Step 2: Apply the 50% profit margin to find the Marked Price. Since profit is on the CP: \[ \text{MP} = 100 + \frac{50}{100} \times 100 \] \[ \text{MP} = 100 + 50 = 150 \]
- Step 3: Decide the required Selling Price. For no profit and no loss, the Selling Price must equal the Cost Price: \[ \text{SP} = 100 \]
- Step 4: Find the amount of discount. The discount is the difference between Marked Price and Selling Price: \[ \text{Discount} = \text{MP} - \text{SP} = 150 - 100 = 50 \]
- Step 5: Convert this discount into a percentage OF THE MARKED PRICE, because discount is always calculated on the MP: \[ \text{Discount}\% = \frac{50}{150} \times 100 \] \[ \text{Discount}\% = \frac{100}{3} = 33\tfrac{1}{3}\% \]
- Step 6: So Surbhi should have offered a discount of about \( 33\tfrac{1}{3}\% \), not 50%. Her plan of a 50% discount would actually give a selling price of \( 150 - \frac{50}{100}\times 150 = 75 \), which is less than the cost price of 100, causing a loss.
Final Answer
The discount should have been \( 33\tfrac{1}{3}\% \) (that is \( \frac{100}{3}\% \)) on the Marked Price, so that the goods are sold exactly at the Cost Price with no profit or loss.
Common Mistake
A common mistake is thinking that a 50% profit is cancelled by a 50% discount. This is wrong because the profit is calculated on the Cost Price, while the discount is calculated on the higher Marked Price. Applying 50% to a bigger amount removes more than 50% was added, causing a loss.