SOLVER7 Study. Nothing Else.
Chapter 8 Examples Q11

Eesha scored \(42\) marks out of \(50\) on an English test and \(70\) marks out of \(80\) in a Science test. Since she lost only \(8\) marks in English but \(10\) marks in Science, she thinks she has done better at English. Reema does not agree! She argues that since Eesha has scored more marks in Science, she has done better at Science. Vishu thinks we cannot compare the scores because the maximum marks are different. Who do you think is correct\(?\)

CBSE Class 8 Maths · Fractions In Disguise

Solution

👶 Simple Explanation

Simple Explanation

Imagine two friends ran races on different tracks — one track is 50 metres and the other is 80 metres. You cannot just say who ran more metres and call them equal. Eesha scored 42 out of 50 in English and 70 out of 80 in Science. Those totals are different, so comparing them directly is unfair. We need to bring both scores to the same scale — like asking, out of 100, how many would each be? That way, we can compare them honestly and find out where she truly did better.

Answer: Vishu is correct that we cannot compare directly because the maximum marks are different. After converting to percentages, English is \( 84\% \) and Science is \( 87.5\% \), so Eesha actually did better in Science.

📖 Comparing Marks Using Percentages

Detailed Explanation

When two tests have different maximum marks, we cannot compare them just by looking at the marks scored or the marks lost. For example, losing 8 marks out of 50 is not the same as losing 10 marks out of 80, because the totals are different. To compare fairly, we bring both scores to the same base by converting them into percentages. A percentage tells us how many marks were scored out of 100, so both subjects are measured on the same scale. Vishu is right that we cannot compare directly, but we CAN compare after converting to percentages.

Formula Used

\[ \text{Percentage} = \frac{\text{Marks scored}}{\text{Maximum marks}} \times 100 \]

Solution

  1. Step 1: Write down what each subject gives. In English, Eesha scored \( 42 \) out of \( 50 \). In Science, she scored \( 70 \) out of \( 80 \). Since the maximum marks are different (\( 50 \) and \( 80 \)), a direct comparison of marks is not fair.
  2. Step 2: Convert the English score to a percentage using the formula. \[ \text{English \%} = \frac{42}{50} \times 100 \] \[ \text{English \%} = 84 \] So she scored \( 84\% \) in English.
  3. Step 3: Convert the Science score to a percentage in the same way. \[ \text{Science \%} = \frac{70}{80} \times 100 \] \[ \text{Science \%} = 87.5 \] So she scored \( 87.5\% \) in Science.
  4. Step 4: Now both scores are on the same scale (out of 100), so we can compare them. Since \( 87.5 > 84 \), the Science percentage is higher.
  5. Step 5: Decide who is correct. Eesha (comparing marks lost) and Reema (comparing raw marks) both compared unfairly because the totals differ. Vishu correctly said we cannot compare directly with different maximums. Once we convert to percentages, Eesha actually performed better in Science.

Final Answer

Vishu is correct that we cannot compare directly because the maximum marks are different. After converting to percentages, English is \( 84\% \) and Science is \( 87.5\% \), so Eesha actually did better in Science.

Common Mistake

A common mistake is comparing the marks lost (8 vs 10) or the raw marks (42 vs 70) directly. This is wrong because the maximum marks are different; you must convert both to percentages first.

🪜 Step-by-step Solution

Step-by-step Solution

  1. Step 1: List the given information clearly. Eesha scored \( 42 \) out of \( 50 \) in English, and \( 70 \) out of \( 80 \) in Science. — Reason: Organising the data first helps us see that the maximum marks are different (\( 50 \) vs \( 80 \)), which means we cannot simply compare \( 42 \) and \( 70 \) side by side.
  2. Step 2: Acknowledge why a direct comparison fails. Losing \( 8 \) marks out of \( 50 \) is much more significant than losing \( 10 \) marks out of \( 80 \), because the totals differ. — Reason: This confirms that Vishu is right to point out the problem; raw marks are on different scales and give a misleading picture.
  3. Step 3: Convert the English score to a percentage using the formula. \[ \text{English \%} = \frac{42}{50} \times 100 \] \[ \text{English \%} = 84 \] So Eesha scored \( 84\% \) in English. — Reason: Multiplying by \( 100 \) re-expresses the fraction as marks out of \( 100 \), giving a standardised score.
  4. Step 4: Convert the Science score to a percentage in exactly the same way. \[ \text{Science \%} = \frac{70}{80} \times 100 \] \[ \text{Science \%} = 87.5 \] So Eesha scored \( 87.5\% \) in Science. — Reason: Applying the same formula to both subjects ensures both results are now measured on an identical scale (out of \( 100 \)).
  5. Step 5: Compare the two percentages directly. We have \( 87.5\% \) in Science and \( 84\% \) in English. Since \( 87.5 > 84 \), Science is the higher score. — Reason: Now that both scores share the same base of \( 100 \), the comparison is completely fair and straightforward.
  6. Step 6: Decide which person's reasoning was correct. Vishu was right that a direct comparison of marks is not valid. However, the conclusion changes once we convert: Eesha performed better in Science, not English. — Reason: Vishu identified the correct problem (different totals), but the percentage calculation reveals which subject had the actually higher performance.

Final Answer

Vishu is correct that we cannot compare directly because the maximum marks are different. After converting to percentages, English is \( 84\% \) and Science is \( 87.5\% \), so Eesha actually did better in Science.

Common Mistake

One common mistake: Students compare the marks lost (\( 50 - 42 = 8 \) vs \( 80 - 70 = 10 \)) and conclude that English is better because fewer marks were dropped, without realising that these losses are out of different totals and cannot be compared directly.

✍️ Exam-ready Answer

Exam-ready Answer

  1. Step 1: English: \[ \frac{42}{50} \times 100 = 84\% \]
  2. Step 2: Science: \[ \frac{70}{80} \times 100 = 87.5\% \]
  3. Step 3: Compare: \( 87.5\% > 84\% \), so Science score is higher.

Answer: Vishu is correct that we cannot compare directly because the maximum marks are different. After converting to percentages, English is \( 84\% \) and Science is \( 87.5\% \), so Eesha actually did better in Science.

➕ More Examples

More Examples

Example 1

Question: Aryan scored 36 marks out of 45 in a Mathematics test and 56 marks out of 75 in a Social Science test. His friend Priya says Aryan did better in Social Science because he scored more marks there. His sister says he did better in Mathematics because he lost only 9 marks compared to 19 marks in Social Science. His teacher says we must convert to percentages before comparing. Who is correct? Find Aryan's percentage in each subject and decide.

Solution: We calculate the percentage score in each subject. For Mathematics: Marks obtained = 36, Maximum marks = 45. \[\text{Percentage in Mathematics} = \frac{36}{45} \times 100\] Simplifying: \[= \frac{36 \times 100}{45} = \frac{3600}{45} = 80\%\] For Social Science: Marks obtained = 56, Maximum marks = 75. \[\text{Percentage in Social Science} = \frac{56}{75} \times 100\] Simplifying: \[= \frac{5600}{75} = 74.\overline{6}\% \approx 74.67\%\] Comparing: \( 80\% > 74.67\% \), so Aryan performed better in Mathematics. Priya is wrong — scoring more raw marks does not mean a better performance when the totals differ. The sister is also wrong — fewer marks lost means nothing without considering the total. The teacher is correct: percentages must be compared for a fair judgement.

Answer: Aryan's percentage in Mathematics is \( 80\% \) and in Social Science is approximately \( 74.67\% \). The teacher is correct — Aryan performed better in Mathematics.

Example 2

Question: In a school competition, Meera scored 48 out of 60 in a quiz and 65 out of 80 in a debate. Her coach says she did better in the debate because her score is higher there. Her father says she did better in the quiz because she lost only 12 marks compared to 15 marks in the debate. Her mother points out that the maximum marks are different, so percentages must be used. Who is correct? Justify your answer by finding percentages.

Solution: We calculate the percentage score for each event. For the Quiz: Marks obtained = 48, Maximum marks = 60. \[\text{Percentage in Quiz} = \frac{48}{60} \times 100\] Simplifying: \[= \frac{4800}{60} = 80\%\] For the Debate: Marks obtained = 65, Maximum marks = 80. \[\text{Percentage in Debate} = \frac{65}{80} \times 100\] Simplifying: \[= \frac{6500}{80} = 81.25\%\] Comparing: \( 81.25\% > 80\% \), so Meera performed better in the Debate. The coach's claim turns out to be correct in conclusion, but the reasoning (higher raw marks) is not a valid method. The father is wrong — fewer marks lost does not directly indicate a better percentage. Meera's mother is absolutely right in insisting that percentages must be used for a fair comparison. Once we compute percentages, we confirm that the Debate performance was indeed slightly better.

Answer: Meera's percentage in the Quiz is \( 80\% \) and in the Debate is \( 81.25\% \). Meera's mother is correct — percentages must be compared; Meera performed better in the Debate.

🎯 Try a Similar Question

Try a Similar Question

Question: Rohan scored 36 marks out of 45 in a Maths test and 56 marks out of 75 in a Social Science test. Rohan says he did better in Maths because he lost only 9 marks there, while he lost 19 marks in Social Science. His friend Priya disagrees and says he did better in Social Science because 56 is greater than 36. Their teacher says neither argument is correct and that both tests must be compared fairly. Who is correct, and in which subject did Rohan actually perform better?

Solution

  1. Step 1: Understand the three arguments: Rohan compares marks lost: lost 9 in Maths vs 19 in Social Science. Priya compares raw marks: 56 > 36. The teacher says we cannot compare directly because the maximum marks are different (45 vs 75). We need to convert both scores to percentages to compare fairly.
  2. Step 2: Calculate percentage score in Maths: Marks obtained in Maths = 36 out of 45. Percentage in Maths = \( \frac{36}{45} \times 100 \). Simplifying: \( \frac{36}{45} = \frac{4}{5} \). So, Percentage in Maths = \( \frac{4}{5} \times 100 = 80\% \).
  3. Step 3: Calculate percentage score in Social Science: Marks obtained in Social Science = 56 out of 75. Percentage in Social Science = \( \frac{56}{75} \times 100 \). Computing: \( \frac{56 \times 100}{75} = \frac{5600}{75} \approx 74.67\% \).
  4. Step 4: Compare the two percentages: Maths percentage = \( 80\% \) and Social Science percentage \( \approx 74.67\% \). Since \( 80\% > 74.67\% \), Rohan performed better in Maths.
  5. Step 5: Evaluate each argument: Rohan's argument (comparing marks lost) is flawed because 9 out of 45 and 19 out of 75 are proportionally different. Priya's argument (comparing raw scores 36 vs 56) is also flawed because the totals are different. The teacher is correct that we must convert to a common base (percentages) before comparing. After doing so, Rohan actually did better in Maths.

Answer: The teacher is correct that we cannot compare directly using raw marks or marks lost, since the maximum marks are different. After converting to percentages, Maths = \( 80\% \) and Social Science \( \approx 74.67\% \). Therefore, Rohan performed better in Maths.

Everything you get with Solver7

More questions in Fractions In Disguise