Detailed Explanation
When two tests have different maximum marks, we cannot compare them just by looking at the marks scored or the marks lost. For example, losing 8 marks out of 50 is not the same as losing 10 marks out of 80, because the totals are different. To compare fairly, we bring both scores to the same base by converting them into percentages. A percentage tells us how many marks were scored out of 100, so both subjects are measured on the same scale. Vishu is right that we cannot compare directly, but we CAN compare after converting to percentages.
Formula Used
\[ \text{Percentage} = \frac{\text{Marks scored}}{\text{Maximum marks}} \times 100 \]
Solution
- Step 1: Write down what each subject gives. In English, Eesha scored \( 42 \) out of \( 50 \). In Science, she scored \( 70 \) out of \( 80 \). Since the maximum marks are different (\( 50 \) and \( 80 \)), a direct comparison of marks is not fair.
- Step 2: Convert the English score to a percentage using the formula. \[ \text{English \%} = \frac{42}{50} \times 100 \] \[ \text{English \%} = 84 \] So she scored \( 84\% \) in English.
- Step 3: Convert the Science score to a percentage in the same way. \[ \text{Science \%} = \frac{70}{80} \times 100 \] \[ \text{Science \%} = 87.5 \] So she scored \( 87.5\% \) in Science.
- Step 4: Now both scores are on the same scale (out of 100), so we can compare them. Since \( 87.5 > 84 \), the Science percentage is higher.
- Step 5: Decide who is correct. Eesha (comparing marks lost) and Reema (comparing raw marks) both compared unfairly because the totals differ. Vishu correctly said we cannot compare directly with different maximums. Once we convert to percentages, Eesha actually performed better in Science.
Final Answer
Vishu is correct that we cannot compare directly because the maximum marks are different. After converting to percentages, English is \( 84\% \) and Science is \( 87.5\% \), so Eesha actually did better in Science.
Common Mistake
A common mistake is comparing the marks lost (8 vs 10) or the raw marks (42 vs 70) directly. This is wrong because the maximum marks are different; you must convert both to percentages first.