SOLVER7 Study. Nothing Else.
Figure It Out 5 Q4(iv)

The monthly percentage change in population (compared to the previous month) of mice in a lab is given: Month \(1\) change was \(+5\%,\) Month \(2\) change was \(-2\%,\) and Month \(3\) change was\( –3\%.\) Which of the following statement(s) are true\(?\) The initial population is \(p .\) The population after three months was \(p.\)

CBSE Class 8 Maths · Fractions In Disguise

Solution

👶 Simple Explanation

Simple Explanation

Imagine a frog jumping on a number line. The frog jumps forward a little, then backward a little, then backward again. Even if the jumps seem balanced, the frog does NOT land exactly where it started. Each jump changes the frog's position by a tiny different amount each time. Adding the percentages like 5 minus 2 minus 3 seems to give zero, but that is a trick. The actual finishing population is \( 0.99813\,p \), which is just a tiny bit less than where we began.

Answer: The population after three months is \( 0.99813\,p \approx 99.81\% \) of \( p \), which is slightly less than the initial population. So the claim that it returns to \( p \) is FALSE.

📖 Successive Percentage Change in Population

Detailed Explanation

When a quantity changes by a percentage each month, we must apply each change one after another (successively), not just add the percentages up. A change of \( +5\% \) means the new value is \( 105\% \) of the old value, so we multiply by \( \frac{105}{100} \). A change of \( -2\% \) means we multiply by \( \frac{98}{100} \), and \( -3\% \) means we multiply by \( \frac{97}{100} \). Each month's change is based on the population of the previous month, so we keep multiplying step by step starting from the initial population \( p \).

Formula Used

\[ \text{New value} = \text{Old value} \times \left(1 + \frac{r}{100}\right) \] where \( r \) is positive for an increase and negative for a decrease.

Solution

  1. Step 1: Start with the initial population \( p \). In Month 1 the change is \( +5\% \), so we multiply by \( \frac{105}{100} \). Population after Month 1 is \[ p \times \frac{105}{100}. \]
  2. Step 2: In Month 2 the change is \( -2\% \), applied to the Month 1 population. Multiply by \( \frac{98}{100} \). Population after Month 2 is \[ p \times \frac{105}{100} \times \frac{98}{100}. \]
  3. Step 3: In Month 3 the change is \( -3\% \), applied to the Month 2 population. Multiply by \( \frac{97}{100} \). Population after Month 3 is \[ p \times \frac{105}{100} \times \frac{98}{100} \times \frac{97}{100}. \]
  4. Step 4: Multiply the three factors. First \[ \frac{105}{100} \times \frac{98}{100} = \frac{10290}{10000} = 1.029. \] Then multiply by \( \frac{97}{100} = 0.97 \): \[ 1.029 \times 0.97 = 0.99813. \]
  5. Step 5: So the population after three months is \( 0.99813\,p \), which is about \( 99.813\% \) of \( p \). This is slightly less than \( p \), not equal to \( p \). Therefore the statement that the population returns to \( p \) is false.

Final Answer

The population after three months is \( 0.99813\,p \approx 99.81\% \) of \( p \), which is slightly less than the initial population. So the claim that it returns to \( p \) is FALSE.

Common Mistake

A common mistake is simply adding the percentages \( +5\% - 2\% - 3\% = 0\% \) and concluding the population stays at \( p \). Percentages applied successively must be multiplied, not added, because each change acts on a different base.

🪜 Step-by-step Solution

Step-by-step Solution

  1. Step 1: Identify the monthly multiplying factors. A rise of 5% means we multiply by \( \frac{105}{100} \). A fall of 2% means we multiply by \( \frac{98}{100} \). A fall of 3% means we multiply by \( \frac{97}{100} \). — Reason: Each percentage change scales the previous value, so we convert every percentage into a decimal multiplier to chain the changes together correctly.
  2. Step 2: Apply Month 1 (rise of 5%) to the initial population \( p \). Population after Month 1: \[ p \times \frac{105}{100} \] — Reason: We start with \( p \) and scale it by \( \frac{105}{100} \) because the population grows by 5% during the first month.
  3. Step 3: Apply Month 2 (fall of 2%) to the Month 1 result. Population after Month 2: \[ p \times \frac{105}{100} \times \frac{98}{100} \] — Reason: The 2% decrease acts on whatever the population is at the end of Month 1, not on the original \( p \), so we multiply the running total by \( \frac{98}{100} \).
  4. Step 4: Apply Month 3 (fall of 3%) to the Month 2 result. Population after Month 3: \[ p \times \frac{105}{100} \times \frac{98}{100} \times \frac{97}{100} \] — Reason: Similarly, the 3% decrease in Month 3 is applied to the Month 2 population, giving us the full chain of three successive multiplications.
  5. Step 5: Multiply the first two factors together. \[ \frac{105}{100} \times \frac{98}{100} = \frac{105 \times 98}{100 \times 100} = \frac{10290}{10000} = 1.029 \] — Reason: Combining two fractions at a time keeps the arithmetic manageable before we bring in the third factor.
  6. Step 6: Now multiply the result by the third factor \( \frac{97}{100} = 0.97 \). \[ 1.029 \times 0.97 = 0.99813 \] So the population after three months is \[ p \times 0.99813 \] — Reason: This single product of all three multipliers tells us the overall scaling factor applied to the initial population over the whole three-month period.
  7. Step 7: Convert the overall factor to a percentage. \[ 0.99813 \times 100 = 99.813\% \approx 99.81\% \] Since \( 99.81\% \) is less than \( 100\% \), the final population is slightly below \( p \). — Reason: Expressing the factor as a percentage makes it easy to compare the final population directly with the original and judge whether the claim holds.

Final Answer

The population after three months is \( 0.99813\,p \approx 99.81\% \) of \( p \), which is slightly less than the initial population. So the claim that it returns to \( p \) is FALSE.

Common Mistake

One common mistake: students add the three percentages algebraically (5 − 2 − 3 = 0) and conclude that the population returns exactly to \( p \). This ignores the fact that each month's decrease is calculated on a different base, so the losses in Months 2 and 3 are larger in absolute terms than a simple percentage sum suggests, leaving the population slightly below \( p \).

✍️ Exam-ready Answer

Exam-ready Answer

  1. Step 1: After Month 1 (+5%): \[ p \times \frac{105}{100} \]
  2. Step 2: After Month 2 (-2%): \[ p \times \frac{105}{100} \times \frac{98}{100} = p \times 1.029 \]
  3. Step 3: After Month 3 (-3%): \[ p \times 1.029 \times \frac{97}{100} = p \times 0.99813 \]

Answer: The population after three months is \( 0.99813\,p \approx 99.81\% \) of \( p \), which is slightly less than the initial population. So the claim that it returns to \( p \) is FALSE.

➕ More Examples

More Examples

Example 1

Question: A shopkeeper's monthly revenue changes as follows over three months: Month 1 increases by 10%, Month 2 decreases by 10%, and Month 3 increases by 5%. If the initial revenue is \( R \) rupees, find the revenue after three months. Is the final revenue equal to \( R \)?

Solution: Let the initial revenue be \( R \). After Month 1 (increase of 10%), the revenue becomes: \[ R \times \frac{110}{100} = \frac{11R}{10} \] After Month 2 (decrease of 10%), the revenue becomes: \[ \frac{11R}{10} \times \frac{90}{100} = \frac{11R}{10} \times \frac{9}{10} = \frac{99R}{100} \] After Month 3 (increase of 5%), the revenue becomes: \[ \frac{99R}{100} \times \frac{105}{100} = \frac{99R \times 105}{10000} = \frac{10395R}{10000} \] Simplifying: \[ \frac{10395R}{10000} = 1.0395R \] Since \( 1.0395R \ne R \), the final revenue is NOT equal to the initial revenue \( R \). The revenue after three months is \( \frac{10395R}{10000} \), which is about 3.95% more than \( R \). Note: Even though Month 1 and Month 2 are +10% and -10%, their combined effect gives \( \frac{11}{10} \times \frac{9}{10} = \frac{99}{100} \), not 1. So the three changes do NOT cancel out to give back \( R \).

Answer: Final revenue = \( \frac{10395R}{10000} \approx 1.0395R \), which is NOT equal to \( R \).

Example 2

Question: The number of bacteria in a culture changes each hour as follows: Hour 1 increases by 20%, Hour 2 decreases by 25%, and Hour 3 decreases by 4%. If the initial count is \( N \), find the bacterial count after three hours. Is the final count less than, equal to, or greater than \( N \)?

Solution: Let the initial bacterial count be \( N \). After Hour 1 (increase of 20%), the count becomes: \[ N \times \frac{120}{100} = \frac{6N}{5} \] After Hour 2 (decrease of 25%), the count becomes: \[ \frac{6N}{5} \times \frac{75}{100} = \frac{6N}{5} \times \frac{3}{4} = \frac{18N}{20} = \frac{9N}{10} \] After Hour 3 (decrease of 4%), the count becomes: \[ \frac{9N}{10} \times \frac{96}{100} = \frac{9N}{10} \times \frac{24}{25} = \frac{216N}{250} = \frac{108N}{125} \] Now, \( \frac{108}{125} = 0.864 \), which is less than 1. Therefore the final count is \( \frac{108N}{125} = 0.864N \), which is less than \( N \). The overall net change is: \[ \frac{108N}{125} - N = \frac{108N - 125N}{125} = \frac{-17N}{125} \] So the bacterial count decreased by \( \frac{17N}{125} \), i.e., by 13.6% of the original count.

Answer: Final count = \( \frac{108N}{125} = 0.864N \), which is less than \( N \) (a net decrease of 13.6%).

🎯 Try a Similar Question

Try a Similar Question

Question: A fish tank starts with a population of \( p \) fish. The monthly percentage changes in population (compared to the previous month) over three months are: Month 1: \(+4\%\), Month 2: \(-3\%\), Month 3: \(+2\%\). A student claims that the population after three months is more than \( p \). Is this claim TRUE or FALSE? Also find the population after three months in terms of \( p \).

Solution

  1. Step 1: Write the multiplying factor for each month: A change of \( +4\% \) means the population is multiplied by \( 1 + \frac{4}{100} = 1.04 \). A change of \( -3\% \) means the population is multiplied by \( 1 - \frac{3}{100} = 0.97 \). A change of \( +2\% \) means the population is multiplied by \( 1 + \frac{2}{100} = 1.02 \).
  2. Step 2: Compute the combined factor: The population after three months is: \[ p \times 1.04 \times 0.97 \times 1.02 \] First, multiply the first two factors: \[ 1.04 \times 0.97 = 1.0088 \] Next, multiply the result by the third factor: \[ 1.0088 \times 1.02 = 1.028976 \]
  3. Step 3: Find the final population: The population after three months is: \[ p \times 1.028976 = 1.028976\, p \] This means the population is approximately \( 102.90\% \) of \( p \).
  4. Step 4: Check the student's claim: Since \( 1.028976 > 1 \), the population after three months is greater than \( p \). Therefore, the student's claim that the population is more than \( p \) is TRUE.

Answer: The population after three months is \( 1.028976\, p \approx 102.90\% \) of \( p \), which is greater than the initial population. So the claim is TRUE.

Everything you get with Solver7

More questions in Fractions In Disguise