SOLVER7 Study. Nothing Else.
Figure It Out 5 Q15(iv)

Look at the following graph. Based on the graph, which of the following statement(s) are valid\(?\) More than a quarter of people in their thirties can use computers.

CBSE Class 8 Maths · Fractions In Disguise

Solution

👶 Simple Explanation

Simple Explanation

Imagine a quarter of a chocolate bar — that is exactly one out of four equal pieces, which equals \( 25\% \). The graph shows that women in their thirties use computers at \( 14\% \), and men at exactly \( 25\% \). Neither number is bigger than \( 25\% \). So nobody in the thirties group goes above a quarter. The statement saying 'more than a quarter' is simply wrong.

Answer: The statement is NOT valid. In the thirties, females are at \( 14\% \) and males at exactly \( 25\% \); since a quarter is \( 25\% \), no value is more than a quarter.

📖 Reading a Bar Graph: People in Their Thirties

Detailed Explanation

This is a data handling question based on a double bar graph. Each age group has two bars, one for Female and one for Male, and the length of each bar shows the percentage of people in that group who can use computers. To check the statement, we first read the exact percentages for the 'Thirties' group. A 'quarter' means one-fourth. As a percentage, \( \frac{1}{4} = 25\% \). So 'more than a quarter' means the value must be greater than \( 25\% \). We must be careful here, because 'people in their thirties' includes both females and males, so we should look at both bars and think about the overall group, not just one bar.

Formula Used

\[ \text{one quarter} = \frac{1}{4} = \frac{25}{100} = 25\% \]

Solution

  1. Step 1: Understand what 'a quarter' means: A quarter is one out of four equal parts. In percentage form \( \frac{1}{4} = 25\% \). So 'more than a quarter' means the value must be strictly greater than \( 25\% \).
  2. Step 2: Read the values for the Thirties group: From the graph, for the age group 'Thirties': the Female bar shows \( 14\% \) and the Male bar shows \( 25\% \).
  3. Step 3: Compare each value with 25%: For females, \( 14\% \) is less than \( 25\% \). For males, the value is exactly \( 25\% \), which is equal to a quarter, not more than a quarter. Neither bar goes above \( 25\% \).
  4. Step 4: Think about the whole 'thirties' group: The statement talks about 'people in their thirties', combining both genders. Since females are only \( 14\% \) and males are exactly \( 25\% \), the ability of the group as a whole cannot cross \( 25\% \). Even the highest single value equals a quarter but does not exceed it.
  5. Step 5: Decide if the statement is valid: For the statement to be valid we needed a value greater than \( 25\% \). The highest value here is exactly \( 25\% \), so the condition 'more than a quarter' is not satisfied. The statement is therefore not valid.

Final Answer

The statement is NOT valid. In the thirties, females are at \( 14\% \) and males at exactly \( 25\% \); since a quarter is \( 25\% \), no value is more than a quarter.

Common Mistake

A common mistake is treating the male value of \( 25\% \) as 'more than a quarter'. But \( 25\% \) is exactly one quarter, so it must be strictly greater than \( 25\% \) to count as 'more than a quarter'.

🪜 Step-by-step Solution

Step-by-step Solution

  1. Step 1: Identify what 'a quarter' means as a percentage. A quarter means one out of four equal parts, so \( \frac{1}{4} = 25\% \). The phrase 'more than a quarter' therefore means a value that is strictly greater than \( 25\% \). — Reason: We need a clear numerical benchmark before we can check any claim from the graph.
  2. Step 2: Locate the 'Thirties' age group on the double bar graph and note the percentage shown by each bar. The Female bar reads \( 14\% \) and the Male bar reads \( 25\% \). — Reason: The statement is about people in their thirties, so both bars for that age group must be examined.
  3. Step 3: Compare the Female value with the benchmark. We have \( 14\% \) for females. Since \( 14 < 25 \), the female percentage is well below a quarter. — Reason: To judge whether the statement holds, each group's value must be individually tested against \( 25\% \).
  4. Step 4: Compare the Male value with the benchmark. We have \( 25\% \) for males. Since \( 25 = 25 \), the male percentage is exactly equal to a quarter, not greater than it. Being equal to \( 25\% \) does not satisfy 'more than a quarter'. — Reason: The phrase 'more than' is strict; equality does not count.
  5. Step 5: Consider the thirties group as a whole. Females stand at \( 14\% \) (below a quarter) and males stand at exactly \( 25\% \) (equal to, not above, a quarter). Neither value exceeds \( 25\% \), so no part of the thirties group uses computers at a rate higher than a quarter. — Reason: The statement covers all people in their thirties, so both genders must be checked before reaching a verdict.
  6. Step 6: State the verdict. Because neither \( 14\% \) nor \( 25\% \) is strictly greater than \( 25\% \), the claim that 'more than a quarter of people in their thirties use computers' is NOT supported by the graph data. — Reason: A true statement would require at least one bar to show a value greater than \( 25\% \), which does not happen here.

Final Answer

The statement is NOT valid. In the thirties, females are at \( 14\% \) and males at exactly \( 25\% \); since a quarter is \( 25\% \), no value is more than a quarter.

Common Mistake

One common mistake: Students often treat 'equal to a quarter' (i.e., exactly \( 25\% \)) as satisfying 'more than a quarter', which is incorrect — the word 'more than' is strict and excludes the equal case.

✍️ Exam-ready Answer

Exam-ready Answer

  1. Step 1: One quarter as a percentage: \( \frac{1}{4} = 25\% \), so "more than a quarter" means value \( > 25\% \).
  2. Step 2: From the graph, Thirties group: Female \( = 14\% \), Male \( = 25\% \).
  3. Step 3: Check: \( 14\% < 25\% \) and \( 25\% = 25\% \) (not strictly greater). Neither value exceeds \( 25\% \).

Answer: The statement is NOT valid. In the thirties, females are at \( 14\% \) and males at exactly \( 25\% \); since a quarter is \( 25\% \), no value is more than a quarter.

➕ More Examples

More Examples

Example 1

Question: A bar graph shows the percentage of people in different age groups who own a smartphone. The data is as follows: Teens (13–19 years): 80%, Twenties: 72%, Thirties: 60%, Forties: 45%, Fifties and above: 28%. Based on this data, evaluate whether the following statement is valid: 'More than half of the people in their forties own a smartphone.'

Solution: From the bar graph, the percentage of people in their forties who own a smartphone is 45%. The benchmark phrase 'more than half' means more than \( 50\% \). We compare: \[ 45\% \text{ vs } 50\% \] Since \( 45\% < 50\% \), the percentage of people in their forties who own a smartphone is NOT more than half. Therefore, the statement is NOT valid.

Answer: The statement is NOT valid, because 45% is less than 50% (half).

Example 2

Question: A pie chart shows how students in a school spend their free time. The sectors (in percentage) are: Reading: 18%, Sports: 35%, Watching TV: 22%, Playing video games: 15%, Other activities: 10%. Based on this data, evaluate whether the following statement is valid: 'More than a quarter of the students spend their free time playing Sports.'

Solution: From the pie chart, the percentage of students who spend their free time on Sports is 35%. The benchmark phrase 'more than a quarter' means more than \( \frac{1}{4} = 25\% \). We compare: \[ 35\% \text{ vs } 25\% \] Since \( 35\% > 25\% \), the percentage of students spending time on Sports is indeed more than a quarter. Therefore, the statement is VALID.

Answer: The statement is VALID, because 35% is greater than 25% (a quarter).

🎯 Try a Similar Question

Try a Similar Question

Question: A survey was conducted across different age groups to find the percentage of people who own a smartphone. The results for the 'forties' age group showed that female ownership was at \( 30\% \) and male ownership was at \( 33\% \). A student looks at the graph and makes the following statement: 'More than one-third of people in their forties own a smartphone.' State whether this statement is VALID or NOT VALID, and justify your answer using the data given.

Solution

  1. Step 1: Understand the benchmark: The statement uses the phrase 'more than one-third.' We first find what one-third means as a percentage. One-third as a percentage is \( \frac{1}{3} \times 100 \approx 33.33\% \). So the claim is that at least one of the values shown in the graph must be strictly greater than \( 33.33\% \).
  2. Step 2: Read the graph values: From the graph (survey data), for the 'forties' age group: Female ownership = \( 30\% \) and Male ownership = \( 33\% \). These are the only two data points for this age group.
  3. Step 3: Compare each value with one-third: Compare female ownership with one-third: \( 30\% < 33.33\% \), so females are below one-third. Compare male ownership with one-third: \( 33\% < 33.33\% \), so males are also below one-third. Note that \( 33\% \) is close to but strictly less than \( 33.33\% \), so it does NOT exceed one-third.
  4. Step 4: Conclude: Since neither \( 30\% \) (female) nor \( 33\% \) (male) is strictly greater than \( 33.33\% \) (one-third), the statement 'More than one-third of people in their forties own a smartphone' is NOT supported by the data.

Answer: The statement is VALID for neither group. Female ownership is \( 30\% \) and male ownership is \( 33\% \); since one-third \( \approx 33.33\% \), both values fall below one-third. Therefore, the statement is NOT VALID.

Everything you get with Solver7

More questions in Fractions In Disguise