SOLVER7 Study. Nothing Else.
Figure It Out 5 Q15(iii)

Look at the following graph. Based on the graph, which of the following statement(s) are valid\(?\) There are more people in their twenties than teenagers.

CBSE Class 8 Maths · Fractions In Disguise

Solution

👶 Simple Explanation

Simple Explanation

Imagine a school where 30 out of every 100 students can ride a bicycle. That tells you how good they are at riding, not how many students are in the school. This graph works the same way. It shows what percentage of people in each age group can use a computer. A higher percentage does not mean there are more people in that group. To know which group has more people, you need the actual count, which this graph simply does not show.

Answer: The statement is NOT valid. The graph shows the percentage of people able to use computers, not the number of people in each age group, so it cannot tell us whether there are more people in their twenties than teenagers.

📖 Reading a Bar Graph: Comparing Twenties and Teenagers

Detailed Explanation

This question is from data handling (bar graphs). A bar graph shows values for different categories using the length of bars. In this graph, each age group has two bars: one for females and one for males. The bars tell us the percentage of people in that age group who are able to use a computer. Very important: the graph shows an ABILITY (a percentage), NOT the actual number of people in each age group. A percentage like 26 percent for females in their twenties means 26 out of every 100 females in their twenties can use a computer. It says nothing about how many people belong to the twenties age group compared to the teenage group. To claim 'there are more people in their twenties than teenagers', we would need population counts, which this graph does not provide.

Formula Used

A bar graph value represents a percentage: \( x\% = \frac{x}{100} \). This describes a proportion within a group, not the total number of people in that group.

Solution

  1. Step 1: Understand what the graph measures: The title says 'Ability to use computer by age and gender'. So each bar shows the percentage of people (in a given age group and gender) who CAN use a computer. It does not show the size of the population.
  2. Step 2: Read the values for Teenagers: For Teenagers, the female bar reads \( 24\% \) and the male bar reads \( 29\% \). These are ability percentages, not head counts.
  3. Step 3: Read the values for Twenties: For Twenties, the female bar reads \( 26\% \) and the male bar reads \( 37\% \). Again, these are ability percentages.
  4. Step 4: Check what the statement is asking: The statement claims there are MORE PEOPLE in their twenties than teenagers. This is a claim about the number of people (population size), not about the percentage who can use a computer.
  5. Step 5: Match the claim with the data: The graph only gives percentages of computer ability. It gives no information about how many people belong to the twenties group or the teenage group. So we cannot compare their populations from this graph.
  6. Step 6: Conclude: Since the graph does not contain population numbers, the statement cannot be supported by the graph. Higher ability percentages in the twenties do NOT mean there are more people in the twenties.

Final Answer

The statement is NOT valid. The graph shows the percentage of people able to use computers, not the number of people in each age group, so it cannot tell us whether there are more people in their twenties than teenagers.

Common Mistake

A common mistake is to see the taller bars for the twenties (like \( 37\% \)) and conclude there are more people in their twenties. This confuses a percentage (ability) with an actual count (population size). A bigger percentage does not mean a bigger group of people.

🪜 Step-by-step Solution

Step-by-step Solution

  1. Step 1: Read the graph title carefully. The title states 'Ability to use computer by age and gender'. — Reason: The title tells us exactly what the bars measure, which is ability (a percentage), not the total number of people in each age group.
  2. Step 2: Note the values shown for Teenagers: the female bar shows \( 24\% \) and the male bar shows \( 29\% \). — Reason: These figures mean 24 out of every 100 teenage females, and 29 out of every 100 teenage males, can use a computer. They say nothing about how many teenagers exist in total.
  3. Step 3: Note the values shown for Twenties: the female bar shows \( 26\% \) and the male bar shows \( 37\% \). — Reason: Similarly, these figures describe computer-use ability within the twenties group, not the size of that group.
  4. Step 4: Compare what the graph provides versus what the statement claims. The statement says 'there are more people in their twenties than teenagers'. To verify this, we would need the actual population count of each age group — a number like 5000 teenagers or 8000 people in their twenties. The graph gives us only \( x\% = \frac{x}{100} \) within each group, which is a proportion, not a count. — Reason: Percentage and population size are two completely different quantities; one cannot be deduced from the other without extra information.
  5. Step 5: Conclude whether the statement is valid. Since the graph contains no information about the number of people in each age category, it is impossible to determine which age group has more people. — Reason: Drawing a conclusion about population size from a percentage-based graph is a logical error; the data simply does not support such a claim.

Final Answer

The statement is NOT valid. The graph shows the percentage of people able to use computers, not the number of people in each age group, so it cannot tell us whether there are more people in their twenties than teenagers.

Common Mistake

One common mistake: Students confuse a higher percentage bar with a larger population. For example, seeing \( 37\% \) for males in their twenties versus \( 29\% \) for teenage males does NOT mean there are more people in their twenties — it only means a greater share of twenties males can use a computer within their own group.

✍️ Exam-ready Answer

Exam-ready Answer

  1. Step 1: Graph measures: percentage of people able to use a computer, where each bar = \( x\% = \frac{x}{100} \) within that age group.
  2. Step 2: Teenagers: female \( 24\% \), male \( 29\% \). Twenties: female \( 26\% \), male \( 37\% \). These are proportions within each group, not population counts.
  3. Step 3: Population size of each age group is not given. A higher ability percentage does NOT imply a larger group size.

Answer: The statement is NOT valid. The graph shows the percentage of people able to use computers, not the number of people in each age group, so it cannot tell us whether there are more people in their twenties than teenagers.

➕ More Examples

More Examples

Example 1

Question: A school conducted a survey on students' favourite sports. The bar graph shows the number of students who prefer each sport: Cricket — 120, Football — 95, Basketball — 120, Badminton — 75, Swimming — 110. \nBased on the data, determine whether each of the following statements is valid or invalid: (a) More students prefer Swimming than Football. (b) Cricket and Basketball are equally popular. (c) Badminton is the most preferred sport. (d) The total number of students who prefer Cricket or Football is less than those who prefer Basketball or Swimming.

Solution: Read the value for each sport from the bar graph data:\nCricket: 120 students\nFootball: 95 students\nBasketball: 120 students\nBadminton: 75 students\nSwimming: 110 students \nStatement (a): More students prefer Swimming than Football.\nCompare Swimming and Football:\nSwimming: 110, Football: 95.\nSince \( 110 > 95 \), this statement is VALID. \nStatement (b): Cricket and Basketball are equally popular.\nCricket: 120, Basketball: 120.\nSince both values are equal, this statement is VALID. \nStatement (c): Badminton is the most preferred sport.\nBadminton has 75 students, which is the lowest value among all sports. The most preferred sports are Cricket and Basketball (both 120).\nThis statement is INVALID. \nStatement (d): The total number of students who prefer Cricket or Football is less than those who prefer Basketball or Swimming.\nCricket + Football: \( 120 + 95 = 215 \)\nBasketball + Swimming: \( 120 + 110 = 230 \)\nSince \( 215 < 230 \), this statement is VALID.

Answer: (a) Valid, (b) Valid, (c) Invalid, (d) Valid

Example 2

Question: A shopkeeper recorded the number of items sold in a week across five categories: Stationery — 340, Snacks — 510, Toys — 270, Books — 510, Electronics — 420. \nBased on this data, determine whether each statement is valid or invalid: (a) The number of Snacks sold equals the number of Books sold. (b) More Electronics were sold than Toys. (c) Stationery items sold were more than Books. (d) The combined sales of Stationery and Toys exceeded the sales of Electronics alone.

Solution: Read the sales figures for each category:\nStationery: 340, Snacks: 510, Toys: 270, Books: 510, Electronics: 420. \nStatement (a): The number of Snacks sold equals the number of Books sold.\nSnacks: 510, Books: 510.\nSince both values are equal, this statement is VALID. \nStatement (b): More Electronics were sold than Toys.\nElectronics: 420, Toys: 270.\nSince \( 420 > 270 \), this statement is VALID. \nStatement (c): Stationery items sold were more than Books.\nStationery: 340, Books: 510.\nSince \( 340 < 510 \), stationery sales are NOT more than books. This statement is INVALID. \nStatement (d): The combined sales of Stationery and Toys exceeded the sales of Electronics alone.\nStationery + Toys: \( 340 + 270 = 610 \)\nElectronics: 420.\nSince \( 610 > 420 \), this statement is VALID.

Answer: (a) Valid, (b) Valid, (c) Invalid, (d) Valid

🎯 Try a Similar Question

Try a Similar Question

Question: A line graph shows the percentage of students in different age groups who own a smartphone. The graph shows that 80% of students aged 13–14 own a smartphone, while only 55% of students aged 17–18 own a smartphone. A student looks at this graph and concludes: 'There are more students aged 13–14 who own a smartphone than students aged 17–18 who own a smartphone.' Is this conclusion valid? Explain your reasoning.

Solution

  1. Step 1: Understand what the graph shows: The line graph displays the percentage of students in each age group who own a smartphone. For example, it shows that \( 80\% \) of students aged 13–14 own a smartphone, and \( 55\% \) of students aged 17–18 own a smartphone.
  2. Step 2: Identify what information is missing: To find the actual number of students who own a smartphone, we need two pieces of information: the percentage AND the total number of students in that age group. The graph only gives us the percentage; it does NOT tell us the total number of students in each age group.
  3. Step 3: Use a counter-example to test the conclusion: Suppose the total number of students aged 13–14 is 100, and the total number of students aged 17–18 is 500. Then, the number of students aged 13–14 who own a smartphone is \( 80\% \times 100 = 80 \). The number of students aged 17–18 who own a smartphone is \( 55\% \times 500 = 275 \). So there are actually MORE students aged 17–18 who own a smartphone (275) than students aged 13–14 (80), even though the percentage is lower for the 17–18 group.
  4. Step 4: State the conclusion: Since the graph shows only percentages and not the actual total number of students in each age group, we cannot determine which age group has more students who own a smartphone. The student's conclusion is NOT valid.

Answer: The conclusion is NOT valid. The graph only shows the percentage of students who own a smartphone within each age group. Without knowing the total number of students in each age group, it is impossible to compare the actual counts. A smaller percentage of a much larger group can still represent a greater number of people than a larger percentage of a smaller group.

Everything you get with Solver7

More questions in Fractions In Disguise