SOLVER7 Study. Nothing Else.
Figure It Out 4 Q6

Giridhar borrows a loan of ₹\(12,500\) at \(12\%\) per annum for \(3\) years without compounding and Raghava borrows the same amount for the same time period at \(10\%\) per annum, compounded annually. Who pays more interest and by how much\(?\)

CBSE Class 8 Maths · Fractions In Disguise

Solution

👶 Simple Explanation

Simple Explanation

Imagine two friends both borrow the same amount of money. Giridhar pays a fixed extra charge every year — like a flat fee that never changes. Raghava pays a smaller fee, but each year his fee grows a little because it is calculated on a bigger pile. You might think Raghava ends up paying more, but the numbers tell a different story! Giridhar's higher rate means he ends up paying more in total, even though his interest does not grow each year.

Answer: Giridhar pays more interest. He pays \( \text{Rs } 4500 \) while Raghava pays \( \text{Rs } 4137.50 \), so Giridhar pays \( \text{Rs } 362.50 \) more.

📖 Comparing Simple Interest and Compound Interest

Detailed Explanation

In simple interest, the interest is calculated only on the original principal for the whole time. It stays the same every year. In compound interest, the interest of each year is added to the principal, so the next year's interest is calculated on a bigger amount. Because of this 'interest on interest' effect, compound interest usually gives a larger amount than simple interest for the same conditions. Giridhar's loan is 'without compounding' (simple interest) while Raghava's loan is 'compounded annually' (compound interest). We calculate each interest separately and then compare.

Formula Used

Simple Interest: \( SI = \frac{P \times R \times T}{100} \). Compound Interest amount: \( A = P\left(1 + \frac{R}{100}\right)^{T} \), and \( CI = A - P \).

Solution

  1. Step 1: Write down what is given. Giridhar: \( P = 12500 \), \( R = 12\% \), \( T = 3 \) years, simple interest. Raghava: \( P = 12500 \), \( R = 10\% \), \( T = 3 \) years, compounded annually.
  2. Step 2: Find Giridhar's simple interest using the formula. \[ SI = \frac{P \times R \times T}{100} \] Substituting the values: \[ SI = \frac{12500 \times 12 \times 3}{100} \] \[ SI = \frac{450000}{100} = 4500 \] So Giridhar pays interest of \( \text{Rs } 4500 \).
  3. Step 3: Find Raghava's compound amount using the CI formula. \[ A = P\left(1 + \frac{R}{100}\right)^{T} \] Substituting the values: \[ A = 12500\left(1 + \frac{10}{100}\right)^{3} \] \[ A = 12500\left(\frac{11}{10}\right)^{3} \]
  4. Step 4: Simplify the power and multiply. \[ \left(\frac{11}{10}\right)^{3} = \frac{1331}{1000} \] So the amount is: \[ A = 12500 \times \frac{1331}{1000} \] \[ A = 12.5 \times 1331 = 16637.5 \] Thus \( A = \text{Rs } 16637.50 \).
  5. Step 5: Find Raghava's compound interest by subtracting the principal. \[ CI = A - P \] \[ CI = 16637.50 - 12500 = 4137.50 \] So Raghava pays interest of \( \text{Rs } 4137.50 \).
  6. Step 6: Compare the two interests. Giridhar's interest is \( \text{Rs } 4500 \) and Raghava's interest is \( \text{Rs } 4137.50 \). Since \( 4500 > 4137.50 \), Giridhar pays more. Find the difference: \[ 4500 - 4137.50 = 362.50 \]

Final Answer

Giridhar pays more interest. He pays \( \text{Rs } 4500 \) while Raghava pays \( \text{Rs } 4137.50 \), so Giridhar pays \( \text{Rs } 362.50 \) more.

Common Mistake

A common mistake is to assume compound interest is always larger, so students forget that Giridhar's higher rate (12%) can beat Raghava's lower rate (10%) even though CI grows faster. Always calculate both amounts and compare the actual numbers instead of guessing.

🪜 Step-by-step Solution

Step-by-step Solution

  1. Step 1: List the given information for both borrowers. Giridhar: Principal \( P = \text{Rs } 12500 \), Rate \( R = 12\% \), Time \( T = 3 \) years, Simple Interest. Raghava: Principal \( P = \text{Rs } 12500 \), Rate \( R = 10\% \), Time \( T = 3 \) years, Compounded Annually. — Reason: Organising the known values clearly prevents confusion when we plug numbers into two different formulas.
  2. Step 2: Apply the Simple Interest formula for Giridhar. \[ SI = \frac{P \times R \times T}{100} \] Substituting \( P = 12500 \), \( R = 12 \), \( T = 3 \): \[ SI = \frac{12500 \times 12 \times 3}{100} \] \[ SI = \frac{450000}{100} = 4500 \] So Giridhar's interest is \( \text{Rs } 4500 \). — Reason: With simple interest the rate is always applied to the original \( \text{Rs } 12500 \), never to a larger growing amount.
  3. Step 3: Set up the Compound Interest formula for Raghava. \[ A = P\left(1 + \frac{R}{100}\right)^{T} \] Substituting \( P = 12500 \), \( R = 10 \), \( T = 3 \): \[ A = 12500 \times \left(1 + \frac{10}{100}\right)^{3} \] \[ A = 12500 \times \left(\frac{11}{10}\right)^{3} \] — Reason: We convert \( 1 + \frac{10}{100} \) to the fraction \( \frac{11}{10} \) so that the arithmetic with the cube is easier to handle.
  4. Step 4: Evaluate the cube \( \left(\frac{11}{10}\right)^{3} \). \[ \left(\frac{11}{10}\right)^{3} = \frac{11^{3}}{10^{3}} = \frac{1331}{1000} \] — Reason: Cubing the numerator and denominator separately keeps the numbers small and easy to multiply.
  5. Step 5: Multiply to find Raghava's total repayment amount \( A \). \[ A = 12500 \times \frac{1331}{1000} \] \[ A = \frac{12500 \times 1331}{1000} = \frac{16637500}{1000} = 16637.50 \] So Raghava repays a total of \( \text{Rs } 16637.50 \). — Reason: Multiplying the principal by the compound factor gives the full amount owed after 3 years.
  6. Step 6: Find Raghava's actual interest by subtracting the original principal. \[ CI = A - P = 16637.50 - 12500 = 4137.50 \] So Raghava's interest is \( \text{Rs } 4137.50 \). — Reason: The interest is only the extra amount paid beyond the principal, so we remove the original \( \text{Rs } 12500 \).
  7. Step 7: Compare the two interest amounts. Giridhar pays \( \text{Rs } 4500 \) and Raghava pays \( \text{Rs } 4137.50 \). Difference: \[ 4500 - 4137.50 = 362.50 \] — Reason: A direct subtraction tells us who pays more and by exactly how much.

Final Answer

Giridhar pays more interest. He pays \( \text{Rs } 4500 \) while Raghava pays \( \text{Rs } 4137.50 \), so Giridhar pays \( \text{Rs } 362.50 \) more.

Common Mistake

One common mistake: Students assume compound interest always produces a higher interest amount than simple interest. Here, Giridhar's simple interest is actually larger because his rate (12%) is higher than Raghava's compound rate (10%), showing that a higher rate can outweigh the compounding effect over just 3 years.

✍️ Exam-ready Answer

Exam-ready Answer

  1. Step 1: Giridhar: \( P = 12500 \), \( R = 12\% \), \( T = 3 \) yrs (SI); Raghava: \( P = 12500 \), \( R = 10\% \), \( T = 3 \) yrs (CI)
  2. Step 2: Giridhar's SI: \[ SI = \frac{12500 \times 12 \times 3}{100} = \frac{450000}{100} = 4500 \]
  3. Step 3: Raghava's CI: \[ A = 12500 \times \left(\frac{11}{10}\right)^{3} = 12500 \times \frac{1331}{1000} = \frac{16637.5}{1} = 16637.50 \] so \( CI = 16637.50 - 12500 = 4137.50 \)
  4. Step 4: Difference: \( 4500 - 4137.50 = 362.50 \)

Answer: Giridhar pays more interest. He pays \( \text{Rs } 4500 \) while Raghava pays \( \text{Rs } 4137.50 \), so Giridhar pays \( \text{Rs } 362.50 \) more.

➕ More Examples

More Examples

Example 1

Question: Meena takes a loan of ₹15,000 at 8% per annum simple interest for 3 years. Her friend Kavya borrows the same amount for the same period at 9% per annum, compounded annually. Who pays more interest and by how much?

Solution: Step 1: Find Meena's Simple Interest. Principal \( P = 15000 \), Rate \( R = 8\% \), Time \( T = 3 \) years. \[ SI = \frac{P \times R \times T}{100} = \frac{15000 \times 8 \times 3}{100} \] \[ SI = \frac{360000}{100} = 3600 \] So Meena pays \( SI = \) ₹3600. Step 2: Find Kavya's Compound Interest. Principal \( P = 15000 \), Rate \( R = 9\% \), Time \( T = 3 \) years. Amount after 1st year: \[ A_1 = 15000 \times \left(1 + \frac{9}{100}\right) = 15000 \times 1.09 = 16350 \] Amount after 2nd year: \[ A_2 = 16350 \times 1.09 = 17821.50 \] Amount after 3rd year: \[ A_3 = 17821.50 \times 1.09 = 19425.435 \approx 19425.44 \] Compound Interest: \[ CI = A_3 - P = 19425.44 - 15000 = 4425.44 \] So Kavya pays \( CI \approx \) ₹4425.44. Step 3: Compare. \[ 4425.44 - 3600 = 825.44 \] Kavya pays more interest. The difference is ₹825.44.

Answer: Kavya (compound interest at 9%) pays more interest than Meena (simple interest at 8%) by ₹825.44.

Example 2

Question: Arjun deposits ₹20,000 in a scheme that offers 10% per annum simple interest for 2 years. His brother Suresh deposits the same amount for the same period in a bank offering 11% per annum, compounded annually. At the end of 2 years, who earns more interest and by how much?

Solution: Step 1: Find Arjun's Simple Interest. Principal \( P = 20000 \), Rate \( R = 10\% \), Time \( T = 2 \) years. \[ SI = \frac{P \times R \times T}{100} = \frac{20000 \times 10 \times 2}{100} \] \[ SI = \frac{400000}{100} = 4000 \] Arjun earns \( SI = \) ₹4000. Step 2: Find Suresh's Compound Interest. Principal \( P = 20000 \), Rate \( R = 11\% \), Time \( T = 2 \) years. Amount after 1st year: \[ A_1 = 20000 \times \left(1 + \frac{11}{100}\right) = 20000 \times 1.11 = 22200 \] Amount after 2nd year: \[ A_2 = 22200 \times 1.11 = 24642 \] Compound Interest: \[ CI = A_2 - P = 24642 - 20000 = 4642 \] Suresh earns \( CI = \) ₹4642. Step 3: Compare. \[ 4642 - 4000 = 642 \] Suresh earns more interest. The difference is ₹642.

Answer: Suresh (compound interest at 11%) earns more interest than Arjun (simple interest at 10%) by ₹642.

🎯 Try a Similar Question

Try a Similar Question

Question: Meena borrows ₹15,000 at 11% per annum simple interest for 3 years. Her friend Seema borrows the same amount for the same period at 12% per annum, compounded annually. Who pays more interest and by how much?

Solution

  1. Step 1: Calculate Simple Interest paid by Meena: Principal \( P = 15000 \), Rate \( R = 11\% \) per annum, Time \( T = 3 \) years. Using the formula \( SI = \frac{P \times R \times T}{100} \): \[ SI = \frac{15000 \times 11 \times 3}{100} \] \[ SI = \frac{4{,}95{,}000}{100} = 4950 \] So Meena pays ₹4,950 as interest.
  2. Step 2: Calculate Compound Interest paid by Seema — Year 1: Principal at the start of Year 1 \( = 15000 \), Rate \( R = 12\% \) per annum. Interest for Year 1: \[ I_1 = \frac{15000 \times 12}{100} = 1800 \] Amount at end of Year 1: \[ A_1 = 15000 + 1800 = 16800 \]
  3. Step 3: Compound Interest — Year 2: Principal for Year 2 \( = 16800 \). Interest for Year 2: \[ I_2 = \frac{16800 \times 12}{100} = 2016 \] Amount at end of Year 2: \[ A_2 = 16800 + 2016 = 18816 \]
  4. Step 4: Compound Interest — Year 3: Principal for Year 3 \( = 18816 \). Interest for Year 3: \[ I_3 = \frac{18816 \times 12}{100} = 2257.92 \] Amount at end of Year 3: \[ A_3 = 18816 + 2257.92 = 21073.92 \]
  5. Step 5: Total Compound Interest paid by Seema: Total CI paid by Seema: \[ CI = A_3 - P = 21073.92 - 15000 = 6073.92 \] So Seema pays ₹6,073.92 as interest.
  6. Step 6: Compare the two amounts: Meena pays ₹4,950 (Simple Interest) and Seema pays ₹6,073.92 (Compound Interest). Difference: \[ 6073.92 - 4950 = 1123.92 \] Seema pays more interest than Meena by ₹1,123.92.

Answer: Seema pays more interest. She pays \( \text{Rs } 6073.92 \) while Meena pays \( \text{Rs } 4950 \), so Seema pays \( \text{Rs } 1123.92 \) more.

Everything you get with Solver7

More questions in Fractions In Disguise