SOLVER7 Study. Nothing Else.
Figure It Out 4 Q3

(Question Reference)
Bank of Yahapur offers an interest of \(10\%\) p.a. Compare how much one gets if they deposit ₹\(20,000\) for a period of \(2\) years with compounding and without compounding annually.
Bank of Wahapur offers an interest of \(5\%\) p.a. Compare how much one gets if one deposits ₹\(20,000\) for a period of \(4\) years with compounding and without compounding annually.
Do you observe anything interesting in the solutions of the two questions above\(?\) Share and discuss.

CBSE Class 8 Maths · Fractions In Disguise

Solution

👶 Simple Explanation

Simple Explanation

Imagine you put money in a piggy bank that gives you a gift every year. One bank gives you the same gift each year, based only on what you started with. Another bank gives you a gift based on everything inside, including last year's gift. Both banks here give you the same gift amount when interest is simple. But when interest is added on top of interest, the bank with more time grows your money a little more. So more compounding means more money at the end!

Answer: Bank of Yahapur: without compounding \( 24000 \), with compounding \( 24200 \). Bank of Wahapur: without compounding \( 24000 \), with compounding about \( 24310.13 \). Interesting point: both simple interest amounts are equal (\( 24000 \)) since \( R \times T = 20 \) in each case, but the compound amounts differ, with more frequent/longer compounding (Wahapur) giving slightly more.

📖 Comparing Compound and Simple Interest

Detailed Explanation

When money is deposited in a bank, it earns interest. There are two ways interest can be added. In simple interest (without compounding), interest is calculated only on the original amount (the principal) every year, so the interest stays the same each year. In compound interest (with compounding annually), the interest earned each year is added to the principal, and the next year's interest is calculated on this new, larger amount. This is why compound interest always gives more money than simple interest for the same rate and time (for more than one year). In these two problems we compare the total amount received under both methods for two banks with different rates and times.

Formula Used

Simple Interest: \( SI = \frac{P \times R \times T}{100} \), so Amount \( = P + SI \). Compound Interest (annually): Amount \( A = P\left(1 + \frac{R}{100}\right)^{T} \), and \( CI = A - P \).

Solution

  1. Step 1: Bank of Yahapur (without compounding). Here principal \( P = 20000 \), rate \( R = 10\% \) and time \( T = 2 \) years. Using simple interest: \[ SI = \frac{20000 \times 10 \times 2}{100} = 4000 \] So the amount received is \[ 20000 + 4000 = 24000 \]
  2. Step 2: Bank of Yahapur (with compounding annually). Using the compound interest amount formula with \( P = 20000 \), \( R = 10\% \), \( T = 2 \): \[ A = 20000\left(1 + \frac{10}{100}\right)^{2} \] \[ A = 20000\left(\frac{11}{10}\right)^{2} = 20000 \times \frac{121}{100} = 24200 \] So with compounding, the amount is \( 24200 \).
  3. Step 3: Compare for Yahapur. Without compounding you get \( 24000 \), and with compounding you get \( 24200 \). The extra \( 200 \) comes from earning interest on the first year's interest of \( 2000 \); that is \( 10\% \) of \( 2000 = 200 \).
  4. Step 4: Bank of Wahapur (without compounding). Here \( P = 20000 \), \( R = 5\% \), \( T = 4 \) years. Using simple interest: \[ SI = \frac{20000 \times 5 \times 4}{100} = 4000 \] So the amount received is \[ 20000 + 4000 = 24000 \]
  5. Step 5: Bank of Wahapur (with compounding annually). Using the amount formula with \( P = 20000 \), \( R = 5\% \), \( T = 4 \): \[ A = 20000\left(1 + \frac{5}{100}\right)^{4} \] \[ A = 20000\left(\frac{21}{20}\right)^{4} \] Compute step by step: \[ \left(\frac{21}{20}\right)^{2} = \frac{441}{400} \] \[ \left(\frac{441}{400}\right)^{2} = \frac{194481}{160000} \] \[ A = 20000 \times \frac{194481}{160000} = 24310.125 \] So with compounding, the amount is about \( 24310.13 \).
  6. Step 6: The interesting observation. In both banks the simple interest amount is exactly the same, \( 24000 \). This is because for Yahapur \( 10\% \times 2 \) years and for Wahapur \( 5\% \times 4 \) years both give the same total \( R \times T = 20 \). But the compound amounts are different: Yahapur gives \( 24200 \) and Wahapur gives \( 24310.13 \). Even though the simple interest is equal, compounding at a smaller rate over more years earns a bit more, because interest keeps being added over more compounding periods.

Final Answer

Bank of Yahapur: without compounding \( 24000 \), with compounding \( 24200 \). Bank of Wahapur: without compounding \( 24000 \), with compounding about \( 24310.13 \). Interesting point: both simple interest amounts are equal (\( 24000 \)) since \( R \times T = 20 \) in each case, but the compound amounts differ, with more frequent/longer compounding (Wahapur) giving slightly more.

Common Mistake

A common mistake is calculating compound interest as if it were simple interest, that is, just multiplying the first year's interest by the number of years. Compound interest requires the amount formula \( A = P\left(1 + \frac{R}{100}\right)^{T} \) because each year's interest is calculated on the updated principal, not on the original principal alone.

🪜 Step-by-step Solution

Step-by-step Solution

  1. Step 1: Identify the given values for Bank of Yahapur: Principal \( P = 20000 \), Rate \( R = 10\% \) per year, Time \( T = 2 \) years. — Reason: Writing down known values first prevents errors while substituting into formulas.
  2. Step 2: Calculate Simple Interest for Bank of Yahapur (without compounding): \[SI = \frac{20000 \times 10 \times 2}{100} = \frac{400000}{100} = 4000\] So the total amount received is \[20000 + 4000 = 24000\] — Reason: In simple interest, the rate applies only to the original principal each year, so we use the straightforward SI formula.
  3. Step 3: Calculate Compound Interest for Bank of Yahapur (with annual compounding): \[A = 20000 \times \left(1 + \frac{10}{100}\right)^{2} = 20000 \times \left(\frac{11}{10}\right)^{2} = 20000 \times \frac{121}{100} = 24200\] — Reason: Each year the interest is added back to the principal, so the second year's interest is calculated on a larger amount, giving a higher final value than simple interest.
  4. Step 4: Identify the given values for Bank of Wahapur: Principal \( P = 20000 \), Rate \( R = 4\% \) per year, Time \( T = 5 \) years. Notice that \( R \times T = 4 \times 5 = 20 \), the same product as for Yahapur (\( 10 \times 2 = 20 \)). — Reason: Spotting this equal product tells us the simple interest amounts will be identical for both banks.
  5. Step 5: Calculate Simple Interest for Bank of Wahapur (without compounding): \[SI = \frac{20000 \times 4 \times 5}{100} = \frac{400000}{100} = 4000\] So the total amount is \[20000 + 4000 = 24000\] — Reason: Confirming that both banks give the same simple interest amount (\( 24000 \)) because \( R \times T \) is equal in both cases.
  6. Step 6: Calculate Compound Interest for Bank of Wahapur (with annual compounding): \[A = 20000 \times \left(1 + \frac{4}{100}\right)^{5} = 20000 \times \left(\frac{104}{100}\right)^{5} = 20000 \times (1.04)^{5}\] Now, \( (1.04)^{5} \approx 1.21551 \), so \[A \approx 20000 \times 1.21551 \approx 24310.13\] — Reason: Over 5 years at 4%, compounding has more cycles to build on, leading to a larger final amount than Yahapur's 2-year compounding, even though simple interest was the same.
  7. Step 7: Compare the results side by side. Bank of Yahapur: without compounding \( 24000 \), with compounding \( 24200 \). Bank of Wahapur: without compounding \( 24000 \), with compounding \( \approx 24310.13 \). The difference in compound amounts (\( 24310.13 - 24200 = 110.13 \)) arises because Wahapur compounds over more periods. — Reason: More compounding periods allow interest to grow on interest for longer, consistently increasing the final amount.

Final Answer

Bank of Yahapur: without compounding \( 24000 \), with compounding \( 24200 \). Bank of Wahapur: without compounding \( 24000 \), with compounding about \( 24310.13 \). Interesting point: both simple interest amounts are equal (\( 24000 \)) since \( R \times T = 20 \) in each case, but the compound amounts differ, with more frequent/longer compounding (Wahapur) giving slightly more.

Common Mistake

One common mistake: students often use the compound interest formula \( A = P\left(1 + \frac{R}{100}\right)^{T} \) but forget to raise the entire bracket to the power \( T \), writing it as \( P \times \left(1 + \frac{R}{100} \times T\right) \) instead — this gives the simple interest amount, not the compound amount.

✍️ Exam-ready Answer

Exam-ready Answer

  1. Bank of Yahapur — Without Compounding: Given: \( P = 20000 \), \( R = 10\% \), \( T = 2 \) years. Amount \( = 20000 + \frac{20000 \times 10 \times 2}{100} = 20000 + 4000 = 24000 \)
  2. Bank of Yahapur — With Compounding: \( A = 20000\left(1 + \frac{10}{100}\right)^{2} = 20000 \times \frac{121}{100} = 24200 \)
  3. Bank of Wahapur — Without Compounding: Given: \( P = 20000 \), \( R = 4\% \), \( T = 5 \) years. Amount \( = 20000 + \frac{20000 \times 4 \times 5}{100} = 20000 + 4000 = 24000 \)
  4. Bank of Wahapur — With Compounding: \( A = 20000\left(1 + \frac{4}{100}\right)^{5} = 20000 \times (1.04)^{5} = 20000 \times 1.21665... \approx 24310.13 \)

Answer: Bank of Yahapur: without compounding \( 24000 \), with compounding \( 24200 \). Bank of Wahapur: without compounding \( 24000 \), with compounding about \( 24310.13 \). Interesting point: both simple interest amounts are equal (\( 24000 \)) since \( R \times T = 20 \) in each case, but the compound amounts differ, with more frequent/longer compounding (Wahapur) giving slightly more.

➕ More Examples

More Examples

Example 1

Question: A bank offers an interest rate of \( 8\% \) per annum. Ravi deposits \( ₹15{,}000 \) for \( 3 \) years. Compare the total amount he receives under Simple Interest and Compound Interest (compounded annually). By how much does CI exceed SI?

Solution: Given: Principal \( P = ₹15{,}000 \), Rate \( R = 8\% \) p.a., Time \( T = 3 \) years. Step 1 — Amount under Simple Interest: Simple Interest is calculated as: \[ SI = \frac{P \times R \times T}{100} \] Substituting the values: \[ SI = \frac{15000 \times 8 \times 3}{100} = \frac{3{,}60{,}000}{100} = ₹3{,}600 \] Amount under SI: \[ A_{SI} = P + SI = 15000 + 3600 = ₹18{,}600 \] Step 2 — Amount under Compound Interest (compounded annually): Using the compound interest formula: \[ A_{CI} = P \left(1 + \frac{R}{100}\right)^T \] Substituting the values: \[ A_{CI} = 15000 \times \left(1 + \frac{8}{100}\right)^3 = 15000 \times \left(\frac{108}{100}\right)^3 \] Calculating \( \left(\frac{108}{100}\right)^3 \): \[ \frac{108}{100} = 1.08 \] \[ 1.08^2 = 1.1664 \] \[ 1.08^3 = 1.1664 \times 1.08 = 1.259712 \] So: \[ A_{CI} = 15000 \times 1.259712 = ₹18{,}895.68 \] Compound Interest earned: \[ CI = A_{CI} - P = 18895.68 - 15000 = ₹3{,}895.68 \] Step 3 — Difference between CI and SI: \[ \text{Difference} = CI - SI = 3895.68 - 3600 = ₹295.68 \] So, with compounding, Ravi earns \( ₹295.68 \) more than with simple interest over 3 years.

Answer: Amount under SI = ₹18,600; Amount under CI = ₹18,895.68; CI exceeds SI by ₹295.68.

Example 2

Question: Bank A offers \( 12\% \) p.a. simple interest and compound interest (compounded annually). Priya deposits \( ₹25{,}000 \) for \( 2 \) years at Bank A. Bank B offers \( 6\% \) p.a. simple interest and compound interest (compounded annually) on the same deposit of \( ₹25{,}000 \) but for \( 4 \) years. Compare the amounts received under both banks with and without compounding. What interesting observation do you notice?

Solution: Given: Principal \( P = ₹25{,}000 \) for both banks. Bank A: Rate \( R_A = 12\% \) p.a., Time \( T_A = 2 \) years. Bank B: Rate \( R_B = 6\% \) p.a., Time \( T_B = 4 \) years. For Bank A — Simple Interest: \[ SI_A = \frac{25000 \times 12 \times 2}{100} = \frac{6{,}00{,}000}{100} = ₹6{,}000 \] Amount: \[ A_{SI,A} = 25000 + 6000 = ₹31{,}000 \] For Bank A — Compound Interest: \[ A_{CI,A} = 25000 \times \left(1 + \frac{12}{100}\right)^2 = 25000 \times \left(\frac{112}{100}\right)^2 \] \[ \left(\frac{112}{100}\right)^2 = \frac{12544}{10000} = 1.2544 \] \[ A_{CI,A} = 25000 \times 1.2544 = ₹31{,}360 \] CI earned at Bank A: \[ CI_A = 31360 - 25000 = ₹6{,}360 \] For Bank B — Simple Interest: \[ SI_B = \frac{25000 \times 6 imes 4}{100} = \frac{6{,}00{,}000}{100} = ₹6{,}000 \] Amount: \[ A_{SI,B} = 25000 + 6000 = ₹31{,}000 \] For Bank B — Compound Interest: \[ A_{CI,B} = 25000 imes \left(1 + \frac{6}{100}\right)^4 = 25000 \times \left(\frac{106}{100}\right)^4 \] \[ \left(\frac{106}{100}\right)^2 = \frac{11236}{10000} = 1.1236 \] \[ \left(\frac{106}{100}\right)^4 = 1.1236^2 = 1.26247696 \] \[ A_{CI,B} = 25000 \times 1.26247696 \approx ₹31{,}561.92 \] CI earned at Bank B: \[ CI_B = 31561.92 - 25000 = ₹6{,}561.92 \] Summary Table: Bank A (12%, 2 yrs): SI Amount = ₹31,000; CI Amount = ₹31,360. Bank B (6%, 4 yrs): SI Amount = ₹31,000; CI Amount = ₹31,561.92. Interesting Observation: The Simple Interest amount is exactly the same (₹31,000) for both banks, because the product \( R \times T \) is the same in both cases: \( 12 \times 2 = 24 \) and \( 6 \times 4 = 24 \). However, the Compound Interest amount is higher for Bank B (lower rate, longer time), showing that compounding over a longer period gives greater returns even at half the interest rate.

Answer: Both banks give the same SI amount of ₹31,000. CI amount at Bank A (12%, 2 yrs) = ₹31,360; CI amount at Bank B (6%, 4 yrs) ≈ ₹31,561.92. Observation: Same SI, but longer compounding period at lower rate gives higher CI.

🎯 Try a Similar Question

Try a Similar Question

Question: Bank A offers an interest rate of \( 15\% \) per annum. Ramesh deposits ₹ 15,000 for 2 years. Bank B offers an interest rate of \( 6\% \) per annum. Seema deposits ₹ 15,000 for 5 years. For each deposit, calculate the amount received (i) without compounding (simple interest) and (ii) with annual compounding. Do you notice anything interesting about the simple interest amounts? Which bank gives a higher amount under compound interest, and why?

Solution

  1. Step 1 – Identify values for both banks: Bank A: Principal \( P = 15000 \), Rate \( R = 15\% \) p.a., Time \( T = 2 \) years. Notice \( R \times T = 15 \times 2 = 30 \). Bank B: Principal \( P = 15000 \), Rate \( R = 6\% \) p.a., Time \( T = 5 \) years. Notice \( R \times T = 6 \times 5 = 30 \). Both products are equal.
  2. Step 2 – Simple Interest for Bank A: Using \( SI = \frac{P \times R \times T}{100} \): \[ SI_A = \frac{15000 \times 15 \times 2}{100} = \frac{450000}{100} = 4500 \] Amount without compounding for Bank A: \[ A_A^{SI} = 15000 + 4500 = 19500 \]
  3. Step 3 – Simple Interest for Bank B: Using \( SI = \frac{P \times R \times T}{100} \): \[ SI_B = \frac{15000 \times 6 \times 5}{100} = \frac{450000}{100} = 4500 \] Amount without compounding for Bank B: \[ A_B^{SI} = 15000 + 4500 = 19500 \] Both simple interest amounts are equal because \( R \times T \) is the same in both cases.
  4. Step 4 – Compound Interest for Bank A: Using \( A = P \left(1 + \frac{R}{100}\right)^{T} \): \[ A_A^{CI} = 15000 \times \left(1 + \frac{15}{100}\right)^{2} = 15000 \times (1.15)^{2} \] We compute \( (1.15)^{2} = 1.3225 \). So: \[ A_A^{CI} = 15000 \times 1.3225 = 19837.50 \]
  5. Step 5 – Compound Interest for Bank B: Using \( A = P \left(1 + \frac{R}{100}\right)^{T} \): \[ A_B^{CI} = 15000 \times \left(1 + \frac{6}{100}\right)^{5} = 15000 \times (1.06)^{5} \] We compute step by step. \( (1.06)^{1} = 1.06 \), \( (1.06)^{2} = 1.1236 \), \( (1.06)^{3} = 1.191016 \), \( (1.06)^{4} = 1.26247696 \), \( (1.06)^{5} = 1.3382255776 \). So: \[ A_B^{CI} = 15000 \times 1.3382255776 \approx 20073.38 \]
  6. Step 6 – Compare and Observe: Summary of results: Simple Interest — Bank A gives ₹ 19500 and Bank B also gives ₹ 19500, which are equal. Compound Interest — Bank A gives ₹ 19837.50 and Bank B gives approximately ₹ 20073.38. Even though both banks give the same simple interest amount (because \( R \times T = 30 \) in both cases), Bank B gives a higher compound interest amount. This is because compounding over a longer period (5 years) at a lower rate still accumulates more interest-on-interest than compounding over a shorter period (2 years) at a higher rate, when \( R \times T \) is equal.

Answer: Without compounding (SI): Both Bank A and Bank B give an amount of ₹ 19500. With annual compounding (CI): Bank A gives ₹ 19837.50 and Bank B gives approximately ₹ 20073.38. The interesting observation is that both simple interest amounts are equal (since \( R \times T = 30 \) in each case), but the compound interest amounts differ — Bank B, with the longer compounding period, gives a higher amount.

Everything you get with Solver7

More questions in Fractions In Disguise