SOLVER7 Study. Nothing Else.
Figure It Out 3 Q12(vi)

Which of the following statement(s) mean the same as — \(\text{“}\)The demand for cameras has fallen by \(85\%\) in the last decade\(\text{”}?\) The demand now is \(185\%\) of the demand a decade ago.

CBSE Class 8 Maths · Fractions In Disguise

Solution

👶 Simple Explanation

Simple Explanation

Imagine you have 100 chocolates. A fall of 85% means you lose 85 chocolates and only 15 are left. So the new amount is just 15% of what you started with. Saying demand is now 185% of the old demand would mean it actually grew bigger, like having 185 chocolates instead of 100. A fall always makes the number smaller, not bigger.

Answer: No, the statement does NOT mean the same thing. A fall of \( 85\% \) makes the new demand \( 100\% - 85\% = 15\% \) of the old demand, not \( 185\% \).

📖 Understanding a Fall of 85% in Demand

Detailed Explanation

When a quantity falls (decreases) by a certain percentage, we subtract that percentage from the original amount. The original amount is always taken as \( 100\% \). If demand falls by \( 85\% \), it means \( 85\% \) of the original demand is lost, so only the remaining part is left. To find what the new demand is as a percentage of the old demand, we do \( 100\% - (\text{fall}) \). A fall means the new value must be LESS than \( 100\% \) of the old value, not more.

Formula Used

\[ \text{New value as percent of old} = 100\% - (\text{percent fall}) \]

Solution

  1. Step 1: Treat the demand a decade ago as the base amount, which equals \( 100\% \).
  2. Step 2: The demand fell by \( 85\% \). A fall means we remove \( 85\% \) from the original \( 100\% \).
  3. Step 3: Calculate the remaining demand: \[ 100\% - 85\% = 15\% \] So the demand now is only \( 15\% \) of the demand a decade ago.
  4. Step 4: Compare this with the given statement, which claims the demand now is \( 185\% \) of the old demand. Since \( 185\% \) is greater than \( 100\% \), it would mean the demand INCREASED, not fell.
  5. Step 5: Because a fall of \( 85\% \) gives \( 15\% \) (a decrease), and the statement gives \( 185\% \) (an increase), the two do NOT mean the same thing.
  6. Step 6: The correct restatement would be: 'The demand now is \( 15\% \) of the demand a decade ago.'

Final Answer

No, the statement does NOT mean the same thing. A fall of \( 85\% \) makes the new demand \( 100\% - 85\% = 15\% \) of the old demand, not \( 185\% \).

Common Mistake

Students often ADD the percentage fall to \( 100\% \) (getting \( 185\% \)) instead of SUBTRACTING it. Remember: a fall or decrease means you subtract, so the answer must be less than \( 100\% \).

🪜 Step-by-step Solution

Step-by-step Solution

  1. Step 1: Set the demand from a decade ago as the base value equal to \( 100\% \). — Reason: In percentage problems, the original (starting) quantity is always treated as \( 100\% \) so that any change can be measured relative to it.
  2. Step 2: Identify what 'a fall of \( 85\% \)' means: \( 85\% \) of the original demand has been lost or removed. — Reason: The word 'fall' tells us demand went down, so we must subtract \( 85\% \) from \( 100\% \), not add it.
  3. Step 3: Calculate the remaining demand after the fall: \[ 100\% - 85\% = 15\% \] — Reason: Subtracting the percentage fall from \( 100\% \) gives the fraction of the original demand that still exists today.
  4. Step 4: Compare the correct result \( 15\% \) with the value in the given statement, which claims the current demand is \( 185\% \) of the old demand. — Reason: We need to check whether both expressions describe the same situation or different ones.
  5. Step 5: Notice that \( 185\% \) is greater than \( 100\% \), which would mean the demand increased, while \( 15\% \) is less than \( 100\% \), which correctly shows a decrease. — Reason: A percentage above \( 100\% \) implies growth, and a percentage below \( 100\% \) implies shrinkage; these are opposite situations.
  6. Step 6: Conclude that the given statement is incorrect. The correct restatement is: the current demand is \( 15\% \) of the demand a decade ago, not \( 185\% \). — Reason: Since \( 15\% \ne 185\% \), the two statements do NOT mean the same thing.

Final Answer

No, the statement does NOT mean the same thing. A fall of \( 85\% \) makes the new demand \( 100\% - 85\% = 15\% \) of the old demand, not \( 185\% \).

Common Mistake

One common mistake: students mistakenly add the percentage fall to \( 100\% \) (getting \( 185\% \)) instead of subtracting it, confusing a fall with a rise.

✍️ Exam-ready Answer

Exam-ready Answer

  1. Step 1: Base demand (a decade ago) = \( 100\% \); given fall = \( 85\% \)
  2. Step 2: New demand = \( 100\% - 85\% = 15\% \) of old demand
  3. Step 3: The statement claims new demand = \( 185\% \) of old demand, which implies an increase — contradiction.

Answer: No, the statement does NOT mean the same thing. A fall of \( 85\% \) makes the new demand \( 100\% - 85\% = 15\% \) of the old demand, not \( 185\% \).

➕ More Examples

More Examples

Example 1

Question: Which of the following statements means the same as: 'The number of daily newspaper readers has fallen by 60% over the past five years'? (A) The number of readers now is 60% of the number five years ago. (B) The number of readers now is 40% of the number five years ago. (C) The number of readers now is 140% of the number five years ago. (D) The number of readers now is 160% of the number five years ago.

Solution: Let the number of daily newspaper readers five years ago be \( 100 \) (taking it as the base). A fall of 60% means the number of readers has decreased by 60% of the original. Decrease in readers: \[ \frac{60}{100} \times 100 = 60 \] Number of readers now: \[ 100 - 60 = 40 \] Expressing the current number as a percentage of the original: \[ \frac{40}{100} \times 100 = 40\% \] So, the number of readers now is 40% of the number five years ago. Checking option (A): 60% of original — this equals the decrease, not the current value. Incorrect. Checking option (B): 40% of original — this matches our calculation. Correct. Checking option (C): 140% of original — this would mean an increase. Incorrect. Checking option (D): 160% of original — this would also mean an increase. Incorrect. Therefore, statement (B) means the same as the given statement.

Answer: Option (B): The number of readers now is 40% of the number five years ago.

Example 2

Question: Which of the following statements means the same as: 'The sales of electric fans have dropped by 35% this summer compared to last summer'? (A) The sales this summer are 35% of last summer's sales. (B) The sales this summer are 65% of last summer's sales. (C) The sales this summer are 135% of last summer's sales. (D) The sales this summer are 100% of last summer's sales.

Solution: Let last summer's sales of electric fans be \( 100 \) units (taking it as the base). A drop of 35% means sales have decreased by 35% of last summer's value. Decrease in sales: \[ \frac{35}{100} \times 100 = 35 \text{ units} \] Sales this summer: \[ 100 - 35 = 65 \text{ units} \] Expressing this summer's sales as a percentage of last summer's sales: \[ \frac{65}{100} \times 100 = 65\% \] So, sales this summer are 65% of last summer's sales. Checking option (A): 35% of last summer's sales — this equals the amount of decrease, not the remaining sales. Incorrect. Checking option (B): 65% of last summer's sales — this matches our calculation. Correct. Checking option (C): 135% of last summer's sales — this would mean sales increased by 35%. Incorrect. Checking option (D): 100% of last summer's sales — this means no change at all. Incorrect. Therefore, statement (B) means the same as the given statement.

Answer: Option (B): The sales this summer are 65% of last summer's sales.

🎯 Try a Similar Question

Try a Similar Question

Question: Decide whether the following statement means the same as — 'The number of tourists visiting a hill station has dropped by 60% compared to last year.' The statement to check: 'The number of tourists this year is 140% of last year's count.' Does this statement convey the same meaning? Justify your answer.

Solution

  1. Step 1: Understand what 'dropped by 60%' means: A drop of 60% means the number of tourists has decreased by 60% of last year's count. So the tourists this year = last year's count minus 60% of last year's count.
  2. Step 2: Calculate this year's count as a percentage of last year's count: This year's count as a percentage of last year's count is: \[ 100\% - 60\% = 40\% \] So this year's tourist count is only \( 40\% \) of last year's count.
  3. Step 3: Check the given statement: The statement claims the tourist count this year is \( 140\% \) of last year's count. But we calculated it should be \( 40\% \) of last year's count.
  4. Step 4: Explain the error in the statement: A value of \( 140\% \) would mean the count has actually INCREASED by \( 40\% \) compared to last year, because \( 140\% = 100\% + 40\% \). This is the opposite of a drop. The correct percentage is \( 40\% \), not \( 140\% \).
  5. Step 5: Conclusion: The given statement does NOT mean the same thing. A drop of \( 60\% \) makes this year's tourist count \( 100\% - 60\% = 40\% \) of last year's count, not \( 140\% \).

Answer: No, the statement does NOT mean the same thing. A drop of \( 60\% \) means this year's tourist count is \( 100\% - 60\% = 40\% \) of last year's count, not \( 140\% \). A count of \( 140\% \) would actually represent a \( 40\% \) increase, not a decrease.

Everything you get with Solver7

More questions in Fractions In Disguise