Which of the following statement(s) mean the same as — \(\text{“}\)The demand for cameras has fallen by \(85\%\) in the last decade\(\text{”}?\) The demand a decade ago was \(185\%\) of the demand now.
CBSE Class 8 Maths · Fractions In Disguise
CBSE Class 8 Maths · Fractions In Disguise
Imagine you had 100 chocolates last year. If you lost 85 of them, you are left with only 15 chocolates now. The question asks: how many times bigger was your old pile compared to your tiny new pile? The old pile of 100 is about 667 times the new pile of 15, not 185 times. So saying the old demand was 185% of the new demand is simply wrong — the correct answer is around 667%.
Answer: The statement does NOT mean the same as 'the demand has fallen by 85%'. A fall of \( 85\% \) leaves only \( 15\% \) of the old demand, which makes the old demand about \( 667\% \) of the new demand, not \( 185\% \).
When a quantity 'falls by a certain percent', that percent is always calculated on the ORIGINAL (starting) value, not on the new value. Here, the original value is the demand a decade ago. Falling by \( 85\% \) means the demand lost \( 85\% \) of its old value, so only \( 15\% \) of the old demand is left now. The statement we must test compares the OLD demand as a percentage of the NEW demand. To check if the two statements match, we take the old demand as \( 100\% \), find the new demand, and then express the old demand as a percentage of the new demand.
New value \( = \) Old value \( \times (100\% - \text{percent fall}) \); and Old as percent of New \( = \dfrac{\text{Old}}{\text{New}} \times 100\% \).
The statement does NOT mean the same as 'the demand has fallen by 85%'. A fall of \( 85\% \) leaves only \( 15\% \) of the old demand, which makes the old demand about \( 667\% \) of the new demand, not \( 185\% \).
A common mistake is to add \( 85\% \) to \( 100\% \) and wrongly conclude the old demand was \( 185\% \) of the new demand. This is wrong because the \( 85\% \) fall is measured on the old value, so the old demand compared to the smaller new demand must be much larger than \( 185\% \).
The statement does NOT mean the same as 'the demand has fallen by 85%'. A fall of \( 85\% \) leaves only \( 15\% \) of the old demand, which makes the old demand about \( 667\% \) of the new demand, not \( 185\% \).
One common mistake: Students confuse 'old demand is 185% of new demand' with 'a fall of 85%'. They incorrectly subtract 85 from 100 to get 15, but then forget to recalculate the old-to-new ratio — instead they wrongly assume the ratio is simply 100 + 85 = 185%.
Answer: The statement does NOT mean the same as 'the demand has fallen by 85%'. A fall of \( 85\% \) leaves only \( 15\% \) of the old demand, which makes the old demand about \( 667\% \) of the new demand, not \( 185\% \).
Question: Which of the following statements means the same as — 'The number of tourists visiting a hill station has fallen by 60% in the last five years'? (A) The number of tourists five years ago was 160% of the number now. (B) The number of tourists five years ago was 250% of the number now. (C) The number now is 60% of the number five years ago. (D) The number now is 40% less than 250% of the current number.
Solution: Let the number of tourists five years ago be T. A fall of 60% means the decrease equals 60% of T. So the number of tourists now is: \[ \text{Current} = T - 60\% \text{ of } T = T - \frac{60}{100} \times T = \frac{40}{100} \times T = 0.4T \] Now we express the original number T as a percentage of the current number: \[ \frac{T}{0.4T} \times 100 = \frac{1}{0.4} \times 100 = 2.5 \times 100 = 250\% \] So the number of tourists five years ago was 250% of the number now. Checking option (B): 'The number of tourists five years ago was 250% of the number now.' — this matches exactly. Option (A) gives 160%, which would correspond to a 37.5% fall, not 60%. Option (C) says the current number is 60% of the old number, but we found it is 40% of the old number. Option (D) is not a standard equivalent statement.
Answer: Option (B): The number of tourists five years ago was 250% of the number now.
Question: A factory's monthly output of bicycles has fallen by 75% over the past year. Rewrite this fact as a statement that expresses the factory's output one year ago as a percentage of its current output.
Solution: Let the output one year ago be B bicycles per month. A fall of 75% means: \[ \text{Decrease} = 75\% \text{ of } B = \frac{75}{100} \times B = \frac{3}{4}B \] Current output: \[ \text{Current} = B - \frac{3}{4}B = \frac{1}{4}B \] Now, express the old output B as a percentage of the current output: \[ \frac{B}{\frac{1}{4}B} \times 100 = 4 \times 100 = 400\% \] So the factory's output one year ago was 400% of its current output. We can verify: if the old output is 400% of the current output, then the current output is \( \frac{1}{4} \) of the old output, meaning output fell by \( \frac{3}{4} \) of the old output, which is exactly 75%. This confirms our answer.
Answer: The factory's output one year ago was 400% of its current output.
Question: Which of the following statements means the same as — 'The number of tourists visiting a heritage site has fallen by 60% over the last five years'? (A) The number of tourists five years ago was 160% of the number now. (B) The number of tourists now is 40% of the number five years ago. (C) The number of tourists five years ago was 250% of the number now. Identify which statement(s) correctly restate the given fact, and explain your reasoning.
Answer: Statements (B) and (C) mean the same as 'the number of tourists has fallen by 60%'. Statement (A) is incorrect. A 60% fall leaves the new value at \( 40\% \) of the old, making the old value \( 250\% \) of the new — NOT \( 160\% \).