SOLVER7 Study. Nothing Else.
Figure It Out 3 Q12(iv)

Which of the following statement(s) mean the same as — \(\text{“}\)The demand for cameras has fallen by \(85\%\) in the last decade\(\text{”}?\) The demand a decade ago was \(15\%\) of the demand now.

CBSE Class 8 Maths · Fractions In Disguise

Solution

👶 Simple Explanation

Simple Explanation

Imagine you had 100 chocolates last year. You ate 85 of them. Now you only have 15 left. So your chocolates NOW are 15% of what you had BEFORE. The tricky part is: the BEFORE amount is always the starting point. Saying the OLD amount was 15% of the NEW amount is completely backwards. The demand fell from the old value, so the old value is the big number. The new demand is only 15% of that big old number, not the other way around.

Answer: The given statement does NOT mean the same thing. The correct interpretation is that the demand NOW is \( 15\% \) of the demand a decade ago, not the other way round.

📖 Understanding an 85% Fall in Demand

Detailed Explanation

When a quantity 'falls by' a certain percentage, that percentage is always measured with respect to the ORIGINAL (starting) value, not the final value. Here the starting point is the demand a decade ago, and the fall happens over the decade to reach today's demand. So a fall of 85% means today's demand is 15% of the demand a decade ago. The given statement swaps the base: it says the OLD demand was 15% of the NOW demand, which reverses which value is the base. So we must carefully identify what the 100% base is.

Formula Used

\( \text{New value} = \text{Old value} - (\text{percentage fall}) \times \text{Old value} \), and \( x\% = \frac{x}{100} \).

Solution

  1. Step 1: Identify the base. The phrase 'fallen by 85% in the last decade' tells us the demand DECREASED over the decade. The starting value is the demand a decade ago, and this starting value is taken as the full \( 100\% \).
  2. Step 2: Apply the fall. A fall of \( 85\% \) removes \( 85\% \) of the demand a decade ago. So the demand now is \( 100\% - 85\% = 15\% \) of the demand a decade ago.
  3. Step 3: Write it correctly. The true meaning is: the demand NOW is \( 15\% \) of the demand a DECADE AGO. In symbols, \[ \text{Demand now} = \frac{15}{100} \times \text{Demand a decade ago} \]
  4. Step 4: Compare with the given statement. The given statement says: 'The demand a decade ago was \( 15\% \) of the demand now', that is \[ \text{Demand a decade ago} = \frac{15}{100} \times \text{Demand now} \] This has the base and the compared value swapped, so it does NOT match the original meaning.
  5. Step 5: Quick number check. Suppose the demand a decade ago was \( 100 \). A fall of \( 85\% \) gives demand now \( = 100 - 85 = 15 \). The correct relation: demand now (15) is \( 15\% \) of demand a decade ago (100) — true. The given statement would need demand a decade ago (100) to be \( 15\% \) of demand now (15), i.e. \( 100 = \frac{15}{100} \times 15 = 2.25 \) — clearly false.

Final Answer

The given statement does NOT mean the same thing. The correct interpretation is that the demand NOW is \( 15\% \) of the demand a decade ago, not the other way round.

Common Mistake

Reversing the base: assuming the 85% (and hence the leftover 15%) is measured against today's demand instead of against the original demand a decade ago. The percentage fall is always taken of the starting value.

🪜 Step-by-step Solution

Step-by-step Solution

  1. Step 1: Identify the base (the 100% reference). The phrase 'demand has fallen by 85% in the last decade' tells us the change happened FROM a decade ago TO now. So the demand a decade ago is the starting value and is treated as \( 100\% \). — Reason: In any percentage change problem, we must first pin down WHICH quantity equals \( 100\% \); here it is the older, larger demand.
  2. Step 2: Calculate the remaining percentage after the fall. If the demand dropped by \( 85\% \) of the old demand, the portion that remains is \( 100\% - 85\% = 15\% \). — Reason: A fall of \( 85\% \) means \( 85\% \) of the original is lost, so only \( 15\% \) survives.
  3. Step 3: Write the correct relationship in symbols. Since the demand NOW is \( 15\% \) of the demand a decade ago, we write: \[ \text{Demand now} = \frac{15}{100} \times \text{Demand a decade ago} \] — Reason: Converting the percentage to a fraction makes the relationship between the two quantities precise.
  4. Step 4: Write what the given (incorrect) statement claims. The given statement says 'the demand a decade ago was \( 15\% \) of the demand now', which in symbols is: \[ \text{Demand a decade ago} = \frac{15}{100} \times \text{Demand now} \] — Reason: We must translate the given statement into an equation so we can compare it with the correct one.
  5. Step 5: Compare the two equations. In Step 3, the demand NOW is the smaller quantity (\( 15\% \) of the old). In Step 4, the demand A DECADE AGO is the smaller quantity (\( 15\% \) of the new). These two equations have the roles of old and new demand completely swapped. — Reason: Swapping which quantity is the base gives a completely different (and much larger) value for the old demand, so the two statements are NOT equivalent.

Final Answer

The given statement does NOT mean the same thing. The correct interpretation is that the demand NOW is \( 15\% \) of the demand a decade ago, not the other way round.

Common Mistake

One common mistake: Students assume that 'A is 15% of B' and 'B is 15% of A' say the same thing — they do not. Swapping the base completely changes the meaning and gives a numerically different result.

✍️ Exam-ready Answer

Exam-ready Answer

  1. Step 1: Base (100%) = demand a decade ago. Fall = \( 85\% \). Demand now = \( 100\% - 85\% = 15\% \) of demand a decade ago.
  2. Step 2: Correct relation: \[ \text{Demand now} = \frac{15}{100} \times \text{Demand a decade ago} \]
  3. Step 3: Given statement claims: \[ \text{Demand a decade ago} = \frac{15}{100} \times \text{Demand now} \] This reverses the base — the two statements are NOT the same.

Answer: The given statement does NOT mean the same thing. The correct interpretation is that the demand NOW is \( 15\% \) of the demand a decade ago, not the other way round.

➕ More Examples

More Examples

Example 1

Question: Which of the following statements means the same as — 'The number of tourists visiting a heritage site has fallen by 60% over the last five years'? (A) The number of tourists five years ago was 60% of the number now. (B) The number of tourists now is 40% of the number five years ago. (C) The number of tourists now is 60% of the number five years ago. (D) The number of tourists five years ago was 40% of the number now.

Solution: Let the number of tourists five years ago (the original value) be \( T \). A fall of 60% means the decrease is 60% of the original. So the number of tourists now is: \[ \text{Tourists now} = T - 60\% \text{ of } T \] \[ = T - \frac{60}{100} \times T \] \[ = T \left(1 - \frac{60}{100}\right) \] \[ = T \times \frac{40}{100} \] \[ = 40\% \text{ of } T \] So the number of tourists now is 40% of the number five years ago. This matches statement (B). Checking the other options: Option (A) says the old number was 60% of the new number — this is incorrect, as the old number is larger than the new number. Option (C) says the new number is 60% of the old number — this would mean a fall of only 40%, not 60%, so it is incorrect. Option (D) says the old number was 40% of the new number — this is incorrect because the old number is larger, not smaller, than the new number. Therefore, only statement (B) is correct.

Answer: Statement (B): The number of tourists now is 40% of the number five years ago.

Example 2

Question: A shopkeeper says, 'The sale of handmade toys in our town has dropped by 75% in the past year.' A student writes down the following interpretations. Which one(s) are correct? (P) The sales last year were 75% of the sales this year. (Q) The sales this year are 25% of the sales last year. (R) If the sales this year are 500 units, then the sales last year were 2000 units. (S) The sales this year are 75% of the sales last year.

Solution: Let the sales last year (the original value) be \( S \). A drop of 75% means: \[ \text{Sales this year} = S - 75\% \text{ of } S \] \[ = S \times \left(1 - \frac{75}{100}\right) \] \[ = S \times \frac{25}{100} \] \[ = 25\% \text{ of } S \] So, sales this year = 25% of sales last year. Now we check each statement: Statement (P): 'Sales last year were 75% of sales this year.' This would mean the original value is smaller than the new value, which contradicts a fall. This is INCORRECT. Statement (Q): 'Sales this year are 25% of sales last year.' This matches our result exactly. This is CORRECT. Statement (R): If sales this year are 500 units, then: \[ 500 = 25\% \text{ of } S_{\text{last year}} \] \[ 500 = \frac{25}{100} \times S_{\text{last year}} \] \[ S_{\text{last year}} = 500 \times \frac{100}{25} \] \[ S_{\text{last year}} = 500 \times 4 = 2000 \text{ units} \] This is CORRECT. Statement (S): 'Sales this year are 75% of sales last year.' This would imply a drop of only 25%, not 75%. This is INCORRECT. Therefore, statements (Q) and (R) are correct.

Answer: Statements (Q) and (R) are correct.

🎯 Try a Similar Question

Try a Similar Question

Question: Which of the following statements means the same as — 'The number of electric vehicles sold in a city has increased by 60% this year compared to last year'? (A) The number of electric vehicles sold last year was 60% more than the number sold this year. (B) The number of electric vehicles sold this year is 160% of the number sold last year. (C) The number of electric vehicles sold last year is 160% of the number sold this year. Identify the correct statement and explain why the others are incorrect.

Solution

  1. Step 1: Understand the original statement: The statement says the number of EVs sold has increased by 60% compared to last year. This means last year's sales is the BASE (reference), and this year's sales is 60% MORE than last year's sales.
  2. Step 2: Set up the relationship using a variable: Let the number of EVs sold last year be \( x \). Since sales increased by \( 60\% \), the number sold this year is \[ x + 60\% \text{ of } x = x + \frac{60}{100} \times x = x + 0.6x = 1.6x. \]
  3. Step 3: Express this year's sales as a percentage of last year's: This year's sales \( = 1.6x \). So this year's sales as a percentage of last year's sales is \[ \frac{1.6x}{x} \times 100 = 160\%. \] Therefore, this year's sales is \( 160\% \) of last year's sales.
  4. Step 4: Check Statement (A): Statement (A) says last year's sales was 60% more than this year's. This would mean last year \( > \) this year, which contradicts the original statement (sales increased, so this year \( > \) last year). Statement (A) is INCORRECT.
  5. Step 5: Check Statement (B): Statement (B) says this year's sales is \( 160\% \) of last year's. From Step 3, this year's sales \( = 1.6x = 160\% \) of \( x \) (last year's sales). Statement (B) is CORRECT.
  6. Step 6: Check Statement (C): Statement (C) says last year's sales is \( 160\% \) of this year's. This would mean last year's value is larger than this year's value (since \( 160\% > 100\% \)), which again contradicts the original statement. Statement (C) is INCORRECT.
  7. Step 7: Verify with a numerical example: Suppose last year's sales \( = 100 \) vehicles. A \( 60\% \) increase gives this year's sales \( = 100 + 60 = 160 \) vehicles. Now, \( 160 \) as a percentage of \( 100 \) is \[ \frac{160}{100} \times 100 = 160\%. \] This confirms Statement (B): this year's sales is \( 160\% \) of last year's sales.

Answer: Statement (B) is correct: 'The number of electric vehicles sold this year is 160% of the number sold last year.' Statements (A) and (C) are incorrect because they either reverse the direction of change or swap the base and the new value.

Everything you get with Solver7

More questions in Fractions In Disguise