Which of the following statement(s) mean the same as — \(\text{“}\)The demand for cameras has fallen by \(85\%\) in the last decade\(\text{”}?\) The demand a decade ago was \(85\%\) of the demand now.
CBSE Class 8 Maths · Fractions In Disguise
CBSE Class 8 Maths · Fractions In Disguise
Imagine you had 100 toffees before. If demand 'falls by 85%', you lose 85 toffees and are left with only 15. So the new amount is just 15% of what you started with. The given statement says the old amount was 85% of the new amount, which actually means things went up, not down. These two ideas are completely different from each other.
Answer: No. 'Fallen by \( 85\% \)' means the current demand is \( 15\% \) of the old demand, whereas the given statement makes the old demand \( 85\% \) of the new demand (which would mean a rise). So the statement does NOT mean the same thing.
When a quantity 'falls by' a certain percentage, that percentage is always measured with respect to the ORIGINAL (starting) value. Here the last decade started with some earlier demand (call it the old demand), and the 'now' demand is the final value. A fall of \( 85\% \) means the demand dropped by \( 85\% \) of the OLD demand, so what remains now is only \( 15\% \) of the old demand. We must compare this with the given statement, which claims the old demand was \( 85\% \) of the new demand.
\[ \text{New value} = \text{Old value} - (\text{percentage fall} \times \text{Old value}) \]
No. 'Fallen by \( 85\% \)' means the current demand is \( 15\% \) of the old demand, whereas the given statement makes the old demand \( 85\% \) of the new demand (which would mean a rise). So the statement does NOT mean the same thing.
Taking the \( 85\% \) on the wrong base and thinking 'fallen by 85%' means the old demand equals 85% of the new demand. The percentage fall is always measured on the ORIGINAL value, so the correct result is that the new demand is only \( 15\% \) of the old demand.
No. 'Fallen by \( 85\% \)' means the current demand is \( 15\% \) of the old demand, whereas the given statement makes the old demand \( 85\% \) of the new demand (which would mean a rise). So the statement does NOT mean the same thing.
One common mistake: Students confuse 'A is 85% of B' with 'A has fallen by 85% from B'. The first is a simple ratio (A = 0.85B), while the second means A has decreased by 85% of B, leaving only 15% of B — these are very different relationships.
Answer: No. 'Fallen by \( 85\% \)' means the current demand is \( 15\% \) of the old demand, whereas the given statement makes the old demand \( 85\% \) of the new demand (which would mean a rise). So the statement does NOT mean the same thing.
Question: Which of the following statements means the same as: 'The number of cinema tickets sold has dropped by 60% over the past year'? (A) The tickets sold this year are 60% of the tickets sold last year. (B) The tickets sold last year were 60% of the tickets sold this year. (C) The tickets sold this year are 40% of the tickets sold last year. (D) The tickets sold last year were 40% of the tickets sold this year.
Solution: Let the number of tickets sold last year (the original, or base) be \( T \). A drop of 60% means: \[ \text{Tickets this year} = T - 60\% \text{ of } T = T - \frac{60}{100} \times T \] Simplifying: \[ \text{Tickets this year} = T \left(1 - \frac{60}{100}\right) = T \times \frac{40}{100} = 40\% \text{ of } T \] So the tickets sold THIS year are 40% of the tickets sold LAST year. Now check each option: Option (A): Tickets this year = 60% of last year. This is WRONG (it should be 40%, not 60%). Option (B): Tickets last year = 60% of this year. This reverses the base incorrectly — WRONG. Option (C): Tickets this year = 40% of last year. This matches our calculation exactly — CORRECT. Option (D): Tickets last year = 40% of this year. This again reverses the base — WRONG. Therefore, statement (C) means the same as the original statement.
Answer: Option (C): The tickets sold this year are 40% of the tickets sold last year.
Question: A shopkeeper says, 'The price of cooking oil has increased by 25% this month.' A customer responds with the following statements. Which one correctly restates the shopkeeper's claim? (A) Last month's price was 125% of this month's price. (B) This month's price is 125% of last month's price. (C) Last month's price was 25% less than this month's price. (D) This month's price is 25% of last month's price.
Solution: Let last month's price (the original base) be \( P \). An increase of 25% means: \[ \text{This month's price} = P + 25\% \text{ of } P = P + \frac{25}{100} \times P \] Simplifying: \[ \text{This month's price} = P \times \left(1 + \frac{25}{100}\right) = P \times \frac{125}{100} = 125\% \text{ of } P \] So this month's price is 125% of last month's price. Now check each option: Option (A): Last month's price = 125% of this month's price. This reverses the base — WRONG. Option (B): This month's price = 125% of last month's price. This matches our calculation exactly — CORRECT. Option (C): Last month's price was 25% less than this month's price. This would mean the base is this month's price, which is not what the shopkeeper said — WRONG. Option (D): This month's price = 25% of last month's price. This would mean a huge decrease, not an increase — WRONG. Therefore, statement (B) correctly restates the shopkeeper's claim.
Answer: Option (B): This month's price is 125% of last month's price.
Question: A shopkeeper claims: 'The number of electric scooters sold in our city has increased by \( 60\% \) in the last year.' A customer interprets this statement as: 'The number of scooters sold last year was \( 60\% \) of the number sold this year.' Do these two statements mean the same thing? Justify your answer with calculations.
Answer: No, the two statements do NOT mean the same thing. 'Increased by \( 60\% \)' means this year's sales are \( 1.6 \) times last year's, which makes last year's sales \( 62.5\% \) of this year's — not \( 60\% \). The customer's interpretation ('last year was \( 60\% \) of this year') actually corresponds to an increase of about \( 66.67\% \), which is different from \( 60\% \).