SOLVER7 Study. Nothing Else.
Figure It Out 3 Q12(ii)

Which of the following statement(s) mean the same as — \(\text{“}\)The demand for cameras has fallen by \(85\%\) in the last decade\(\text{”}?\) The demand a decade ago was \(85\%\) of the demand now.

CBSE Class 8 Maths · Fractions In Disguise

Solution

👶 Simple Explanation

Simple Explanation

Imagine you had 100 toffees before. If demand 'falls by 85%', you lose 85 toffees and are left with only 15. So the new amount is just 15% of what you started with. The given statement says the old amount was 85% of the new amount, which actually means things went up, not down. These two ideas are completely different from each other.

Answer: No. 'Fallen by \( 85\% \)' means the current demand is \( 15\% \) of the old demand, whereas the given statement makes the old demand \( 85\% \) of the new demand (which would mean a rise). So the statement does NOT mean the same thing.

📖 Understanding a 85% Fall in Demand

Detailed Explanation

When a quantity 'falls by' a certain percentage, that percentage is always measured with respect to the ORIGINAL (starting) value. Here the last decade started with some earlier demand (call it the old demand), and the 'now' demand is the final value. A fall of \( 85\% \) means the demand dropped by \( 85\% \) of the OLD demand, so what remains now is only \( 15\% \) of the old demand. We must compare this with the given statement, which claims the old demand was \( 85\% \) of the new demand.

Formula Used

\[ \text{New value} = \text{Old value} - (\text{percentage fall} \times \text{Old value}) \]

Solution

  1. Step 1: Identify the base. A fall is always taken on the original amount. So the original (a decade ago) demand is the base, and the current demand is the result after the fall. Let the old demand be \( D \).
  2. Step 2: Apply the fall of \( 85\% \). Falling by \( 85\% \) means the demand decreased by \( 85\% \) of \( D \). What remains now is \[ D - 0.85D = 0.15D \] So the current demand is \( 15\% \) of the old demand.
  3. Step 3: Write the correct relationship. Current demand \( = 0.15D \), where \( D \) is the old demand. In words: the demand now is \( 15\% \) of the demand a decade ago.
  4. Step 4: Check the given statement. The statement says: 'the demand a decade ago was \( 85\% \) of the demand now', i.e. \[ D = 0.85 \times (\text{demand now}) \] This says the OLD demand is smaller than the new demand, which would mean demand actually INCREASED, not fell.
  5. Step 5: Compare. The original statement means demand now is \( 15\% \) of the old demand (a big drop). The given statement means old demand is \( 85\% \) of the new demand (a rise). These are completely different situations, so they do NOT mean the same thing.

Final Answer

No. 'Fallen by \( 85\% \)' means the current demand is \( 15\% \) of the old demand, whereas the given statement makes the old demand \( 85\% \) of the new demand (which would mean a rise). So the statement does NOT mean the same thing.

Common Mistake

Taking the \( 85\% \) on the wrong base and thinking 'fallen by 85%' means the old demand equals 85% of the new demand. The percentage fall is always measured on the ORIGINAL value, so the correct result is that the new demand is only \( 15\% \) of the old demand.

🪜 Step-by-step Solution

Step-by-step Solution

  1. Step 1: Name the quantities clearly: Let the demand a decade ago (the starting value) be \( D \) and the demand right now be the unknown result. — Reason: Giving a name to the old demand makes it easier to set up the calculation and compare the two statements.
  2. Step 2: Identify the base for the percentage: When we say a quantity 'falls by' a percentage, that percentage is always taken on the ORIGINAL amount. Here the original amount is \( D \) (the demand a decade ago). — Reason: Understanding which value is the base prevents the most common error in percentage problems.
  3. Step 3: Calculate the current demand after an 85% fall: A fall of \( 85\% \) means the demand decreased by \( 0.85 \times D \). Subtracting that decrease: \[ \text{Current demand} = D - 0.85D = 0.15D \] So the current demand is just \( 15\% \) of the old demand \( D \). — Reason: This is what 'fallen by 85%' actually means mathematically.
  4. Step 4: Write the correct relationship in words: From Step 3, the current demand equals \( 0.15D \), which means \[ \frac{\text{Current demand}}{D} = 0.15 \] In plain language: the demand now is \( 15\% \) of the demand a decade ago. — Reason: Expressing the result as a ratio makes it easy to compare with the given statement.
  5. Step 5: Decode the given statement mathematically: The given statement says: 'the demand a decade ago was \( 85\% \) of the demand now.' Writing this algebraically: \[ D = 0.85 \times \text{Current demand} \] Rearranging gives \[ \text{Current demand} = \frac{D}{0.85} \approx 1.176D \] — Reason: Converting the words into an equation reveals what the statement is actually claiming about the two demands.
  6. Step 6: Compare the two relationships: Correct interpretation of '85% fall': Current demand \( = 0.15D \) (demand went DOWN drastically). Given statement: Current demand \( \approx 1.176D \) (demand actually went UP, since the current demand is larger than \( D \)). These two results are completely different. — Reason: The comparison exposes that the given statement implies a rise, not a fall, so it cannot mean the same thing.

Final Answer

No. 'Fallen by \( 85\% \)' means the current demand is \( 15\% \) of the old demand, whereas the given statement makes the old demand \( 85\% \) of the new demand (which would mean a rise). So the statement does NOT mean the same thing.

Common Mistake

One common mistake: Students confuse 'A is 85% of B' with 'A has fallen by 85% from B'. The first is a simple ratio (A = 0.85B), while the second means A has decreased by 85% of B, leaving only 15% of B — these are very different relationships.

✍️ Exam-ready Answer

Exam-ready Answer

  1. Step 1: Let old demand = \( D \). Fall of \( 85\% \) on old demand: current demand = \( D - 0.85D = 0.15D \)
  2. Step 2: Given statement: \( D = 0.85 \times \text{current demand} \), i.e. old demand is \( 85\% \) of new demand, implying demand rose.
  3. Step 3: \( 0.15D \ne 0.85 \times \text{current demand} \), so the two statements are NOT equivalent.

Answer: No. 'Fallen by \( 85\% \)' means the current demand is \( 15\% \) of the old demand, whereas the given statement makes the old demand \( 85\% \) of the new demand (which would mean a rise). So the statement does NOT mean the same thing.

➕ More Examples

More Examples

Example 1

Question: Which of the following statements means the same as: 'The number of cinema tickets sold has dropped by 60% over the past year'? (A) The tickets sold this year are 60% of the tickets sold last year. (B) The tickets sold last year were 60% of the tickets sold this year. (C) The tickets sold this year are 40% of the tickets sold last year. (D) The tickets sold last year were 40% of the tickets sold this year.

Solution: Let the number of tickets sold last year (the original, or base) be \( T \). A drop of 60% means: \[ \text{Tickets this year} = T - 60\% \text{ of } T = T - \frac{60}{100} \times T \] Simplifying: \[ \text{Tickets this year} = T \left(1 - \frac{60}{100}\right) = T \times \frac{40}{100} = 40\% \text{ of } T \] So the tickets sold THIS year are 40% of the tickets sold LAST year. Now check each option: Option (A): Tickets this year = 60% of last year. This is WRONG (it should be 40%, not 60%). Option (B): Tickets last year = 60% of this year. This reverses the base incorrectly — WRONG. Option (C): Tickets this year = 40% of last year. This matches our calculation exactly — CORRECT. Option (D): Tickets last year = 40% of this year. This again reverses the base — WRONG. Therefore, statement (C) means the same as the original statement.

Answer: Option (C): The tickets sold this year are 40% of the tickets sold last year.

Example 2

Question: A shopkeeper says, 'The price of cooking oil has increased by 25% this month.' A customer responds with the following statements. Which one correctly restates the shopkeeper's claim? (A) Last month's price was 125% of this month's price. (B) This month's price is 125% of last month's price. (C) Last month's price was 25% less than this month's price. (D) This month's price is 25% of last month's price.

Solution: Let last month's price (the original base) be \( P \). An increase of 25% means: \[ \text{This month's price} = P + 25\% \text{ of } P = P + \frac{25}{100} \times P \] Simplifying: \[ \text{This month's price} = P \times \left(1 + \frac{25}{100}\right) = P \times \frac{125}{100} = 125\% \text{ of } P \] So this month's price is 125% of last month's price. Now check each option: Option (A): Last month's price = 125% of this month's price. This reverses the base — WRONG. Option (B): This month's price = 125% of last month's price. This matches our calculation exactly — CORRECT. Option (C): Last month's price was 25% less than this month's price. This would mean the base is this month's price, which is not what the shopkeeper said — WRONG. Option (D): This month's price = 25% of last month's price. This would mean a huge decrease, not an increase — WRONG. Therefore, statement (B) correctly restates the shopkeeper's claim.

Answer: Option (B): This month's price is 125% of last month's price.

🎯 Try a Similar Question

Try a Similar Question

Question: A shopkeeper claims: 'The number of electric scooters sold in our city has increased by \( 60\% \) in the last year.' A customer interprets this statement as: 'The number of scooters sold last year was \( 60\% \) of the number sold this year.' Do these two statements mean the same thing? Justify your answer with calculations.

Solution

  1. Step 1: Understand what 'increased by 60%' means: Let the number of scooters sold last year be \( S \). 'Increased by \( 60\% \)' means this year's sales are \( 60\% \) MORE than last year's sales. So, sales this year \[ = S + 60\% \text{ of } S = S + \frac{60}{100} \times S = S\left(1 + 0.6\right) = 1.6S \] This means last year's sales \( = S \) and this year's sales \( = 1.6S \).
  2. Step 2: Express last year's sales as a percentage of this year's sales (from the shopkeeper's claim): From Step 1, this year's sales \( = 1.6S \). Now, last year's sales as a percentage of this year's sales \[ = \frac{S}{1.6S} \times 100 = \frac{1}{1.6} \times 100 = \frac{100}{1.6} = 62.5\% \] So, according to the shopkeeper's correct statement, last year's sales were \( 62.5\% \) of this year's sales.
  3. Step 3: Understand what the customer's interpretation means: The customer says: 'Last year's sales were \( 60\% \) of this year's sales.' Let this year's sales be \( T \). Then last year's sales \( = 60\% \) of \( T \) \[ = \frac{60}{100} \times T = 0.6T \] This would mean this year's sales increased over last year's by \[ \frac{T - 0.6T}{0.6T} \times 100 = \frac{0.4T}{0.6T} \times 100 = \frac{0.4}{0.6} \times 100 = 66.67\% \] So the customer's statement implies an increase of \( 66.67\% \), not \( 60\% \).
  4. Step 4: Compare the two statements: The shopkeeper's statement ('increased by \( 60\% \)') implies last year's sales were \( 62.5\% \) of this year's sales. The customer's interpretation ('last year's sales were \( 60\% \) of this year's sales') implies an increase of \( 66.67\% \), not \( 60\% \). Since \( 62.5\% \ne 60\% \), the two statements do NOT mean the same thing.

Answer: No, the two statements do NOT mean the same thing. 'Increased by \( 60\% \)' means this year's sales are \( 1.6 \) times last year's, which makes last year's sales \( 62.5\% \) of this year's — not \( 60\% \). The customer's interpretation ('last year was \( 60\% \) of this year') actually corresponds to an increase of about \( 66.67\% \), which is different from \( 60\% \).

Everything you get with Solver7

More questions in Fractions In Disguise