SOLVER7 Study. Nothing Else.
Figure It Out 3 Q12(i)

Which of the following statement(s) mean the same as — \(\text{“}\)The demand for cameras has fallen by \(85\%\) in the last decade\(\text{”}?\) The demand now is \(85\%\) of the demand a decade ago.

CBSE Class 8 Maths · Fractions In Disguise

Solution

👶 Simple Explanation

Simple Explanation

Imagine you have 100 cookies. Someone eats 85 of them. You are left with only 15 cookies, not 85. Saying the cookies 'fell by 85' is very different from saying 'you now have 85 cookies.' The word 'by' makes a big difference! A fall of 85% means 85% is gone, so only \( 100\\% - 85\\% = 15\\% \) is left behind. The two phrases point to completely different amounts.

Answer: No, the statement does NOT mean the same. A fall of 85% leaves the demand at \( 100\% - 85\% = 15\% \) of the demand a decade ago, not 85%.

📖 Understanding a Percentage Fall in Demand

Detailed Explanation

When something 'falls by 85%', it means 85% of the original amount has been removed. The part that remains is what is left after subtracting this fall. So a fall of 85% does NOT mean the new value is 85% of the old value; instead, the new value is the original 100% minus the 85% that was lost. This is a common language trap in percentage problems: 'fallen by 85%' and 'is 85% of' describe two completely different situations.

Formula Used

\( \text{Remaining percentage} = 100\% - \text{fall percentage} \)

Solution

  1. Step 1: Take the demand a decade ago as the whole, that is \( 100\% \). All comparisons are made against this original value.
  2. Step 2: The phrase 'fallen by 85%' means 85% of the original demand has been lost. So the amount removed is \( 85\% \) of the demand a decade ago.
  3. Step 3: Find the remaining demand by subtracting the fall from the whole: \( 100\% - 85\% = 15\% \). This means the demand now is \( 15\% \) of the demand a decade ago.
  4. Step 4: Compare with the given statement. The given statement says the demand now is \( 85\% \) of the earlier demand, but our correct value is \( 15\% \). Since \( 15\% \ne 85\% \), the two statements do NOT mean the same thing.

Final Answer

No, the statement does NOT mean the same. A fall of 85% leaves the demand at \( 100\% - 85\% = 15\% \) of the demand a decade ago, not 85%.

Common Mistake

Reading 'fallen by 85%' as 'the new value is 85% of the old value'. In reality, 'fallen by 85%' means only \( 15\% \) is left; the 85% is the part that was lost, not the part that remains.

🪜 Step-by-step Solution

Step-by-step Solution

  1. Step 1: Set the demand from a decade ago as the reference value, equal to \( 100\% \). — Reason: Every percentage comparison needs a base value, and here the original demand serves as that base.
  2. Step 2: Understand what 'fallen by \( 85\% \)' actually means: it tells us that \( 85\% \) of the original demand has been lost or removed, not what is left behind. — Reason: The phrase 'fallen by' describes the amount of reduction, which is subtracted from the total, not the amount that survives.
  3. Step 3: Calculate the demand that still remains by subtracting the fall from the whole: \( 100\% - 85\% = 15\% \). So the current demand is \( 15\% \) of the demand a decade ago. — Reason: Whatever is not lost still exists, so removing the fallen portion from \( 100\% \) gives us what is left.
  4. Step 4: Now compare this result with the statement being evaluated. The statement claims that the current demand is \( 85\% \) of the earlier demand. Our calculation shows the correct remaining demand is \( 15\% \), not \( 85\% \). Since \( 15\% \ne 85\% \), the two statements describe entirely different situations. — Reason: A direct comparison reveals whether the given statement is mathematically accurate or not.

Final Answer

No, the statement does NOT mean the same. A fall of 85% leaves the demand at \( 100\% - 85\% = 15\% \) of the demand a decade ago, not 85%.

Common Mistake

One common mistake: Students confuse 'demand fell by 85%' with 'demand is 85% of the original' — remember, 'fell by 85%' means 85% was taken away, so only \( 15\% \) remains, not \( 85\% \).

✍️ Exam-ready Answer

Exam-ready Answer

  1. Step 1: Demand a decade ago = \( 100\% \). Fall of \( 85\% \) means \( 85\% \) is removed.
  2. Step 2: Remaining demand = \( 100\% - 85\% = 15\% \), not \( 85\% \).
  3. Step 3: Since \( 15\% \ne 85\% \), the two statements are NOT the same.

Answer: No, the statement does NOT mean the same. A fall of 85% leaves the demand at \( 100\% - 85\% = 15\% \) of the demand a decade ago, not 85%.

➕ More Examples

More Examples

Example 1

Question: Which of the following statements means the same as — 'The number of tourists visiting a hill station has fallen by 60% over the last five years'? (A) The number of tourists now is 60% of what it was five years ago. (B) The number of tourists now is 40% of what it was five years ago. (C) The number of tourists has increased by 40% over the last five years. (D) The number of tourists now is 160% of what it was five years ago.

Solution: Let the number of tourists five years ago be \( T \). A fall of 60% means the decrease is 60% of the original, so the remaining percentage of tourists is: \[ 100\% - 60\% = 40\% \] Therefore, the new number of tourists is: \[ \frac{40}{100} \times T = 0.4T \] This means the number of tourists now is 40% of what it was five years ago. Checking the options: Option (A) says 60% of original — this would mean a fall of only 40%, which is WRONG. Option (B) says 40% of original — this correctly represents a fall of 60%, which is CORRECT. Option (C) says an increase of 40% — this is WRONG; the number fell, not rose. Option (D) says 160% of original — this would mean an increase of 60%, which is WRONG. So, option (B) is the correct interpretation.

Answer: Option (B): The number of tourists now is 40% of what it was five years ago.

Example 2

Question: A factory produced 4000 units of a product last year. This year, the production has fallen by 35%. Which of the following correctly describes this year's production? (A) This year's production is 35% of last year's production. (B) This year's production is 65% of last year's production. (C) This year's production decreased by 65 units. (D) This year's production is 135% of last year's production.

Solution: Given: Last year's production \( = 4000 \) units, and production has fallen by \( 35\% \). Step 1: Find the percentage that remains after the fall. \[ 100\% - 35\% = 65\% \] Step 2: Find this year's actual production. \[ \text{This year's production} = \frac{65}{100} \times 4000 \] \[ = 0.65 \times 4000 = 2600 \text{ units} \] So this year's production is 2600 units, which is 65% of last year's production. Verification: The decrease \( = 4000 - 2600 = 1400 \) units. \[ \frac{1400}{4000} \times 100 = 35\% \] This confirms the fall is indeed 35%. Checking the options: Option (A) says 35% of last year — that would be \( 0.35 \times 4000 = 1400 \) units, meaning a fall of 65%, which is WRONG. Option (B) says 65% of last year — that gives 2600 units, correctly matching a fall of 35%, which is CORRECT. Option (C) says decreased by 65 units — the actual decrease is 1400 units, so this is WRONG. Option (D) says 135% of last year — that would mean an increase of 35%, which is WRONG. So, option (B) is the correct interpretation.

Answer: Option (B): This year's production is 65% of last year's production, i.e., 2600 units.

🎯 Try a Similar Question

Try a Similar Question

Question: Decide whether the following statement means the same as the given fact or not. Give a reason for your answer. Fact: 'The number of tourists visiting a hill station has increased by 40% this year compared to last year.' Statement: 'The number of tourists this year is 40% of the number of tourists last year.'

Solution

  1. Step 1: Understand what 'increased by 40%' means: When we say the number of tourists has increased by 40%, it means the increase equals 40% of last year's number. So the new number equals the original number plus 40% of the original number.
  2. Step 2: Express this as a percentage of the original: This year's tourists = Last year's tourists + 40% of last year's tourists. In percentage terms, this equals \( (100 + 40)\% \) of last year's tourists, which is \( 140\% \) of last year's tourists.
  3. Step 3: Use a numerical example to verify: Suppose last year there were 1000 tourists. An increase of 40% means an increase of \( \frac{40}{100} \times 1000 = 400 \) tourists. So this year's count = \( 1000 + 400 = 1400 \), which is indeed \( 140\% \) of 1000.
  4. Step 4: Compare with the given statement: The given statement says this year's tourists is 40% of last year's tourists. Using our example, 40% of 1000 = \( \frac{40}{100} \times 1000 = 400 \). But the actual number this year is 1400, not 400. The statement is therefore incorrect.
  5. Step 5: Conclusion: The fact states an increase of 40%, which means the current number is \( (100 + 40)\% = 140\% \) of last year's number — not 40% of it. The two statements do NOT mean the same.

Answer: No, the statement does NOT mean the same. An increase of 40% means this year's tourist count is \( (100 + 40)\% = 140\% \) of last year's count, not 40% of it.

Everything you get with Solver7

More questions in Fractions In Disguise