SOLVER7 Study. Nothing Else.
Figure It Out 3 Q10

A milkman sold two buffaloes for ₹\(80,000\) each. On one of them, he made a profit of \(5\%\) and on the other a loss of \(10\%.\) Find his overall profit or loss.

CBSE Class 8 Maths · Fractions In Disguise

Solution

👶 Simple Explanation

Simple Explanation

Imagine a milkman buys two buffaloes and sells both for the same price. On one he earns a little extra, and on the other he loses more than he gains. Even though one profit and one loss sounds like they cancel out, they do not, because each buffalo cost him a different amount. It is like losing a big bag of coins but finding a smaller bag — you are still behind overall. In the end, the milkman loses about 5079 rupees in total.

Answer: The milkman has an overall loss of about \( 5079 \) rupees, which is a loss of nearly \( 3.08\% \) on his total cost price.

📖 Overall Profit or Loss on Selling Two Buffaloes

Detailed Explanation

When an item is sold, profit or loss is always calculated on the Cost Price (CP), not on the Selling Price (SP). Here we are given the Selling Price of each buffalo and the profit or loss percent. So we must first work backwards to find the Cost Price of each buffalo. Once we know both cost prices, we add them to get the total CP. We already know the total SP (since both are sold for the same price). Finally, comparing total CP and total SP tells us whether there is an overall profit or loss. A common surprise here is that even though one profit is \( 5\% \) and one loss is \( 10\% \), the amounts of money are different because the cost prices are different, so the two percentages do NOT simply cancel out.

Formula Used

\( SP = CP \times \left(1 + \frac{\text{Profit}\%}{100}\right) \) for profit, and \( SP = CP \times \left(1 - \frac{\text{Loss}\%}{100}\right) \) for loss.

Solution

  1. Step 1: Write down what is given. Each buffalo is sold for \( SP = 80000 \). On the first buffalo there is a profit of \( 5\% \), and on the second buffalo there is a loss of \( 10\% \). We need the cost price of each, because profit and loss percent are always taken on the cost price.
  2. Step 2: Find the cost price of the first buffalo (the one sold at 5% profit). Here selling price is 105% of the cost price, so \[ 80000 = CP_1 \times \frac{105}{100} \] Solving for \( CP_1 \): \[ CP_1 = 80000 \times \frac{100}{105} = \frac{8000000}{105} \approx 76190.48 \]
  3. Step 3: Find the cost price of the second buffalo (the one sold at 10% loss). Here selling price is 90% of the cost price, so \[ 80000 = CP_2 \times \frac{90}{100} \] Solving for \( CP_2 \): \[ CP_2 = 80000 \times \frac{100}{90} = \frac{8000000}{90} \approx 88888.89 \]
  4. Step 4: Add the two cost prices to get the total cost price. \[ \text{Total CP} = 76190.48 + 88888.89 \approx 165079.37 \]
  5. Step 5: Find the total selling price. Since both buffaloes were sold for \( 80000 \) each, \[ \text{Total SP} = 80000 + 80000 = 160000 \]
  6. Step 6: Compare total CP and total SP. Since \( \text{Total CP} \approx 165079.37 \) is greater than \( \text{Total SP} = 160000 \), there is an overall loss. \[ \text{Loss} = 165079.37 - 160000 = 5079.37 \]
  7. Step 7: Find the loss percent on the total cost price. \[ \text{Loss}\% = \frac{5079.37}{165079.37} \times 100 \approx 3.08\% \]

Final Answer

The milkman has an overall loss of about \( 5079 \) rupees, which is a loss of nearly \( 3.08\% \) on his total cost price.

Common Mistake

A very common mistake is to think that \( 5\% \) profit and \( 10\% \) loss give a net \( 5\% \) loss by simply subtracting the percentages. This is wrong because the two percentages are taken on different cost prices, so the money amounts differ. Always find each cost price first, then compare total CP with total SP.

🪜 Step-by-step Solution

Step-by-step Solution

  1. Step 1: Write down the known information. Both buffaloes are sold at the same price: \( SP_1 = SP_2 = 80000 \) rupees. The first buffalo is sold at a profit of \( 5\% \) and the second at a loss of \( 10\% \). — Reason: Clearly listing the given data helps us identify what formula to use for each buffalo.
  2. Step 2: Find the Cost Price of the first buffalo (sold at \( 5\% \) profit). Since the selling price is \( 105\% \) of its cost price, we write: \[ 80000 = CP_1 \times \frac{105}{100} \] Solving for \( CP_1 \): \[ CP_1 = \frac{80000 \times 100}{105} = \frac{8000000}{105} \approx 76190.48 \] — Reason: We rearrange the profit formula to isolate \( CP_1 \), because profit percent is defined on the cost price, not the selling price.
  3. Step 3: Find the Cost Price of the second buffalo (sold at \( 10\% \) loss). Since the selling price is only \( 90\% \) of its cost price, we write: \[ 80000 = CP_2 \times \frac{90}{100} \] Solving for \( CP_2 \): \[ CP_2 = \frac{80000 \times 100}{90} = \frac{8000000}{90} \approx 88888.89 \] — Reason: A loss means the item was sold for less than its cost price, so the selling price equals \( (100 - 10)\% \) of CP, and we reverse this to find \( CP_2 \).
  4. Step 4: Calculate the total Cost Price and total Selling Price for both buffaloes. \[ \text{Total CP} = CP_1 + CP_2 \approx 76190.48 + 88888.89 \approx 165079.37 \] \[ \text{Total SP} = 80000 + 80000 = 160000 \] — Reason: We combine both transactions so we can judge whether the milkman made an overall profit or loss.
  5. Step 5: Determine overall profit or loss. Since Total CP is greater than Total SP, the milkman incurred a loss. \[ \text{Loss} = \text{Total CP} - \text{Total SP} \approx 165079.37 - 160000 \approx 5079.37 \] Rounding, the loss is approximately \( 5079 \) rupees. — Reason: When the cost price exceeds the selling price, money has been lost overall.
  6. Step 6: Calculate the loss percentage on the total cost price. \[ \text{Loss}\% = \frac{\text{Loss}}{\text{Total CP}} \times 100 \approx \frac{5079.37}{165079.37} \times 100 \approx 3.08\% \] — Reason: Expressing the loss as a percentage of the total cost price lets us understand how significant the overall loss is relative to what the milkman originally spent.

Final Answer

The milkman has an overall loss of about \( 5079 \) rupees, which is a loss of nearly \( 3.08\% \) on his total cost price.

Common Mistake

One common mistake: Students assume that a \( 5\% \) profit on one item and a \( 10\% \) loss on another simply average out or partially cancel — but because the two cost prices are different, the actual rupee amounts gained and lost are not equal, so you must always find each cost price separately before comparing totals.

✍️ Exam-ready Answer

Exam-ready Answer

  1. Step 1: Find CP of each buffalo: Buffalo 1 (5% profit): \[CP_1 = 80000 \times \frac{100}{105} \approx 76190.48\] Buffalo 2 (10% loss): \[CP_2 = 80000 \times \frac{100}{90} \approx 88888.89\]
  2. Step 2: Total CP and Total SP: Total CP \( = 76190.48 + 88888.89 = 165079.37 \), Total SP \( = 80000 + 80000 = 160000 \)
  3. Step 3: Overall Loss and Loss%: Loss \( = 165079.37 - 160000 \approx 5079 \), Loss% \( = \frac{5079}{165079.37} \times 100 \approx 3.08\% \)

Answer: The milkman has an overall loss of about \( 5079 \) rupees, which is a loss of nearly \( 3.08\% \) on his total cost price.

➕ More Examples

More Examples

Example 1

Question: A trader sold two laptops for ₹45,000 each. On one laptop he made a profit of 8% and on the other a loss of 12%. Find his overall profit or loss.

Solution: Step 1: Find the Cost Price of the laptop sold at 8% profit. Selling Price of first laptop = ₹45,000, Profit = 8%. \[CP_1 = \frac{SP \times 100}{100 + \text{Profit}\%} = \frac{45000 \times 100}{100 + 8} = \frac{4500000}{108}\] Simplifying: \[CP_1 = \frac{4500000}{108} \approx 41666.67\] So \( CP_1 = \frac{125000}{3} \) rupees (exact value). Step 2: Find the Cost Price of the laptop sold at 12% loss. Selling Price of second laptop = ₹45,000, Loss = 12%. \[CP_2 = \frac{SP \times 100}{100 - \text{Loss}\%} = \frac{45000 \times 100}{100 - 12} = \frac{4500000}{88}\] Simplifying: \[CP_2 = \frac{4500000}{88} = \frac{562500}{11} \approx 51136.36\] Step 3: Calculate Total Cost Price. \[\text{Total CP} = CP_1 + CP_2 = \frac{125000}{3} + \frac{562500}{11}\] Finding a common denominator (LCM of 3 and 11 is 33): \[\text{Total CP} = \frac{125000 \times 11}{33} + \frac{562500 \times 3}{33} = \frac{1375000 + 1687500}{33} = \frac{3062500}{33}\] \[\text{Total CP} \approx 92803.03\] Step 4: Calculate Total Selling Price. \[\text{Total SP} = 45000 + 45000 = 90000\] Step 5: Since Total SP < Total CP, there is a loss. \[\text{Overall Loss} = \text{Total CP} - \text{Total SP} = \frac{3062500}{33} - 90000\] \[= \frac{3062500 - 2970000}{33} = \frac{92500}{33} \approx 2803.03\] So the trader incurs an overall loss of approximately ₹2803.

Answer: Overall Loss ≈ ₹2803 (exact: ₹92500/33)

Example 2

Question: A shopkeeper sold two refrigerators for ₹18,000 each. On one he gained 20% and on the other he lost 20%. Find his overall profit or loss and the percentage of profit or loss on the whole transaction.

Solution: Step 1: Find the Cost Price of the refrigerator sold at 20% profit. Selling Price = ₹18,000, Profit = 20%. \[CP_1 = \frac{SP \times 100}{100 + 20} = \frac{18000 \times 100}{120} = \frac{1800000}{120} = 15000\] So \( CP_1 = \) ₹15,000. Step 2: Find the Cost Price of the refrigerator sold at 20% loss. Selling Price = ₹18,000, Loss = 20%. \[CP_2 = \frac{SP \times 100}{100 - 20} = \frac{18000 \times 100}{80} = \frac{1800000}{80} = 22500\] So \( CP_2 = \) ₹22,500. Step 3: Calculate Total Cost Price and Total Selling Price. \[\text{Total CP} = 15000 + 22500 = 37500\] \[\text{Total SP} = 18000 + 18000 = 36000\] Step 4: Since Total SP < Total CP, there is a loss. \[\text{Overall Loss} = 37500 - 36000 = 1500\] Step 5: Calculate the percentage loss on the whole transaction. \[\text{Loss}\% = \frac{\text{Loss}}{\text{Total CP}} \times 100 = \frac{1500}{37500} \times 100 = \frac{150000}{37500} = 4\] So the overall loss percentage is 4%. Note: When the same selling price is used and the profit percentage equals the loss percentage, there is always a net loss. The loss percentage in such cases equals \( \frac{(\text{common}\%)^2}{100} \). Here \( \frac{20^2}{100} = \frac{400}{100} = 4\% \), which confirms our answer.

Answer: Overall Loss = ₹1500, Loss% = 4%

🎯 Try a Similar Question

Try a Similar Question

Question: A trader sold two laptops for ₹ 36,000 each. On one laptop he made a profit of \( 20\% \) and on the other a loss of \( 25\% \). Find his overall profit or loss in rupees and as a percentage of his total cost price.

Solution

  1. Step 1: Find the Cost Price of the laptop sold at a profit: The selling price of the first laptop is ₹ 36,000 and it was sold at a profit of \( 20\% \). Using the formula \( CP_1 = \frac{SP \times 100}{100 + \text{Profit}\%} \): \[ CP_1 = \frac{36000 \times 100}{100 + 20} = \frac{3600000}{120} = 30000 \] So the cost price of the first laptop is ₹ 30,000.
  2. Step 2: Find the Cost Price of the laptop sold at a loss: The selling price of the second laptop is ₹ 36,000 and it was sold at a loss of \( 25\% \). Using the formula \( CP_2 = \frac{SP \times 100}{100 - \text{Loss}\%} \): \[ CP_2 = \frac{36000 \times 100}{100 - 25} = \frac{3600000}{75} = 48000 \] So the cost price of the second laptop is ₹ 48,000.
  3. Step 3: Calculate the Total Cost Price and Total Selling Price: Total Cost Price: \[ TCP = CP_1 + CP_2 = 30000 + 48000 = 78000 \] Total Selling Price: \[ TSP = 36000 + 36000 = 72000 \]
  4. Step 4: Determine Overall Profit or Loss: Since the Total Selling Price \( 72000 \) is less than the Total Cost Price \( 78000 \), there is an overall loss. The loss in rupees is: \[ \text{Loss} = TCP - TSP = 78000 - 72000 = 6000 \] So the trader has an overall loss of ₹ 6,000.
  5. Step 5: Calculate the Loss Percentage: The loss percentage is calculated on the total cost price: \[ \text{Loss}\% = \frac{\text{Loss}}{TCP} \times 100 = \frac{6000}{78000} \times 100 = \frac{600000}{78000} \approx 7.69\% \] So the overall loss percentage is approximately \( 7.69\% \).

Answer: The trader has an overall loss of ₹ 6,000, which is a loss of approximately \( 7.69\% \) on his total cost price of ₹ 78,000.

Everything you get with Solver7

More questions in Fractions In Disguise