For which of the following solids is the lateral / curved surface area and total surface area the same ? (A) Cube (B) Cuboid (C) Hemisphere (D) Sphere
CBSE Class 10 Maths · Surface Areas And Volumes
CBSE Class 10 Maths · Surface Areas And Volumes
Imagine wrapping a gift box with paper. The box has flat sides and a flat bottom, so you need extra paper for those flat parts. A ball is different — it has no flat bottom at all! Every part of a ball is curved. So the outside skin of a ball and its total surface are exactly the same thing. Among a cube, a cuboid, a hemisphere, and a sphere, only the sphere has zero flat parts. That is why its curved surface area equals its total surface area, both equal to \( 4\pi r^2 \).
Answer: Option (D) Sphere — A sphere has no flat base, so its Curved Surface Area and Total Surface Area are the same: \( 4\pi r^2 \).
For any 3D solid, the Total Surface Area (TSA) is the sum of ALL faces (including the base or bases). The Lateral Surface Area (LSA) or Curved Surface Area (CSA) covers only the side faces — NOT the flat bases.
So TSA = LSA/CSA + Area of base(s).
For TSA and LSA/CSA to be equal, the area of the base(s) must be zero — meaning the solid has NO flat base at all.
A Sphere is the only solid among the options that has no flat base. Its entire surface is curved, so its Curved Surface Area and Total Surface Area are exactly the same.
Let us check each option: (A) Cube — has 6 square faces. TSA = 6a^2, LSA = 4a^2. They are NOT equal. (B) Cuboid — has 6 rectangular faces. TSA = 2(lb + bh + lh), LSA = 2h(l + b). They are NOT equal. (C) Hemisphere — has one curved surface AND one flat circular base. TSA = 3\pi r^2, CSA = 2\pi r^2. They are NOT equal. (D) Sphere — has only one continuous curved surface, NO flat base. TSA = CSA = 4\pi r^2. They ARE equal.
For a Sphere of radius r:
Curved Surface Area = Total Surface Area = \( 4\pi r^2 \)
For a Hemisphere of radius r:
CSA = \( 2\pi r^2 \), TSA = \( 3\pi r^2 \) (they are NOT equal)
For a Cube of side a:
LSA = \( 4a^2 \), TSA = \( 6a^2 \) (they are NOT equal)
Option (D) Sphere — A sphere has no flat base, so its Curved Surface Area and Total Surface Area are the same: \( 4\pi r^2 \).
Students often confuse a Hemisphere with a Sphere. A hemisphere has one flat circular base, so its TSA (\( 3\pi r^2 \)) is greater than its CSA (\( 2\pi r^2 \)). Only the Sphere, which has no flat face at all, has equal CSA and TSA.
Option (D) Sphere — A sphere has no flat base, so its Curved Surface Area and Total Surface Area are the same: \( 4\pi r^2 \).
One common mistake: Students often confuse a Hemisphere with a Sphere and assume both have equal CSA and TSA. Remember, a hemisphere has one flat circular base of area \( \pi r^2 \), so its TSA \( = 3\pi r^2 \) is larger than its CSA \( = 2\pi r^2 \). Only a full sphere has no flat face at all.
Answer: Option (D) Sphere — A sphere has no flat base, so its Curved Surface Area and Total Surface Area are the same: \( 4\pi r^2 \).
Question: For which of the following solids are the Curved Surface Area and Total Surface Area equal? (A) Cylinder (B) Cone (C) Sphere (D) Cuboid
Solution: Let us examine each option:
Option (A) — Cylinder: The Lateral Surface Area is \( 2\pi r h \). The Total Surface Area is \( 2\pi r h + 2\pi r^2 \). Since the two circular bases add \( 2\pi r^2 \), TSA \( \ne \) CSA.
Option (B) — Cone: The Curved Surface Area is \( \pi r l \). The Total Surface Area is \( \pi r l + \pi r^2 \). The circular base adds \( \pi r^2 \), so TSA \( \ne \) CSA.
Option (C) — Sphere: The Curved Surface Area is \( 4\pi r^2 \). A sphere has no flat face or base. Therefore the Total Surface Area is also \( 4\pi r^2 \). Hence CSA = TSA.
Option (D) — Cuboid: It has six rectangular faces. The Lateral Surface Area covers only four faces, while TSA covers all six. So TSA \( \ne \) LSA.
Since a sphere has no flat surface at all, every part of its surface is curved, making CSA = TSA.
Answer: (C) Sphere
Question: A student lists four solids: a cube, a sphere, a cone, and a hemisphere. The student claims that for exactly one of these solids, the Lateral (or Curved) Surface Area is the same as the Total Surface Area. Identify that solid and justify your answer.
Solution: Let us check each solid:
Cube: A cube has 6 equal square faces. The Lateral Surface Area covers 4 faces, so LSA = \( 4a^2 \). The Total Surface Area covers all 6 faces, so TSA = \( 6a^2 \). Clearly TSA \( \ne \) LSA.
Sphere: A sphere has only one continuous curved surface with no flat faces. Its Curved Surface Area is \( 4\pi r^2 \) and its Total Surface Area is also \( 4\pi r^2 \). Therefore CSA = TSA.
Cone: The Curved Surface Area is \( \pi r l \). The Total Surface Area is \( \pi r l + \pi r^2 \). The flat circular base contributes \( \pi r^2 \), so TSA \( \ne \) CSA.
Hemisphere: The Curved Surface Area is \( 2\pi r^2 \). The Total Surface Area includes the flat circular base as well: TSA = \( 2\pi r^2 + \pi r^2 = 3\pi r^2 \). So TSA \( \ne \) CSA.
Among the four solids, only the sphere has no flat face, so its curved surface area accounts for its entire surface area.
Answer: Sphere — because it has no flat face, so its Curved Surface Area equals its Total Surface Area, both being \( 4\pi r^2 \).
Question: For which of the following solids are the Curved Surface Area and the Total Surface Area NOT equal? (A) Sphere (B) Cone (C) Cylinder (D) Both (B) and (C)
Answer: Option (D) — Both Cone and Cylinder have flat base(s), so their Curved Surface Area and Total Surface Area are NOT equal.