SOLVER7 Study. Nothing Else.
Figure It Out 4 Q9

Which has greater area — an equilateral triangle or a square of the same sidelength as the triangle? Which has greater area — two identical equilateral triangles together or a square of the same sidelength as the triangle\(?\) Give reasons.

CBSE Class 8 Maths · Area

Solution

👶 Simple Explanation

Simple Explanation

Imagine drawing a square and a triangle on paper, both with sides of the same length. The square looks like a box and fills up a lot of space. The triangle looks like a pointy roof and is much more cramped inside. This happens because the triangle's middle height is shorter than its side, so it covers less area. Even if you put two triangles together, they still cover less ground than one square of the same side length.

Answer: The square has the greater area than a single equilateral triangle of the same side length, because the triangle's height (about \( 0.87a \)) is shorter than the square's side \( a \), giving areas of about \( 0.43a^2 \) versus \( a^2 \). Even two identical triangles together (about \( 0.86a^2 \)) still have less area than the square (\( a^2 \)), so the square is greater in both cases.

📖 Comparing Areas of an Equilateral Triangle and a Square

Detailed Explanation

When a triangle and a square have the same side length, they do NOT have the same area. The square encloses more space than the triangle. Think of the square as a triangle 'straightened out' into a right corner \( 90^\circ \), which pushes its area up. The height of an equilateral triangle is shorter than its side, so its area comes out smaller. To compare areas fairly, we compute each area for a common side length, say \( a \), and then compare the numbers.

Formula Used

Area of a square of side \( a \) is \( a^2 \). Area of an equilateral triangle of side \( a \) is \( \frac{1}{2} \times a \times h \), where \( h \) is its height. For an equilateral triangle the height is approximately \( h \approx 0.87a \).

Solution

  1. Step 1: Take the same side length for both figures. Let each side be \( a \). This is important because we are told the triangle and the square have the same side length, so a fair comparison uses one common value of \( a \).
  2. Step 2: Find the area of the square. A square of side \( a \) has area \[ \text{Area of square} = a^2. \]
  3. Step 3: Find the height of the equilateral triangle. An equilateral triangle does not have a right angle at its base, so its height \( h \) is less than its side. For an equilateral triangle the height is about \[ h \approx 0.87a. \] The height is shorter than the side \( a \), and this is the key reason the triangle covers less space.
  4. Step 4: Find the area of the equilateral triangle using base and height. \[ \text{Area of triangle} = \frac{1}{2} \times a \times h \] Substituting \( h \approx 0.87a \): \[ \text{Area of triangle} \approx \frac{1}{2} \times a \times 0.87a \approx 0.43a^2. \]
  5. Step 5: Compare one triangle with the square. The square has area \( a^2 \) while the triangle has area about \( 0.43a^2 \). Since \[ 0.43a^2 < a^2, \] the square has the greater area. So a single equilateral triangle covers less than half the area of the square.
  6. Step 6: Now compare TWO identical triangles with the square. Two triangles together give \[ 2 \times 0.43a^2 = 0.86a^2. \] Comparing with the square's area \( a^2 \): \[ 0.86a^2 < a^2. \] So even two triangles together still have less area than the square.

Final Answer

The square has the greater area than a single equilateral triangle of the same side length, because the triangle's height (about \( 0.87a \)) is shorter than the square's side \( a \), giving areas of about \( 0.43a^2 \) versus \( a^2 \). Even two identical triangles together (about \( 0.86a^2 \)) still have less area than the square (\( a^2 \)), so the square is greater in both cases.

Common Mistake

A common mistake is thinking that because a square is made of two triangles, two equilateral triangles must equal the square. But the square splits into two right-angled triangles, NOT equilateral ones. Equilateral triangles are 'shorter' (smaller height), so even two of them stay below the square's area.

🪜 Step-by-step Solution

Step-by-step Solution

  1. Step 1: Fix a common side length: Let the side length of both the square and the equilateral triangle be \( a \). — Reason: Both shapes share the same side length, so using one symbol \( a \) keeps the comparison fair and general.
  2. Step 2: Calculate the area of the square: A square has all four sides equal, so its area is simply side multiplied by side: \[ A_{\text{square}} = a \times a = a^2 \] — Reason: This gives us the benchmark area we will compare the triangle against.
  3. Step 3: Find the height of the equilateral triangle: In an equilateral triangle, all angles are \( 60^\circ \), so the height \( h \) drawn from one vertex to the opposite side is shorter than the side itself. The approximate value is \[ h \approx 0.87a \] — Reason: The height is needed to compute the triangle's area using the standard formula, and noticing that \( 0.87a < a \) already hints that the triangle will have less area.
  4. Step 4: Calculate the area of one equilateral triangle: Substituting base \( = a \) and height \( h \approx 0.87a \) into the triangle area formula: \[ A_{\text{triangle}} = \frac{1}{2} \times a \times 0.87a = \frac{0.87a^2}{2} \approx 0.43a^2 \] — Reason: This is the actual space covered by one equilateral triangle of side \( a \).
  5. Step 5: Compare one triangle with the square: We now place the two areas side by side: \[ A_{\text{square}} = a^2 \quad \text{and} \quad A_{\text{triangle}} \approx 0.43a^2 \] Since \( 0.43a^2 < a^2 \), the square has more area than one equilateral triangle. — Reason: A direct numerical comparison settles which shape encloses more space.
  6. Step 6: Check whether two identical triangles together beat the square: Area of two such triangles combined: \[ 2 \times A_{\text{triangle}} \approx 2 \times 0.43a^2 = 0.86a^2 \] Comparing with the square: \( 0.86a^2 < a^2 \). — Reason: Even doubling the triangles still leaves their total area smaller than the square's area, confirming the square's superiority in both scenarios.

Final Answer

The square has the greater area than a single equilateral triangle of the same side length, because the triangle's height (about \( 0.87a \)) is shorter than the square's side \( a \), giving areas of about \( 0.43a^2 \) versus \( a^2 \). Even two identical triangles together (about \( 0.86a^2 \)) still have less area than the square (\( a^2 \)), so the square is greater in both cases.

Common Mistake

One common mistake: Students assume that because the triangle and the square have the same side length, they must have the same area — but area depends on the shape's height and overall geometry, not just its side length. Always compute the actual area using the correct formula for each shape.

✍️ Exam-ready Answer

Exam-ready Answer

  1. Step 1: Side length for both shapes: \( a \). Area of square: \[ a^2 \]
  2. Step 2: Height of equilateral triangle: \( h \approx 0.87a \). Area of one triangle: \[ \frac{1}{2} \times a \times 0.87a = 0.435a^2 \approx 0.43a^2 \]
  3. Step 3: Area of two identical triangles: \[ 2 \times 0.43a^2 = 0.86a^2 \]
  4. Step 4: Comparison: \( 0.43a^2 < a^2 \) and \( 0.86a^2 < a^2 \), so square \( > \) triangle(s) in both cases.

Answer: The square has the greater area than a single equilateral triangle of the same side length, because the triangle's height (about \( 0.87a \)) is shorter than the square's side \( a \), giving areas of about \( 0.43a^2 \) versus \( a^2 \). Even two identical triangles together (about \( 0.86a^2 \)) still have less area than the square (\( a^2 \)), so the square is greater in both cases.

➕ More Examples

More Examples

Example 1

Question: A regular hexagon is divided into 6 equilateral triangles, each with side length 8 cm. Compare the area of one equilateral triangle with side 8 cm to the area of a square with the same side length 8 cm. Which is greater and by approximately how much? Also compare: do three such equilateral triangles together have a greater area than the square?

Solution: Step 1: Find the area of the equilateral triangle with side \( a = 8 \) cm. The area of an equilateral triangle with side a is: \[ \text{Area of triangle} = \frac{\sqrt{3}}{4} a^2 \] Substituting \( a = 8 \): \[ \text{Area of triangle} = \frac{\sqrt{3}}{4} \times 8^2 = \frac{\sqrt{3}}{4} \times 64 = 16\sqrt{3} \] Using \( \sqrt{3} \approx 1.732 \): \[ \text{Area of triangle} \approx 16 \times 1.732 = 27.712 \text{ cm}^2 \] Step 2: Find the area of the square with side 8 cm. \[ \text{Area of square} = 8^2 = 64 \text{ cm}^2 \] Step 3: Compare the two areas (one triangle vs. one square). Since \( 27.712 \text{ cm}^2 < 64 \text{ cm}^2 \), the square has a greater area. The square is larger by approximately: \[ 64 - 27.712 \approx 36.288 \text{ cm}^2 \] Step 4: Compare three equilateral triangles together with the square. \[ \text{Area of 3 triangles} = 3 \times 16\sqrt{3} = 48\sqrt{3} \approx 48 \times 1.732 = 83.136 \text{ cm}^2 \] Since \( 83.136 \text{ cm}^2 > 64 \text{ cm}^2 \), three equilateral triangles together have a greater area than the square. Reason: Each equilateral triangle has area \( \approx 0.433 a^2 \), which is less than \( a^2 \) (area of square). So one triangle is smaller. But three triangles give area \( \approx 1.299 a^2 \), which is greater than \( a^2 \), so three triangles together are larger than the square.

Answer: One equilateral triangle (area \( \approx 27.71 \) cm\(^2\)) is smaller than the square (area \( = 64 \) cm\(^2\)). Three equilateral triangles together (area \( \approx 83.14 \) cm\(^2\)) are greater than the square.

Example 2

Question: A farmer has a piece of wire of length 60 cm. He bends it into an equilateral triangle. A second farmer bends the same length of wire into a square. Both shapes use all 60 cm of wire. Which shape has the greater area — the equilateral triangle or the square? Also, if four identical equilateral triangles (each with the same side as the first triangle) are placed together, do they together have a greater area than the square? Show your working.

Solution: Step 1: Find the side of each shape. The equilateral triangle has perimeter 60 cm, so each side: \[ a = \frac{60}{3} = 20 \text{ cm} \] The square has perimeter 60 cm, so each side: \[ s = \frac{60}{4} = 15 \text{ cm} \] Note: The side lengths are different here — the triangle has side 20 cm and the square has side 15 cm. Step 2: Find the area of the equilateral triangle (side 20 cm). \[ \text{Area of triangle} = \frac{\sqrt{3}}{4} \times 20^2 = \frac{\sqrt{3}}{4} \times 400 = 100\sqrt{3} \] Using \( \sqrt{3} \approx 1.732 \): \[ \text{Area of triangle} \approx 100 \times 1.732 = 173.2 \text{ cm}^2 \] Step 3: Find the area of the square (side 15 cm). \[ \text{Area of square} = 15^2 = 225 \text{ cm}^2 \] Step 4: Compare (one triangle vs. one square). Since \( 173.2 \text{ cm}^2 < 225 \text{ cm}^2 \), the square has the greater area. Reason: Even though the triangle's side (20 cm) is longer, the formula for the equilateral triangle gives area \( \approx 0.433 a^2 \), while the square gives \( s^2 = 225 \). So \( 0.433 \times 400 = 173.2 < 225 \). Step 5: Compare four equilateral triangles (each with side 20 cm) with the square (side 15 cm). \[ \text{Area of 4 triangles} = 4 \times 100\sqrt{3} = 400\sqrt{3} \approx 400 \times 1.732 = 692.8 \text{ cm}^2 \] Since \( 692.8 \text{ cm}^2 > 225 \text{ cm}^2 \), four equilateral triangles together are much larger than the square. Conclusion: One equilateral triangle (from 60 cm wire) is smaller in area than the square (from the same wire length). Four such triangles together are larger than the square.

Answer: The square (area \( = 225 \) cm\(^2\)) has greater area than one equilateral triangle (area \( \approx 173.2 \) cm\(^2\)). Four equilateral triangles together (area \( \approx 692.8 \) cm\(^2\)) have far greater area than the square.

🎯 Try a Similar Question

Try a Similar Question

Question: A rectangle has its shorter side equal to the side length \( a \) of an equilateral triangle, and its longer side is twice that length (i.e., \( 2a \)). (i) Which has the greater area — the equilateral triangle or the rectangle? (ii) Which has the greater area — three identical equilateral triangles placed together or the same rectangle? Give reasons with calculations.

Solution

  1. Step 1: Write the area of the equilateral triangle: The formula for the area of an equilateral triangle with side \( a \) is \[ A_{\triangle} = \frac{\sqrt{3}}{4} a^2. \] Since \( \sqrt{3} \approx 1.732 \), we get \[ A_{\triangle} \approx \frac{1.732}{4} a^2 \approx 0.433 a^2. \]
  2. Step 2: Write the area of the rectangle: The rectangle has sides \( a \) and \( 2a \), so its area is \[ A_{\text{rect}} = a \times 2a = 2a^2. \]
  3. Step 3: Compare the triangle and the rectangle (Part i): We compare \( 0.433 a^2 \) with \( 2a^2 \). Since \( 0.433 a^2 < 2a^2 \) for any positive side length \( a \), the rectangle has a much greater area than a single equilateral triangle.
  4. Step 4: Find the area of three equilateral triangles: The combined area of three identical equilateral triangles is \[ 3 \times A_{\triangle} = 3 \times 0.433 a^2 = 1.299 a^2 \approx 1.3 a^2. \]
  5. Step 5: Compare three triangles and the rectangle (Part ii): We compare \( 1.3 a^2 \) with \( 2a^2 \). Since \( 1.3 a^2 < 2a^2 \), even three equilateral triangles together still have less area than the rectangle. The rectangle remains greater in area.
  6. Step 6: State the conclusion: In both cases, the rectangle (with sides \( a \) and \( 2a \)) has the greater area. A single equilateral triangle covers only about \( 0.433 a^2 \) and three such triangles together cover only about \( 1.3 a^2 \), both less than the rectangle's area of \( 2a^2 \).

Answer: The rectangle is greater in area in both cases. (i) One equilateral triangle has area \( \approx 0.433 a^2 \), while the rectangle has area \( 2a^2 \), so the rectangle is larger. (ii) Three equilateral triangles together have area \( \approx 1.3 a^2 \), which is still less than the rectangle's area of \( 2a^2 \), so the rectangle is still larger.

Everything you get with Solver7

More questions in Area