Detailed Explanation
When a triangle and a square have the same side length, they do NOT have the same area. The square encloses more space than the triangle. Think of the square as a triangle 'straightened out' into a right corner \( 90^\circ \), which pushes its area up. The height of an equilateral triangle is shorter than its side, so its area comes out smaller. To compare areas fairly, we compute each area for a common side length, say \( a \), and then compare the numbers.
Formula Used
Area of a square of side \( a \) is \( a^2 \). Area of an equilateral triangle of side \( a \) is \( \frac{1}{2} \times a \times h \), where \( h \) is its height. For an equilateral triangle the height is approximately \( h \approx 0.87a \).
Solution
- Step 1: Take the same side length for both figures. Let each side be \( a \). This is important because we are told the triangle and the square have the same side length, so a fair comparison uses one common value of \( a \).
- Step 2: Find the area of the square. A square of side \( a \) has area \[ \text{Area of square} = a^2. \]
- Step 3: Find the height of the equilateral triangle. An equilateral triangle does not have a right angle at its base, so its height \( h \) is less than its side. For an equilateral triangle the height is about \[ h \approx 0.87a. \] The height is shorter than the side \( a \), and this is the key reason the triangle covers less space.
- Step 4: Find the area of the equilateral triangle using base and height. \[ \text{Area of triangle} = \frac{1}{2} \times a \times h \] Substituting \( h \approx 0.87a \): \[ \text{Area of triangle} \approx \frac{1}{2} \times a \times 0.87a \approx 0.43a^2. \]
- Step 5: Compare one triangle with the square. The square has area \( a^2 \) while the triangle has area about \( 0.43a^2 \). Since \[ 0.43a^2 < a^2, \] the square has the greater area. So a single equilateral triangle covers less than half the area of the square.
- Step 6: Now compare TWO identical triangles with the square. Two triangles together give \[ 2 \times 0.43a^2 = 0.86a^2. \] Comparing with the square's area \( a^2 \): \[ 0.86a^2 < a^2. \] So even two triangles together still have less area than the square.
Final Answer
The square has the greater area than a single equilateral triangle of the same side length, because the triangle's height (about \( 0.87a \)) is shorter than the square's side \( a \), giving areas of about \( 0.43a^2 \) versus \( a^2 \). Even two identical triangles together (about \( 0.86a^2 \)) still have less area than the square (\( a^2 \)), so the square is greater in both cases.
Common Mistake
A common mistake is thinking that because a square is made of two triangles, two equilateral triangles must equal the square. But the square splits into two right-angled triangles, NOT equilateral ones. Equilateral triangles are 'shorter' (smaller height), so even two of them stay below the square's area.