SOLVER7 Study. Nothing Else.
Figure It Out 4 Q4

Consider a rectangle and a parallelogram of the same sidelengths: \(5\ cm\) and \(4\ cm.\) Which has the greater area\(? [Hint:\) Imagine constructing them on the same base\(.]\)

CBSE Class 8 Maths · Area

Solution

👶 Simple Explanation

Simple Explanation

Imagine two books lying flat, both the same width. One book stands up perfectly straight, but the other leans sideways like the Tower of Pisa. Even though both have sides of the same length, the leaning book is actually shorter from bottom to top. The rectangle is like the straight book — its side goes straight up, so its full length counts as height. The parallelogram leans over, so its real up-down height is smaller. A slanted side is always longer than the true straight-up height.

Answer: The rectangle has the greater area. Its area is \( 20\ cm^2 \), while the parallelogram's area is less than \( 20\ cm^2 \) because its perpendicular height is smaller than \( 4\ cm \) (the \( 4\ cm \) is only the slanted side, not the height).

📖 Rectangle vs Parallelogram: Comparing Areas

Detailed Explanation

The area of a rectangle depends on its length and breadth, but the area of a parallelogram depends on its base and its height (the perpendicular distance between the base and the opposite side), not on its slanted side. In the image, both figures are built on the same base of \( 5\ cm \). The rectangle has vertical sides of \( 4\ cm \), so its height is exactly \( 4\ cm \). The parallelogram has a slanted side of \( 4\ cm \), but because that side leans over, the perpendicular height (the straight up-down distance from the base to the top) is LESS than \( 4\ cm \). This is the key idea: the slanted side is not the height.

Formula Used

Area of a rectangle \( = \text{length} \times \text{breadth} \). Area of a parallelogram \( = \text{base} \times \text{height} \), where height is the perpendicular distance between the base and the opposite side.

Solution

  1. Step 1: Note the given measurements from the figure. Both the rectangle and the parallelogram share the same base of \( 5\ cm \), and both have a side of length \( 4\ cm \).
  2. Step 2: Find the area of the rectangle. In a rectangle the side of \( 4\ cm \) stands straight up, so it is also the height. \[ \text{Area}_{rectangle} = \text{length} \times \text{breadth} = 5 \times 4 = 20\ cm^2 \]
  3. Step 3: Understand the height of the parallelogram. In the parallelogram, the \( 4\ cm \) side is slanted (it leans to one side). The height of a parallelogram is the perpendicular distance from the base to the opposite side, NOT the length of the slanted side. Because the side is tilted, this perpendicular height is smaller than \( 4\ cm \).
  4. Step 4: Compare the areas using the same base. Both figures rest on the same base of \( 5\ cm \). The rectangle rises to a full height of \( 4\ cm \), while the parallelogram, having a slanted side, rises to a height less than \( 4\ cm \). \[ \text{Area}_{parallelogram} = 5 \times (\text{height less than } 4) < 5 \times 4 \]
  5. Step 5: Draw the conclusion. Since the parallelogram's height is less than the rectangle's height while both share the same base, the parallelogram covers less area. Therefore the rectangle has the greater area.

Final Answer

The rectangle has the greater area. Its area is \( 20\ cm^2 \), while the parallelogram's area is less than \( 20\ cm^2 \) because its perpendicular height is smaller than \( 4\ cm \) (the \( 4\ cm \) is only the slanted side, not the height).

Common Mistake

A common mistake is to use the slanted \( 4\ cm \) side as the height and compute the parallelogram's area as \( 5 \times 4 = 20\ cm^2 \), concluding the areas are equal. The height of a parallelogram must always be the perpendicular distance between the base and the opposite side, which here is less than \( 4\ cm \).

🪜 Step-by-step Solution

Step-by-step Solution

  1. Step 1: Read the given information from the figure. Both the rectangle and the parallelogram share the same base of \( 5\ cm \), and each has a side measuring \( 4\ cm \). — Reason: Identifying shared and different measurements helps us pinpoint exactly where the two shapes will differ in area.
  2. Step 2: Calculate the area of the rectangle. Its \( 4\ cm \) side stands perfectly vertical, so it IS the perpendicular height. \[ \text{Area}_{\text{rectangle}} = 5 \times 4 = 20\ cm^2 \] — Reason: In a rectangle every side is perpendicular to the adjacent side, so the breadth of \( 4\ cm \) directly serves as the height — no adjustment needed.
  3. Step 3: Examine the parallelogram's \( 4\ cm \) side carefully. This side is slanted — it leans at an angle rather than standing straight up. — Reason: Recognising that the side is slanted (not vertical) is the crucial observation; it tells us the \( 4\ cm \) measurement is the length of the slant, not the height.
  4. Step 4: Determine the parallelogram's perpendicular height. Imagine dropping a vertical line from the top edge straight down to the base — that vertical distance is the true height, and it is strictly less than \( 4\ cm \). We can write: perpendicular height \( < 4\ cm \). — Reason: The perpendicular (straight-down) distance is always shorter than the slanted path connecting the same two parallel lines; this is a geometric fact similar to how the hypotenuse of a right triangle is longer than either leg.
  5. Step 5: Estimate the area of the parallelogram. Since its perpendicular height is less than \( 4\ cm \), we get: \[ \text{Area}_{\text{parallelogram}} = 5 \times (\text{perpendicular height}) < 5 \times 4 = 20\ cm^2 \] — Reason: Multiplying the same base \( 5\ cm \) by a smaller height must give a smaller product, confirming the parallelogram's area falls short of \( 20\ cm^2 \).
  6. Step 6: Compare the two areas. Rectangle area \( = 20\ cm^2 \); Parallelogram area \( < 20\ cm^2 \). Therefore the rectangle has the greater area. — Reason: A direct numerical comparison gives the final conclusion about which shape covers more surface.

Final Answer

The rectangle has the greater area. Its area is \( 20\ cm^2 \), while the parallelogram's area is less than \( 20\ cm^2 \) because its perpendicular height is smaller than \( 4\ cm \) (the \( 4\ cm \) is only the slanted side, not the height).

Common Mistake

One common mistake: Students often treat the slanted side of the parallelogram as its height and wrongly calculate its area as \( 5 \times 4 = 20\ cm^2 \), concluding both shapes have equal areas — but the height must always be the perpendicular (straight-down) distance, not the length of the leaning side.

✍️ Exam-ready Answer

Exam-ready Answer

  1. Step 1: Rectangle: base = \( 5\ cm \), side = \( 4\ cm \) (vertical, so height = \( 4\ cm \)). \[Area_{rectangle} = 5 \times 4 = 20\ cm^2\]
  2. Step 2: Parallelogram: base = \( 5\ cm \), slanted side = \( 4\ cm \). Perpendicular height \( < 4\ cm \), so \[Area_{parallelogram} = 5 \times h,\quad h < 4\ cm\]
  3. Step 3: Since \( h < 4\ cm \), we get \( Area_{parallelogram} < 20\ cm^2 \). Rectangle area \( > \) Parallelogram area.

Answer: The rectangle has the greater area. Its area is \( 20\ cm^2 \), while the parallelogram's area is less than \( 20\ cm^2 \) because its perpendicular height is smaller than \( 4\ cm \) (the \( 4\ cm \) is only the slanted side, not the height).

➕ More Examples

More Examples

Example 1

Question: A rectangle and a parallelogram both have sides of length 7 cm and 3 cm. The perpendicular height of the parallelogram (measured from the base of 7 cm) is 2.4 cm. Find the area of each figure and state which has the greater area.

Solution: Step 1: Find the area of the rectangle. For the rectangle with length 7 cm and breadth 3 cm: \[\text{Area of rectangle} = 7 \times 3 = 21 \text{ cm}^2\] Step 2: Find the area of the parallelogram. The base of the parallelogram is 7 cm and its perpendicular height is 2.4 cm (note that 2.4 cm is less than the slant side of 3 cm): \[\text{Area of parallelogram} = 7 \times 2.4 = 16.8 \text{ cm}^2\] Step 3: Compare the two areas. Since \(21 > 16.8\), the rectangle has the greater area. Key reason: The sides of the parallelogram are the same as those of the rectangle, but the perpendicular height of the parallelogram (2.4 cm) is strictly less than the breadth (3 cm), because the parallelogram leans. Therefore, the area of the parallelogram is always less than the area of the rectangle when they share the same side lengths and the parallelogram is non-rectangular.

Answer: Area of rectangle = 21 cm², Area of parallelogram = 16.8 cm². The rectangle has the greater area.

Example 2

Question: A school garden is shaped like a parallelogram with base 10 m and a slant side of 6 m. A neighbouring plot is a rectangle also with length 10 m and width 6 m. If the perpendicular height of the parallelogram is 5 m, which plot has the larger area, and by how much?

Solution: Step 1: Find the area of the rectangular plot. Length = 10 m, Width = 6 m: \[\text{Area of rectangle} = 10 \times 6 = 60 \text{ m}^2\] Step 2: Find the area of the parallelogram-shaped garden. Base = 10 m, perpendicular height = 5 m (which is less than the slant side of 6 m, confirming the shape leans): \[\text{Area of parallelogram} = 10 \times 5 = 50 \text{ m}^2\] Step 3: Find the difference in areas. \[\text{Difference} = 60 - 50 = 10 \text{ m}^2\] Step 4: Compare and conclude. Since \(60 > 50\), the rectangular plot has the larger area. It is larger by 10 m². Key reason: Both figures share the same side lengths (10 m and 6 m), but the perpendicular height of the parallelogram (5 m) is less than 6 m because the figure is slanted. This makes the parallelogram's area smaller than the rectangle's area.

Answer: Area of rectangle = 60 m², Area of parallelogram = 50 m². The rectangular plot is larger by 10 m².

🎯 Try a Similar Question

Try a Similar Question

Question: A rectangle and a parallelogram are drawn on the same base of \( 9 \) cm. The other side of each shape is \( 6 \) cm. The parallelogram is tilted so that its perpendicular height is \( 4.5 \) cm. (i) Find the area of the rectangle. (ii) Find the area of the parallelogram. (iii) Which shape has the greater area, and why?

Solution

  1. Step 1 — Identify the dimensions: Both the rectangle and the parallelogram have a base of \( 9 \) cm and a side of \( 6 \) cm. In the rectangle, the side of \( 6 \) cm is perpendicular to the base, so it acts as the height. In the parallelogram, the side of \( 6 \) cm is slanted, and the actual perpendicular height is given as \( 4.5 \) cm.
  2. Step 2 — Calculate the area of the rectangle: Area of rectangle = length \( \times \) breadth. Substituting the values: \[ \text{Area} = 9 \times 6 = 54 \text{ cm}^2 \]
  3. Step 3 — Calculate the area of the parallelogram: Area of parallelogram = base \( \times \) perpendicular height. The perpendicular height is \( 4.5 \) cm, not \( 6 \) cm. Substituting: \[ \text{Area} = 9 \times 4.5 = 40.5 \text{ cm}^2 \]
  4. Step 4 — Compare the two areas: Area of rectangle \( = 54 \) cm\(^2\). Area of parallelogram \( = 40.5 \) cm\(^2\). Since \( 54 > 40.5 \), the rectangle has the greater area.
  5. Step 5 — Explain why: Even though both shapes have the same base and the same side length of \( 6 \) cm, the parallelogram is tilted. Its perpendicular height \( (4.5 \text{ cm}) \) is always less than its slanted side \( (6 \text{ cm}) \). The rectangle uses the full \( 6 \) cm as its height, giving it a larger area.

Answer: The rectangle has the greater area. Area of the rectangle \( = 54 \) cm\(^2\); area of the parallelogram \( = 40.5 \) cm\(^2\). The rectangle's area is larger because its side of \( 6 \) cm is perpendicular to the base and serves as the full height, whereas the parallelogram's perpendicular height (\( 4.5 \) cm) is less than its slanted side (\( 6 \) cm).

Everything you get with Solver7

More questions in Area