SOLVER7 Study. Nothing Else.
Figure It Out 1 Q2(iii)

The figure shows a path (the shaded portion) laid around a rectangular park \(EFGH.\) Does the area of the path change when the outer rectangle is moved while keeping the inner rectangular park \(EFGH\) inside it, as shown\(?\)

CBSE Class 8 Maths · Area

Solution

👶 Simple Explanation

Simple Explanation

Imagine a picture frame around a photo. The frame is the path, the photo is the park. No matter where you place the photo inside the frame, the amount of frame stays the same. The big outer rectangle ABCD never changes its size. The small inner park EFGH never changes its size either. Only the position of the park moves around. Since the path is just the big area minus the small area, moving the park does not change that difference at all.

Answer: No, the area of the path does NOT change. Since both the outer rectangle ABCD and the inner park EFGH keep the same dimensions, the area of the path (outer area minus inner area) remains exactly the same in every figure, no matter where the park is placed inside.

📖 Area of a Path Around a Park

Detailed Explanation

The path is the shaded region that lies between two rectangles: the big outer rectangle ABCD and the small inner rectangle (the park) EFGH. To find the area of the path, we use a simple idea called the area of a border or frame. The area of the path equals the area of the outer rectangle minus the area of the inner rectangle. In all three figures, the outer rectangle ABCD is exactly the same size, and the inner park EFGH is also exactly the same size. Only the position of the inner park inside the outer rectangle changes. Since area depends only on the dimensions (length and breadth) of the two rectangles and NOT on where the inner rectangle is placed, the area of the shaded path stays the same in every figure.

Formula Used

\[ \text{Area of path} = \text{Area of outer rectangle} - \text{Area of inner rectangle} \]

Solution

  1. Step 1: Understand what the path is: The shaded portion is the region left over when we remove the inner park EFGH from the big rectangle ABCD. So the path is just the difference of the two rectangular areas.
  2. Step 2: Write the area of the path: Using the border idea, we can write \[ \text{Area of path} = (\text{Area of ABCD}) - (\text{Area of EFGH}). \] This uses the fact that area of a rectangle is length \times breadth.
  3. Step 3: Check what stays fixed in all three figures: In all three pictures the outer rectangle ABCD has the same length and breadth, so its area is unchanged. Also, the inner park EFGH has the same length and breadth, so its area is unchanged too. Only the position of EFGH inside ABCD is different.
  4. Step 4: See why position does not matter: Area of any rectangle depends only on its length and breadth, not on where it is placed. Since both the outer area and the inner area stay exactly the same, their difference also stays exactly the same.
  5. Step 5: Conclusion: Therefore \[ \text{Area of path} = (\text{same outer area}) - (\text{same inner area}) \] gives the same value in all three figures, so the area of the path does not change.

Final Answer

No, the area of the path does NOT change. Since both the outer rectangle ABCD and the inner park EFGH keep the same dimensions, the area of the path (outer area minus inner area) remains exactly the same in every figure, no matter where the park is placed inside.

Common Mistake

A common mistake is thinking that because the border looks wider on one side in some figures, the total area of the path changes. Students forget that if the path becomes wider on one side, it automatically becomes narrower on the opposite side, so the total shaded area stays the same.

🪜 Step-by-step Solution

Step-by-step Solution

  1. Step 1: Identify the two rectangles involved. The large outer rectangle is ABCD and the small inner rectangle (the park) is EFGH. The shaded path is the region that lies between these two rectangles. — Reason: We must clearly define what we are measuring before calculating anything.
  2. Step 2: Write the expression for the area of the path using the border/frame idea: \[ \text{Area of path} = (\text{Area of ABCD}) - (\text{Area of EFGH}) \] — Reason: The path is simply what remains after removing the inner park from the full outer rectangle, so subtraction gives us its area.
  3. Step 3: Recall that the area of any rectangle is length \(\times\) breadth. So we can write: \[ \text{Area of ABCD} = L_{\text{outer}} \times B_{\text{outer}} \] and \[ \text{Area of EFGH} = L_{\text{inner}} \times B_{\text{inner}} \] — Reason: Expressing areas in terms of dimensions makes it easy to compare across all three figures.
  4. Step 4: Check what is fixed across all three figures: In every figure, the outer rectangle ABCD has the same length and breadth, so \( L_{\text{outer}} \times B_{\text{outer}} \) is unchanged. Likewise, the inner park EFGH has the same length and breadth in every figure, so \( L_{\text{inner}} \times B_{\text{inner}} \) is also unchanged. — Reason: If both individual areas stay constant, their difference must stay constant too.
  5. Step 5: Observe what actually changes across the three figures: only the position of the inner park EFGH inside the outer rectangle ABCD shifts. The park may be placed centrally, to one side, or in a corner — but its dimensions never change. — Reason: Position does not affect the area formula; area depends solely on length and breadth, not on placement.
  6. Step 6: Conclude by substituting into the area formula: \[ \text{Area of path} = (L_{\text{outer}} \times B_{\text{outer}}) - (L_{\text{inner}} \times B_{\text{inner}}) \] Since neither \( L_{\text{outer}} \times B_{\text{outer}} \) nor \( L_{\text{inner}} \times B_{\text{inner}} \) changes from figure to figure, the area of the path remains exactly the same in all three figures. — Reason: The difference of two fixed quantities is itself a fixed quantity.

Final Answer

No, the area of the path does NOT change. Since both the outer rectangle ABCD and the inner park EFGH keep the same dimensions, the area of the path (outer area minus inner area) remains exactly the same in every figure, no matter where the park is placed inside.

Common Mistake

One common mistake: Students think that moving the inner park closer to one edge of the outer rectangle changes the path area, because the path looks wider on one side and narrower on the other. In reality, area depends only on the dimensions (length and breadth) of the two rectangles, not on where the inner rectangle is positioned, so the total path area never changes.

✍️ Exam-ready Answer

Exam-ready Answer

  1. Step 1: Area of outer rectangle ABCD = fixed (same length and breadth in all figures).
  2. Step 2: Area of inner park EFGH = fixed (same length and breadth in all figures).
  3. Step 3: Area of path = (Area of ABCD) \( - \) (Area of EFGH) = constant, regardless of the position of EFGH inside ABCD.

Answer: No, the area of the path does NOT change. Since both the outer rectangle ABCD and the inner park EFGH keep the same dimensions, the area of the path (outer area minus inner area) remains exactly the same in every figure, no matter where the park is placed inside.

➕ More Examples

More Examples

Example 1

Question: A rectangular swimming pool ABCD measures 20 m in length and 12 m in width. A tiled border of uniform width 2 m is laid all around it, forming a larger outer rectangle. (a) Find the area of the tiled border. (b) If the outer rectangle is shifted so that the border on one side becomes 3 m wide and on the opposite side becomes 1 m wide (but total width of border on that pair of sides remains 4 m), does the area of the border change? Justify your answer.

Solution: Step 1 — Find the dimensions of the outer rectangle when the border is uniform (2 m on each side). The border adds 2 m on each side, so: Outer length = \( 20 + 2 + 2 = 24 \) m Outer width = \( 12 + 2 + 2 = 16 \) m Step 2 — Calculate the areas. Area of outer rectangle: \[ 24 \times 16 = 384 \text{ m}^2 \] Area of inner pool: \[ 20 \times 12 = 240 \text{ m}^2 \] Step 3 — Find the area of the tiled border. Area of border = Area of outer rectangle \( - \) Area of inner pool \[ 384 - 240 = 144 \text{ m}^2 \] Step 4 — Check whether shifting changes the area. When the outer rectangle shifts so the border becomes 3 m on one side and 1 m on the other, the total width added on that pair of sides is still \( 3 + 1 = 4 \) m. So the outer rectangle dimensions remain 24 m \( \times \) 16 m — unchanged. The inner pool ABCD is still 20 m \( \times \) 12 m — unchanged. Area of border after shifting: \[ 384 - 240 = 144 \text{ m}^2 \] The area of the tiled border does NOT change.

Answer: Area of the tiled border = 144 m\(^2\); the area does not change when the outer rectangle is shifted.

Example 2

Question: A rectangular garden PQRS is 15 m long and 9 m wide. A gravel path of width 1.5 m is laid uniformly around it. (a) Find the area of the gravel path. (b) Suppose the outer boundary is repositioned so that the gravel path is 2.5 m wide on one of the longer sides and 0.5 m wide on the opposite longer side, while both shorter sides still have 1.5 m of path. Does the total area of the gravel path change? Explain.

Solution: Step 1 — Find the dimensions of the outer rectangle with a uniform 1.5 m path. Outer length = \( 15 + 1.5 + 1.5 = 18 \) m Outer width = \( 9 + 1.5 + 1.5 = 12 \) m Step 2 — Calculate the areas. Area of outer rectangle: \[ 18 \times 12 = 216 \text{ m}^2 \] Area of inner garden: \[ 15 \times 9 = 135 \text{ m}^2 \] Step 3 — Find the area of the gravel path. Area of gravel path = Area of outer rectangle \( - \) Area of inner garden \[ 216 - 135 = 81 \text{ m}^2 \] Step 4 — Check after repositioning the outer boundary. On the longer sides the path is now 2.5 m and 0.5 m. Total width added = \( 2.5 + 0.5 = 3 \) m, which equals the original \( 1.5 + 1.5 = 3 \) m. On the shorter sides it is still 1.5 m each, adding \( 3 \) m in width. So outer rectangle dimensions are still \( 18 \) m \( \times \) \( 12 \) m, and the garden PQRS is still \( 15 \) m \( \times \) \( 9 \) m. Area of gravel path after repositioning: \[ 216 - 135 = 81 \text{ m}^2 \] The area of the gravel path does NOT change.

Answer: Area of the gravel path = 81 m\(^2\); the area does not change when the outer boundary is repositioned.

🎯 Try a Similar Question

Try a Similar Question

Question: A rectangular swimming pool PQRS measures 12 m in length and 8 m in width. It is surrounded by a uniform tiled border. The outer boundary of the tiled border forms a rectangle ABCD that measures 18 m in length and 14 m in width. (i) Calculate the area of the tiled border. (ii) If the pool PQRS is shifted to one corner inside the outer rectangle ABCD (so that it is no longer centrally placed), but the dimensions of both rectangles remain the same, does the area of the tiled border change? Justify your answer with a calculation.

Solution

  1. Step 1: Find the area of the outer rectangle ABCD: The outer rectangle ABCD has length 18 m and width 14 m. Area of outer rectangle: \[Area_{ABCD} = 18 \times 14 = 252 \text{ m}^2\]
  2. Step 2: Find the area of the inner rectangle PQRS (the pool): The pool PQRS has length 12 m and width 8 m. Area of pool: \[Area_{PQRS} = 12 \times 8 = 96 \text{ m}^2\]
  3. Step 3: Calculate the area of the tiled border: The area of the tiled border is the area of the outer rectangle minus the area of the inner pool. \[Area_{\text{border}} = Area_{ABCD} - Area_{PQRS} = 252 - 96 = 156 \text{ m}^2\]
  4. Step 4: Check whether shifting the pool changes the border area: Now suppose the pool PQRS is shifted so that it sits in one corner of the outer rectangle ABCD instead of being centrally placed. The dimensions of the outer rectangle ABCD are still 18 m by 14 m, so its area is still \( 252 \text{ m}^2 \). The dimensions of the pool PQRS are still 12 m by 8 m, so its area is still \( 96 \text{ m}^2 \). Therefore, the area of the border is still: \[Area_{\text{border}} = 252 - 96 = 156 \text{ m}^2\]
  5. Step 5: Conclusion: Yes, the area of the tiled border DOES change — this is a trick question designed to test understanding. Actually, the area does NOT change. Since the area of the border depends only on the dimensions of the two rectangles (outer minus inner), and those dimensions remain fixed at 18 m \(\times\) 14 m and 12 m \(\times\) 8 m respectively, the border area remains \( 156 \text{ m}^2 \) regardless of where the pool is placed inside the outer rectangle.

Answer: The area of the tiled border is \( 156 \text{ m}^2 \). Shifting the pool PQRS to a corner (or any other position) inside ABCD does NOT change the area of the tiled border, because the border area depends only on the dimensions of the outer and inner rectangles, both of which remain the same. The border area stays \( 252 - 96 = 156 \text{ m}^2 \) in every case.

Everything you get with Solver7

More questions in Area