SOLVER7 Study. Nothing Else.
Figure It Out 2 Q8

Gopal needs to carry water from the river to his water tank. He starts from his house. What is the shortest path he can take from his house to the river and then to the water tank\(?\) Roughly recreate the map in your notebook and trace the shortest path.

CBSE Class 8 Maths · Area

Solution

👶 Simple Explanation

Simple Explanation

Imagine you want to bounce a ball off a wall to reach your friend. The smartest throw is when you pretend your starting spot has a twin on the other side of the wall. Draw a straight line from that twin to your friend. Where that line crosses the wall is the best bouncing spot. Gopal does the same thing with the river. He finds the mirror copy of his House on the other side of the river, draws a straight line to the Water tank, and the spot where that line crosses the river is the perfect stopping point.

Answer: The shortest path is: go straight from the House to the point \( P \) where the straight line joining the mirror image of the House (reflected across the river) and the Water tank meets the river, then go straight from \( P \) to the Water tank. Trace these two straight segments House to \( P \) and \( P \) to Water tank on the map.

📖 Shortest Path from House to River to Water Tank

Detailed Explanation

In the map, the river is drawn as a straight line at the top. The house and the water tank are two separate points below the river. Gopal must go from the house, touch the river at some point, and then reach the water tank. The total distance he walks depends on which point of the river he touches. The key geometric idea here is that the shortest distance between two points is always a straight line. But since Gopal is forced to touch the river in between, we use a clever trick called reflection. We reflect one point (say the house) across the river line to get its mirror image. A path from the mirror image to the water tank will cross the river at exactly the correct point, and because reflection keeps distances equal, this gives the shortest possible route. This is the same idea used in symmetry, which you study in geometry.

Formula Used

Shortest distance between two points is a straight line. Using reflection: distance(House to River point) = distance(Mirror image of House to same River point), so the shortest path touching the river = straight line from mirror image of House to Water tank.

Solution

  1. Step 1: Redraw the map. Draw a horizontal straight line for the river at the top. Mark a point for the House lower down on the left and a point for the Water tank a little higher up on the right, exactly as shown in the given figure.
  2. Step 2: Understand the condition. Gopal cannot go straight from the House to the Water tank, because he must first touch the river to collect water. So his path always has two parts: House to some point on the river, then that river point to the Water tank.
  3. Step 3: Use the reflection idea. Reflect the House across the river line to get its mirror image, call it \( H' \). Since the river acts like a mirror, the straight-line distance from the House to any point on the river equals the distance from \( H' \) to that same point. This lets us replace the House with \( H' \) in our distance thinking.
  4. Step 4: Draw the shortest line. Join \( H' \) to the Water tank with a straight line. Let this straight line cross the river at a point, call it \( P \). Because a straight line is the shortest distance between two points, the path \( H' \) to \( P \) to Water tank is the shortest.
  5. Step 5: Convert back to the real path. The point \( P \) on the river is exactly where Gopal should collect water. Now trace the real journey: draw a straight line from the House to \( P \), and then a straight line from \( P \) to the Water tank. This is the shortest possible route on the actual map.
  6. Step 6: Why this works. The path House to \( P \) has the same length as \( H' \) to \( P \) because of reflection. So the real path length equals the straight-line length \( H' \) to Water tank, which is the smallest value any path can have. Any other river point would make a longer bent path.

Final Answer

The shortest path is: go straight from the House to the point \( P \) where the straight line joining the mirror image of the House (reflected across the river) and the Water tank meets the river, then go straight from \( P \) to the Water tank. Trace these two straight segments House to \( P \) and \( P \) to Water tank on the map.

Common Mistake

A common mistake is to draw the river point directly below the House (the nearest point on the river) and then go to the water tank. This does NOT give the shortest total path. The correct point is found using the reflection of the House across the river, not simply the closest point.

🪜 Step-by-step Solution

Step-by-step Solution

  1. Step 1: Set up the map. Draw a horizontal straight line near the top of your page to represent the river. Below this line, mark a point labelled House on the left side and a point labelled Water tank on the right side, matching the positions in the given figure. — Reason: A clear diagram helps you see the geometry of the problem and identify all the key points before solving.
  2. Step 2: Understand the constraint. Notice that Gopal cannot walk directly from the House to the Water tank in a single straight line, because the problem requires him to touch the river first (to collect water). So the path must be: House \( \to \) some point \( P \) on the river \( \to \) Water tank. — Reason: Identifying the constraint tells you why a simple straight line from House to Water tank is not allowed and why you need a smarter approach.
  3. Step 3: Apply the reflection trick. Draw a perpendicular from the House down to the river line, then extend it an equal distance on the other side of the river. Mark this new point as \( H' \), the mirror image (reflection) of the House across the river. — Reason: Reflection is used because for any point \( P \) on the river, the distance from the House to \( P \) equals the distance from \( H' \) to \( P \) (mirror images preserve distances). This lets you replace the House-to-river leg with a leg from \( H' \), turning a two-segment problem into a single straight-line problem.
  4. Step 4: Draw the straight line from \( H' \) to the Water tank. Mark the point where this straight line crosses the river as \( P \). — Reason: The straight line from \( H' \) to the Water tank is the shortest possible distance between those two points. Since \( H'P = \text{House-to-}P \), the total path length House \( \to P \to \) Water tank equals \( H' \to P \to \) Water tank, which is smallest when all three lie on one straight line — exactly as drawn.
  5. Step 5: Verify why any other river point gives a longer path. If Gopal touches any other point \( Q \) on the river instead of \( P \), then: \[ H'Q + Q\text{-to-Water tank} > H'P + P\text{-to-Water tank} \] because a straight line is shorter than any broken path between the same two endpoints. Since \( H'Q = \text{House-to-}Q \), the path through \( Q \) is always longer than the path through \( P \). — Reason: This confirms mathematically that \( P \) is truly the optimal (shortest) point on the river to touch.
  6. Step 6: Trace the final shortest path on the map. Draw the segment from the House straight to \( P \), and then draw the segment from \( P \) straight to the Water tank. These two segments together form Gopal's shortest route. — Reason: Once \( P \) is located, the actual path Gopal walks is House \( \to P \to \) Water tank (not via the mirror image \( H' \)), so you must draw the real-world segments on the correct side of the river.

Final Answer

The shortest path is: go straight from the House to the point \( P \) where the straight line joining the mirror image of the House (reflected across the river) and the Water tank meets the river, then go straight from \( P \) to the Water tank. Trace these two straight segments House to \( P \) and \( P \) to Water tank on the map.

Common Mistake

One common mistake: Students draw the path from the House to the mirror image point and then to the Water tank, but forget to trace the actual path on the correct (same) side of the river. The mirror image \( H' \) is only a construction tool — Gopal's real path goes from the House (not \( H' \)) to \( P \), and then to the Water tank.

✍️ Exam-ready Answer

Exam-ready Answer

  1. Step 1: Reflect the House across the river line to obtain its mirror image \( H' \).
  2. Step 2: Draw the straight line joining \( H' \) (mirror image of House) to the Water tank \( T \). Let \( P \) be the point where this line meets the river.
  3. Step 3: The shortest path is: House \( \to P \to \) Water tank, since \( H'P + PT \) is minimised when \( H' \), \( P \), and \( T \) are collinear, and \( H'P = \) House\( \to P \) by reflection.

Answer: The shortest path is: go straight from the House to the point \( P \) where the straight line joining the mirror image of the House (reflected across the river) and the Water tank meets the river, then go straight from \( P \) to the Water tank. Trace these two straight segments House to \( P \) and \( P \) to Water tank on the map.

➕ More Examples

More Examples

Example 1

Question: Meena starts from her home and needs to collect water from a well before going to her school. On a grid map, her home is at point H, the well is at point W, and her school is at point S. From H, the well W is 6 m east and 8 m north. From the well W, the school S is 5 m east and 12 m north. Find the shortest distance Meena must travel from her home to the well, and then from the well to her school. What is the total shortest distance she travels?

Solution: Step 1: Find the shortest distance from Home (H) to Well (W). The well is 6 m east and 8 m north of the home. These two distances form the two legs of a right-angled triangle, and the straight-line (shortest) path HW is the hypotenuse. Using the Pythagoras theorem: \[ HW^2 = 6^2 + 8^2 \] \[ HW^2 = 36 + 64 \] \[ HW^2 = 100 \] \[ HW = \sqrt{100} = 10 \text{ m} \] Step 2: Find the shortest distance from Well (W) to School (S). The school is 5 m east and 12 m north of the well. These form the two legs of another right-angled triangle. Using the Pythagoras theorem: \[ WS^2 = 5^2 + 12^2 \] \[ WS^2 = 25 + 144 \] \[ WS^2 = 169 \] \[ WS = \sqrt{169} = 13 \text{ m} \] Step 3: Find the total shortest distance. Total distance = HW + WS \[ = 10 + 13 = 23 \text{ m} \]

Answer: The shortest distance from Home to Well is 10 m, from Well to School is 13 m, and the total shortest distance is 23 m.

Example 2

Question: Raju is a farmer. He starts from his farm (F) and must stop at a pond (P) to collect water before reaching his field (D). On a grid map, the pond P is located 9 m to the right and 12 m below the farm F. The field D is located 8 m to the right and 15 m below the pond P. Find the shortest path Raju can take from his farm to the pond and then to his field.

Solution: Step 1: Find the shortest distance from Farm (F) to Pond (P). The pond is 9 m to the right and 12 m below the farm. These are the two perpendicular legs of a right-angled triangle. The shortest straight-line path FP is the hypotenuse. Using the Pythagoras theorem: \[ FP^2 = 9^2 + 12^2 \] \[ FP^2 = 81 + 144 \] \[ FP^2 = 225 \] \[ FP = \sqrt{225} = 15 \text{ m} \] Step 2: Find the shortest distance from Pond (P) to Field (D). The field is 8 m to the right and 15 m below the pond. These are the two perpendicular legs of a right-angled triangle. Using the Pythagoras theorem: \[ PD^2 = 8^2 + 15^2 \] \[ PD^2 = 64 + 225 \] \[ PD^2 = 289 \] \[ PD = \sqrt{289} = 17 \text{ m} \] Step 3: Find the total shortest distance. Total distance = FP + PD \[ = 15 + 17 = 32 \text{ m} \]

Answer: The shortest distance from Farm to Pond is 15 m, from Pond to Field is 17 m, and the total shortest distance is 32 m.

🎯 Try a Similar Question

Try a Similar Question

Question: Priya's school is located some distance from a straight canal. She wants to walk from her school to the canal to fill her bottle, and then continue to the community garden. Describe and trace the shortest path Priya can take from her school to the canal and then to the community garden. (Roughly sketch the map in your notebook with the canal as a straight horizontal line, the school above it, and the community garden below it on the opposite bank.)

Solution

  1. Step 1: Understand the Setup: Draw a rough map. Place the canal as a straight horizontal line. Mark the school (S) above the canal and the community garden (G) below the canal. Priya must touch the canal at some point before reaching the garden.
  2. Step 2: Recall the Reflection Principle: Any path from S to a point on the canal and then to G involves two segments. To minimise the total length, we use the reflection principle: reflect one of the two endpoints across the canal.
  3. Step 3: Reflect the School Across the Canal: Draw the mirror image of the school (call it S') on the other side of the canal, at the same perpendicular distance from the canal as the school but on the opposite side. S' is the reflection of S across the canal.
  4. Step 4: Draw the Straight Line from S' to G: Draw a straight line from S' (the reflected school) to G (the community garden). This straight line will cross the canal at exactly one point. Label this point P.
  5. Step 5: Identify the Shortest Path: The shortest path for Priya is: walk straight from S to P (on the canal), then walk straight from P to G (the community garden). The total distance equals the straight-line distance from S' to G, which is the shortest possible combined length by the triangle inequality.
  6. Step 6: Why This Works: For any other point Q on the canal, the path S to Q to G is longer because S to Q equals S' to Q (by reflection), so the total path S to Q + Q to G equals S' to Q + Q to G, which is always greater than or equal to the straight line S' to G. The straight line S' to G gives the minimum, achieved only at point P.
  7. Step 7: Trace on the Sketch: On your notebook sketch, mark the point P where the line S'G meets the canal. Draw and highlight the two segments: school S to point P, and point P to community garden G. These two straight segments together form the shortest path.

Answer: The shortest path is: reflect the school (S) across the canal to get its mirror image S'. Draw a straight line from S' to the community garden (G). The point P where this line crosses the canal is the optimal point to stop. Priya should walk straight from her school (S) to point P on the canal, then straight from P to the community garden (G). This two-segment path S to P to G is the shortest possible route.

Everything you get with Solver7

More questions in Area