Detailed Explanation
A number is rational if it can be written as \( \frac{p}{q} \) where \( p \) and \( q \) are integers and \( q \ne 0 \). The formula \( \pi = \frac{c}{d} \) looks like a ratio, so at first it seems \( \pi \) should be rational. But the key point is this: for \( \pi \) to be rational, BOTH the circumference \( c \) and the diameter \( d \) would need to be measured as exact integers (or rational numbers) at the same time. In reality this never happens. When we measure any physical circle, we only get approximate values, not exact ones. Mathematically, if the diameter of a circle is a rational number, then its circumference must be irrational, and if the circumference is rational, then the diameter must be irrational. So \( c \) and \( d \) can never both be rational together. That is why their ratio \( \pi \) turns out to be irrational, with a non-terminating and non-recurring decimal expansion.
Formula Used
\( \pi = \frac{c}{d} \), where \( c \) is the circumference and \( d \) is the diameter of a circle.
Solution
- Step 1: Recall the definition. Pi is defined as \[ \pi = \frac{c}{d} \] where \( c \) is the circumference and \( d \) is the diameter of the same circle.
- Step 2: Recall what a rational number is. A number is rational only if it can be written as \( \frac{p}{q} \) with \( p \) and \( q \) both integers and \( q \ne 0 \). So for \( \pi \) to be rational, both \( c \) and \( d \) must be integers (or rational) at the same time.
- Step 3: Understand the measurement limitation. When we measure \( c \) or \( d \) using any instrument, we only obtain approximate values. We can never measure both the circumference and diameter of a circle exactly at the same time.
- Step 4: State the mathematical fact. For a circle, if the diameter \( d \) is rational, then the circumference \( c \) is irrational, and if \( c \) is rational, then \( d \) is irrational. They are never both rational together, so the ratio \( \frac{c}{d} \) is not of the form \( \frac{p}{q} \) with integers.
- Step 5: Conclude. Since \( c \) and \( d \) cannot both be integers (or rational) simultaneously, the value \( \frac{c}{d} \) is irrational. This is confirmed by the fact that \( \pi = 3.14159265... \) is a non-terminating, non-recurring decimal. Values like \( \frac{22}{7} \) or \( 3.14 \) are only approximations of \( \pi \), not its exact value.
Final Answer
There is no contradiction. Although \( \pi = \frac{c}{d} \) looks like a ratio, the circumference \( c \) and diameter \( d \) can never both be rational (integers) at the same time. So \( \frac{c}{d} \) cannot be expressed as \( \frac{p}{q} \) with integers \( p, q \), which means \( \pi \) is irrational. Its decimal expansion \( 3.14159265... \) is non-terminating and non-recurring.
Common Mistake
Students think that because \( \pi = \frac{22}{7} \), it must be rational. But \( \frac{22}{7} \) is only an approximation of \( \pi \), not its exact value, so this does not make \( \pi \) rational.