SOLVER7 Study. Nothing Else.
Exercise 1.4 Q3

Recall,\(\pi\) is defined as the ratio of the circumference \((\)say \(c)\) of a circle to its diameter \((\)say \(d).\) That is, \(\pi=\dfrac{c}{d}.\) This seems to contradict the fact that \(\pi\) is irrational. How will you resolve this contradiction.\(?\)

CBSE Class 9 Maths · Number Systems

Solution

👶 Simple Explanation

Simple Explanation

Imagine measuring the distance around a coin and its width across. One of those two measurements will always be a messy, never-ending number. You simply cannot get both measurements to be neat whole numbers at the same time. That is the secret about \( \pi \). It looks like a division of two lengths, but those two lengths can never both be tidy numbers together. So \( \pi \) stays forever messy, with digits that go on without stopping or repeating.

Answer: There is no contradiction. Although \( \pi = \frac{c}{d} \) looks like a ratio, the circumference \( c \) and diameter \( d \) can never both be rational (integers) at the same time. So \( \frac{c}{d} \) cannot be expressed as \( \frac{p}{q} \) with integers \( p, q \), which means \( \pi \) is irrational. Its decimal expansion \( 3.14159265... \) is non-terminating and non-recurring.

📖 Resolving the Pi Contradiction

Detailed Explanation

A number is rational if it can be written as \( \frac{p}{q} \) where \( p \) and \( q \) are integers and \( q \ne 0 \). The formula \( \pi = \frac{c}{d} \) looks like a ratio, so at first it seems \( \pi \) should be rational. But the key point is this: for \( \pi \) to be rational, BOTH the circumference \( c \) and the diameter \( d \) would need to be measured as exact integers (or rational numbers) at the same time. In reality this never happens. When we measure any physical circle, we only get approximate values, not exact ones. Mathematically, if the diameter of a circle is a rational number, then its circumference must be irrational, and if the circumference is rational, then the diameter must be irrational. So \( c \) and \( d \) can never both be rational together. That is why their ratio \( \pi \) turns out to be irrational, with a non-terminating and non-recurring decimal expansion.

Formula Used

\( \pi = \frac{c}{d} \), where \( c \) is the circumference and \( d \) is the diameter of a circle.

Solution

  1. Step 1: Recall the definition. Pi is defined as \[ \pi = \frac{c}{d} \] where \( c \) is the circumference and \( d \) is the diameter of the same circle.
  2. Step 2: Recall what a rational number is. A number is rational only if it can be written as \( \frac{p}{q} \) with \( p \) and \( q \) both integers and \( q \ne 0 \). So for \( \pi \) to be rational, both \( c \) and \( d \) must be integers (or rational) at the same time.
  3. Step 3: Understand the measurement limitation. When we measure \( c \) or \( d \) using any instrument, we only obtain approximate values. We can never measure both the circumference and diameter of a circle exactly at the same time.
  4. Step 4: State the mathematical fact. For a circle, if the diameter \( d \) is rational, then the circumference \( c \) is irrational, and if \( c \) is rational, then \( d \) is irrational. They are never both rational together, so the ratio \( \frac{c}{d} \) is not of the form \( \frac{p}{q} \) with integers.
  5. Step 5: Conclude. Since \( c \) and \( d \) cannot both be integers (or rational) simultaneously, the value \( \frac{c}{d} \) is irrational. This is confirmed by the fact that \( \pi = 3.14159265... \) is a non-terminating, non-recurring decimal. Values like \( \frac{22}{7} \) or \( 3.14 \) are only approximations of \( \pi \), not its exact value.

Final Answer

There is no contradiction. Although \( \pi = \frac{c}{d} \) looks like a ratio, the circumference \( c \) and diameter \( d \) can never both be rational (integers) at the same time. So \( \frac{c}{d} \) cannot be expressed as \( \frac{p}{q} \) with integers \( p, q \), which means \( \pi \) is irrational. Its decimal expansion \( 3.14159265... \) is non-terminating and non-recurring.

Common Mistake

Students think that because \( \pi = \frac{22}{7} \), it must be rational. But \( \frac{22}{7} \) is only an approximation of \( \pi \), not its exact value, so this does not make \( \pi \) rational.

🪜 Step-by-step Solution

Step-by-step Solution

  1. Step 1: Write the definition of \( \pi \). We have \[ \pi = \frac{c}{d} \] where \( c \) is the circumference and \( d \) is the diameter of any circle. — Reason: Starting from the definition helps us clearly see why the expression looks like a ratio of two quantities.
  2. Step 2: Recall what a rational number actually is. A number is called rational if and only if it can be written as \( \frac{p}{q} \), where both \( p \) and \( q \) are integers and \( q \ne 0 \). — Reason: We need this precise definition to judge whether \( \pi \) qualifies as rational, rather than relying on appearances alone.
  3. Step 3: Identify what condition \( \pi \) would need to satisfy to be rational. For \( \frac{c}{d} \) to equal some \( \frac{p}{q} \) with integer \( p \) and \( q \), both \( c \) and \( d \) must themselves be integers (or at least rational numbers) simultaneously. — Reason: A ratio of two numbers is rational only when both numbers in the ratio are rational; one irrational quantity in the pair breaks the condition.
  4. Step 4: Examine whether \( c \) and \( d \) can both be rational at the same time. It is a proven mathematical fact that if the diameter \( d \) is a rational number, then the circumference \( c = \pi \cdot d \) must be irrational, and if \( c \) is rational, then \( d = \frac{c}{\pi} \) must be irrational. — Reason: Because \( \pi \) itself appears in the relationship between \( c \) and \( d \), one of them always inherits the irrationality of \( \pi \).
  5. Step 5: Resolve the apparent contradiction. The expression \( \frac{c}{d} \) looks like an ordinary fraction, but it is not a ratio of two integers. Since \( c \) and \( d \) can never both be rational (integers) at the same time, the condition required for \( \pi \) to be rational is never met. — Reason: Looking like a fraction and being a ratio of integers are two different things; only the latter makes a number rational.
  6. Step 6: State the conclusion about the decimal expansion of \( \pi \). Because \( \pi \) is irrational, its decimal expansion \( 3.14159265\ldots \) is non-terminating and non-recurring. Common rational approximations such as \( \frac{22}{7} \) or \( 3.14 \) are only estimates, not exact values. — Reason: Every irrational number has a decimal that goes on forever without any repeating block, which is consistent with what we observe for \( \pi \).

Final Answer

There is no contradiction. Although \( \pi = \frac{c}{d} \) looks like a ratio, the circumference \( c \) and diameter \( d \) can never both be rational (integers) at the same time. So \( \frac{c}{d} \) cannot be expressed as \( \frac{p}{q} \) with integers \( p, q \), which means \( \pi \) is irrational. Its decimal expansion \( 3.14159265... \) is non-terminating and non-recurring.

Common Mistake

One common mistake: Students assume that because \( \pi = \frac{c}{d} \) resembles the form \( \frac{p}{q} \), it must be rational — they forget that \( p \) and \( q \) in the definition of a rational number must specifically be integers, not just any real quantities.

✍️ Exam-ready Answer

Exam-ready Answer

  1. Step 1: Definition: \( \pi = \frac{c}{d} \); for \( \pi \) to be rational, both \( c \) and \( d \) must simultaneously be integers (or rational numbers).
  2. Step 2: Key fact: if \( d \) is rational, then \( c \) is irrational; if \( c \) is rational, then \( d \) is irrational — so \( c \) and \( d \) can never both be rational at the same time.
  3. Step 3: Therefore \( \frac{c}{d} \ne \frac{p}{q} \) for any integers \( p, q \), so \( \pi \) is irrational with decimal expansion \( 3.14159265\ldots \) (non-terminating, non-recurring).

Answer: There is no contradiction. Although \( \pi = \frac{c}{d} \) looks like a ratio, the circumference \( c \) and diameter \( d \) can never both be rational (integers) at the same time. So \( \frac{c}{d} \) cannot be expressed as \( \frac{p}{q} \) with integers \( p, q \), which means \( \pi \) is irrational. Its decimal expansion \( 3.14159265... \) is non-terminating and non-recurring.

➕ More Examples

More Examples

Example 1

Question: The surface area of a sphere is given by \( S = 4\pi r^2 \) and the square of its diameter is \( d^2 = 4r^2 \). A student writes \( \frac{S}{d^2} = \pi \) and claims: 'Since S and \( d^2 \) are both lengths squared (real numbers), their ratio must be rational, but \( \pi \) is irrational — this is a contradiction!' How would you resolve this contradiction?

Solution: The student has confused 'ratio of two real numbers' with 'ratio of two integers.' Recall the definition: a number is rational if it can be expressed as \( \frac{p}{q} \) where both \( p \) and \( q \) are integers and \( q \ne 0 \). There is no rule that says the ratio of any two real numbers must be rational. In fact, the ratio of two irrational numbers (or two non-integer real numbers) can itself be irrational. For example, take a sphere of radius \( r = 1 \) unit. Then the surface area is \( S = 4\pi \cdot 1^2 = 4\pi \), and the square of the diameter is \( d^2 = (2 \times 1)^2 = 4 \). Here \( S = 4\pi \) is irrational, \( d^2 = 4 \) is an integer, and their ratio is \( \frac{4\pi}{4} = \pi \), which is indeed irrational — perfectly consistent. If instead \( r = \sqrt{2} \) units, then \( S = 4\pi (\sqrt{2})^2 = 8\pi \) (irrational) and \( d^2 = (2\sqrt{2})^2 = 8 \) (rational), and again \( \frac{S}{d^2} = \frac{8\pi}{8} = \pi \). In general, \( S \) and \( d^2 \) are real numbers, not necessarily integers. The formula \( \frac{S}{d^2} = \pi \) simply defines a fixed ratio between two geometric quantities. The value \( \pi \) is irrational because it cannot be expressed as a ratio of two integers — not because it cannot appear as a ratio of two real numbers. Therefore there is no contradiction.

Answer: There is no contradiction. The ratio \( \frac{S}{d^2} = \pi \) is a ratio of two real (geometric) quantities, not a ratio of two integers. Irrationality means the number cannot be written as \( \frac{p}{q} \) with \( p, q \in \mathbb{Z} \). A ratio of two real numbers can be irrational, and \( \pi \) being irrational is entirely consistent with the formula \( \frac{S}{d^2} = \pi \).

Example 2

Question: The volume of a cube of side \( a \) is \( V = a^3 \) and its total surface area is \( T = 6a^2 \). A student computes \( \frac{V}{T} = \frac{a^3}{6a^2} = \frac{a}{6} \). She then picks a cube whose side is \( a = \sqrt{3} \) cm and gets \( \frac{V}{T} = \frac{\sqrt{3}}{6} \). She argues: 'Volume and surface area are just real-number measurements, so their ratio must be rational, but \( \frac{\sqrt{3}}{6} \) is irrational — contradiction!' Resolve her confusion.

Solution: The student is incorrectly assuming that the ratio of any two real-number measurements must be rational. The definition of a rational number is a number that can be written as \( \frac{p}{q} \) where \( p \) and \( q \) are integers and \( q \ne 0 \). This has nothing to do with whether the quantities being divided are lengths, areas, volumes, or any other real numbers. Let us verify the student's calculation. With \( a = \sqrt{3} \) cm: The volume is \[ V = (\sqrt{3})^3 = 3\sqrt{3} \text{ cm}^3 \] The total surface area is \[ T = 6 \times (\sqrt{3})^2 = 6 \times 3 = 18 \text{ cm}^2 \] Their ratio is \[ \frac{V}{T} = \frac{3\sqrt{3}}{18} = \frac{\sqrt{3}}{6} \] Now, \( \frac{\sqrt{3}}{6} \) is irrational because \( \sqrt{3} \) is irrational and dividing an irrational number by a non-zero rational number gives an irrational number. This is not a contradiction at all. The ratio \( \frac{V}{T} = \frac{a}{6} \) is a ratio of two real numbers. When \( a \) is irrational, the ratio is irrational; when \( a \) is rational, the ratio is rational. For instance, if \( a = 3 \) cm, then \( \frac{V}{T} = \frac{3}{6} = \frac{1}{2} \), which is rational. So the nature of the ratio — rational or irrational — depends on the value of \( a \). There is no rule that forces a ratio of two real (geometric) measurements to be rational. Hence there is no contradiction.

Answer: There is no contradiction. The ratio \( \frac{V}{T} = \frac{\sqrt{3}}{6} \) is irrational because \( a = \sqrt{3} \) is irrational. Rationality requires the number to be expressible as \( \frac{p}{q} \) with integer \( p, q \). A ratio of two real measurements is under no obligation to be rational, so the result is completely consistent.

🎯 Try a Similar Question

Try a Similar Question

Question: A student says: 'The circumference of a circle of radius \( r \) is \( C = 2\pi r \). If I take a circle with radius \( r = 1 \) unit (a rational number), then \( C = 2\pi \), which is irrational. But circumference is just a length — a real measurable quantity — so it must be possible to express it as a ratio of two integers. This means \( 2\pi \) must be rational, contradicting the fact that \( \pi \) is irrational.' How would you resolve this student's contradiction?

Solution

  1. Step 1: Identify the student's error: The student incorrectly assumes that any measurable length can automatically be expressed as a ratio of two integers, i.e., as a rational number. This assumption is false. A length is a real number, and real numbers include both rational and irrational numbers.
  2. Step 2: Recall the definition of irrational numbers: A real number is called irrational if it cannot be written in the form \( \frac{p}{q} \), where \( p \) and \( q \) are integers and \( q \ne 0 \). The number \( \pi \) is proven to be irrational — its decimal expansion is non-terminating and non-recurring: \( 3.14159265\ldots \)
  3. Step 3: Analyse the specific case: When \( r = 1 \) (a rational number), the circumference is \( C = 2\pi \times 1 = 2\pi \). Since \( \pi \) is irrational and \( 2 \) is a non-zero rational number, their product \( 2\pi \) is also irrational. An irrational multiple of a rational number is irrational.
  4. Step 4: Resolve the contradiction: There is no real contradiction. The formula \( C = 2\pi r \) is correct. When \( r \) is rational (say an integer), the circumference \( C = 2\pi r \) turns out to be irrational — it is a perfectly valid real length, but it simply cannot be expressed as a ratio of two integers. The student confused 'measurable length' with 'rational number', but lengths can be irrational.
  5. Step 5: State the conclusion: If the radius \( r \) is rational (and non-zero), then the circumference \( C = 2\pi r \) is irrational, because \( \pi \) itself is irrational. Conversely, if \( C \) were rational, then \( r \) would have to be irrational. In either case, both \( C \) and \( r \) cannot simultaneously be rational (integer) values. So expressing \( C \) as a measurable length does not make it rational, and there is no contradiction.

Answer: There is no contradiction. The student wrongly assumed every measurable length must be rational. When the radius \( r \) is a rational number (e.g., \( r = 1 \)), the circumference \( C = 2\pi r \) is irrational because \( \pi \) is irrational. A length can be an irrational real number. It is impossible for both \( r \) and \( C = 2\pi r \) to be rational simultaneously (since that would force \( \pi \) to be rational, which it is not). Hence \( 2\pi \) is irrational and the formula \( C = 2\pi r \) is perfectly consistent with \( \pi \) being irrational.

Everything you get with Solver7

More questions in Number Systems