Are the square roots of all positive integers irrational? If not, give an example of the square root of a number that is a rational number.
CBSE Class 9 Maths · Number Systems
CBSE Class 9 Maths · Number Systems
Imagine you have a square tile. If its area is 4, the side length is exactly 2. That side length is \( \sqrt{4} = 2 \), a perfectly normal whole number. Not every square root is a messy, never-ending decimal. Some positive integers, like 4, 9, and 16, are called perfect squares. Their square roots come out as neat whole numbers. So saying all square roots are irrational is like saying every pizza must be cut unevenly — that is simply not true!
Answer: No, the square roots of all positive integers are not irrational. For example, \[ \sqrt{4} = 2, \] which is a rational number. The square root of any perfect square (such as 4, 9, 16, 25) is rational.
A number is called rational if it can be written in the form \( \frac{p}{q} \) where \( p \) and \( q \) are integers and \( q \ne 0 \). A number that cannot be written in this form is called irrational. The square root of a positive integer \( n \), written \( \sqrt{n} \), asks: which number, when multiplied by itself, gives \( n \)? If \( n \) is a perfect square (like 1, 4, 9, 16, 25, ...), its square root is a whole number, and every whole number is rational. If \( n \) is not a perfect square (like 2, 3, 5, 7, ...), then \( \sqrt{n} \) turns out to be irrational. So the answer is NO — not all square roots of positive integers are irrational.
A number is rational if it can be written as \( \frac{p}{q} \) with \( p, q \in \mathbb{Z} \) and \( q \ne 0 \). If \( n = m^2 \) for some integer \( m \), then \( \sqrt{n} = m \), which is rational.
No, the square roots of all positive integers are not irrational. For example, \[ \sqrt{4} = 2, \] which is a rational number. The square root of any perfect square (such as 4, 9, 16, 25) is rational.
A common mistake is to assume that a square root symbol always means an irrational number. In reality, if the number under the root is a perfect square, like \( \sqrt{9} = 3 \) or \( \sqrt{25} = 5 \), the result is a whole number and therefore rational.
No, the square roots of all positive integers are not irrational. For example, \[ \sqrt{4} = 2, \] which is a rational number. The square root of any perfect square (such as 4, 9, 16, 25) is rational.
One common mistake: students assume that because \( \sqrt{2} \) and \( \sqrt{3} \) are irrational, ALL square roots of positive integers must be irrational. They forget that perfect squares like 4, 9, and 16 have whole-number square roots, which are rational.
Answer: No, the square roots of all positive integers are not irrational. For example, \[ \sqrt{4} = 2, \] which is a rational number. The square root of any perfect square (such as 4, 9, 16, 25) is rational.
Question: Is it true that the square roots of all positive integers are irrational? Justify your answer. If your answer is no, give two examples of positive integers whose square roots are rational.
Solution: The statement is NOT true. A square root of a positive integer is rational whenever that integer is a perfect square. A number is rational if it can be written in the form \(\frac{p}{q}\) where \(p\) and \(q\) are integers and \(q \ne 0\). Consider the positive integer 36. We compute its square root: \[\sqrt{36} = 6\] Since 6 is an integer, it can be written as \(\frac{6}{1}\), which is rational. Next, consider the positive integer 81. We compute: \[\sqrt{81} = 9\] Since 9 is an integer, it equals \(\frac{9}{1}\), which is rational. On the other hand, for a non-perfect-square positive integer like 5, the value \(\sqrt{5}\) is irrational and cannot be expressed as \(\frac{p}{q}\) for any integers \(p\) and \(q\). Therefore, the square roots of ALL positive integers are NOT necessarily irrational. The square roots of perfect squares such as 36 and 81 are rational numbers.
Answer: No. For example, \(\sqrt{36} = 6\) and \(\sqrt{81} = 9\), both of which are rational numbers.
Question: A student claims: 'For any positive integer n, \(\sqrt{n}\) is always irrational.' Is the student correct? Give a counterexample with a positive integer greater than 50 whose square root is a rational number, and also identify a positive integer less than 50 whose square root is irrational.
Solution: The student's claim is INCORRECT. To find a counterexample (a positive integer greater than 50 with a rational square root), we look for a perfect square greater than 50. We know that \(8^2 = 64\), so: \[\sqrt{64} = 8\] Since 8 is an integer, it is rational. Thus 64 is a positive integer greater than 50 whose square root is rational, disproving the student's claim. For a positive integer less than 50 whose square root is irrational, consider 7. Since 7 is not a perfect square (no integer multiplied by itself gives 7), we have: \[\sqrt{7} \text{ is irrational.}\] To confirm 7 is not a perfect square: \(2^2 = 4\) and \(3^2 = 9\), so 7 lies strictly between two consecutive perfect squares, meaning \(\sqrt{7}\) cannot be an integer or any simple fraction. Conclusion: The student's claim is false. \(\sqrt{64} = 8\) is a rational square root of the positive integer 64, while \(\sqrt{7}\) is an example of an irrational square root of a positive integer less than 50.
Answer: No, the student is incorrect. \(\sqrt{64} = 8\) is rational (counterexample greater than 50); \(\sqrt{7}\) is irrational (example less than 50).
Question: A student claims: 'The cube root of every positive integer is irrational.' Is this claim correct? Justify your answer. Also, separately, state whether the square root of every positive integer is irrational, and give a counter-example using a two-digit perfect square to support your answer.
Answer: Both claims are false. Counter-example for cube roots: \( \sqrt[3]{27} = 3 \), which is rational. Counter-example for square roots using a two-digit perfect square: \( \sqrt{25} = 5 \), which is rational. The square roots (and cube roots) of perfect powers are always rational integers, not irrational numbers.