SOLVER7 Study. Nothing Else.
Figure It Out 4 Q3

The area of Delhi is \(1,484\) sq. km and the area of Mumbai is \(550\) sq. km. The population of Delhi is approximately \(30\) million and that of Mumbai is \(20\) million people. Which city is more crowded\(?\) Why do you say so\(?\)

CBSE Class 8 Maths · Proportional Reasoning - 1

Solution

👶 Simple Explanation

Simple Explanation

Imagine two classrooms. One has 30 kids but is very large. Another has 20 kids but is tiny. The smaller room feels much more squished! Cities work the same way. Delhi has more people than Mumbai, but Delhi is also much bigger in size. Mumbai is like the tiny classroom — lots of people packed into a small space. We check how many people share each square kilometre. Mumbai fits about 36364 people per square kilometre, while Delhi fits only about 20216. So Mumbai feels far more crowded.

Answer: Mumbai is more crowded. Its population density (about \( 36364 \) people per sq. km) is much higher than that of Delhi (about \( 20216 \) people per sq. km), meaning more people are packed into each square kilometre in Mumbai.

📖 Comparing Crowdedness of Delhi and Mumbai

Detailed Explanation

To decide which city is more crowded, we cannot just look at the population alone, because a bigger city can hold more people comfortably. What really matters is how many people live in each square kilometre of area. This is called population density. A higher population density means more people are packed into the same amount of space, so that place is more crowded. We calculate it by dividing the total population by the total area, which is really an application of the unitary method (finding the value per one unit of area).

Formula Used

\[ \text{Population density} = \frac{\text{Total population}}{\text{Total area}} \]

Solution

  1. Step 1: Write down the given data. For Delhi: area \( = 1484 \) sq. km and population \( = 30 \) million. For Mumbai: area \( = 550 \) sq. km and population \( = 20 \) million.
  2. Step 2: Understand what to compare. Delhi has more people, but it also has much more area. So comparing populations directly is unfair. Instead, we compare how many people live in each square kilometre, that is, the population density.
  3. Step 3: Find the population density of Delhi. \[ \text{Density of Delhi} = \frac{30\,000\,000}{1484} \] This gives approximately \( 20216 \) people per sq. km.
  4. Step 4: Find the population density of Mumbai. \[ \text{Density of Mumbai} = \frac{20\,000\,000}{550} \] This gives approximately \( 36364 \) people per sq. km.
  5. Step 5: Compare the two densities. Delhi has about \( 20216 \) people per sq. km, while Mumbai has about \( 36364 \) people per sq. km. Since \( 36364 > 20216 \), Mumbai has many more people living in each square kilometre.
  6. Step 6: Draw the conclusion. Because Mumbai fits far more people into each square kilometre of space, it is the more crowded city.

Final Answer

Mumbai is more crowded. Its population density (about \( 36364 \) people per sq. km) is much higher than that of Delhi (about \( 20216 \) people per sq. km), meaning more people are packed into each square kilometre in Mumbai.

Common Mistake

A common mistake is to say Delhi is more crowded just because it has more people (30 million vs 20 million). Crowdedness depends on people per unit area, not on total population, so you must divide by the area first.

🪜 Step-by-step Solution

Step-by-step Solution

  1. Step 1: List the given data clearly. Delhi: Area \( = 1484 \) sq. km, Population \( = 30 \) million \( = 30{,}000{,}000 \). Mumbai: Area \( = 550 \) sq. km, Population \( = 20 \) million \( = 20{,}000{,}000 \). — Reason: Organising data first prevents confusion between the two cities during calculation.
  2. Step 2: Decide what to compare. Delhi has a larger total population, but it also occupies much more land. Comparing raw populations is therefore unfair. Instead, we must find how many people share each single square kilometre in each city, which is the population density. — Reason: A city can have fewer people overall yet still be far more crowded if its land area is tiny.
  3. Step 3: Calculate the population density of Delhi. \[ \text{Density of Delhi} = \frac{30{,}000{,}000}{1484} \approx 20{,}216 \text{ people per sq. km} \] — Reason: Dividing total population by total area gives us the number of people per one square kilometre, which is the unitary method applied to area.
  4. Step 4: Calculate the population density of Mumbai. \[ \text{Density of Mumbai} = \frac{20{,}000{,}000}{550} \approx 36{,}364 \text{ people per sq. km} \] — Reason: We apply the same formula to Mumbai so that both values are expressed in identical units and can be fairly compared.
  5. Step 5: Compare the two densities side by side. Delhi's density is approximately \( 20{,}216 \) people per sq. km, while Mumbai's density is approximately \( 36{,}364 \) people per sq. km. Since \( 36{,}364 > 20{,}216 \), Mumbai has a higher population density. — Reason: The city with the greater density has more people squeezed into the same amount of space, making it more crowded.

Final Answer

Mumbai is more crowded. Its population density (about \( 36364 \) people per sq. km) is much higher than that of Delhi (about \( 20216 \) people per sq. km), meaning more people are packed into each square kilometre in Mumbai.

Common Mistake

One common mistake: Students compare the total populations directly and conclude that Delhi (30 million) is more crowded than Mumbai (20 million), completely ignoring the fact that Delhi's area is nearly three times larger — always use population density, not raw population, when judging how crowded a place is.

✍️ Exam-ready Answer

Exam-ready Answer

  1. Step 1: Given: Delhi — population \( = 30{,}000{,}000 \), area \( = 1484 \) sq. km; Mumbai — population \( = 20{,}000{,}000 \), area \( = 550 \) sq. km.
  2. Step 2: Density of Delhi: \[ \frac{30{,}000{,}000}{1484} \approx 20216 \text{ people per sq. km} \]
  3. Step 3: Density of Mumbai: \[ \frac{20{,}000{,}000}{550} \approx 36364 \text{ people per sq. km} \]
  4. Step 4: Since \( 36364 > 20216 \), Mumbai has a higher population density.

Answer: Mumbai is more crowded. Its population density (about \( 36364 \) people per sq. km) is much higher than that of Delhi (about \( 20216 \) people per sq. km), meaning more people are packed into each square kilometre in Mumbai.

➕ More Examples

More Examples

Example 1

Question: The area of Bengaluru is 709 sq. km and the area of Jaipur is 467 sq. km. The population of Bengaluru is approximately 12 million and that of Jaipur is approximately 4 million. Which city is more crowded? Give a reason.

Solution: To find which city is more crowded, we calculate the population density of each city. Population density is calculated as: Population Density = Total Population divided by Total Area For Bengaluru: Total Population = 12 million = 12,000,000 Total Area = 709 sq. km \[\text{Population Density of Bengaluru} = \frac{12{,}000{,}000}{709}\] \[\approx 16{,}926 \text{ people per sq. km}\] For Jaipur: Total Population = 4 million = 4,000,000 Total Area = 467 sq. km \[\text{Population Density of Jaipur} = \frac{4{,}000{,}000}{467}\] \[\approx 8{,}565 \text{ people per sq. km}\] Comparing the two densities: \[16{,}926 > 8{,}565\] Since the population density of Bengaluru is greater than that of Jaipur, Bengaluru is more crowded.

Answer: Bengaluru is more crowded, with a population density of approximately 16,926 people per sq. km, compared to Jaipur's approximately 8,565 people per sq. km.

Example 2

Question: City A has an area of 850 sq. km and a population of 6.8 million people. City B has an area of 1,200 sq. km and a population of 10.8 million people. Which city has a higher population density? Show your working.

Solution: We compare the population density of both cities. Population Density = Total Population divided by Total Area For City A: Total Population = 6.8 million = 6,800,000 Total Area = 850 sq. km \[\text{Population Density of City A} = \frac{6{,}800{,}000}{850}\] \[= 8{,}000 \text{ people per sq. km}\] For City B: Total Population = 10.8 million = 10,800,000 Total Area = 1,200 sq. km \[\text{Population Density of City B} = \frac{10{,}800{,}000}{1{,}200}\] \[= 9{,}000 \text{ people per sq. km}\] Comparing the two: \[9{,}000 > 8{,}000\] Although City B has a larger area and a larger population, its population density is higher than that of City A. Therefore, City B is more crowded.

Answer: City B is more crowded, with a population density of 9,000 people per sq. km, compared to City A's 8,000 people per sq. km.

🎯 Try a Similar Question

Try a Similar Question

Question: The area of Bengaluru is 709 sq. km and the area of Kolkata is 185 sq. km. The population of Bengaluru is approximately 12 million and that of Kolkata is approximately 5 million. Which city is more crowded? Support your answer with calculations.

Solution

  1. Step 1: Understand the Concept: To decide which city is more crowded, we calculate the population density of each city using the formula: Population Density = \( \frac{\text{Total Population}}{\text{Total Area}} \). The city with the higher population density is more crowded.
  2. Step 2: Write the Populations and Areas: Population of Bengaluru = 12 million = \( 1{,}20{,}00{,}000 \) people, Area of Bengaluru = 709 sq. km. Population of Kolkata = 5 million = \( 50{,}00{,}000 \) people, Area of Kolkata = 185 sq. km.
  3. Step 3: Calculate Population Density of Bengaluru: Population Density of Bengaluru = \( \frac{1{,}20{,}00{,}000}{709} \) Dividing: \[ \frac{1{,}20{,}00{,}000}{709} \approx 16{,}925 \text{ people per sq. km} \]
  4. Step 4: Calculate Population Density of Kolkata: Population Density of Kolkata = \( \frac{50{,}00{,}000}{185} \) Dividing: \[ \frac{50{,}00{,}000}{185} \approx 27{,}027 \text{ people per sq. km} \]
  5. Step 5: Compare the Two Cities: Population density of Bengaluru \( \approx 16{,}925 \) people per sq. km. Population density of Kolkata \( \approx 27{,}027 \) people per sq. km. Since \( 27{,}027 > 16{,}925 \), Kolkata has a higher population density.
  6. Step 6: State the Conclusion: Kolkata is more crowded than Bengaluru. Even though Bengaluru has a larger total population, Kolkata packs approximately \( 27{,}027 \) people into every square kilometre compared to only \( 16{,}925 \) people per square kilometre in Bengaluru.

Answer: Kolkata is more crowded. Its population density (approximately \( 27{,}027 \) people per sq. km) is much higher than that of Bengaluru (approximately \( 16{,}925 \) people per sq. km), meaning more people are packed into each square kilometre in Kolkata.

Everything you get with Solver7

More questions in Proportional Reasoning - 1