Detailed Explanation
At first glance it looks like Nitin's wall is stronger because he used more cement (3 bags) than Hari (2 bags). But strength does not depend on the total number of bags alone — it depends on how much cement is spread over each unit of wall length. A longer wall naturally needs more cement to be equally strong. So the fair way to compare is to find the amount of cement used per foot of wall for each person. This is a ratio (or unitary method) comparison. If both walls use the same amount of cement per foot, they are equally strong. We compare the two ratios by making the denominators the same (equal length) or by finding cement per foot for each.
Formula Used
Cement per foot \( = \dfrac{\text{number of bags}}{\text{length of wall in feet}} \)
Solution
- Step 1: Write down what each person did. Nitin: length \( = 60 \) ft, cement \( = 3 \) bags. Hari: length \( = 40 \) ft, cement \( = 2 \) bags.
- Step 2: Understand that total bags cannot be compared directly because the walls have different lengths. We must compare cement used per foot of wall, since a longer wall needs more cement for the same strength.
- Step 3: Find Nitin's cement per foot: \[ \frac{3}{60} = \frac{1}{20} \text{ bag per foot} \] This means Nitin used \( \frac{1}{20} \) of a bag for every 1 foot of wall.
- Step 4: Find Hari's cement per foot: \[ \frac{2}{40} = \frac{1}{20} \text{ bag per foot} \] So Hari also used \( \frac{1}{20} \) of a bag for every 1 foot of wall.
- Step 5: Compare the two ratios. Both give the same value: \[ \frac{3}{60} = \frac{1}{20} = \frac{2}{40} \] Since the cement used per foot is exactly equal, the two ratios are in proportion: \( 3 : 60 = 2 : 40 \).
- Step 6: Conclude. Because both walls receive the same amount of cement for each foot of length, both walls are equally strong. Nitin's worry is not correct — using fewer bags is fine because Hari's wall is also shorter.
Final Answer
Both walls used \( \frac{1}{20} \) bag of cement per foot, so \( 3 : 60 = 2 : 40 \). The walls are equally strong, and Nitin's worry is unfounded.
Common Mistake
A common mistake is comparing only the total number of bags (3 vs 2) and concluding Nitin's wall is stronger, without accounting for the different wall lengths. Strength must be compared as cement per foot, not as total cement.