SOLVER7 Study. Nothing Else.
Chapter 7 Examples Q3

Nitin and Hari were constructing a compound wall around their house. Nitin was building the longer side, \(60\) ft in length, and Hari was building the shorter side, \(40\) ft in length. Nitin used \(3\) bags of cement but Hari used only \(2\) bags of cement. Nitin was worried that the wall Hari built would not be as strong as the wall he built because she used less cement.

CBSE Class 8 Maths · Proportional Reasoning - 1

Solution

👶 Simple Explanation

Simple Explanation

Imagine spreading butter on bread. A big slice needs more butter to taste the same as a small slice. Nitin built a longer wall, so he naturally used more cement bags. Hari built a shorter wall and used fewer bags. When we check how much cement each person used for every single foot of wall, both used exactly \( \frac{1}{20} \) of a bag per foot. Equal cement per foot means equal strength. So Nitin's wall is not weaker at all!

Answer: Both walls used \( \frac{1}{20} \) bag of cement per foot, so \( 3 : 60 = 2 : 40 \). The walls are equally strong, and Nitin's worry is unfounded.

📖 Is Hari's Wall Weaker? Comparing Using Ratios

Detailed Explanation

At first glance it looks like Nitin's wall is stronger because he used more cement (3 bags) than Hari (2 bags). But strength does not depend on the total number of bags alone — it depends on how much cement is spread over each unit of wall length. A longer wall naturally needs more cement to be equally strong. So the fair way to compare is to find the amount of cement used per foot of wall for each person. This is a ratio (or unitary method) comparison. If both walls use the same amount of cement per foot, they are equally strong. We compare the two ratios by making the denominators the same (equal length) or by finding cement per foot for each.

Formula Used

Cement per foot \( = \dfrac{\text{number of bags}}{\text{length of wall in feet}} \)

Solution

  1. Step 1: Write down what each person did. Nitin: length \( = 60 \) ft, cement \( = 3 \) bags. Hari: length \( = 40 \) ft, cement \( = 2 \) bags.
  2. Step 2: Understand that total bags cannot be compared directly because the walls have different lengths. We must compare cement used per foot of wall, since a longer wall needs more cement for the same strength.
  3. Step 3: Find Nitin's cement per foot: \[ \frac{3}{60} = \frac{1}{20} \text{ bag per foot} \] This means Nitin used \( \frac{1}{20} \) of a bag for every 1 foot of wall.
  4. Step 4: Find Hari's cement per foot: \[ \frac{2}{40} = \frac{1}{20} \text{ bag per foot} \] So Hari also used \( \frac{1}{20} \) of a bag for every 1 foot of wall.
  5. Step 5: Compare the two ratios. Both give the same value: \[ \frac{3}{60} = \frac{1}{20} = \frac{2}{40} \] Since the cement used per foot is exactly equal, the two ratios are in proportion: \( 3 : 60 = 2 : 40 \).
  6. Step 6: Conclude. Because both walls receive the same amount of cement for each foot of length, both walls are equally strong. Nitin's worry is not correct — using fewer bags is fine because Hari's wall is also shorter.

Final Answer

Both walls used \( \frac{1}{20} \) bag of cement per foot, so \( 3 : 60 = 2 : 40 \). The walls are equally strong, and Nitin's worry is unfounded.

Common Mistake

A common mistake is comparing only the total number of bags (3 vs 2) and concluding Nitin's wall is stronger, without accounting for the different wall lengths. Strength must be compared as cement per foot, not as total cement.

🪜 Step-by-step Solution

Step-by-step Solution

  1. Step 1: Write down the given information clearly. Nitin built a wall of length \( 60 \) ft using \( 3 \) bags of cement. Hari built a wall of length \( 40 \) ft using \( 2 \) bags of cement. — Reason: Organising the data first prevents confusion when comparing the two situations.
  2. Step 2: Recognise that comparing total bags (\( 3 \) vs \( 2 \)) is not meaningful, because the two walls have different lengths. A longer wall naturally requires more cement even if both walls are equally strong. — Reason: Direct comparison of totals is unfair when the quantities being measured (lengths) are different; we need a common unit to compare.
  3. Step 3: Calculate Nitin's cement used per foot of wall: \[ \frac{3}{60} = \frac{1}{20} \] So Nitin used \( \frac{1}{20} \) bag per foot. — Reason: Dividing the number of bags by the wall length gives the rate of cement use, which is a fair basis for comparison.
  4. Step 4: Calculate Hari's cement used per foot of wall: \[ \frac{2}{40} = \frac{1}{20} \] So Hari also used \( \frac{1}{20} \) bag per foot. — Reason: Applying the same calculation to Hari's data lets us compare the two rates directly.
  5. Step 5: Compare the two rates: Nitin's rate = \( \frac{1}{20} \) bag per foot and Hari's rate = \( \frac{1}{20} \) bag per foot. Since both rates are identical, the ratio of cement to wall length is the same for both: \[ 3 : 60 = 2 : 40 \] — Reason: Equal rates of cement per foot mean the walls were built with the same mixture proportion, so they are equally strong.

Final Answer

Both walls used \( \frac{1}{20} \) bag of cement per foot, so \( 3 : 60 = 2 : 40 \). The walls are equally strong, and Nitin's worry is unfounded.

Common Mistake

One common mistake: Students compare only the total number of cement bags (3 vs 2) and conclude Nitin's wall is stronger, without accounting for the fact that his wall is also longer. Always compare cement per unit length, not total cement, when the wall lengths differ.

✍️ Exam-ready Answer

Exam-ready Answer

  1. Step 1: Nitin: \( \dfrac{3}{60} = \dfrac{1}{20} \) bag per foot
  2. Step 2: Hari: \( \dfrac{2}{40} = \dfrac{1}{20} \) bag per foot
  3. Step 3: Since \( \dfrac{3}{60} = \dfrac{2}{40} = \dfrac{1}{20} \), the ratios are equal.

Answer: Both walls used \( \frac{1}{20} \) bag of cement per foot, so \( 3 : 60 = 2 : 40 \). The walls are equally strong, and Nitin's worry is unfounded.

➕ More Examples

More Examples

Example 1

Question: Priya and Rajan were laying a brick pathway in their garden. Priya laid a pathway 75 m long and used 5 bags of cement. Rajan laid a pathway 45 m long and used 3 bags of cement. Rajan felt his pathway was less sturdy because he used fewer bags of cement. Is Rajan's concern valid? Compare the rate of cement used per metre by each person.

Solution: We need to find the amount of cement used per metre of pathway by each person and compare the two rates. For Priya: Length of pathway = 75 m, Cement used = 5 bags. Priya's rate of cement per metre: \[ \text{Rate}_{\text{Priya}} = \frac{5}{75} = \frac{1}{15} \text{ bags per metre} \] For Rajan: Length of pathway = 45 m, Cement used = 3 bags. Rajan's rate of cement per metre: \[ \text{Rate}_{\text{Rajan}} = \frac{3}{45} = \frac{1}{15} \text{ bags per metre} \] Comparing the two rates: Both Priya and Rajan used \( \frac{1}{15} \) bags of cement per metre of pathway. Since the rate of cement used per metre is exactly the same for both, the cement concentration (and hence the strength) of both pathways is equal. Therefore, Rajan's concern is NOT valid. His pathway is just as strong as Priya's pathway.

Answer: Both pathways use \( \frac{1}{15} \) bag of cement per metre, so both are equally strong. Rajan's concern is not valid.

Example 2

Question: Meena and Suresh were constructing boundary walls for their farms. Meena built a wall 84 m long and used 6 bags of cement. Suresh built a wall 56 m long and used 4 bags of cement. Meena claimed that her wall is stronger because she used more cement. Is Meena's claim correct? Find the rate of cement used per metre by each person to justify your answer.

Solution: To check Meena's claim, we compare the cement used per metre of wall by each person. For Meena: Length of wall = 84 m, Cement used = 6 bags. Meena's rate of cement per metre: \[ \text{Rate}_{\text{Meena}} = \frac{6}{84} = \frac{1}{14} \text{ bags per metre} \] For Suresh: Length of wall = 56 m, Cement used = 4 bags. Suresh's rate of cement per metre: \[ \text{Rate}_{\text{Suresh}} = \frac{4}{56} = \frac{1}{14} \text{ bags per metre} \] Comparing the two rates: Both Meena and Suresh used \( \frac{1}{14} \) bags of cement per metre of wall. Although Meena used more cement in total (6 bags vs 4 bags), she also built a longer wall. The cement per metre of wall is identical for both. Therefore, Meena's claim is NOT correct. Both walls are equally strong because the rate of cement used per metre is the same.

Answer: Both walls use \( \frac{1}{14} \) bag of cement per metre, so both are equally strong. Meena's claim is not correct.

🎯 Try a Similar Question

Try a Similar Question

Question: Priya and Rohan were painting a fence around their garden. Priya painted a longer section of 75 metres and used 5 tins of paint. Rohan painted a shorter section of 45 metres and used 3 tins of paint. Priya felt that Rohan had used less paint and therefore his section would not be as well covered as hers. Is Priya's concern valid? Justify your answer using ratios.

Solution

  1. Step 1: Find Priya's paint usage per metre: Priya painted 75 metres using 5 tins of paint. Her paint used per metre is: \[ \frac{5}{75} = \frac{1}{15} \text{ tin per metre} \]
  2. Step 2: Find Rohan's paint usage per metre: Rohan painted 45 metres using 3 tins of paint. His paint used per metre is: \[ \frac{3}{45} = \frac{1}{15} \text{ tin per metre} \]
  3. Step 3: Compare the two unit rates: Both Priya and Rohan used \( \frac{1}{15} \) tin of paint per metre. Therefore the ratios are equal: \[ 5 : 75 = 3 : 45 \] This means both sections received the same amount of paint per metre.
  4. Step 4: Conclusion: Since the unit rate of paint used is identical for both Priya and Rohan, both sections of the fence are equally well covered. Priya's concern is not valid.

Answer: Both sections used \( \frac{1}{15} \) tin of paint per metre, so \( 5 : 75 = 3 : 45 \). Both sections are equally well covered, and Priya's concern is unfounded.

Everything you get with Solver7

More questions in Proportional Reasoning - 1