SOLVER7 Study. Nothing Else.
Chapter 7 Examples Q10

A small farmer in Himachal Pradesh sells each \(200\ g\) packet of tea for ₹\(200.\) A large estate in Meghalaya sells each \(1\) kg packet of tea for ₹\(800.\) Are the weight-to-price ratios in both places proportional\(?\) Which tea is more expensive\(?\)

CBSE Class 8 Maths · Proportional Reasoning - 1

Solution

👶 Simple Explanation

Simple Explanation

Imagine you are shopping for tea at two different stalls. One stall in Himachal sells a small packet of 200 grams for ₹200. Another stall from Meghalaya sells a big 1 kg bag for ₹800. To compare them fairly, think about how much 1 full kilogram would cost at each stall. The Himachal packet is only one-fifth of a kilogram, so a full kilogram would cost five times ₹200, which is ₹1000. The Meghalaya bag already costs ₹800 per kilogram. Since ₹1000 is more than ₹800, the Himachal tea is pricier.

Answer: The weight-to-price ratios are NOT proportional. Himachal tea costs ₹\( 1000 \) per kg while Meghalaya tea costs ₹\( 800 \) per kg, so the Himachal (small farmer's) tea is more expensive.

📖 Comparing Tea Prices Using Unit Rates

Detailed Explanation

Two quantities are in proportion when their ratios are equal. Here we compare weight (in grams or kilograms) to price (in rupees). To compare two deals fairly, we bring both to the same base — the easiest is to find the price for the same amount of tea, usually 1 kg. This is called the unit rate. If the price per kilogram is the same in both places, the weight-to-price ratios are proportional. If not, the tea with the higher price per kilogram is more expensive. Remember that 1 kg = 1000 g, so a 200 g packet is one-fifth of a kilogram.

Formula Used

Two ratios are proportional if \( \frac{w_1}{p_1} = \frac{w_2}{p_2} \). Unit rate (price per kg) \( = \frac{\text{price}}{\text{weight in kg}} \).

Solution

  1. Step 1: Note down both deals. Himachal farmer: \( 200 \text{ g} \) for ₹\( 200 \). Meghalaya estate: \( 1 \text{ kg} \) for ₹\( 800 \).
  2. Step 2: Convert to the same unit of weight. Since \( 1 \text{ kg} = 1000 \text{ g} \), the farmer's packet is \( 200 \text{ g} = \frac{200}{1000} \text{ kg} = \frac{1}{5} \text{ kg} \).
  3. Step 3: Find the farmer's price for 1 kg using the unitary method. If \( \frac{1}{5} \text{ kg} \) costs ₹\( 200 \), then \( 1 \text{ kg} \) costs \[ 200 \times 5 = 1000. \] So the Himachal tea costs ₹\( 1000 \) per kg.
  4. Step 4: The Meghalaya tea already costs ₹\( 800 \) per kg. Now compare the two unit rates: \( 1000 \) per kg and \( 800 \) per kg.
  5. Step 5: Check for proportion by comparing the ratios. Farmer: \( \frac{200 \text{ g}}{200} = \frac{200}{200} = 1 \) g per rupee. Estate: \( \frac{1000 \text{ g}}{800} = \frac{5}{4} = 1.25 \) g per rupee. Since \( 1 \ne 1.25 \), the ratios are not equal.
  6. Step 6: Interpret the result. The ratios are not proportional. The Himachal tea costs more per kilogram (₹\( 1000 \) versus ₹\( 800 \)), so it is the more expensive tea.

Final Answer

The weight-to-price ratios are NOT proportional. Himachal tea costs ₹\( 1000 \) per kg while Meghalaya tea costs ₹\( 800 \) per kg, so the Himachal (small farmer's) tea is more expensive.

Common Mistake

Comparing ₹\( 200 \) with ₹\( 800 \) directly and concluding the Meghalaya tea is dearer, forgetting that the two packets have different weights. You must bring both to the same weight (per kg) before comparing prices.

🪜 Step-by-step Solution

Step-by-step Solution

  1. Step 1: Write down both deals clearly. Himachal small farmer: \( 200 \text{ g} \) for ₹\( 200 \). Meghalaya estate: \( 1 \text{ kg} \) for ₹\( 800 \). — Reason: Listing the given data first prevents mix-ups and makes it easy to compare the two situations.
  2. Step 2: Convert the Himachal packet's weight from grams to kilograms, since the Meghalaya deal is already in kilograms. Using \( 1 \text{ kg} = 1000 \text{ g} \): \[ 200 \text{ g} = \frac{200}{1000} \text{ kg} = \frac{1}{5} \text{ kg} \] — Reason: We must use the same unit of weight before comparing prices; mixing grams and kilograms would give a meaningless result.
  3. Step 3: Find the Himachal tea's price for \( 1 \text{ kg} \) using the unitary method. If \( \frac{1}{5} \text{ kg} \) costs ₹\( 200 \), then \( 1 \text{ kg} \) costs: \[ 200 \times 5 = 1000 \] So the Himachal tea costs ₹\( 1000 \) per kg. — Reason: Scaling up to 1 kg (the unit rate) lets us compare both deals on equal footing.
  4. Step 4: Note the Meghalaya tea's unit rate directly from the problem. It already costs ₹\( 800 \) per kg, so no conversion is needed. — Reason: Since this deal is already expressed per kilogram, we can read off the unit rate immediately.
  5. Step 5: Check whether the two weight-to-price ratios are equal. Himachal ratio: \( \frac{200 \text{ g}}{200} = \frac{1 \text{ g}}{\text{₹}1} \). Meghalaya ratio: \( \frac{1000 \text{ g}}{800} = \frac{1.25 \text{ g}}{\text{₹}1} \). Since \( \frac{1}{1} \ne \frac{1.25}{1} \), the ratios are NOT equal. — Reason: Proportionality requires the two ratios to be identical; a difference here confirms the deals are not proportional.
  6. Step 6: Compare the two unit rates to decide which tea is more expensive. Himachal: ₹\( 1000 \) per kg. Meghalaya: ₹\( 800 \) per kg. Since \( 1000 > 800 \), the Himachal tea costs more per kilogram. — Reason: A higher price per kilogram means the buyer pays more for the same quantity, so that tea is the more expensive option.

Final Answer

The weight-to-price ratios are NOT proportional. Himachal tea costs ₹\( 1000 \) per kg while Meghalaya tea costs ₹\( 800 \) per kg, so the Himachal (small farmer's) tea is more expensive.

Common Mistake

One common mistake: Students forget to convert grams to kilograms before comparing, and mistakenly write the Himachal ratio as \( \frac{200}{200} \) versus \( \frac{1}{800} \), mixing up units and arriving at a completely wrong conclusion about which tea is more expensive.

✍️ Exam-ready Answer

Exam-ready Answer

  1. Step 1: Himachal: \( 200 \text{ g} = \frac{1}{5} \text{ kg} \) for ₹\( 200 \). Meghalaya: \( 1 \text{ kg} \) for ₹\( 800 \).
  2. Step 2: Himachal price per kg: \( 200 \times 5 = \) ₹\( 1000 \) per kg.
  3. Step 3: Check proportion: \( \frac{200}{200} = 1 \) g per ₹ but \( \frac{1000}{800} = \frac{5}{4} \) g per ₹, so \( \frac{1}{5} \div 200 \ne 1 \div 800 \). Ratios are NOT equal.

Answer: The weight-to-price ratios are NOT proportional. Himachal tea costs ₹\( 1000 \) per kg while Meghalaya tea costs ₹\( 800 \) per kg, so the Himachal (small farmer's) tea is more expensive.

➕ More Examples

More Examples

Example 1

Question: A local dairy in Amul sells a 250 g packet of butter for ₹55. A premium brand sells a 1 kg pack of butter for ₹196. Are the price-to-weight ratios of both brands proportional? Which butter is more expensive per gram?

Solution: First, express both weights in the same unit (grams). Local dairy: Weight = 250 g, Price = ₹55. Premium brand: Weight = 1 kg = 1000 g, Price = ₹196. Now find the price per gram for each brand. For the local dairy: \[ \text{Price per gram} = \frac{55}{250} = \frac{11}{50} = 0.22 \text{ rupees per gram} \] For the premium brand: \[ \text{Price per gram} = \frac{196}{1000} = 0.196 \text{ rupees per gram} \] Now check if the ratios are proportional, i.e., check whether \( \frac{55}{250} = \frac{196}{1000} \). Cross-multiplying: \[ 55 \times 1000 = 55000 \] \[ 196 \times 250 = 49000 \] Since \( 55000 \ne 49000 \), the ratios are NOT proportional. Comparing the unit prices: \( 0.22 > 0.196 \), so the local dairy butter costs more per gram.

Answer: The ratios are NOT proportional. The local dairy butter (₹0.22 per gram) is more expensive than the premium brand (₹0.196 per gram).

Example 2

Question: A street vendor in Jaipur sells 400 g of mixed dry fruits for ₹280. A supermarket in Delhi sells 1.5 kg of the same mixed dry fruits for ₹1050. Are the price-to-weight ratios proportional? Which seller charges more per kilogram?

Solution: Convert all weights to kilograms for easy comparison. Street vendor: Weight = 400 g = \( \frac{400}{1000} \) kg = 0.4 kg, Price = ₹280. Supermarket: Weight = 1.5 kg, Price = ₹1050. Find the price per kilogram for each seller. For the street vendor: \[ \text{Price per kg} = \frac{280}{0.4} = \frac{280 \times 10}{4} = \frac{2800}{4} = 700 \text{ rupees per kg} \] For the supermarket: \[ \text{Price per kg} = \frac{1050}{1.5} = \frac{1050 \times 10}{15} = \frac{10500}{15} = 700 \text{ rupees per kg} \] Now check if the ratios are proportional, i.e., whether \( \frac{280}{0.4} = \frac{1050}{1.5} \). Both equal 700, so the ratios are equal. We can also verify by cross-multiplying with the original values: \[ 280 \times 1.5 = 420 \] \[ 1050 \times 0.4 = 420 \] Since both products are equal, the ratios ARE proportional. Both sellers charge ₹700 per kg, so neither is more expensive — they charge the same price per kilogram.

Answer: The ratios ARE proportional. Both the street vendor and the supermarket charge the same price of ₹700 per kg; neither is more expensive.

🎯 Try a Similar Question

Try a Similar Question

Question: A local dairy in Amul cooperative sells each 250 g packet of butter for ₹60. A large dairy in another state sells each 500 g packet of butter for ₹105. Are the weight-to-price ratios in both places proportional? Which butter is more expensive per kg?

Solution

  1. Step 1: Convert weights to kilograms: The Amul cooperative packet weighs 250 g. Converting to kg: \[ \frac{250}{1000} = 0.25 \text{ kg} \] The other dairy's packet weighs 500 g. Converting to kg: \[ \frac{500}{1000} = 0.5 \text{ kg} \]
  2. Step 2: Find the price per kg for each dairy: Price per kg for the Amul cooperative butter: \[ \frac{60}{0.25} = 60 \times 4 = ₹240 \text{ per kg} \] Price per kg for the other dairy's butter: \[ \frac{105}{0.5} = 105 \times 2 = ₹210 \text{ per kg} \]
  3. Step 3: Write the weight-to-price ratios: Weight-to-price ratio for the Amul cooperative: \[ \frac{0.25 \text{ kg}}{₹60} = \frac{1}{240} \text{ kg per rupee} \] Weight-to-price ratio for the other dairy: \[ \frac{0.5 \text{ kg}}{₹105} = \frac{1}{210} \text{ kg per rupee} \]
  4. Step 4: Check whether the ratios are proportional: For the ratios to be proportional, we need \( \frac{0.25}{60} = \frac{0.5}{105} \). Cross-multiplying: \[ 0.25 \times 105 = 26.25 \] \[ 0.5 \times 60 = 30 \] Since \( 26.25 \ne 30 \), the two ratios are NOT equal, so the weight-to-price ratios are NOT proportional.
  5. Step 5: Compare and conclude: The Amul cooperative butter costs ₹240 per kg, while the other dairy's butter costs ₹210 per kg. Since \( 240 > 210 \), the Amul cooperative butter is more expensive per kg.

Answer: The weight-to-price ratios are NOT proportional. The Amul cooperative butter costs ₹240 per kg while the other dairy's butter costs ₹210 per kg, so the Amul cooperative butter is more expensive.

Everything you get with Solver7

More questions in Proportional Reasoning - 1