Detailed Explanation
Two quantities are in proportion when their ratios are equal. Here we compare weight (in grams or kilograms) to price (in rupees). To compare two deals fairly, we bring both to the same base — the easiest is to find the price for the same amount of tea, usually 1 kg. This is called the unit rate. If the price per kilogram is the same in both places, the weight-to-price ratios are proportional. If not, the tea with the higher price per kilogram is more expensive. Remember that 1 kg = 1000 g, so a 200 g packet is one-fifth of a kilogram.
Formula Used
Two ratios are proportional if \( \frac{w_1}{p_1} = \frac{w_2}{p_2} \). Unit rate (price per kg) \( = \frac{\text{price}}{\text{weight in kg}} \).
Solution
- Step 1: Note down both deals. Himachal farmer: \( 200 \text{ g} \) for ₹\( 200 \). Meghalaya estate: \( 1 \text{ kg} \) for ₹\( 800 \).
- Step 2: Convert to the same unit of weight. Since \( 1 \text{ kg} = 1000 \text{ g} \), the farmer's packet is \( 200 \text{ g} = \frac{200}{1000} \text{ kg} = \frac{1}{5} \text{ kg} \).
- Step 3: Find the farmer's price for 1 kg using the unitary method. If \( \frac{1}{5} \text{ kg} \) costs ₹\( 200 \), then \( 1 \text{ kg} \) costs \[ 200 \times 5 = 1000. \] So the Himachal tea costs ₹\( 1000 \) per kg.
- Step 4: The Meghalaya tea already costs ₹\( 800 \) per kg. Now compare the two unit rates: \( 1000 \) per kg and \( 800 \) per kg.
- Step 5: Check for proportion by comparing the ratios. Farmer: \( \frac{200 \text{ g}}{200} = \frac{200}{200} = 1 \) g per rupee. Estate: \( \frac{1000 \text{ g}}{800} = \frac{5}{4} = 1.25 \) g per rupee. Since \( 1 \ne 1.25 \), the ratios are not equal.
- Step 6: Interpret the result. The ratios are not proportional. The Himachal tea costs more per kilogram (₹\( 1000 \) versus ₹\( 800 \)), so it is the more expensive tea.
Final Answer
The weight-to-price ratios are NOT proportional. Himachal tea costs ₹\( 1000 \) per kg while Meghalaya tea costs ₹\( 800 \) per kg, so the Himachal (small farmer's) tea is more expensive.
Common Mistake
Comparing ₹\( 200 \) with ₹\( 800 \) directly and concluding the Meghalaya tea is dearer, forgetting that the two packets have different weights. You must bring both to the same weight (per kg) before comparing prices.