SOLVER7 Study. Nothing Else.
Problem Set 9 Q12

Prove that any three points on a circle cannot be collinear.

MAH STATE BOARD Mah SB Class 10 Maths · Circle

Solution

👶 Simple Explanation

Simple Explanation

Imagine a circle like a perfectly round running track. Pick any three spots on that track. Now, a straight road cannot touch three spots on a round track all at once. Here is why: if two spots are joined, the middle of that join always points back to the centre of the track. Two different joins give two different pointers to the centre. If the three spots were in a straight line, those two pointers would never meet, but they must both reach the same centre. That is impossible, so the three spots can never be in a straight line.

Answer: Hence proved: Any three points on a circle cannot be collinear, because assuming they are collinear forces two distinct perpendicular bisectors through the centre to be parallel, which is impossible.

📖 Proof: Three Points on a Circle Are Not Collinear

Detailed Explanation

A circle is the set of all points in a plane that are at a fixed distance (the radius) from a fixed point (the centre). A key property of a circle is that the perpendicular bisector of any chord always passes through the centre of the circle. We will use this property along with proof by contradiction. In proof by contradiction, we assume the opposite of what we want to prove and then show that this assumption leads to something impossible. Collinear points are points that lie on the same straight line. If three points on a circle were collinear, they would all lie on one straight line, but as we will see, this contradicts the properties of a circle.

Formula Used

Key property used: The perpendicular bisector of any chord of a circle passes through the centre of the circle. Also, two distinct lines can intersect in at most one point.

Solution

  1. Step 1: Assume the opposite of what we want to prove. Let \(A\), \(B\), and \(C\) be any three points on a circle with centre \(O\). Suppose, for the sake of contradiction, that \(A\), \(B\), and \(C\) are collinear, meaning they all lie on the same straight line \(l\).
  2. Step 2: Since \(A\), \(B\), and \(C\) lie on the circle, the segments \(AB\) and \(BC\) are chords of the circle. Let \(M\) be the midpoint of chord \(AB\) and \(N\) be the midpoint of chord \(BC\).
  3. Step 3: Draw the perpendicular bisector of chord \(AB\) at point \(M\); call it \(p_1\). Draw the perpendicular bisector of chord \(BC\) at point \(N\); call it \(p_2\). By the property of a circle, both \(p_1\) and \(p_2\) must pass through the centre \(O\).
  4. Step 4: Since \(A\), \(B\), \(C\) all lie on the same line \(l\), both chords \(AB\) and \(BC\) lie along \(l\). Therefore, \(p_1\) is perpendicular to \(l\) at \(M\), and \(p_2\) is perpendicular to \(l\) at \(N\). This means \(p_1\) and \(p_2\) are both perpendicular to the same line \(l\), so \(p_1 \parallel p_2\).
  5. Step 5: But we also said that both \(p_1\) and \(p_2\) pass through the centre \(O\). Two parallel lines cannot have a common point unless they are the same line. Since \(M \ne N\) (as \(A\), \(B\), \(C\) are distinct points), \(p_1\) and \(p_2\) are distinct lines. This is a contradiction: two distinct parallel lines cannot meet at \(O\).
  6. Step 6: Since our assumption that \(A\), \(B\), \(C\) are collinear leads to a contradiction, the assumption must be false. Hence, any three points on a circle cannot be collinear.

Final Answer

Hence proved: Any three points on a circle cannot be collinear, because assuming they are collinear forces two distinct perpendicular bisectors through the centre to be parallel, which is impossible.

Common Mistake

A common mistake is to try to prove this directly without using contradiction, or to forget to state the key property that the perpendicular bisector of a chord passes through the centre of the circle. Without this property, the argument does not work.

🪜 Step-by-step Solution

Step-by-step Solution

  1. Step 1: Set up the contradiction assumption: Let \ \(A\), \(B\), and \(C\) be three points lying on a circle with centre \(O\). We want to prove they cannot be collinear, so we assume the opposite: suppose \(A\), \(B\), and \(C\) all lie on the same straight line \(l\). — Reason: This is the method of proof by contradiction; we assume the negation of our goal and derive an impossibility.
  2. Step 2: Identify the chords formed: Since \(A\), \(B\), and \(C\) lie on the circle, the segment \(AB\) is a chord of the circle, and the segment \(BC\) is also a chord of the circle. Under our assumption, both chords lie along the same line \(l\). — Reason: Any segment joining two points on a circle is a chord, and we need two distinct chords to apply the perpendicular bisector property twice.
  3. Step 3: Construct the perpendicular bisectors: Let \(M\) be the midpoint of chord \(AB\) and let \(N\) be the midpoint of chord \(BC\). Draw line \(p_1\), the perpendicular bisector of \(AB\) at \(M\), and draw line \(p_2\), the perpendicular bisector of \(BC\) at \(N\). Since both chords lie along line \(l\), both \(p_1\) and \(p_2\) are perpendicular to \(l\). — Reason: The perpendicular bisector of a segment is the unique line through its midpoint that is at right angles to it; being perpendicular to the same line \(l\) makes \(p_1 \parallel p_2\).
  4. Step 4: Apply the centre-property to both chords: By the circle theorem, the perpendicular bisector of every chord passes through the centre. Therefore \(p_1\) passes through \(O\) and \(p_2\) also passes through \(O\). This means both \(p_1\) and \(p_2\) contain the point \(O\). — Reason: This theorem holds for every chord, so it applies to both \(AB\) and \(BC\) simultaneously.
  5. Step 5: Reach the contradiction: From Step 3, \(p_1 \parallel p_2\) (both are perpendicular to line \(l\)). From Step 4, both lines pass through \(O\). But two distinct parallel lines can never share a common point. Hence \(p_1\) and \(p_2\) cannot both be parallel and both pass through \(O\) — this is a contradiction. — Reason: The simultaneous requirements of being parallel and intersecting at \(O\) are mutually exclusive, so our assumption must be false.
  6. Step 6: Conclude the proof: Since assuming \(A\), \(B\), \(C\) are collinear leads to a contradiction, the assumption is false. Therefore, any three points on a circle cannot be collinear. — Reason: In proof by contradiction, a false assumption confirms the truth of the original statement we wished to prove.

Final Answer

Hence proved: Any three points on a circle cannot be collinear, because assuming they are collinear forces two distinct perpendicular bisectors through the centre to be parallel, which is impossible.

Common Mistake

One common mistake: Students forget that \(A\), \(B\), \(C\) must be three distinct points; if any two coincide, you do not get two distinct chords, and the argument about two separate perpendicular bisectors breaks down.

✍️ Exam-ready Answer

Exam-ready Answer

  1. Step 1: Assume contradiction: Let \(A\), \(B\), \(C\) be three points on a circle with centre \(O\). Assume \(A\), \(B\), \(C\) are collinear, i.e., they all lie on a single straight line \(l\).
  2. Step 2: Identify chords and their perpendicular bisectors: \(AB\) and \(BC\) are chords of the circle. Let \(p_1\) be the perpendicular bisector of \(AB\) and \(p_2\) be the perpendicular bisector of \(BC\). By the key property, both \(p_1\) and \(p_2\) must pass through \(O\).
  3. Step 3: Derive the contradiction: Since \(A\), \(B\), \(C\) are collinear, \(AB\) and \(BC\) both lie on line \(l\). Their perpendicular bisectors \(p_1\) and \(p_2\) are both perpendicular to \(l\), so \(p_1 \parallel p_2\). But two parallel lines cannot share a common point, contradicting the fact that both pass through \(O\).

Answer: Hence proved: Any three points on a circle cannot be collinear, because assuming they are collinear forces two distinct perpendicular bisectors through the centre to be parallel, which is impossible.

➕ More Examples

More Examples

Example 1

Question: Prove that it is impossible for three distinct points lying on a circle to lie on the same straight line.

Solution: We use proof by contradiction. \nAssume, for the sake of contradiction, that three distinct points A, B, and C all lie on a circle with centre O and radius r, AND that A, B, C are collinear (i.e., they all lie on a single straight line l). \nSince A, B, and C lie on the circle, each of them is at a distance r from the centre O. \nNow, the line l passes through A, B, and C. Consider the relationship between the straight line l and the circle. \nA straight line and a circle can intersect in at most 2 points. This is because substituting the equation of a line into the equation of a circle yields a quadratic equation, which has at most 2 solutions. \nThe quadratic equation of intersection is of the form: \[ ax^2 + bx + c = 0 \] \nA quadratic equation has at most 2 roots, so the line l can meet the circle in at most 2 distinct points. \nHowever, our assumption states that the line l passes through 3 distinct points A, B, and C on the circle — that is, it intersects the circle in 3 points. \nThis is a contradiction, since a line can intersect a circle in at most 2 points. \nTherefore, our assumption is false. Hence, the three points A, B, and C on the circle cannot be collinear. This completes the proof.

Answer: Proved by contradiction: since a line meets a circle in at most 2 points, three points on a circle cannot be collinear.

Example 2

Question: Points P, Q, and R are three distinct points on a circle with centre O and radius 5 cm. A student claims that P, Q, and R can be collinear. Disprove this claim with a clear mathematical argument.

Solution: We disprove the student's claim using a proof by contradiction. \nSuppose the claim is true: P, Q, and R all lie on the circle with centre O and radius \[ r = 5 \text{ cm} \] \nand simultaneously, P, Q, R are collinear, lying on some straight line l. \nThe equation of the circle with centre O at the origin is: \[ x^2 + y^2 = 25 \] \nLet the line l have equation \[ y = mx + c \] \nfor some constants m and c (a similar argument holds for a vertical line). Substituting into the circle's equation: \[ x^2 + (mx + c)^2 = 25 \] \nExpanding: \[ x^2 + m^2x^2 + 2mcx + c^2 = 25 \] \nCollecting terms: \[ (1 + m^2)x^2 + 2mcx + (c^2 - 25) = 0 \] \nThis is a quadratic equation in x. By the Fundamental Theorem of Algebra, a quadratic equation has at most 2 real solutions, so the line l can intersect the circle in at most 2 distinct points. \nHowever, the assumption requires the line l to pass through 3 distinct points P, Q, and R on the circle, meaning 3 intersections — which is impossible for a quadratic equation. \nThis is a contradiction. Therefore, P, Q, and R cannot be collinear, and the student's claim is false.

Answer: Disproved: substituting the line's equation into the circle's equation gives a quadratic with at most 2 solutions, so no line can meet a circle in 3 or more points, making P, Q, R non-collinear.

🎯 Try a Similar Question

Try a Similar Question

Question: Prove that it is impossible for three distinct points lying on a circle to be collinear (i.e., to all lie on a single straight line). Use the property of perpendicular bisectors of chords in your proof.

Solution

  1. Step 1 – Assume the contrary: Let \ \(A\), \(B\), and \(C\) be three distinct points on a circle with centre \(O\). Assume, for the sake of contradiction, that \(A\), \(B\), and \(C\) are collinear, i.e., they all lie on a single straight line \(\ell\).
  2. Step 2 – Identify two chords: Since \(A\), \(B\), \(C\) lie on the circle, the segments \(AB\) and \(BC\) are both chords of the circle. By our assumption, both chords lie along the same straight line \(\ell\).
  3. Step 3 – Apply the perpendicular bisector property: A key theorem states: the perpendicular bisector of any chord of a circle passes through the centre of the circle. Therefore, the perpendicular bisector of chord \(AB\) passes through \(O\), and the perpendicular bisector of chord \(BC\) also passes through \(O\).
  4. Step 4 – Analyse the perpendicular bisectors: The perpendicular bisector of a segment is, by definition, perpendicular to that segment. Since both \(AB\) and \(BC\) lie along the same line \(\ell\), the perpendicular bisector of \(AB\) is perpendicular to \(\ell\), and the perpendicular bisector of \(BC\) is also perpendicular to \(\ell\). Two distinct lines that are both perpendicular to the same line are parallel to each other.
  5. Step 5 – Reach the contradiction: So we have two perpendicular bisectors that are parallel to each other. But both must pass through the single point \(O\) (the centre). Two distinct parallel lines cannot share a common point. This is a contradiction. Hence our assumption that \(A\), \(B\), \(C\) are collinear must be false.
  6. Step 6 – State the conclusion: Therefore, three distinct points lying on a circle can never be collinear. In other words, no three points on a circle can lie on the same straight line.

Answer: It is impossible for three distinct points on a circle to be collinear. Assuming collinearity forces the perpendicular bisectors of the two chords formed to be parallel, yet both must pass through the centre — a contradiction. Hence, three points on a circle are always non-collinear.

Everything you get with Solver7

More questions in Circle

Chapter 9 Examples Q1 Practice Set 9.1 Q1 (i) Practice Set 9.2 Q1 Practice Set 9.3 Q1 Practice Set 9.4 Q1 (i) Practice Set 9.5 Q1 Problem Set 9 Q1 (i) 03/2018 2018 / Question 4 Q1 03/2019 2019 / Question 5 Q1 N397 2024 / Question 2 QA (i) N397 2024 / Question 5 Q1 N397 2026 / Question 2 QA (i) N397 2026 / Question 5 Q1 (a) N632 2024 / Question 2 QA (i) N723 2022 / Question 3 QA (i) N832 2025 / Question 2 QA (i) N832 2025 / Question 5 Q1 N926 2023 / Question 2 QA (i) N926 2023 / Question 5 Q1 N932 2026 / Question 2 QA (i) N932 2026 / Question 5 Q1 (a) Chapter 9 Examples Q2 Practice Set 9.1 Q1 (ii) Practice Set 9.2 Q2 Practice Set 9.3 Q2 (i) Practice Set 9.4 Q1 (ii) Practice Set 9.5 Q2 (i) Problem Set 9 Q1 (ii) 03/2018 2018 / Question 1 Q2 03/2018 2018 / Question 2 Q2 03/2019 2019 / Question 3 QA (ii) 03/2019 2019 / Question 4 Q2 (a) N397 2024 / Question 1 QA (ii) N397 2026 / Question 1 QA (ii) N397 2026 / Question 5 Q1 (b) N632 2024 / Question 3 QA (ii) N697 2025 / Question 1 QA (ii) N697 2025 / Question 2 QA (ii) N697 2025 / Question 3 QA (ii) N723 2022 / Question 1 QA (ii) N723 2022 / Question 4 Q2 N832 2025 / Question 1 QA (ii) N832 2025 / Question 2 QA (ii) N926 2023 / Question 1 QA (ii) N932 2026 / Question 1 QA (ii) N932 2026 / Question 5 Q1 (b) Practice Set 9.1 Q1 (iii) Practice Set 9.2 Q3 (i) Chapter 9 Examples Q3 (i) Practice Set 9.3 Q2 (ii) Practice Set 9.4 Q1 (iii) Practice Set 9.5 Q2 (ii) Problem Set 9 Q1 (iii) 03/2019 2019 / Question 1 QA (iii) 03/2019 2019 / Question 4 Q2 (b) N397 2024 / Question 3 QB (i) N397 2026 / Question 2 QA (iii) N397 2026 / Question 5 Q1 (c) N632 2024 / Question 4 Q3 N697 2025 / Question 2 QA (iii)