Example 1
Question: Two circles with centres M and N touch each other externally at point T. A straight line through T intersects the first circle at point C and the second circle at point D. Prove that seg MC is parallel to seg ND.
Solution: Let the common tangent to both circles at the point of contact T be the line XY. \nStep 1: Tangent–radius relationship for circle with centre M.\nSince XY is the common tangent at T and MT is a radius of the circle with centre M, we have MT perpendicular to XY.\nHence \ \angle MTX = 90^\circ. \nStep 2: Angle in a semicircle for circle with centre M.\nSince CT is a chord of the circle with centre M passing through T, and M is the centre, the angle subtended by the chord at the centre is twice that at any point on the circle. However, we use the simpler property: MC = MT (radii), so triangle MCT is isosceles.\nLet \ \angle MTC = \alpha. Then \ \angle MCT = \alpha (base angles of isosceles triangle MCT).\nAlso, since MT is perpendicular to XY (the tangent at T), and CTD is the secant line through T: \[ \angle MTC = \angle MTX - \angle CTX = 90^\circ - \angle CTX \]\nWait — let us use the tangent–chord angle directly. \nThe angle between tangent XY and chord TC equals the inscribed angle in the alternate segment. More directly:\nSince MC = MT (radii), triangle MCT is isosceles, so \ \angle MCT = \angle MTC.\nBut by the tangent–radius property, \ \angle MTX = 90^\circ, so: \[ \angle MTC = 90^\circ - \angle CTX \]\nHence \ \angle MCT = 90^\circ - \angle CTX. \nStep 3: Tangent–radius relationship for circle with centre N.\nSimilarly, NT is perpendicular to XY, so \ \angle NTX = 90^\circ.\nSince ND = NT (radii), triangle NDT is isosceles, so \ \angle NDT = \angle NTD.\nNow, \ \angle NTD = \angle NTX - \angle DTX. But D is on the opposite side of T from C on the line CTD, so: \[ \angle NTD = 90^\circ - \angle DTX \]\nSince CTD is a straight line, \ \angle CTX + \angle DTX = 180^\circ... \nActually, C, T, D are collinear with T between C and D (the line passes through T). So \ \angle CTX and \ \angle DTX are supplementary only if X is not on line CTD.\nMore carefully: \angle DTX = 180^\circ - \angle CTX (angles on a straight line CTD with ray TX).\nSo: \[ \angle NTD = 90^\circ - (180^\circ - \angle CTX) = \angle CTX - 90^\circ \]\nThat gives a negative value for small angles, so let us place the diagram carefully. \nLet T lie between C and D on the line. Let the tangent XY be such that X is on one side. Then \ \angle CTX is acute (say). The ray TX makes angle \ \angle CTX with TC and \ \angle DTX = 180^\circ - \angle CTX with TD (since CTD is a straight line). \[ \angle NTD = \angle NTX - \angle DTX \]\nBut \ \angle NTX = 90^\circ and \ \angle DTX = 180^\circ - \angle CTX, so if \ \angle CTX < 90^\circ: \[ \angle NTD = 90^\circ - (180^\circ - \angle CTX) \]\nThis is negative, meaning D and X are on the same side of NT.\nSo instead: \ \angle NTD = \angle DTX - \angle NTX... \nLet us restate using alternate angles cleanly. \nStep 4 (Clean approach): \nIn circle with centre M: MT \perp XY (tangent–radius). In triangle MCT, MC = MT (radii), so it is isosceles.\nBy the tangent–chord angle theorem: \ \angle between tangent TX and chord TC = \angle in alternate segment.\nActually the cleanest proof: \ \angle MTC = \angle MCT (isosceles triangle, MC = MT).\nAlso, \ \angle MTX = 90^\circ, so \ \angle MTC + \angle CTX = 90^\circ (if C and X are on opposite sides)... \nLet \ \angle CTX = \theta. Then \ \angle MTC = 90^\circ - \theta, and since triangle MCT is isosceles, \ \angle MCT = 90^\circ - \theta. \nIn circle with centre N: NT \perp XY, NT = ND (radii), triangle NDT isosceles. \ \angle DTX = 180^\circ - \theta (straight line CTD).\nSo \ \angle NTD = \angle NTX - \angle DTX... Let us measure from the other side:\nSince \ \angle NTX = 90^\circ and \ \angle DTX = 180^\circ - \theta: \ \angle NTD = \angle DTX - 90^\circ = 90^\circ - \theta (taking the acute angle between NT and TD).\nSo \ \angle NDT = \angle NTD = 90^\circ - \theta. \nStep 5: Conclude parallel lines.\nNow, line CD acts as a transversal cutting lines MC and ND. \ \angle MCT = 90^\circ - \theta (angle that MC makes with transversal CD at point C). \ \angle NDT = 90^\circ - \theta (angle that ND makes with transversal CD at point D).\nThese are alternate interior angles (\angle MCT and \angle NDT are on opposite sides of the transversal CD), and they are equal.\nHence, seg MC is parallel to seg ND.
Answer: seg MC \(\parallel\) seg ND, proved using the tangent–radius perpendicularity property, isosceles triangles formed by equal radii, and the equal alternate interior angles criterion for parallel lines.
Example 2
Question: Two circles with centres X and Y touch each other internally at point K. A line through K meets the larger circle (centre X) at point E and the smaller circle (centre Y) at point F (with F between E and K, or K between E and F). Prove that XE is parallel to YF.
Solution: Let the common internal tangent to both circles at K be the line PQ. \nStep 1: Tangent is perpendicular to radius for circle with centre X.\nSince PQ is tangent to the circle with centre X at K, and XK is a radius: \[ XK \perp PQ \]\nSo \ \angle XKP = 90^\circ. \nStep 2: Tangent is perpendicular to radius for circle with centre Y.\nSince PQ is also tangent to the circle with centre Y at K, and YK is a radius: \[ YK \perp PQ \]\nSo \ \angle YKP = 90^\circ. (This confirms X, K, Y are collinear, which is consistent with internal tangency.) \nStep 3: Set up angles.\nLet the line EKF pass through K, making an angle \ \theta with the tangent PQ at K.\nSo \ \angle EKP = \theta (angle between line EF and tangent PQ at K).\nSince \ \angle XKP = 90^\circ: \[ \angle XKE = 90^\circ - \theta \] \nStep 4: Triangle XEK is isosceles.\nXK = XE (both radii of circle with centre X).\nSo triangle XEK is isosceles with \ \angle XEK = \angle XKE.\nHence: \[ \angle XEK = 90^\circ - \theta \] \nStep 5: Angle for circle with centre Y.\nFor the circle with centre Y: YK = YF (radii), so triangle YFK is isosceles.\nNow, \ \angle FKP = 180^\circ - \theta (since EKF is a straight line and \ \angle EKP = \theta, angles on a straight line: \ \angle FKP = 180^\circ - \theta).\nSince \ \angle YKP = 90^\circ: \[ \angle YKF = \angle FKP - \angle YKP = (180^\circ - \theta) - 90^\circ = 90^\circ - \theta \]\nSince triangle YFK is isosceles (YK = YF): \[ \angle YFK = \angle YKF = 90^\circ - \theta \] \nStep 6: Prove XE \parallel YF.\nConsider line EF as a transversal.\ \angle XEF = 90^\circ - \theta (angle at E) and \ \angle YFE = 90^\circ - \theta (angle at F).\nBoth angles are on the same side of the transversal EF and at points E and F respectively.\nSince \ \angle XEK = \angle YFK = 90^\circ - \theta, these are alternate interior angles formed by the transversal EF with lines XE and YF.\nSince the alternate interior angles are equal: \[ XE \parallel YF \]\nHence, seg XE is parallel to seg YF.
Answer: seg XE \(\parallel\) seg YF, proved by showing that the alternate interior angles formed by the transversal EF with lines XE and YF are both equal to \(90^\circ - \theta\), using the tangent–radius perpendicularity and the isosceles triangle property.