SOLVER7 Study. Nothing Else.
2023 Board Paper Q35(a)

Show that the following lines do not intersect each other :
\(\dfrac{x-1}{3}=\dfrac{y+1}{2}=\dfrac{z-1}{5};\ \dfrac{x+2}{4}=\dfrac{y-1}{3}=\dfrac{z+1}{-2}.\)

CBSE Class 12 Maths · Three Dimensional Geometry

Solution

👶 Simple Explanation

Simple Explanation

Imagine two cars driving along two different roads in a city. Each car follows its own path. We want to know if they ever reach the same spot at the same time. We give each car a number to track its position. We then ask: can both cars land on the exact same location? When we try to match their positions, the numbers simply do not agree. Because the numbers never match, the two roads never cross.

Answer: No values of \(\lambda\) and \(\mu\) satisfy all three equations at once, so the two lines have no common point. Therefore the given lines do not intersect each other.

📖 Showing Two Lines Do Not Intersect

Detailed Explanation

A line in 3D given in symmetric form \(\dfrac{x-x_1}{a}=\dfrac{y-y_1}{b}=\dfrac{z-z_1}{c}\) passes through the point \((x_1,y_1,z_1)\) and has direction ratios \((a,b,c)\). To find whether two lines intersect, we write each line in parametric form using a parameter (say \(\lambda\) for the first line and \(\mu\) for the second). If the lines intersect, there must exist values of \(\lambda\) and \(\mu\) that give the SAME point, i.e. the \(x\), \(y\) and \(z\) coordinates all match at once. We get three equations. We solve any two of them for \(\lambda\) and \(\mu\), and then check the third. If the third equation is NOT satisfied by those values, the system is inconsistent, so no common point exists and the lines do not intersect.

Formula Used

Line 1: \((1+3\lambda,\ -1+2\lambda,\ 1+5\lambda)\); Line 2: \((-2+4\mu,\ 1+3\mu,\ -1-2\mu)\). Lines intersect only if all three coordinates are equal for some \(\lambda,\mu\).

Solution

  1. Step 1: Write each line in parametric form. For the first line \(\dfrac{x-1}{3}=\dfrac{y+1}{2}=\dfrac{z-1}{5}=\lambda\), a general point is \[(1+3\lambda,\ -1+2\lambda,\ 1+5\lambda).\]
  2. Step 2: For the second line \(\dfrac{x+2}{4}=\dfrac{y-1}{3}=\dfrac{z+1}{-2}=\mu\), a general point is \[(-2+4\mu,\ 1+3\mu,\ -1-2\mu).\]
  3. Step 3: If the lines intersect, these points are the same for some \(\lambda\) and \(\mu\). Equating coordinates gives three equations: \[1+3\lambda=-2+4\mu,\] \[-1+2\lambda=1+3\mu,\] \[1+5\lambda=-1-2\mu.\]
  4. Step 4: Simplify the first two equations. From the first: \[3\lambda-4\mu=-3.\] From the second: \[2\lambda-3\mu=2.\]
  5. Step 5: Solve these two equations for \(\lambda\) and \(\mu\). Multiply the first by 3 and the second by 4: \[9\lambda-12\mu=-9,\] \[8\lambda-12\mu=8.\] Subtracting gives \[\lambda=-17.\]
  6. Step 6: Substitute \(\lambda=-17\) into \(2\lambda-3\mu=2\): \[2(-17)-3\mu=2\] \[-34-3\mu=2\] \[-3\mu=36\] \[\mu=-12.\]
  7. Step 7: Now test these values in the third equation \(1+5\lambda=-1-2\mu\). Left side: \[1+5(-17)=1-85=-84.\] Right side: \[-1-2(-12)=-1+24=23.\] Since \(-84\ne 23\), the third equation is not satisfied.
  8. Step 8: The values \(\lambda=-17,\ \mu=-12\) satisfy the first two equations but fail the third. Hence there is no pair \((\lambda,\mu)\) giving a common point, so the three equations are inconsistent.

Final Answer

No values of \(\lambda\) and \(\mu\) satisfy all three equations at once, so the two lines have no common point. Therefore the given lines do not intersect each other.

Common Mistake

A common mistake is to use the SAME parameter (like \(\lambda\)) for both lines. Each line must have its own independent parameter (\(\lambda\) and \(\mu\)), otherwise you force a false relationship and get a wrong conclusion. Also, students often forget to verify the third equation after solving the first two.

🪜 Step-by-step Solution

Step-by-step Solution

  1. Step 1: Convert Line 1 to parametric form. Set \(\dfrac{x-1}{3} = \dfrac{y+1}{2} = \dfrac{z-1}{5} = \lambda\). Then every point on Line 1 is \[(1 + 3\lambda,\ -1 + 2\lambda,\ 1 + 5\lambda).\] Reason: Introducing a single parameter \(\lambda\) lets us describe every point on the line algebraically, making it easy to equate coordinates with the second line.
  2. Step 2: Convert Line 2 to parametric form. Set \(\dfrac{x+2}{4} = \dfrac{y-1}{3} = \dfrac{z+1}{-2} = \mu\). Then every point on Line 2 is \[(-2 + 4\mu,\ 1 + 3\mu,\ -1 - 2\mu).\] Reason: A separate parameter \(\mu\) is used for Line 2 because the two lines are independent; they may or may not share a common point.
  3. Step 3: Set the parametric coordinates equal to form three simultaneous equations. Equating \(x\)-coordinates: \[1 + 3\lambda = -2 + 4\mu.\] Equating \(y\)-coordinates: \[-1 + 2\lambda = 1 + 3\mu.\] Equating \(z\)-coordinates: \[1 + 5\lambda = -1 - 2\mu.\] Reason: If the lines share a point, all three coordinate pairs must agree at the same \(\lambda\) and \(\mu\).
  4. Step 4: Rewrite the equations in standard form. From the \(x\)-equation: \[3\lambda - 4\mu = -3. \quad \text{...(i)}\] From the \(y\)-equation: \[2\lambda - 3\mu = 2. \quad \text{...(ii)}\] From the \(z\)-equation: \[5\lambda + 2\mu = -2. \quad \text{...(iii)}\] Reason: Rearranging collects all unknowns on one side, making the system easier to solve.
  5. Step 5: Solve equations (i) and (ii) for \(\lambda\) and \(\mu\). Multiply (i) by 3 and (ii) by 4: \[9\lambda - 12\mu = -9,\] \[8\lambda - 12\mu = 8.\] Subtract the second from the first: \[\lambda = -17.\] Substitute \(\lambda = -17\) into (ii): \[2(-17) - 3\mu = 2 \implies -34 - 3\mu = 2 \implies \mu = -12.\] Reason: Eliminating \(\mu\) by matching its coefficient gives a unique value for \(\lambda\), and back-substitution gives \(\mu\).
  6. Step 6: Check whether \(\lambda = -17\) and \(\mu = -12\) satisfy equation (iii). Substitute into the left-hand side of (iii): \[5(-17) + 2(-12) = -85 - 24 = -109.\] The right-hand side of (iii) is \(-2\). Since \(-109 \ne -2\), equation (iii) is not satisfied. Reason: All three equations must hold simultaneously for an intersection to exist; failing even one equation means no common point exists.

Final Answer

No values of \(\lambda\) and \(\mu\) satisfy all three equations at once, so the two lines have no common point. Therefore the given lines do not intersect each other.

Common Mistake

One common mistake: Students solve only two of the three coordinate equations and declare the lines intersecting as soon as they find a pair \((\lambda, \mu)\), forgetting to verify the solution in the third equation. All three equations must be consistent for an intersection to exist.

✍️ Exam-ready Answer

Exam-ready Answer

  1. Step 1: Parametric points: Line 1 gives \((1+3\lambda,\ -1+2\lambda,\ 1+5\lambda)\); Line 2 gives \((-2+4\mu,\ 1+3\mu,\ -1-2\mu)\).
  2. Step 2: Equating coordinates: \[3\lambda - 4\mu = -3 \quad \text{...(i)}\] \[2\lambda - 3\mu = 2 \quad \text{...(ii)}\] \[5\lambda + 2\mu = -2 \quad \text{...(iii)}\]
  3. Step 3: From (i) and (ii): multiply (i) by 3 and (ii) by 4, then subtract: \(9\lambda - 12\mu = -9\) and \(8\lambda - 12\mu = 8\), giving \(\lambda = -17\). Substituting into (ii): \(2(-17) - 3\mu = 2 \Rightarrow \mu = -12\).
  4. Step 4: Check in (iii): \(5(-17) + 2(-12) = -85 - 24 = -109 \ne -2\). Equation (iii) is not satisfied.

Answer: No values of \(\lambda\) and \(\mu\) satisfy all three equations at once, so the two lines have no common point. Therefore the given lines do not intersect each other.

➕ More Examples

More Examples

Example 1

Question: Show that the following lines do not intersect each other: \[\frac{x-2}{1} = \frac{y-3}{2} = \frac{z-4}{3}\] and \[\frac{x-1}{2} = \frac{y-4}{3} = \frac{z-5}{4}.\]

Solution: Write each line in parametric form. For Line 1, let the common ratio be \(\lambda\): \[x = 2 + \lambda,\quad y = 3 + 2\lambda,\quad z = 4 + 3\lambda.\] For Line 2, let the common ratio be \(\mu\): \[x = 1 + 2\mu,\quad y = 4 + 3\mu,\quad z = 5 + 4\mu.\] For intersection, equate the coordinates: From x-coordinates: \(2 + \lambda = 1 + 2\mu\), which gives \[\lambda - 2\mu = -1 \quad \cdots (1)\] From y-coordinates: \(3 + 2\lambda = 4 + 3\mu\), which gives \[2\lambda - 3\mu = 1 \quad \cdots (2)\] From z-coordinates: \(4 + 3\lambda = 5 + 4\mu\), which gives \[3\lambda - 4\mu = 1 \quad \cdots (3)\] Solve equations (1) and (2). Multiply (1) by 2: \[2\lambda - 4\mu = -2 \quad \cdots (4)\] Subtract (4) from (2): \[(2\lambda - 3\mu) - (2\lambda - 4\mu) = 1 - (-2)\] \[\mu = 3.\] Substitute \(\mu = 3\) into (1): \[\lambda - 2(3) = -1 \Rightarrow \lambda = 5.\] Now verify using equation (3): \[3\lambda - 4\mu = 3(5) - 4(3) = 15 - 12 = 3.\] But equation (3) requires \(3\lambda - 4\mu = 1\), and we got 3, which is not equal to 1. Since \(\lambda = 5,\ \mu = 3\) satisfies equations (1) and (2) but NOT equation (3), the system is inconsistent. Therefore, the two lines do not intersect each other.

Answer: The lines are skew (do not intersect), as the system of equations from equating coordinates is inconsistent: equations (1) and (2) give \(\lambda = 5,\ \mu = 3\), but these values do not satisfy equation (3).

Example 2

Question: Show that the following lines do not intersect each other: \[\frac{x+1}{2} = \frac{y-2}{3} = \frac{z-3}{-1}\] and \[\frac{x-2}{1} = \frac{y+1}{2} = \frac{z+2}{3}.\]

Solution: Write each line in parametric form. For Line 1, let the common ratio be \(\lambda\): \[x = -1 + 2\lambda,\quad y = 2 + 3\lambda,\quad z = 3 - \lambda.\] For Line 2, let the common ratio be \(\mu\): \[x = 2 + \mu,\quad y = -1 + 2\mu,\quad z = -2 + 3\mu.\] For intersection, equate the coordinates: From x-coordinates: \(-1 + 2\lambda = 2 + \mu\), which gives \[2\lambda - \mu = 3 \quad \cdots (1)\] From y-coordinates: \(2 + 3\lambda = -1 + 2\mu\), which gives \[3\lambda - 2\mu = -3 \quad \cdots (2)\] From z-coordinates: \(3 - \lambda = -2 + 3\mu\), which gives \[\lambda + 3\mu = 5 \quad \cdots (3)\] Solve equations (1) and (2). Multiply (1) by 2: \[4\lambda - 2\mu = 6 \quad \cdots (4)\] Subtract (2) from (4): \[(4\lambda - 2\mu) - (3\lambda - 2\mu) = 6 - (-3)\] \[\lambda = 9.\] Substitute \(\lambda = 9\) into (1): \[2(9) - \mu = 3 \Rightarrow \mu = 15.\] Now verify using equation (3): \[\lambda + 3\mu = 9 + 3(15) = 9 + 45 = 54.\] But equation (3) requires \(\lambda + 3\mu = 5\), and we got 54, which is not equal to 5. Since the values \(\lambda = 9,\ \mu = 15\) satisfy equations (1) and (2) but do NOT satisfy equation (3), the system is inconsistent. Therefore, the two lines do not intersect each other.

Answer: The lines are skew (do not intersect), as the system of parametric equations is inconsistent: equations (1) and (2) give \(\lambda = 9,\ \mu = 15\), which does not satisfy equation (3), confirming the lines are skew lines.

🎯 Try a Similar Question

Try a Similar Question

Question: Show that the following two lines do not intersect each other: \[\frac{x-2}{1} = \frac{y+3}{2} = \frac{z-1}{3}\] and \[\frac{x+1}{2} = \frac{y-2}{3} = \frac{z+2}{1}.\]

Solution

  1. Step 1: Write Parametric Equations for Line 1: Let the common ratio for the first line equal \( \lambda \). Then the parametric equations of Line 1 are: \[x = 2 + \lambda,\quad y = -3 + 2\lambda,\quad z = 1 + 3\lambda.\]
  2. Step 2: Write Parametric Equations for Line 2: Let the common ratio for the second line equal \( \mu \). Then the parametric equations of Line 2 are: \[x = -1 + 2\mu,\quad y = 2 + 3\mu,\quad z = -2 + \mu.\]
  3. Step 3: Equate x-coordinates: For an intersection point, the x-coordinates must be equal: \[2 + \lambda = -1 + 2\mu\] which gives \[\lambda - 2\mu = -3. \quad \cdots (1)\]
  4. Step 4: Equate y-coordinates: Equating y-coordinates: \[-3 + 2\lambda = 2 + 3\mu\] which gives \[2\lambda - 3\mu = 5. \quad \cdots (2)\]
  5. Step 5: Solve Equations (1) and (2): From equation (1): \( \lambda = 2\mu - 3 \). Substituting into equation (2): \[2(2\mu - 3) - 3\mu = 5\] \[4\mu - 6 - 3\mu = 5\] \[\mu = 11.\] Then \( \lambda = 2(11) - 3 = 19 \).
  6. Step 6: Check z-coordinates: Substitute \( \lambda = 19 \) into the z-expression for Line 1: \[z = 1 + 3(19) = 1 + 57 = 58.\] Substitute \( \mu = 11 \) into the z-expression for Line 2: \[z = -2 + 11 = 9.\] Since \( 58 \ne 9 \), the z-coordinates do not match.
  7. Step 7: Conclusion: The values \( \lambda = 19 \) and \( \mu = 11 \) satisfy the equations for x and y but give different z-values (58 and 9 respectively). Hence there is no point common to both lines, and the two given lines do not intersect each other.

Answer: The values \( \lambda = 19 \) and \( \mu = 11 \) satisfy the x- and y-equations but yield \( z = 58 \) on Line 1 and \( z = 9 \) on Line 2. Since the z-coordinates differ, no common point exists, and therefore the two given lines do not intersect each other.

Everything you get with Solver7

More questions in Three Dimensional Geometry