In Fig. 6.19, \(DE\parallel AC\) and \( DF\parallel AE\) . Prove that \(\dfrac{BF}{FE}\) \(= \) \(\dfrac{BE}{EC}\)
CBSE Class 10 Maths · Triangles
CBSE Class 10 Maths · Triangles
Imagine you are cutting a ribbon inside a triangle using scissors that always cut perfectly parallel to one side. When you cut parallel to a side, both parts of the triangle always split in the exact same ratio. Here, two such parallel cuts are made inside the triangle. Both cuts share the same ratio from the first piece. Because they share that same ratio, the two results must equal each other. It is like two different roads leading to the same destination — the final comparison of the pieces turns out equal.
Answer: Since BD/DA = BE/EC (from DE \parallel AC) and BD/DA = BF/FE (from DF \parallel AE), we conclude that BF/FE = BE/EC. Hence proved.
This question is based on the Basic Proportionality Theorem (BPT), also known as Thales' Theorem. It says that if a line is drawn parallel to one side of a triangle and it cuts the other two sides, then it divides those two sides in the same ratio.
From the figure, in \(\triangle ABC\), point \( D \) lies on \( AB \) and points \( F, E \) lie on \( BC \). We are given two pieces of information: \( DE \parallel AC \) and \( DF \parallel AE \). The trick is to apply BPT in two different triangles and then combine the results.
Basic Proportionality Theorem: If a line parallel to one side of a triangle intersects the other two sides at distinct points, then
\[\dfrac{\text{one part of side 1}}{\text{other part}} = \dfrac{\text{one part of side 2}}{\text{other part}}\]
Using \( DE \parallel AC \) and \( DF \parallel AE \) with BPT, we get \(\dfrac{BF}{FE} = \dfrac{BE}{EC}\). Hence proved.
Students often apply \( DF \parallel AE \) in the wrong triangle (\(\triangle ABC\) instead of \(\triangle ABE\)). Always choose the triangle whose side is parallel to the drawn line before writing the ratio.
Since \(\dfrac{BD}{DA} = \dfrac{BE}{EC}\) (from \( DE \parallel AC \)) and \(\dfrac{BD}{DA} = \dfrac{BF}{FE}\) (from \( DF \parallel AE \)), we conclude that \(\dfrac{BF}{FE} = \dfrac{BE}{EC}\). Hence proved.
One common mistake: Students apply BPT only once in \(\triangle ABC\) and try to conclude the result directly, forgetting that a second application inside \(\triangle ABE\) is necessary to introduce the segments \( BF \) and \( FE \) into the proof.
In \(\triangle ABC\), \( DE \parallel AC \) \( \Rightarrow \) (BPT): \[\dfrac{BD}{DA} = \dfrac{BE}{EC} \quad \text{...(i)}\] In \(\triangle ABE\), (BPT):[\dfrac{BD}{DA} = \dfrac{BF}{FE} \quad \text{...(ii)}[From (i) and (ii):]\dfrac{BF}{FE} = \dfrac{BE}{EC}]
Answer: Since \(\dfrac{BD}{DA} = \dfrac{BE}{EC}\) (from \( DE \parallel AC \)) and \(\dfrac{BD}{DA} = \dfrac{BF}{FE}\) (from \( DF \parallel AE \)), we conclude that \(\dfrac{BF}{FE} = \dfrac{BE}{EC}\). Hence proved.
Question: In the figure, in △ABC, PQ ∥ BC (where P is on AB and Q is on AC) and PF ∥ BQ (where F is on AQ). Prove that
\[\dfrac{QF}{FR} = \dfrac{BQ}{QC}\]
where R is the point where line CF extended meets AQ (i.e., using the standard configuration: in △ABQ, PF ∥ BQ with F on AQ, and in △ABC, PQ ∥ BC — prove \(\dfrac{AF}{FQ} = \dfrac{AQ}{QC}\), equivalently \(\dfrac{FQ}{AF} = \dfrac{QC}{AQ}\)).
Restated clearly: In △ABC, PQ ∥ BC with P on AB and Q on AC. Also PF ∥ BQ with F on AQ (F between A and Q). Prove that \(\dfrac{AF}{FQ} = \dfrac{AP}{PB}\) and hence \(\dfrac{FQ}{AF} = \dfrac{QC}{AQ}\).
Solution:
Answer: \(\dfrac{AF}{FQ} = \dfrac{AQ}{QC}\) — Proved ✓
Question: In △XYZ, MN ∥ YZ where M is on XY and N is on XZ. Also, MG ∥ YN where G is on XN. Prove that:
\[\dfrac{XG}{GN} = \dfrac{XN}{NZ}\]
Solution:
Verification of Logic: Both ratios equal \(\dfrac{XM}{MY}\), so they must equal each other. This is a direct consequence of applying BPT twice in two different triangles (△XYZ and △XYN) that share the same vertex X and the same transversal point M on XY.
Answer: \(\dfrac{XG}{GN} = \dfrac{XN}{NZ}\) — Proved ✓
Students often apply BPT in the wrong triangle — they forget to identify which triangle contains the parallel line and which sides are being divided. Always clearly label the triangle and the parallel line before applying the theorem. For instance, PF ∥ BQ should be applied inside △ABQ (not △ABC) since both endpoints P and F lie on sides of △ABQ.
Question: In the figure, in △ABC, D is a point on side AB and E is a point on side BC. It is given that DE ∥ BC and DF ∥ EC, where F is a point on BE (between B and E). Prove that: \[\dfrac{BF}{FE} = \dfrac{BD}{DA}\]
We use the Basic Proportionality Theorem (BPT): If a line is drawn parallel to one side of a triangle, it divides the other two sides in the same ratio.
Answer: Using BPT twice — first in △ABC (with DE ∥ AC) giving \(\dfrac{BD}{DA} = \dfrac{BE}{EC}\), and then in △BEC (with DF ∥ EC) giving \(\dfrac{BF}{FE} = \dfrac{BD}{DC}\) — and combining these results, we prove that\[\dfrac{BF}{FE} = \dfrac{BD}{DA}\] Hence proved.
Common Mistake: Applying BPT without clearly identifying which triangle is being used, or incorrectly labelling which segments correspond to which sides of the ratio.