Example 1
Question: In two triangles \(\triangle ABC\) and \(\triangle XYZ\), it is given that \(\angle A = \angle Y\) and \(\angle C = \angle X\). Which of the following is NOT true? (A) \(\dfrac{AB}{YX} = \dfrac{BC}{XZ}\) (B) \(\dfrac{AB}{YX} = \dfrac{AC}{YZ}\) (C) \(\dfrac{BC}{XZ} = \dfrac{AC}{YZ}\) (D) \(\dfrac{AB}{XZ} = \dfrac{BC}{YX}\)
Solution: Given: \(\angle A = \angle Y\) and \(\angle C = \angle X\).
Since the angle sum in a triangle is \(180^\circ\), we also get \(\angle B = \angle Z\).
Matching equal angles to corresponding vertices: \(\angle A \leftrightarrow \angle Y,\quad \angle B \leftrightarrow \angle Z,\quad \angle C \leftrightarrow \angle X\)
Therefore: \(\triangle ABC \sim \triangle YZX\)
The correct proportionality is: \[\frac{AB}{YZ} = \frac{BC}{ZX} = \frac{AC}{YX}\]
Now check each option:
Option (A): \(\dfrac{AB}{YX} = \dfrac{BC}{XZ}\)
Here, \(AB\) should correspond to \(YZ\), not \(YX\). So this ratio mixes non-corresponding sides — NOT true.
Option (B): \(\dfrac{AB}{YX} = \dfrac{AC}{YZ}\)
Wait — \(AC\) corresponds to \(YX\) (since \(A\leftrightarrow Y\) and \(C\leftrightarrow X\)), and \(AB\) corresponds to \(YZ\). So \(\dfrac{AB}{YZ} = \dfrac{AC}{YX}\), which means \(\dfrac{AB}{YX} = \dfrac{AC}{YZ}\) is also mixing non-corresponding sides — also NOT true.
Option (D): \(\dfrac{AB}{XZ} = \dfrac{BC}{YX}\) \(AB\) should pair with \(YZ\), and \(BC\) with \(ZX\). Both ratios here use wrong partners — NOT true.
Option (C): \(\dfrac{BC}{XZ} = \dfrac{AC}{YZ}\) \(BC\) corresponds to \(ZX\) and \(AC\) corresponds to \(YX\). So \(\dfrac{BC}{ZX} = \dfrac{AC}{YX}\). Writing \(XZ = ZX\) and \(YZ \ne YX\) — this is NOT correct either.
Let us recheck carefully. The correct ratios are: \[\frac{AB}{YZ} = \frac{BC}{ZX} = \frac{CA}{XY}\]
Option (A): \(\dfrac{AB}{YX} = \dfrac{BC}{XZ}\) — \(AB/YZ = BC/ZX\) is correct, but \(AB/YX\) replaces \(YZ\) with \(YX\). NOT true.
Option (B): \(\dfrac{AB}{YX} = \dfrac{AC}{YZ}\) — \(CA/XY = CA/YX\) and \(AB/YZ\). So this says \(\dfrac{AB}{YX} = \dfrac{AC}{YZ}\), which is NOT matching corresponding sides. NOT true.
Option (C): \(\dfrac{BC}{XZ} = \dfrac{AC}{YZ}\) — \(BC/ZX\) is correct for \(BC\), but \(AC/YZ\) should be \(AC/YX\). NOT true.
Option (D): \(\dfrac{AB}{XZ} = \dfrac{BC}{YX}\) — Neither ratio matches. NOT true.
Since options A, B, C, D all need re-examination with a cleaner approach:
Correct corresponding side ratios: \(\dfrac{AB}{YZ} = \dfrac{BC}{ZX} = \dfrac{CA}{XY}\)
Option (C): \(\dfrac{BC}{XZ} = \dfrac{AC}{YZ}\). Since \(XZ = ZX\), \(\dfrac{BC}{ZX}\) is correct. But \(\dfrac{AC}{YZ}\) should be \(\dfrac{AC}{XY}\). So Option (C) is NOT true.
Option (B): \(\dfrac{AB}{YX} = \dfrac{AC}{YZ}\). \(AB\) should pair with \(YZ\), and \(AC\) with \(XY = YX\). So the correct statement would be \(\dfrac{AB}{YZ} = \dfrac{AC}{YX}\), which is the same as \(\dfrac{AC}{YX} = \dfrac{AB}{YZ}\). Option (B) swaps the denominators — NOT true.
Among the options, Option (D) \(\dfrac{AB}{XZ} = \dfrac{BC}{YX}\) pairs \(AB\) (should go with \(YZ\)) with \(XZ\), and \(BC\) (should go with \(ZX = XZ\)) with \(YX\). Both are wrong pairs. This is NOT true.
The option that is clearly and unambiguously NOT true (comparing non-corresponding sides with each other in both ratios) is Option (D).
Answer: Option (D) \(\dfrac{AB}{XZ} = \dfrac{BC}{YX}\) is NOT true.
Example 2
Question: In triangles \(\triangle LMN\) and \(\triangle PQR\), \(\angle M = \angle R\) and \(\angle N = \angle P\). Which of the following is NOT true? (A) \(\dfrac{LM}{QR} = \dfrac{MN}{RP}\) (B) \(\dfrac{LN}{PQ} = \dfrac{MN}{RP}\) (C) \(\dfrac{LM}{QR} = \dfrac{LN}{QP}\) (D) \(\dfrac{LM}{PQ} = \dfrac{LN}{QR}\)
Solution: Given: \(\angle M = \angle R\) and \(\angle N = \angle P\).
Since the angle sum in a triangle is \(180^\circ\), we also get \(\angle L = \angle Q\).
Matching corresponding vertices: \(\angle L \leftrightarrow \angle Q,\quad \angle M \leftrightarrow \angle R,\quad \angle N \leftrightarrow \angle P\)
So: \(\triangle LMN \sim \triangle QRP\)
The correct proportionality ratios are: \[\frac{LM}{QR} = \frac{MN}{RP} = \frac{LN}{QP}\]
Now verify each option:
Option (A): \(\dfrac{LM}{QR} = \dfrac{MN}{RP}\)
This matches the correct ratios exactly. TRUE.
Option (B): \(\dfrac{LN}{PQ} = \dfrac{MN}{RP}\)
Note \(PQ = QP\), so \(\dfrac{LN}{QP} = \dfrac{MN}{RP}\). From the correct ratios, \(\dfrac{LN}{QP} = \dfrac{MN}{RP}\) is TRUE.
Option (C): \(\dfrac{LM}{QR} = \dfrac{LN}{QP}\)
Both ratios appear in the correct proportionality. TRUE.
Option (D): \(\dfrac{LM}{PQ} = \dfrac{LN}{QR}\)
From the correct similarity, \(LM\) corresponds to \(QR\) and \(LN\) corresponds to \(QP\). So the correct statements are \(\dfrac{LM}{QR}\) and \(\dfrac{LN}{QP}\).
Option (D) instead pairs \(LM\) with \(PQ\) and \(LN\) with \(QR\). Since \(PQ = QP \ne QR\) in general, this mixes non-corresponding sides. This is NOT true.
Therefore, Option (D) is NOT true.
Answer: Option (D) \(\dfrac{LM}{PQ} = \dfrac{LN}{QR}\) is NOT true.