Example 1
Question: Which of the following statements is INCORRECT? (A) Two congruent triangles are always similar. (B) Two circles are always similar. (C) A rectangle and a square of equal perimeter are always similar. (D) Two similar figures need not be congruent.
Solution: Let us examine each statement one by one.
Statement (A): Two congruent triangles are always similar.
If two triangles are congruent, their corresponding angles are equal and the ratio of corresponding sides is 1, which satisfies the conditions of similarity. So this statement is CORRECT.
Statement (B): Two circles are always similar.
Any circle can be obtained from another by a uniform scaling (enlargement or reduction). All circles have the same shape, so any two circles are always similar. This statement is CORRECT.
Statement (C): A rectangle and a square of equal perimeter are always similar.
Consider a square with side \( a \) and a rectangle with sides \( l \) and \( b \) such that their perimeters are equal.
Perimeter of square: \[ 4a \] Perimeter of rectangle: \[ 2(l + b) \] Setting them equal: \[ 4a = 2(l + b) \implies l + b = 2a \]
For the rectangle to be similar to the square, all sides of the square are equal, so we need the ratio of length to breadth of the rectangle to equal 1, i.e., the rectangle must also be a square. But a rectangle with \( l + b = 2a \) need not have \( l = b \). For example, if \( a = 5 \), then \( l = 7, b = 3 \) satisfies \( l + b = 10 \), but the rectangle \( 7 \times 3 \) is NOT similar to the \( 5 \times 5 \) square because the ratios \( \frac{7}{5} \ne \frac{3}{5} \). So this statement is INCORRECT.
Statement (D): Two similar figures need not be congruent.
Similarity only requires the same shape, not the same size. For example, two equilateral triangles with sides 3 cm and 6 cm are similar but not congruent. This statement is CORRECT.
Therefore, the incorrect statement is (C).
Answer: (C) A rectangle and a square of equal perimeter are always similar.
Example 2
Question: Which of the following statements is INCORRECT? (A) All equilateral triangles are similar to each other. (B) Two isosceles triangles are always similar. (C) Two congruent figures are always similar. (D) Two squares are always similar to each other.
Solution: Let us analyse each statement.
Statement (A): All equilateral triangles are similar to each other.
In every equilateral triangle, each angle equals \( 60^\circ \). Since all corresponding angles are equal, any two equilateral triangles satisfy the AA similarity criterion. This statement is CORRECT.
Statement (B): Two isosceles triangles are always similar.
An isosceles triangle has two equal angles, but the value of those angles can differ from one isosceles triangle to another. For example, one isosceles triangle may have angles \( 40^\circ, 40^\circ, 100^\circ \) and another may have angles \( 70^\circ, 70^\circ, 40^\circ \). Their corresponding angles are NOT equal, so they are NOT similar. This statement is INCORRECT.
Statement (C): Two congruent figures are always similar.
Congruent figures have equal corresponding angles and a side ratio of 1, so they satisfy all conditions for similarity. This statement is CORRECT.
Statement (D): Two squares are always similar to each other.
In any square, all angles are \( 90^\circ \) and all sides are equal. For any two squares with sides \( s_1 \) and \( s_2 \), the ratio of corresponding sides is \( \frac{s_1}{s_2} \), which is constant for all sides. So any two squares are always similar. This statement is CORRECT.
The incorrect statement is (B).
Answer: (B) Two isosceles triangles are always similar.