In the given figure, from which point can the tangent not be drawn to the circle with radius r ? (A)X (B) P (C) Q (D) Y
CBSE Class 10 Maths · Circles
CBSE Class 10 Maths · Circles
Imagine drawing a straight line that just barely touches a circle, like a ruler resting against a ball. You can only do that from outside the circle. Point Y sits inside the smaller circle of radius \( r \). It is like being trapped inside the ball. Any line you draw from inside will always cross the circle at two places, never just touch it gently. So no tangent is possible from point Y to that circle.
Answer: Option (D) Y — a tangent to the circle of radius \(r\) cannot be drawn from point Y since Y lies inside that circle.
A tangent to a circle is a straight line that touches the circle at exactly one point. Whether a tangent can be drawn to a circle from a given point depends on the location of that point relative to the circle. There are three possible cases: (1) If the point lies outside the circle, exactly two tangents can be drawn from it. (2) If the point lies on the circle, exactly one tangent can be drawn at that point. (3) If the point lies inside the circle, no tangent can be drawn to the circle from that point, because any line through an interior point will cut the circle at two points (it becomes a secant, not a tangent). In the figure, we have two concentric circles — an inner circle of radius \(r\) and an outer circle of radius \(R\). We must check the position of each point (X, P, Q, Y) with respect to the inner circle of radius \(r\).
For a point at distance \(d\) from the centre of a circle of radius \(r\): if \(d > r\), two tangents exist; if \(d = r\), one tangent exists; if \(d < r\), no tangent exists.
Option (D) Y — a tangent to the circle of radius \(r\) cannot be drawn from point Y since Y lies inside that circle.
A common mistake is to think that tangents can be drawn from any point, including points inside the circle. Remember: from a point inside a circle, no tangent to that circle is possible, because every line through an interior point cuts the circle at two points (it is a secant).
Option (D) Y — a tangent to the circle of radius \(r\) cannot be drawn from point Y since Y lies inside that circle.
One common mistake: Students sometimes confuse the two circles and check the position of points relative to the outer circle of radius \(R\) instead of the inner circle of radius \(r\), leading them to incorrectly conclude that tangents can or cannot be drawn from every point.
Answer: Option (D) Y — a tangent to the circle of radius \(r\) cannot be drawn from point Y since Y lies inside that circle.
Question: A circle has its centre at \( O(2, 3) \) and radius \( r = 5 \) units. Four points are given: \( A(2, 10) \), \( B(6, 6) \), \( C(2, 3) \) (the centre itself), and \( D(-2, 0) \). From which of these points can a tangent NOT be drawn to the circle? Justify your answer by calculating the distance of each point from the centre.
Solution: We calculate the distance of each point from the centre \( O(2, 3) \) and compare with \( r = 5 \).
For point \( A(2, 10) \): \[ d_A = \sqrt{(2-2)^2 + (10-3)^2} = \sqrt{0 + 49} = 7 \]
Since \( 7 > 5 \), point \( A \) is OUTSIDE the circle. Tangents can be drawn from \( A \).
For point \( B(6, 6) \): \[ d_B = \sqrt{(6-2)^2 + (6-3)^2} = \sqrt{16 + 9} = \sqrt{25} = 5 \]
Since \( d_B = r = 5 \), point \( B \) lies ON the circle. A tangent at \( B \) touches the circle there, but no external tangent from \( B \) to the circle exists in the usual (two-tangent) sense.
For point \( C(2, 3) \): \[ d_C = \sqrt{(2-2)^2 + (3-3)^2} = \sqrt{0} = 0 \]
Since \( 0 < 5 \), point \( C \) is the centre itself, lying INSIDE the circle. No tangent can be drawn from \( C \).
For point \( D(-2, 0) \): \[ d_D = \sqrt{(-2-2)^2 + (0-3)^2} = \sqrt{16 + 9} = \sqrt{25} = 5 \]
Since \( d_D = r = 5 \), point \( D \) also lies ON the circle.
Among the four points, point \( C \) lies strictly inside the circle (distance from centre \( = 0 < 5 \)), so a tangent to the circle CANNOT be drawn from point \( C \).
Answer: Point \( C(2,3) \) — it lies inside the circle, so no tangent can be drawn from it.
Question: Consider a circle centred at \( O(0, 0) \) with radius \( r = 6 \) units. Four points are given: \( P(8, 0) \), \( Q(0, 6) \), \( R(3, 4) \), and \( S(-1, 2) \). Identify the point from which a tangent to the circle CANNOT be drawn.
Solution: We calculate the distance of each point from the centre \( O(0, 0) \) and compare with \( r = 6 \).
For point \( P(8, 0) \): \[ d_P = \sqrt{8^2 + 0^2} = \sqrt{64} = 8 \]
Since \( 8 > 6 \), point \( P \) is OUTSIDE the circle. Two tangents can be drawn from \( P \).
For point \( Q(0, 6) \): \[ d_Q = \sqrt{0^2 + 6^2} = \sqrt{36} = 6 \]
Since \( d_Q = r = 6 \), point \( Q \) lies ON the circle. The tangent at \( Q \) is the line touching the circle exactly at \( Q \).
For point \( R(3, 4) \): \[ d_R = \sqrt{3^2 + 4^2} = \sqrt{9 + 16} = \sqrt{25} = 5 \]
Since \( 5 < 6 \), point \( R \) lies INSIDE the circle. No tangent can be drawn from \( R \).
For point \( S(-1, 2) \): \[ d_S = \sqrt{(-1)^2 + 2^2} = \sqrt{1 + 4} = \sqrt{5} \ \approx 2.24 \]
Since \( \sqrt{5} < 6 \), point \( S \) also lies INSIDE the circle. No tangent can be drawn from \( S \) either.
Between \( R \) and \( S \), both lie inside, but if the question asks which single point (among all four) most clearly represents a point from which a tangent cannot be drawn, the answer is \( R(3, 4) \) (and also \( S \)), since their distances from the centre are less than the radius. In a typical multiple-choice setting with one correct answer, \( R(3, 4) \) is the intended answer because \( d_R = 5 < 6 = r \).
Answer: Point \( R(3, 4) \) — it lies inside the circle (\( d = 5 < r = 6 \)), so no tangent to the circle can be drawn from it.
Question: A circle has centre O and radius 5 cm. Four points A, B, C, and D are given such that OA = 8 cm, OB = 5 cm, OC = 3 cm, and OD = 6 cm. From which of the following points can a tangent NOT be drawn to the circle? (A) A (B) B (C) C (D) D
Answer: Option (C) C — a tangent cannot be drawn from point C because OC = 3 cm is less than the radius 5 cm, meaning C lies inside the circle.