SOLVER7 Study. Nothing Else.
Chapter 3 Examples Q2(b)

Try adding the following numbers without converting them to Hindu numerals: \(LXXXVII + LXXVIII\)

CBSE Class 8 Maths · A Story of Numbers

Solution

👶 Simple Explanation

Simple Explanation

Roman numerals are like a secret number code using letters. The letter I means 1, V means 5, X means 10, L means 50, and C means 100. Adding two Roman numbers is like mixing two bags of letter-tokens together. Once you mix them, you trade small tokens for bigger ones — like trading ten pennies for a ten-rupee coin. Keep trading until no more trades are possible, and the letters left over spell your answer!

Answer: \( LXXXVII + LXXVIII = CLXV \) (which equals 165).

📖 Adding Roman Numerals Directly: LXXXVII + LXXVIII

Detailed Explanation

Roman numerals use letters to stand for values: I = 1, V = 5, X = 10, L = 50, C = 100. To add two Roman numerals directly, we write down all the symbols of both numbers together, then group and simplify them using the rules that ten I's make one X, two V's make one X, ten X's make one C, and two L's make one C. We rearrange from the largest symbol to the smallest, and keep bundling small symbols into bigger ones until the result follows standard Roman numeral form.

Formula Used

Grouping rules used: \( V + V = X \), \( X + X + X + X + X = L \) with \( L + L = C \), and ten \( I \)'s combine as \( I + I + I + I + I = V \).

Solution

  1. Step 1: Write out both numerals fully. \( LXXXVII = L + X + X + X + V + I + I \) and \( LXXVIII = L + X + X + V + I + I + I \).
  2. Step 2: Collect all symbols of the same type together. The L's: \( L + L \). The X's: \( X + X + X + X + X \) (three from the first number and two from the second, so five X's). The V's: \( V + V \). The I's: \( I + I + I + I + I \) (two from the first and three from the second, so five I's).
  3. Step 3: Simplify the I's first. Five I's make one V: \( I + I + I + I + I = V \). We now have this new V plus the two original V's, giving three V's in total.
  4. Step 4: Simplify the V's. Two V's make one X: \( V + V = X \). From three V's, one pair becomes an X and one V is left over. So we get an extra X and a single V remaining.
  5. Step 5: Add the new X to the X group. We had five X's, and now we add one more, giving six X's. Ten X's make an L, but six is not enough, so we bundle five of them into an L: \( X + X + X + X + X = L \). That leaves one X remaining, plus this new L.
  6. Step 6: Simplify the L's. We had two original L's, and now a third L from the X's, giving three L's. Two L's make a C: \( L + L = C \). So one C is formed and one L is left over.
  7. Step 7: Write the leftovers in order from largest to smallest: one C, one L, one X, one V. Putting them together gives \( C + L + X + V = CLXV \).
  8. Step 8: Check with ordinary numbers: \( 87 + 78 = 165 \), and \( CLXV = 100 + 50 + 10 + 5 = 165 \). The direct Roman addition matches.

Final Answer

\( LXXXVII + LXXVIII = CLXV \) (which equals 165).

Common Mistake

A common mistake is forgetting to convert a full bundle into the next symbol, for example leaving five X's as they are instead of turning them into an L, or leaving two V's instead of making an X. Always keep simplifying until no small symbol appears the maximum number of times.

🪜 Step-by-step Solution

Step-by-step Solution

  1. Step 1: Expand each Roman numeral into its individual symbol components. \( LXXXVII = L + X + X + X + V + I + I \) and \( LXXVIII = L + X + X + V + I + I + I \) — Reason: Breaking both numbers into separate symbols makes it easy to count how many of each letter we have in total.
  2. Step 2: Gather symbols of the same type from both numbers. L's: \( L + L \) (one from each number, giving 2 L's). X's: \( X + X + X + X + X \) (three from the first, two from the second, giving 5 X's). V's: \( V + V \) (one from each number, giving 2 V's). I's: \( I + I + I + I + I \) (two from the first, three from the second, giving 5 I's) — Reason: Sorting by symbol type sets us up to apply the exchange rules one group at a time.
  3. Step 3: Simplify the I group first. Five I's exchange for one V: \( I + I + I + I + I = V \). Add this new V to the 2 existing V's to get 3 V's in total — Reason: We always simplify the smallest symbols first so that any new symbols created can be folded into the next group up.
  4. Step 4: Simplify the V group. From the 3 V's, one pair exchanges for one X: \( V + V = X \). One V remains. So the V group is now 1 V, and we carry 1 new X forward — Reason: Two V's always equal one X; the leftover single V stays as is because it cannot be exchanged further on its own.
  5. Step 5: Add the new X to the existing X group. We had 5 X's; adding the carried X gives 6 X's total. From these, one group of five X's exchanges for one L: \( X + X + X + X + X = L \). One X remains. So the X group is now 1 X, and we carry 1 new L forward — Reason: Five X's always equal one L; the single leftover X is kept as it cannot be bundled further alone.
  6. Step 6: Add the new L to the existing L group. We had 2 L's; adding the carried L gives 3 L's. From these, one pair of L's exchanges for one C: \( L + L = C \). One L remains. So the L group is now 1 L, and we carry 1 new C forward — Reason: Two L's always equal one C; the single leftover L stays.
  7. Step 7: Assemble the final result by writing all remaining symbols from largest to smallest: C, L, X, V. Combining: \( C + L + X + V = CLXV \), which equals \( 100 + 50 + 10 + 5 = 165 \) — Reason: Standard Roman numeral form always lists symbols from the greatest value to the least, with no further simplification possible here.

Final Answer

\( LXXXVII + LXXVIII = CLXV \) (which equals 165).

Common Mistake

One common mistake: students forget to carry the new symbol created during an exchange back into the correct group — for example, after turning five I's into a V, they forget to add that new V to the existing V count, causing them to undercount and reach a wrong answer.

✍️ Exam-ready Answer

Exam-ready Answer

  1. Step 1: Expand: \( LXXXVII = L + X + X + X + V + I + I \) and \( LXXVIII = L + X + X + V + I + I + I \)
  2. Step 2: Group by symbol: \( L+L \), \( X+X+X+X+X \), \( V+V \), \( I+I+I+I+I \)
  3. Step 3: Simplify: \( I+I+I+I+I = V \), so V-count becomes 3; \( V+V = X \) leaves 1 V and adds 1 X, giving 6 X's; \( X+X+X+X+X+X = LX \); \( L+L = C \)
  4. Step 4: Combine: \( C + LX + V = CLXV \)

Answer: \( LXXXVII + LXXVIII = CLXV \) (which equals 165).

➕ More Examples

More Examples

Example 1

Question: Add the following Roman numerals WITHOUT converting them to Hindu-Arabic numerals first: XCIV + LXVIII

Solution: First, write out each Roman numeral by expanding any subtractive notation. XCIV means: XC (which is 100 - 10, written as a subtractive pair) and IV (which is 5 - 1, written as a subtractive pair). To add directly, it is easiest to convert the subtractive pairs to additive form: XC = LXXXX (i.e., 50 + 10 + 10 + 10 + 10) IV = IIII (i.e., 1 + 1 + 1 + 1) So XCIV in expanded additive form = LXXXXIIII LXVIII in expanded additive form = LXVIII (already fully additive) Now list all the symbols together: L, X, X, X, X, I, I, I, I (from XCIV) and L, X, V, I, I, I (from LXVIII) Group by symbol: L: LL X: XXXXX (five Xs) V: V I: IIIIIII (seven Is) Now simplify step by step: Step 1 — Simplify Is: IIIIIII = IIIII + II = V + II = VII So I-group becomes VII. Step 2 — Combine V-groups: V (original) + V (from step 1) = VV, and VII has a V with II left over. Total Vs: V + V = VV = X, with II remaining. So V-group and I-group together give X and II, i.e., XII. Step 3 — Simplify Xs: XXXXX (five Xs) + X (from step 2) = XXXXXX (six Xs). XXXXX = L, so XXXXXX = LX. Step 4 — Simplify Ls: LL (original two Ls) + L (from step 3) = LLL = LC? No — LLL = C + L? Let us count: LL = C, so LLL = C + L. Wait, let us recount. Original Ls: L + L = LL = C. The extra L from step 3 makes it C + L = CL. Step 5 — Combine remaining: CL + X + II = CLXII. Therefore, XCIV + LXVIII = CLXII. Verification (for the teacher): XCIV = 94, LXVIII = 68, sum = 162 = CLXII. Confirmed.

Answer: CLXII

Example 2

Question: Add the following Roman numerals WITHOUT converting them to Hindu-Arabic numerals first: CXLV + DCLIX

Solution: First, expand any subtractive notation into additive form. CXLV: XL = XXXX (40), so CXLV = CXXXXV DCLIX: IX = VIIII (9), so DCLIX = DCLVIIII Now list all symbols together: From CXLV expanded: C, X, X, X, X, V From DCLIX expanded: D, C, L, V, I, I, I, I Group by symbol: D: D (one D) C: CC (two Cs) L: L (one L) X: XXXX (four Xs) V: VV (two Vs) I: IIII (four Is) Simplify step by step: Step 1 — Simplify Is: IIII = IV in subtractive form, but for combining we note IIIII = V. We only have IIII, so they remain as IIII for now. Step 2 — Simplify Vs: VV = X. So the two Vs become X. Step 3 — Combine Xs: XXXX (original) + X (from step 2) = XXXXX = L. Step 4 — Combine Ls: L (original) + L (from step 3) = LL = C. Step 5 — Combine Cs: CC (original) + C (from step 4) = CCC. Step 6 — Combine Ds: We have D and CCC. DDD = M? No — we only have one D. So the result so far from higher symbols is D + CCC = DCCC. Step 7 — Add remaining Is: IIII. In standard Roman numerals, IIII is written as IV. Combining everything: DCCC + IV = DCCCIV. Verification (for the teacher): CXLV = 145, DCLIX = 659, sum = 804 = DCCCIV. Confirmed.

Answer: DCCCIV

🎯 Try a Similar Question

Try a Similar Question

Question: Add the following numbers without converting them to Hindu-Arabic numerals first: XCIV + CXIX

Solution

  1. Step 1: Write out the value of each symbol in both numbers: XCIV means: X before C (subtractive, so 90) + I before V (subtractive, so 4). So XCIV = 90 + 4. \nCXIX means: C (100) + X before I... wait — let us re-read: C + X + I + X. Actually, reading left to right: C (100), X (10), I before X is subtractive (9). So CXIX = 100 + 10 + 9 = 119. \nLet us confirm: XCIV = 94 and CXIX = 119.
  2. Step 2: Break each numeral into its additive parts: XCIV: XC (which is 90) + IV (which is 4). \nCXIX: C (which is 100) + X (which is 10) + IX (which is 9).
  3. Step 3: Group all parts together: Collect all the parts: \nC + XC + X + IX + IV \nIn values this gives us: 100 + 90 + 10 + 9 + 4.
  4. Step 4: Combine the tens: Look at the tens group: XC + X = 90 + 10 = 100, which is written as C. \nSo now we have: C + C + IX + IV.
  5. Step 5: Combine the hundreds: C + C = 200, written as CC. \nSo we have: CC + IX + IV.
  6. Step 6: Combine the units: IX + IV = 9 + 4 = 13. 13 in Roman numerals: 10 + 3 = X + III = XIII. \nSo we have: CC + XIII.
  7. Step 7: Write the final Roman numeral: CC + XIII = CCXIII. \nVerification: \( 94 + 119 = 213 \), and CCXIII = 200 + 10 + 3 = 213. Correct!

Answer: XCIV + CXIX = CCXIII (which equals 213).

Everything you get with Solver7

More questions in A Story of Numbers