SOLVER7 Study. Nothing Else.
2023 Board Paper Q32

A relation R is defined on a set of real numbers \(\mathbb{R}\) as
\(R=\{(x, y) : x . y\) is an irrational number \(\}.\)
Check whether R is reflexive, symmetric and transitive or not.

CBSE Class 12 Maths · Relations and Functions

Solution

👶 Simple Explanation

Simple Explanation

Imagine a rule that says two numbers are 'friends' if multiplying them gives a weird, never-ending decimal (an irrational number). Now, can a number be friends with itself? Take 2: multiply it by itself and you get 4, a perfectly normal number — so no, not every number is its own friend. Can friendship go both ways? Yes, because \( x \times y \) and \( y \times x \) always give the same result. Can friendship spread? No — \( \sqrt{2} \) and \( \sqrt{3} \) are friends, and \( \sqrt{3} \) and \( \sqrt{2} \) are friends, but \( \sqrt{2} \times \sqrt{2} = 2 \), which is normal, so they break the chain.

Answer: The relation \( R \) is NOT reflexive (since \( 2 \cdot 2 = 4 \) is rational), IS symmetric (since \( x \cdot y = y \cdot x \)), and is NOT transitive (using \( \sqrt{2}, \sqrt{3}, \sqrt{2} \), the products \( \sqrt{6} \) are irrational but \( \sqrt{2} \cdot \sqrt{2} = 2 \) is rational).

📖 Checking Reflexive, Symmetric, Transitive for R (product is irrational)

Detailed Explanation

A relation \( R \) on a set is just a collection of ordered pairs \( (x, y) \). Here \( (x, y) \in R \) means the product \( x \cdot y \) is an irrational number. To decide the three properties, recall their definitions. Reflexive: every element relates to itself, i.e. \( (x, x) \in R \) for all \( x \). Symmetric: whenever \( (x, y) \in R \), we must also have \( (y, x) \in R \). Transitive: whenever \( (x, y) \in R \) and \( (y, z) \in R \), we must have \( (x, z) \in R \). A useful fact: the product of two rationals is rational, and the product of a nonzero rational with an irrational is irrational, but the product of two irrationals can be either rational or irrational. To disprove a property, only ONE counterexample is needed.

Formula Used

Reflexive: \( (x, x) \in R \ \forall x \). Symmetric: \( (x, y) \in R \Rightarrow (y, x) \in R \). Transitive: \( (x, y) \in R \text{ and } (y, z) \in R \Rightarrow (x, z) \in R \).

Solution

  1. Step 1: Check reflexivity. We must test whether \( (x, x) \in R \), i.e. whether \( x \cdot x = x^2 \) is irrational for every real \( x \). Take \( x = 2 \). Then \( x \cdot x = 2 \cdot 2 = 4 \), which is rational. So \( (2, 2) \notin R \). Since even one element fails, \( R \) is NOT reflexive.
  2. Step 2: Check symmetry. Suppose \( (x, y) \in R \), which means \( x \cdot y \) is irrational. Since multiplication of real numbers is commutative, \( y \cdot x = x \cdot y \), so \( y \cdot x \) is also irrational. Therefore \( (y, x) \in R \). This holds for every such pair, so \( R \) IS symmetric.
  3. Step 3: Check transitivity. We look for a counterexample using pairs whose products are irrational, but where the product of the outer elements is rational. Choose \( x = \sqrt{2} \), \( y = \sqrt{3} \), \( z = \sqrt{2} \).
  4. Step 4: Verify the two given pairs are in \( R \). First, \( x \cdot y = \sqrt{2} \cdot \sqrt{3} = \sqrt{6} \), which is irrational, so \( (x, y) \in R \). Second, \( y \cdot z = \sqrt{3} \cdot \sqrt{2} = \sqrt{6} \), which is irrational, so \( (y, z) \in R \).
  5. Step 5: Now test the required pair \( (x, z) \). Here \( x \cdot z = \sqrt{2} \cdot \sqrt{2} = 2 \), which is rational. So \( (x, z) \notin R \). We have \( (x, y) \in R \) and \( (y, z) \in R \) but \( (x, z) \notin R \). Hence \( R \) is NOT transitive.

Final Answer

The relation \( R \) is NOT reflexive (since \( 2 \cdot 2 = 4 \) is rational), IS symmetric (since \( x \cdot y = y \cdot x \)), and is NOT transitive (using \( \sqrt{2}, \sqrt{3}, \sqrt{2} \), the products \( \sqrt{6} \) are irrational but \( \sqrt{2} \cdot \sqrt{2} = 2 \) is rational).

Common Mistake

A common mistake is assuming the product of two irrational numbers is always irrational and concluding \( R \) is transitive. In fact \( \sqrt{2} \cdot \sqrt{2} = 2 \) is rational, which is exactly why transitivity fails.

🪜 Step-by-step Solution

Step-by-step Solution

  1. Step 1: Understand the relation: The relation is defined on \( \mathbb{R} \) as: \( (x, y) \in R \) if and only if \( x \cdot y \) is irrational. — Reason: Before testing any property, you must clearly know what it means for two numbers to be related; here, their product must be irrational.
  2. Step 2: Test Reflexivity: For R to be reflexive, every element must relate to itself, meaning \( x \cdot x \) must be irrational for every real \( x \). Choose the counterexample \( x = 2 \). Then \( x \cdot x = 2 \cdot 2 = 4 \), which is rational, so \( (2, 2) \notin R \). — Reason: One failed case is sufficient to conclude that R is NOT reflexive.
  3. Step 3: Conclude on Reflexivity: Since \( (2, 2) \notin R \), the relation R fails the reflexivity condition. — Reason: Reflexivity requires ALL elements to satisfy the condition; even one exception breaks it.
  4. Step 4: Test Symmetry: Suppose \( (x, y) \in R \), meaning \( x \cdot y \) is irrational. We must check whether \( (y, x) \in R \), i.e., whether \( y \cdot x \) is also irrational. Since multiplication of real numbers is commutative, \( y \cdot x = x \cdot y \), which is irrational by assumption. Therefore \( (y, x) \in R \). — Reason: Commutativity of multiplication means the product is unchanged when the order is swapped, so symmetry holds in all cases.
  5. Step 5: Conclude on Symmetry: Since \( y \cdot x = x \cdot y \) always holds for real numbers, the relation R IS symmetric. — Reason: This works universally for all real \( x \) and \( y \), so no counterexample can exist.
  6. Step 6: Test Transitivity: For transitivity, we need: whenever \( (x, y) \in R \) and \( (y, z) \in R \), it must follow that \( (x, z) \in R \). Choose \( x = \sqrt{2} \), \( y = \sqrt{3} \), \( z = \sqrt{2} \). Check: \( x \cdot y = \sqrt{2} \cdot \sqrt{3} = \sqrt{6} \), which is irrational, so \( (\sqrt{2}, \sqrt{3}) \in R \). Also \( y \cdot z = \sqrt{3} \cdot \sqrt{2} = \sqrt{6} \), which is irrational, so \( (\sqrt{3}, \sqrt{2}) \in R \). — Reason: Both conditions for transitivity are satisfied for this triple, so we can now check the conclusion.
  7. Step 7: Conclude on Transitivity: Now check \( x \cdot z = \sqrt{2} \cdot \sqrt{2} = 2 \), which is rational. So \( (\sqrt{2}, \sqrt{2}) \notin R \), even though both \( (\sqrt{2}, \sqrt{3}) \in R \) and \( (\sqrt{3}, \sqrt{2}) \in R \). — Reason: This single counterexample shows the transitive condition breaks down, so R is NOT transitive.

Final Answer

The relation \( R \) is NOT reflexive (since \( 2 \cdot 2 = 4 \) is rational), IS symmetric (since \( x \cdot y = y \cdot x \)), and is NOT transitive (using \( \sqrt{2}, \sqrt{3}, \sqrt{2} \), the products \( \sqrt{6} \) are irrational but \( \sqrt{2} \cdot \sqrt{2} = 2 \) is rational).

Common Mistake

One common mistake: students often assume that because two irrational numbers have an irrational product in one case, this will always be true — but the product of two irrationals can be rational (for example, \( \sqrt{2} \cdot \sqrt{2} = 2 \)), which is exactly why transitivity fails here.

✍️ Exam-ready Answer

Exam-ready Answer

  1. Reflexivity: Take \( x = 2 \): \( 2 \cdot 2 = 4 \), which is rational, so \( (2, 2) \notin R \). Hence R is NOT reflexive.
  2. Symmetry: \( (x, y) \in R \Rightarrow x \cdot y \) is irrational \( \Rightarrow y \cdot x \) is irrational (commutativity) \( \Rightarrow (y, x) \in R \). Hence R IS symmetric.
  3. Transitivity: Take \( x = \sqrt{2},\, y = \sqrt{3},\, z = \sqrt{2} \): \( \sqrt{2} \cdot \sqrt{3} = \sqrt{6} \) (irrational), \( \sqrt{3} \cdot \sqrt{2} = \sqrt{6} \) (irrational), but \( \sqrt{2} \cdot \sqrt{2} = 2 \) (rational), so \( (x, z) \notin R \). Hence R is NOT transitive.

Answer: The relation \( R \) is NOT reflexive (since \( 2 \cdot 2 = 4 \) is rational), IS symmetric (since \( x \cdot y = y \cdot x \)), and is NOT transitive (using \( \sqrt{2}, \sqrt{3}, \sqrt{2} \), the products \( \sqrt{6} \) are irrational but \( \sqrt{2} \cdot \sqrt{2} = 2 \) is rational).

➕ More Examples

More Examples

Example 1

Question: A relation R is defined on the set of real numbers \( \mathbb{R} \) as \[ R = \{(x, y) : x + y \text{ is an irrational number}\}. \] Check whether R is reflexive, symmetric, and transitive.

Solution: We examine each property in turn. Reflexivity: We need \( (x, x) \in R \) for every \( x \in \mathbb{R} \), i.e., \( x + x = 2x \) must be irrational for all real \( x \). However, if \( x = 1 \) (a rational number), then \( x + x = 2 \), which is rational, so \( (1, 1) \notin R \). Hence R is NOT reflexive. Symmetry: Suppose \( (x, y) \in R \), meaning \( x + y \) is irrational. Since addition is commutative, \( y + x = x + y \) is also irrational, so \( (y, x) \in R \). Hence R IS symmetric. Transitivity: We look for a counterexample. Let \( x = \sqrt{2} \), \( y = 1 - \sqrt{2} \), and \( z = \sqrt{2} \). Check \( (x, y) \in R \): \[ x + y = \sqrt{2} + (1 - \sqrt{2}) = 1, \] which is rational, so \( (x,y) \notin R \). That example does not work; let us choose more carefully. Let \( x = \sqrt{2} \), \( y = 1 \), \( z = \sqrt{2} \). Check \( (x, y) \): \[ x + y = \sqrt{2} + 1, \] which is irrational, so \( (x, y) \in R \). Check \( (y, z) \): \[ y + z = 1 + \sqrt{2}, \] which is irrational, so \( (y, z) \in R \). Check \( (x, z) \): \[ x + z = \sqrt{2} + \sqrt{2} = 2\sqrt{2}, \] which is irrational, so \( (x, z) \in R \). This does not give a counterexample. Now let \( x = \sqrt{2} \), \( y = 2 - \sqrt{2} \), \( z = \sqrt{3} \). Check \( (x, y) \): \[ x + y = \sqrt{2} + 2 - \sqrt{2} = 2, \] which is rational, so \( (x, y) \notin R \). Still not suitable. Let \( x = \sqrt{2} \), \( y = 1 \), \( z = -\sqrt{2} + 2 \). Check \( (x, y) \): \[ \sqrt{2} + 1 \text{ is irrational} \Rightarrow (x, y) \in R. \] Check \( (y, z) \): \[ 1 + (-\sqrt{2} + 2) = 3 - \sqrt{2} \text{ is irrational} \Rightarrow (y, z) \in R. \] Check \( (x, z) \): \[ \sqrt{2} + (2 - \sqrt{2}) = 2, \] which is rational, so \( (x, z) \notin R \). This is a valid counterexample. With \( x = \sqrt{2} \), \( y = 1 \), \( z = 2 - \sqrt{2} \) we have \( (x, y) \in R \) and \( (y, z) \in R \) but \( (x, z) \notin R \). Hence R is NOT transitive.

Answer: R is NOT reflexive, IS symmetric, and is NOT transitive.

Example 2

Question: A relation R is defined on the set of real numbers \( \mathbb{R} \) as \[ R = \{(x, y) : |x - y| \text{ is an irrational number}\}. \] Check whether R is reflexive, symmetric, and transitive.

Solution: We examine each property in turn. Reflexivity: We need \( (x, x) \in R \) for every \( x \in \mathbb{R} \), i.e., \( |x - x| = 0 \) must be irrational. But \( 0 \) is a rational number, so \( (x, x) \notin R \) for any \( x \in \mathbb{R} \). Hence R is NOT reflexive. Symmetry: Suppose \( (x, y) \in R \), meaning \( |x - y| \) is irrational. Since \( |y - x| = |x - y| \), the value \( |y - x| \) is also irrational, so \( (y, x) \in R \). Hence R IS symmetric. Transitivity: We look for a counterexample. Consider \( x = 0 \), \( y = \sqrt{2} \), \( z = 2\sqrt{2} \). Check \( (x, y) \in R \): \[ |x - y| = |0 - \sqrt{2}| = \sqrt{2}, \] which is irrational, so \( (x, y) \in R \). Check \( (y, z) \in R \): \[ |y - z| = |\sqrt{2} - 2\sqrt{2}| = |-\sqrt{2}| = \sqrt{2}, \] which is irrational, so \( (y, z) \in R \). Check \( (x, z) \in R \): \[ |x - z| = |0 - 2\sqrt{2}| = 2\sqrt{2}, \] which is irrational, so \( (x, z) \in R \). This is not a counterexample. Now try \( x = 0 \), \( y = \sqrt{2} \), \( z = 2 - \sqrt{2} \). Check \( (x, y) \): \[ |0 - \sqrt{2}| = \sqrt{2}, \] irrational, so \( (x, y) \in R \). Check \( (y, z) \): \[ |\sqrt{2} - (2 - \sqrt{2})| = |2\sqrt{2} - 2| = 2(\sqrt{2} - 1), \] and since \( \sqrt{2} - 1 \) is irrational, \( 2(\sqrt{2}-1) \) is also irrational, so \( (y, z) \in R \). Check \( (x, z) \): \[ |0 - (2 - \sqrt{2})| = |\sqrt{2} - 2| = 2 - \sqrt{2}, \] which is irrational, so \( (x, z) \in R \). Still not a counterexample. Now try \( x = 1 + \sqrt{2} \), \( y = 1 \), \( z = 1 + \sqrt{2} \). Wait, that would make \( (x,z) \) have \( |x-z|=0 \) which is rational; but we need \( (y,z) \in R \) first: \( |1 - (1+\sqrt{2})| = \sqrt{2} \), irrational; and \( (x,y) \in R \): \( |(1+\sqrt{2})-1| = \sqrt{2} \), irrational. Now \( (x,z) \): \[ |(1+\sqrt{2}) - (1+\sqrt{2})| = 0, \] which is rational, so \( (x,z) \notin R \). This is a valid counterexample: with \( x = 1 + \sqrt{2} \), \( y = 1 \), \( z = 1 + \sqrt{2} \) we have \( (x, y) \in R \) and \( (y, z) \in R \) but \( (x, z) \notin R \) (since \( |x - z| = 0 \) is rational). Hence R is NOT transitive.

Answer: R is NOT reflexive, IS symmetric, and is NOT transitive.

🎯 Try a Similar Question

Try a Similar Question

Question: A relation R is defined on the set of real numbers \( \mathbb{R} \) as \[ R = \{(x, y) : x + y \text{ is an irrational number}\}. \] Check whether R is reflexive, symmetric, and transitive.

Solution

  1. Step 1: Check Reflexivity: R is reflexive if \( (x, x) \in R \) for every \( x \in \mathbb{R} \), i.e., if \( x + x = 2x \) is always irrational. Take \( x = 3 \in \mathbb{R} \). Then \( x + x = 3 + 3 = 6 \), which is rational. So \( (3, 3) \notin R \). Therefore, R is NOT reflexive.
  2. Step 2: Check Symmetry: R is symmetric if \( (x, y) \in R \Rightarrow (y, x) \in R \). Suppose \( (x, y) \in R \), meaning \( x + y \) is irrational. Since addition of real numbers is commutative, \( y + x = x + y \), which is also irrational. Hence \( (y, x) \in R \). Therefore, R IS symmetric.
  3. Step 3: Check Transitivity: R is transitive if \( (x, y) \in R \) and \( (y, z) \in R \) together imply \( (x, z) \in R \). We look for a counterexample. Let \( x = \sqrt{2} \), \( y = 1 - \sqrt{2} \), and \( z = \sqrt{2} \). Then \( x + y = \sqrt{2} + (1 - \sqrt{2}) = 1 \), which is rational, so \( (x, y) \notin R \). We need a better counterexample. Let \( x = \sqrt{2} \), \( y = 1 \), \( z = \sqrt{2} \). Then \( x + y = \sqrt{2} + 1 \), which is irrational, so \( (x, y) \in R \). Also \( y + z = 1 + \sqrt{2} \), which is irrational, so \( (y, z) \in R \). But \( x + z = \sqrt{2} + \sqrt{2} = 2\sqrt{2} \), which is irrational, so this example does not give a contradiction. Now try \( x = \sqrt{3} \), \( y = 1 \), \( z = -\sqrt{3} \). Then \( x + y = \sqrt{3} + 1 \) is irrational, so \( (x, y) \in R \). Also \( y + z = 1 + (-\sqrt{3}) = 1 - \sqrt{3} \) is irrational, so \( (y, z) \in R \). But \( x + z = \sqrt{3} + (-\sqrt{3}) = 0 \), which is rational, so \( (x, z) \notin R \). This is a valid counterexample. Therefore, R is NOT transitive.
  4. Step 4: Conclusion: The relation R defined by \( x + y \) being irrational is NOT reflexive (since \( 3 + 3 = 6 \) is rational), IS symmetric (since \( x + y = y + x \)), and is NOT transitive (since taking \( x = \sqrt{3} \), \( y = 1 \), \( z = -\sqrt{3} \) shows \( (x,y) \in R \) and \( (y,z) \in R \) but \( (x,z) \notin R \) as \( \sqrt{3} + (-\sqrt{3}) = 0 \) is rational).

Answer: The relation R defined by \( x + y \) being irrational is NOT reflexive (counterexample: \( (3,3) \notin R \) since \( 3+3=6 \) is rational), IS symmetric (since \( x+y = y+x \)), and is NOT transitive (counterexample: \( \sqrt{3}, 1, -\sqrt{3} \) give \( \sqrt{3}+1 \) and \( 1-\sqrt{3} \) both irrational, but \( \sqrt{3}+(-\sqrt{3})=0 \) is rational).

Everything you get with Solver7

More questions in Relations and Functions