SOLVER7 Study. Nothing Else.
Exercise 1.1 Q2

Show that the relation R in the set \(R\) of real numbers, defined as \(R=\{(a, b) : a \le b^2\}\) is neither reflexive nor symmetric nor transitive.

CBSE Class 12 Maths · Relations and Functions

Solution

👶 Simple Explanation

Simple Explanation

Imagine a rule that says a number \( a \) is friends with a number \( b \) only when \( a \) is not bigger than \( b^2 \). A good rule should let everyone be friends with themselves, but \( \tfrac{1}{2} \) is not friends with itself here. A good rule should also work both ways, but \( 1 \) is friends with \( 2 \) while \( 2 \) refuses to be friends with \( 1 \). Even passing friendship along a chain fails, so this rule breaks all three friendship tests.

Answer: Using the counterexamples \( \left(\tfrac{1}{2},\tfrac{1}{2}\right) \notin R \), the pair \( (1,2) \in R \) but \( (2,1) \notin R \), and \( (3,-2),(-2,1) \in R \) but \( (3,1) \notin R \), we conclude that \( R = \{(a,b) : a \le b^2\} \) is neither reflexive, nor symmetric, nor transitive.

📖 R defined by a ≤ b² is neither reflexive, symmetric nor transitive

Detailed Explanation

A relation \( R \) on a set is examined for three key properties. Reflexive means every element is related to itself, that is \( (a,a) \in R \) for all \( a \). Symmetric means whenever \( (a,b) \in R \), we must also have \( (b,a) \in R \). Transitive means whenever \( (a,b) \in R \) and \( (b,c) \in R \), we must have \( (a,c) \in R \). To DISPROVE any property, it is enough to find a single counterexample. Here the relation on the set of real numbers is \( R = \{(a,b) : a \le b^2\} \), so a pair belongs to \( R \) only when the first number is less than or equal to the square of the second number.

Formula Used

\( (a,b) \in R \iff a \le b^2 \). Reflexive: \( (a,a) \in R \ \forall a \). Symmetric: \( (a,b) \in R \Rightarrow (b,a) \in R \). Transitive: \( (a,b),(b,c) \in R \Rightarrow (a,c) \in R \).

Solution

  1. Step 1: Check reflexivity. For \( R \) to be reflexive we need \( a \le a^2 \) for every real number \( a \). Test a fraction like \( a = \tfrac{1}{2} \). Then \( a^2 = \tfrac{1}{4} \), and we ask whether \( \tfrac{1}{2} \le \tfrac{1}{4} \), which is false.
  2. Step 2: Since \( \left(\tfrac{1}{2}, \tfrac{1}{2}\right) \notin R \), the condition \( (a,a) \in R \) fails for some real number. Therefore \( R \) is not reflexive.
  3. Step 3: Check symmetry. Take \( a = 1 \) and \( b = 2 \). Since \( 1 \le 2^2 = 4 \), we have \( (1,2) \in R \). Now check the reverse pair: is \( 2 \le 1^2 = 1 \)? This is false, so \( (2,1) \notin R \).
  4. Step 4: We found \( (1,2) \in R \) but \( (2,1) \notin R \). Hence the symmetric condition fails, so \( R \) is not symmetric.
  5. Step 5: Check transitivity. We need three numbers where \( (a,b) \in R \) and \( (b,c) \in R \) but \( (a,c) \notin R \). Take \( a = 3 \), \( b = -2 \), \( c = 1 \). Check \( (3,-2) \): is \( 3 \le (-2)^2 = 4 \)? Yes. Check \( (-2,1) \): is \( -2 \le 1^2 = 1 \)? Yes.
  6. Step 6: Now check the required pair \( (3,1) \): is \( 3 \le 1^2 = 1 \)? This is false, so \( (3,1) \notin R \). Thus \( (3,-2) \in R \) and \( (-2,1) \in R \) but \( (3,1) \notin R \), so \( R \) is not transitive.

Final Answer

Using the counterexamples \( \left(\tfrac{1}{2},\tfrac{1}{2}\right) \notin R \), the pair \( (1,2) \in R \) but \( (2,1) \notin R \), and \( (3,-2),(-2,1) \in R \) but \( (3,1) \notin R \), we conclude that \( R = \{(a,b) : a \le b^2\} \) is neither reflexive, nor symmetric, nor transitive.

Common Mistake

A common mistake is to test reflexivity only with integers like \( a = 2 \) where \( 2 \le 4 \) holds, and wrongly conclude \( R \) is reflexive. Reflexivity requires the condition to hold for ALL real numbers, so you must test fractions such as \( \tfrac{1}{2} \), where \( a \le a^2 \) fails.

🪜 Step-by-step Solution

Step-by-step Solution

  1. Step 1: Understand the membership rule. A pair \( (a,b) \) belongs to \( R \) if and only if \( a \le b^2 \). So before testing any property, substitute specific values and compare \( a \) with \( b^2 \). — Reason: Knowing exactly what puts a pair inside or outside \( R \) is essential before checking any property.
  2. Step 2: Check reflexivity. For \( R \) to be reflexive, every pair \( (a,a) \) must satisfy \( a \le a^2 \). Test \( a = \tfrac{1}{2} \): we need \( \tfrac{1}{2} \le \left(\tfrac{1}{2}\right)^2 = \tfrac{1}{4} \), but \( \tfrac{1}{2} > \tfrac{1}{4} \), so \( \left(\tfrac{1}{2}, \tfrac{1}{2}\right) \notin R \). — Reason: One failed instance is enough to conclude the property does not hold for the entire relation.
  3. Step 3: Conclude about reflexivity. Since the pair \( \left(\tfrac{1}{2}, \tfrac{1}{2}\right) \notin R \), the reflexivity condition breaks down. Therefore \( R \) is NOT reflexive. — Reason: Reflexivity demands the condition holds for every real number, and we have found one for which it fails.
  4. Step 4: Check symmetry. Take \( a = 1 \) and \( b = 2 \). Since \( 1 \le 2^2 = 4 \), the pair \( (1,2) \in R \). Now reverse the pair and test: is \( 2 \le 1^2 = 1 \)? Since \( 2 > 1 \), we get \( (2,1) \notin R \). — Reason: Symmetry requires both \( (a,b) \) and \( (b,a) \) to be in \( R \); a single pair where the reverse fails disproves it.
  5. Step 5: Conclude about symmetry. Because \( (1,2) \in R \) but \( (2,1) \notin R \), the symmetric property fails. Therefore \( R \) is NOT symmetric. — Reason: Symmetry must hold for every pair in \( R \), and this specific pair violates it.
  6. Step 6: Check transitivity. Consider \( a = 3 \), \( b = -2 \), \( c = 1 \). First, \( 3 \le (-2)^2 = 4 \), so \( (3,-2) \in R \). Next, \( -2 \le 1^2 = 1 \), so \( (-2,1) \in R \). For transitivity, we would need \( (3,1) \in R \), meaning \( 3 \le 1^2 = 1 \). But \( 3 > 1 \), so \( (3,1) \notin R \). — Reason: Transitivity demands that whenever both \( (a,b) \) and \( (b,c) \) are in \( R \), the pair \( (a,c) \) must also be in \( R \); this chain breaks here.
  7. Step 7: Conclude about transitivity. Even though \( (3,-2) \in R \) and \( (-2,1) \in R \), the required pair \( (3,1) \notin R \). Therefore \( R \) is NOT transitive. — Reason: A single failing triple is sufficient to rule out transitivity for the whole relation.

Final Answer

Using the counterexamples \( \left(\tfrac{1}{2},\tfrac{1}{2}\right) \notin R \), the pair \( (1,2) \in R \) but \( (2,1) \notin R \), and \( (3,-2),(-2,1) \in R \) but \( (3,1) \notin R \), we conclude that \( R = \{(a,b) : a \le b^2\} \) is neither reflexive, nor symmetric, nor transitive.

Common Mistake

One common mistake: Students often test only positive integers when checking reflexivity, missing that fractions between 0 and 1 satisfy \( a^2 < a \), which causes the reflexivity condition \( a \le a^2 \) to fail for those values.

✍️ Exam-ready Answer

Exam-ready Answer

  1. Check Reflexivity: Need \( a \le a^2 \) for all \( a \in \mathbb{R} \). At \( a = \tfrac{1}{2} \): \( \tfrac{1}{2} \le \tfrac{1}{4} \) is false, so \( \left(\tfrac{1}{2}, \tfrac{1}{2}\right) \notin R \). Not reflexive.
  2. Check Symmetry: \( (1,2) \in R \) since \( 1 \le 4 \), but \( (2,1) \notin R \) since \( 2 \le 1 \) is false. Not symmetric.
  3. Check Transitivity: \( (3,-2) \in R \) since \( 3 \le 4 \); \( (-2,1) \in R \) since \( -2 \le 1 \); but \( (3,1) \notin R \) since \( 3 \le 1 \) is false. Not transitive.

Answer: Using the counterexamples \( \left(\tfrac{1}{2},\tfrac{1}{2}\right) \notin R \), the pair \( (1,2) \in R \) but \( (2,1) \notin R \), and \( (3,-2),(-2,1) \in R \) but \( (3,1) \notin R \), we conclude that \( R = \{(a,b) : a \le b^2\} \) is neither reflexive, nor symmetric, nor transitive.

➕ More Examples

More Examples

Example 1

Question: Show that the relation R in the set of all real numbers, defined as \( R = \{(a, b) : a \le b^3\} \), is neither reflexive, nor symmetric, nor transitive.

Solution: We check each property using counterexamples. Checking Reflexivity: R is reflexive if \( (a, a) \in R \) for every real number \( a \), i.e., if \( a \le a^3 \) for all real \( a \). Let \( a = \frac{1}{2} \). Then \( a^3 = \frac{1}{8} \). We need to check whether \( \frac{1}{2} \le \frac{1}{8} \). This is FALSE since \( \frac{1}{2} > \frac{1}{8} \). Hence \( \left(\frac{1}{2}, \frac{1}{2}\right) \notin R \), so R is NOT reflexive. Checking Symmetry: R is symmetric if \( (a, b) \in R \) implies \( (b, a) \in R \). Let \( a = -2 \) and \( b = -1 \). Then \( b^3 = -1 \). Check: \( a \le b^3 \) means \( -2 \le -1 \), which is TRUE, so \( (-2, -1) \in R \). Now check whether \( (b, a) = (-1, -2) \in R \), i.e., whether \( -1 \le (-2)^3 = -8 \). This is FALSE since \( -1 > -8 \). Hence \( (-1, -2) \notin R \), so R is NOT symmetric. Checking Transitivity: R is transitive if \( (a, b) \in R \) and \( (b, c) \in R \) together imply \( (a, c) \in R \). Let \( a = 10 \), \( b = 2 \), \( c = \frac{3}{2} \). First, check \( (a, b) = (10, 2) \in R \): Is \( 10 \le 2^3 = 8 \)? No. So this example fails. Let us choose better values. Let \( a = 2 \), \( b = 2 \), \( c = \frac{3}{2} \). Check \( (2, 2) \in R \): Is \( 2 \le 2^3 = 8 \)? Yes. Check \( \left(2, \frac{3}{2}\right) \in R \): Is \( 2 \le \left(\frac{3}{2}\right)^3 = \frac{27}{8} = 3.375 \)? Yes. Now check \( \left(a, c\right) = \left(2, \frac{3}{2}\right) \in R \): Is \( 2 \le \left(\frac{3}{2}\right)^3 = \frac{27}{8} \)? Yes. This does not serve as a counterexample. We need a fresh triple. Let \( a = 100 \), \( b = 5 \), \( c = 2 \). Check \( (100, 5) \in R \): Is \( 100 \le 5^3 = 125 \)? Yes. Check \( (5, 2) \in R \): Is \( 5 \le 2^3 = 8 \)? Yes. Check \( (100, 2) \in R \): Is \( 100 \le 2^3 = 8 \)? No, since \( 100 > 8 \). So \( (100, 5) \in R \) and \( (5, 2) \in R \), but \( (100, 2) \notin R \). Hence R is NOT transitive. Conclusion: The relation R is neither reflexive, nor symmetric, nor transitive.

Answer: R is neither reflexive (counterexample: \( a = \frac{1}{2} \)), nor symmetric (counterexample: \( (-2,-1) \in R \) but \( (-1,-2) \notin R \)), nor transitive (counterexample: \( (100,5),(5,2) \in R \) but \( (100,2) \notin R \)).

Example 2

Question: Show that the relation R defined on the set of real numbers by \( R = \{(a, b) : a \ge b^2 - 1\} \) is neither reflexive, nor symmetric, nor transitive.

Solution: We check each property using counterexamples. Checking Reflexivity: R is reflexive if \( (a, a) \in R \) for all real \( a \), i.e., \( a \ge a^2 - 1 \) for all \( a \in \mathbb{R} \), which means \( a^2 - a - 1 \le 0 \) for all \( a \). Let \( a = 3 \). Then \( a^2 - a - 1 = 9 - 3 - 1 = 5 > 0 \), so \( 3 < 3^2 - 1 = 8 \). Hence \( (3, 3) \notin R \), so R is NOT reflexive. Checking Symmetry: R is symmetric if \( (a, b) \in R \) implies \( (b, a) \in R \). Let \( a = 3 \), \( b = 0 \). Check \( (3, 0) \in R \): Is \( 3 \ge 0^2 - 1 = -1 \)? Yes, since \( 3 \ge -1 \). So \( (3, 0) \in R \). Now check \( (0, 3) \in R \): Is \( 0 \ge 3^2 - 1 = 8 \)? No, since \( 0 < 8 \). Hence \( (3, 0) \in R \) but \( (0, 3) \notin R \), so R is NOT symmetric. Checking Transitivity: R is transitive if \( (a, b) \in R \) and \( (b, c) \in R \) imply \( (a, c) \in R \). Let \( a = 0 \), \( b = 0 \), \( c = 4 \). Check \( (0, 0) \in R \): Is \( 0 \ge 0^2 - 1 = -1 \)? Yes. Check \( (0, 4) \in R \): Is \( 0 \ge 4^2 - 1 = 15 \)? No. So this pair fails. Try a different triple. Let \( a = 3 \), \( b = 0 \), \( c = 3 \). Check \( (3, 0) \in R \): Is \( 3 \ge -1 \)? Yes. Check \( (0, 3) \in R \): Is \( 0 \ge 8 \)? No. So \( (b, c) \notin R \). Let \( a = 3 \), \( b = -1 \), \( c = 3 \). Check \( (3, -1) \in R \): Is \( 3 \ge (-1)^2 - 1 = 0 \)? Yes. Check \( (-1, 3) \in R \): Is \( -1 \ge 3^2 - 1 = 8 \)? No. Try \( a = 2 \), \( b = 1 \), \( c = 2 \). Check \( (2, 1) \in R \): Is \( 2 \ge 1^2 - 1 = 0 \)? Yes. Check \( (1, 2) \in R \): Is \( 1 \ge 2^2 - 1 = 3 \)? No. Try \( a = 2 \), \( b = 1 \), \( c = -3 \). Check \( (2, 1) \in R \): Is \( 2 \ge 0 \)? Yes. Check \( (1, -3) \in R \): Is \( 1 \ge (-3)^2 - 1 = 8 \)? No. Try \( a = 0 \), \( b = 0 \), \( c = 0 \) — trivially in R. We need a non-trivial failure. Let \( a = 9 \), \( b = 3 \), \( c = -3 \). Check \( (9, 3) \in R \): Is \( 9 \ge 3^2 - 1 = 8 \)? Yes. Check \( (3, -3) \in R \): Is \( 3 \ge (-3)^2 - 1 = 8 \)? No. Try \( a = 9 \), \( b = 3 \), \( c = 2 \). Check \( (9, 3) \in R \): Is \( 9 \ge 8 \)? Yes. Check \( (3, 2) \in R \): Is \( 3 \ge 2^2 - 1 = 3 \)? Yes (\( 3 \ge 3 \)). Check \( (9, 2) \in R \): Is \( 9 \ge 2^2 - 1 = 3 \)? Yes. So this does not give a failure. Try \( a = 3 \), \( b = 2 \), \( c = 2.5 \). Check \( (3, 2) \in R \): Is \( 3 \ge 3 \)? Yes. Check \( (2, 2.5) \in R \): Is \( 2 \ge (2.5)^2 - 1 = 6.25 - 1 = 5.25 \)? No. Try \( a = 9 \), \( b = 3 \), \( c = 3.5 \). Check \( (9, 3) \in R \): Is \( 9 \ge 8 \)? Yes. Check \( (3, 3.5) \in R \): Is \( 3 \ge (3.5)^2 - 1 = 12.25 - 1 = 11.25 \)? No. Try \( a = 3 \), \( b = 2 \), \( c = 2 \). Both \( (3,2) \in R \) and \( (2,2) \in R \) (since \( 2 \ge 4-1=3 \)? No, \( 2 < 3 \)). Not valid. Let \( b = 1 \). \( (b,b) = (1,1) \in R \) iff \( 1 \ge 1-1=0 \). Yes. Try \( a = 3, b = 1, c = 3 \). Check \( (3,1) \in R \): Is \( 3 \ge 0 \)? Yes. Check \( (1,3) \in R \): Is \( 1 \ge 8 \)? No. Try \( a = 1, b = 1, c = 3 \). Check \( (1,1) \in R \): Is \( 1 \ge 0 \)? Yes. Check \( (1,3) \in R \): Is \( 1 \ge 8 \)? No. Not useful. Try \( a = 3, b = 1, c = 1 \). Check \( (3,1) \in R \): Yes (\(3 \ge 0\)). Check \( (1,1) \in R \): Yes (\(1 \ge 0\)). Check \( (3,1) \in R \): Yes. Not a failure. For a clean counterexample, use \( a = 9, b = 3, c = -4 \). Check \( (9,3) \in R \): Is \( 9 \ge 8 \)? Yes. Check \( (3,-4) \in R \): Is \( 3 \ge (-4)^2 - 1 = 15 \)? No, \( 3 < 15 \). Since \( (b,c) \notin R \), this triple doesn't work. The difficulty is constructing a transitive failure. Let us try \( a = 1, b = 0, c = 0 \). Check \( (1,0) \in R \): Is \( 1 \ge -1 \)? Yes. Check \( (0,0) \in R \): Is \( 0 \ge -1 \)? Yes. Check \( (1,0) \in R \): Is \( 1 \ge -1 \)? Yes. Not a failure. Let \( a = 0, b = 1, c = 2 \). Check \( (0,1) \in R \): Is \( 0 \ge 1-1=0 \)? Yes (\(0 \ge 0\)). Check \( (1,2) \in R \): Is \( 1 \ge 4-1=3 \)? No. Not valid. Let \( a = 0, b = 1, c = -2 \). Check \( (0,1) \in R \): Is \( 0 \ge 0 \)? Yes. Check \( (1,-2) \in R \): Is \( 1 \ge 4-1=3 \)? No. Let \( a = 3, b = 2, c = -2 \). Check \( (3,2) \in R \): Is \( 3 \ge 3 \)? Yes. Check \( (2,-2) \in R \): Is \( 2 \ge 4-1=3 \)? No. Let \( a = 3, b = -2, c = 3 \). Check \( (3,-2) \in R \): Is \( 3 \ge 4-1=3 \)? Yes. Check \( (-2,3) \in R \): Is \( -2 \ge 8 \)? No. Let \( a = 3, b = -2, c = -2 \). Check \( (3,-2) \in R \): Is \( 3 \ge 3 \)? Yes. Check \( (-2,-2) \in R \): Is \( -2 \ge 4-1=3 \)? No. Let \( a = 3, b = -2, c = 1 \). Check \( (3,-2) \in R \): Yes. Check \( (-2,1) \in R \): Is \( -2 \ge 1-1=0 \)? No. Let \( a = 3, b = -2, c = 0 \). Check \( (3,-2) \in R \): Yes (\(3 \ge 3\)). Check \( (-2, 0) \in R \): Is \( -2 \ge 0^2-1 = -1 \)? No, since \(-2 < -1\). Let \( a = 3, b = 0, c = 3 \). Check \( (3,0) \in R \): Is \( 3 \ge -1 \)? Yes. Check \( (0,3) \in R \): Is \( 0 \ge 8 \)? No. For a valid triple: \( a = 5, b = 0, c = 0 \). Check \( (5,0) \in R \): Yes. Check \( (0,0) \in R \): Yes. Check \( (5,0) \in R \): Yes. Transitive holds here. Let \( a = 2, b = 0, c = -1 \). Check \( (2,0) \in R \): Is \( 2 \ge -1 \)? Yes. Check \( (0,-1) \in R \): Is \( 0 \ge (-1)^2-1 = 0 \)? Yes (\(0 \ge 0\)). Check \( (2,-1) \in R \): Is \( 2 \ge 0 \)? Yes. Not a failure. Let \( a = 0, b = -1, c = 3 \). Check \( (0,-1) \in R \): Is \( 0 \ge 0 \)? Yes. Check \( (-1,3) \in R \): Is \( -1 \ge 8 \)? No. Let \( a = 0, b = -1, c = 2 \). Check \( (0,-1) \in R \): Yes. Check \( (-1,2) \in R \): Is \( -1 \ge 3 \)? No. Let \( a = 0, b = -1, c = -1 \). Check \( (0,-1) \in R \): Yes. Check \( (-1,-1) \in R \): Is \( -1 \ge 0 \)? No. Let \( a = 0, b = -1, c = 0 \). Check \( (0,-1) \in R \): Yes. Check \( (-1,0) \in R \): Is \( -1 \ge -1 \)? Yes. Check \( (0,0) \in R \): Is \( 0 \ge -1 \)? Yes. Not a failure. Let \( a = 0, b = -1, c = -0.5 \). Check \( (0,-1) \in R \): Yes. Check \( (-1,-0.5) \in R \): Is \( -1 \ge 0.25-1=-0.75 \)? No (\(-1 < -0.75\)). Let \( a = -0.5, b = 0, c = -1 \). Check \( (-0.5,0) \in R \): Is \( -0.5 \ge -1 \)? Yes. Check \( (0,-1) \in R \): Is \( 0 \ge 0 \)? Yes. Check \( (-0.5,-1) \in R \): Is \( -0.5 \ge 0 \)? No (\(-0.5 < 0\)). We have found the counterexample for transitivity: \( a = -0.5 \), \( b = 0 \), \( c = -1 \). Summary: \( (-0.5, 0) \in R \) since \( -0.5 \ge 0^2 - 1 = -1 \); \( (0,-1) \in R \) since \( 0 \ge (-1)^2 - 1 = 0 \); but \( (-0.5,-1) \notin R \) since \( -0.5 < (-1)^2 - 1 = 0 \). Hence R is NOT transitive. Conclusion: The relation R is neither reflexive, nor symmetric, nor transitive.

Answer: R is neither reflexive (counterexample: \( a = 3 \)), nor symmetric (counterexample: \( (3,0) \in R \) but \( (0,3) \notin R \)), nor transitive (counterexample: \( (-0.5,0),(0,-1) \in R \) but \( (-0.5,-1) \notin R \)).

🎯 Try a Similar Question

Try a Similar Question

Question: Show that the relation \( R \) in the set \( \mathbb{R} \) of real numbers, defined as \( R = \{(a, b) : a \le b^3\} \), is neither reflexive nor symmetric nor transitive.

Solution

  1. Step 1: Check Reflexivity: For R to be reflexive, we need \( (a, a) \in R \) for every real number \( a \), i.e., \( a \le a^3 \) must hold for all \( a \in \mathbb{R} \). Consider \( a = \dfrac{1}{2} \). We check whether \( \dfrac{1}{2} \le \left(\dfrac{1}{2}\right)^3 \). \[ \left(\frac{1}{2}\right)^3 = \frac{1}{8} \] Since \( \dfrac{1}{2} = 0.5 \) and \( \dfrac{1}{8} = 0.125 \), we have \( \dfrac{1}{2} > \dfrac{1}{8} \), so \( \dfrac{1}{2} \not\le \dfrac{1}{8} \). Thus \( \left(\dfrac{1}{2},\, \dfrac{1}{2}\right) \notin R \), which shows R is NOT reflexive.
  2. Step 2: Check Symmetry: For R to be symmetric, whenever \( (a, b) \in R \) (i.e., \( a \le b^3 \)), we must also have \( (b, a) \in R \) (i.e., \( b \le a^3 \)). Consider \( a = 1 \) and \( b = 2 \). Check whether \( (1, 2) \in R \): \[ 1 \le 2^3 = 8 \quad \text{TRUE} \] So \( (1, 2) \in R \). Now check whether \( (2, 1) \in R \), i.e., whether \( 2 \le 1^3 \): \[ 2 \le 1 \quad \text{FALSE} \] Since \( (1, 2) \in R \) but \( (2, 1) \notin R \), R is NOT symmetric.
  3. Step 3: Check Transitivity: For R to be transitive, whenever \( (a, b) \in R \) and \( (b, c) \in R \), we must have \( (a, c) \in R \). Consider \( a = 5 \), \( b = -2 \), \( c = 1 \). Check \( (5, -2) \in R \), i.e., \( 5 \le (-2)^3 \): \[ (-2)^3 = -8, \quad 5 \le -8 \quad \text{FALSE} \] This counterexample does not work. Try \( a = -2 \), \( b = -1 \), \( c = 1 \). Check \( (-2, -1) \in R \): \( -2 \le (-1)^3 = -1 \). Since \( -2 \le -1 \), TRUE. Check \( (-1, 1) \in R \): \( -1 \le 1^3 = 1 \). Since \( -1 \le 1 \), TRUE. Now check \( (-2, 1) \in R \): \( -2 \le 1^3 = 1 \). TRUE. This does not give a counterexample. Try \( a = 4 \), \( b = 2 \), \( c = \dfrac{3}{2} \). Check \( (4, 2) \in R \): \( 4 \le 2^3 = 8 \). TRUE. Check \( \left(2, \dfrac{3}{2}\right) \in R \): \( 2 \le \left(\dfrac{3}{2}\right)^3 = \dfrac{27}{8} = 3.375 \). TRUE. Check \( \left(4, \dfrac{3}{2}\right) \in R \): \( 4 \le \left(\dfrac{3}{2}\right)^3 = \dfrac{27}{8} = 3.375 \). \[ 4 \le 3.375 \quad \text{FALSE} \] So \( (4, 2) \in R \) and \( \left(2, \dfrac{3}{2}\right) \in R \), but \( \left(4, \dfrac{3}{2}\right) \notin R \). Therefore R is NOT transitive.
  4. Step 4: Conclusion: We have shown: 1. \( \left(\dfrac{1}{2}, \dfrac{1}{2}\right) \notin R \), so R is not reflexive. 2. \( (1, 2) \in R \) but \( (2, 1) \notin R \), so R is not symmetric. 3. \( (4, 2) \in R \) and \( \left(2, \dfrac{3}{2}\right) \in R \) but \( \left(4, \dfrac{3}{2}\right) \notin R \), so R is not transitive. Hence, \( R = \{(a, b) : a \le b^3\} \) is neither reflexive, nor symmetric, nor transitive.

Answer: The relation \( R = \{(a, b) : a \le b^3\} \) on \( \mathbb{R} \) is neither reflexive (counterexample: \( \left(\dfrac{1}{2}, \dfrac{1}{2}\right) \notin R \)), nor symmetric (counterexample: \( (1,2) \in R \) but \( (2,1) \notin R \)), nor transitive (counterexample: \( (4,2) \in R \) and \( \left(2, \dfrac{3}{2}\right) \in R \) but \( \left(4, \dfrac{3}{2}\right) \notin R \)).

Everything you get with Solver7

More questions in Relations and Functions