The sum of the perimeter of a circle and square is \(k,\) where \(k\) is some constant. Prove that the sum of their areas is least when the side of square is double the radius of the circle.
CBSE Class 12 Maths · Application of Derivatives
CBSE Class 12 Maths · Application of Derivatives
Imagine you have a fixed length of ribbon and you must bend part of it into a circle and the rest into a square. You want the two shapes together to cover the least possible area. There is a sweet spot where this happens. It turns out the square's side must be exactly twice the circle's radius. The math checks this is truly a smallest value, not a largest one, because the curve of the area graph bends upward at that point.
Answer: The sum of the areas is minimum when \( x = 2r \), that is, the side of the square is double the radius of the circle. The second derivative \( \frac{d^2A}{dr^2} = 2\pi + \frac{\pi^2}{2} > 0 \) confirms this is indeed a minimum.
This is a maxima-minima problem from Application of Derivatives. We are told the total perimeter of a circle and a square is a fixed constant \( k \). Because the total perimeter is fixed, the radius of the circle and the side of the square are linked by one equation (a constraint). We use this constraint to express the total area as a function of a single variable, then differentiate. Setting the first derivative to zero gives the critical point, and checking the sign of the second derivative confirms whether it gives a minimum. The key skill is reducing a two-variable expression to one variable using the given condition.
Perimeter of circle \( = 2\pi r \), Perimeter of square \( = 4x \). Area of circle \( = \pi r^2 \), Area of square \( = x^2 \). For a minimum: \( \frac{dA}{dr} = 0 \) and \( \frac{d^2A}{dr^2} > 0 \).
The sum of the areas is minimum when \( x = 2r \), that is, the side of the square is double the radius of the circle. The second derivative \( \frac{d^2A}{dr^2} = 2\pi + \frac{\pi^2}{2} > 0 \) confirms this is indeed a minimum.
A common mistake is to forget the constraint \( 2\pi r + 4x = k \) and try to minimize \( A = \pi r^2 + x^2 \) directly in two variables, or to skip the second derivative test. Without using the constraint to reduce to one variable, and without checking \( \frac{d^2A}{dr^2} > 0 \), the proof is incomplete.
The sum of the areas is minimum when \( x = 2r \), that is, the side of the square is double the radius of the circle. The second derivative \( \frac{d^2A}{dr^2} = 2\pi + \frac{\pi^2}{2} > 0 \) confirms this is indeed a minimum.
One common mistake: students forget to substitute the expression for \( x \) back to check the ratio \( x = 2r \), and instead leave the answer only in terms of \( k \), missing the elegant geometric relationship between the two shapes.
Answer: The sum of the areas is minimum when \( x = 2r \), that is, the side of the square is double the radius of the circle. The second derivative \( \frac{d^2A}{dr^2} = 2\pi + \frac{\pi^2}{2} > 0 \) confirms this is indeed a minimum.
Question: A piece of wire of fixed length \(L\) is cut into two pieces. One piece is bent into a circle and the other into an equilateral triangle. Show that the sum of the areas enclosed is minimum when the side of the equilateral triangle is equal to \(\dfrac{3\sqrt{3}}{\pi + 3\sqrt{3}}\) times the total length \(L\), and equivalently when the radius of the circle is \(\dfrac{\sqrt{3}}{2(\pi + 3\sqrt{3})} \cdot L\). (In other words, prove that the total area is least when the length used for the triangle is \(\dfrac{3\sqrt{3}}{\pi + 3\sqrt{3}} \cdot L\).)
Solution: Let the length of wire used for the circle be \(x\), so the length used for the equilateral triangle is \(L - x\), where \(0 < x < L\). Radius of the circle: \[r = \frac{x}{2\pi}\] Side of the equilateral triangle: \[a = \frac{L - x}{3}\] Area of the circle: \[A_1 = \pi r^2 = \pi \cdot \frac{x^2}{4\pi^2} = \frac{x^2}{4\pi}\] Area of the equilateral triangle: \[A_2 = \frac{\sqrt{3}}{4}a^2 = \frac{\sqrt{3}}{4} \cdot \frac{(L-x)^2}{9} = \frac{\sqrt{3}(L-x)^2}{36}\] Total area: \[S(x) = \frac{x^2}{4\pi} + \frac{\sqrt{3}(L-x)^2}{36}\] Differentiating with respect to \(x\): \[\frac{dS}{dx} = \frac{2x}{4\pi} + \frac{\sqrt{3} \cdot 2(L-x)(-1)}{36} = \frac{x}{2\pi} - \frac{\sqrt{3}(L-x)}{18}\] Setting \(\frac{dS}{dx} = 0\): \[\frac{x}{2\pi} = \frac{\sqrt{3}(L-x)}{18}\] Cross-multiplying: \[18x = 2\pi\sqrt{3}(L - x)\] \[18x = 2\pi\sqrt{3}\,L - 2\pi\sqrt{3}\,x\] \[18x + 2\pi\sqrt{3}\,x = 2\pi\sqrt{3}\,L\] \[x(18 + 2\pi\sqrt{3}) = 2\pi\sqrt{3}\,L\] \[x = \frac{2\pi\sqrt{3}\,L}{18 + 2\pi\sqrt{3}} = \frac{\pi\sqrt{3}\,L}{9 + \pi\sqrt{3}}\] The length used for the triangle is: \[L - x = L - \frac{\pi\sqrt{3}\,L}{9 + \pi\sqrt{3}} = \frac{9L}{9 + \pi\sqrt{3}}\] Since \(9 = 3\sqrt{3} \cdot \sqrt{3}\) and \(9 + \pi\sqrt{3} = \sqrt{3}(3\sqrt{3} + \pi)\), we get: \[L - x = \frac{9L}{\sqrt{3}(\pi + 3\sqrt{3})} = \frac{3\sqrt{3}\,L}{\pi + 3\sqrt{3}}\] So the fraction of \(L\) used for the triangle is \(\dfrac{3\sqrt{3}}{\pi + 3\sqrt{3}}\), as required. Second derivative test: \[\frac{d^2S}{dx^2} = \frac{1}{2\pi} + \frac{\sqrt{3}}{18}\] Both terms are positive, so \(\frac{d^2S}{dx^2} > 0\) for all \(x\). Hence \(S\) is minimum at the critical point. Thus the sum of areas is least when the length devoted to the equilateral triangle is \(\dfrac{3\sqrt{3}}{\pi + 3\sqrt{3}} \cdot L\).
Answer: Total area is minimum when the wire length used for the equilateral triangle equals \(\dfrac{3\sqrt{3}}{\pi + 3\sqrt{3}} \cdot L\) and the wire length used for the circle equals \(\dfrac{\pi\sqrt{3}}{\pi\sqrt{3} + 9} \cdot L\).
Question: The sum of the circumferences of a circle and a square is a fixed constant \(k\). Prove that the sum of their areas is least when the diameter of the circle equals the side of the square (i.e., the side of the square is equal to twice the radius of the circle). Additionally, if the total perimeter \(k = 28\) cm, find the dimensions (radius and side) that minimise the total area.
Solution: Let the radius of the circle be \(r\) and the side of the square be \(a\). Constraint (fixed total perimeter): \[2\pi r + 4a = k\] Solving for \(a\): \[a = \frac{k - 2\pi r}{4}\] Total area: \[S = \pi r^2 + a^2 = \pi r^2 + \left(\frac{k - 2\pi r}{4}\right)^2\] \[S(r) = \pi r^2 + \frac{(k - 2\pi r)^2}{16}\] Differentiating with respect to \(r\): \[\frac{dS}{dr} = 2\pi r + \frac{2(k - 2\pi r)(-2\pi)}{16} = 2\pi r - \frac{\pi(k - 2\pi r)}{4}\] Setting \(\frac{dS}{dr} = 0\): \[2\pi r = \frac{\pi(k - 2\pi r)}{4}\] Dividing both sides by \(\pi\): \[2r = \frac{k - 2\pi r}{4}\] \[8r = k - 2\pi r\] \[8r + 2\pi r = k\] \[r(8 + 2\pi) = k\] \[r = \frac{k}{2(4 + \pi)}\] The corresponding side of the square: \[a = \frac{k - 2\pi r}{4} = \frac{k - \dfrac{2\pi k}{2(4+\pi)}}{4} = \frac{k - \dfrac{\pi k}{4 + \pi}}{4}\] \[a = \frac{k \left(1 - \dfrac{\pi}{4+\pi}\right)}{4} = \frac{k \cdot \dfrac{4}{4+\pi}}{4} = \frac{k}{4+\pi}\] Now compare \(a\) and \(2r\): \[2r = \frac{2k}{2(4+\pi)} = \frac{k}{4+\pi} = a\] Hence \(a = 2r\), i.e., the side of the square equals the diameter of the circle. This proves the required result. Second derivative test: \[\frac{d^2S}{dr^2} = 2\pi + \frac{4\pi^2}{16} = 2\pi + \frac{\pi^2}{4} > 0\] So the critical point gives a minimum. For \(k = 28\) cm: \[r = \frac{28}{2(4 + \pi)} = \frac{14}{4 + \pi} \approx \frac{14}{7.14} \approx 1.96 \text{ cm}\] \[a = 2r = \frac{28}{4+\pi} \approx 3.92 \text{ cm}\]
Answer: The total area is minimum when the side of the square equals twice the radius of the circle, i.e., \(a = 2r\). For \(k = 28\) cm: \(r = \dfrac{14}{4+\pi}\) cm and \(a = \dfrac{28}{4+\pi}\) cm.
Question: The sum of the perimeters of a circle and an equilateral triangle is a fixed constant \( k \). Show that the sum of their areas is least when the side of the equilateral triangle equals \( \dfrac{\sqrt{3}}{\pi + \sqrt{3}} \cdot k \), and find the relationship between the side of the triangle and the radius of the circle at this minimum.
Answer: The sum of the areas is minimum when the side of the equilateral triangle is \( a = \dfrac{\sqrt{3}\,k}{\pi + 3\sqrt{3}} \). At this minimum, \( a = 2\sqrt{3}\, r \), i.e., the side of the equilateral triangle is \( 2\sqrt{3} \) times the radius of the circle. The second derivative \( \dfrac{d^2A}{da^2} = \dfrac{9}{2\pi} + \dfrac{\sqrt{3}}{2} > 0 \) confirms this is a minimum.