Detailed Explanation
From the figure, A and B are the feet of the two poles on the ground, and R is a point on the segment AB. Let AR = x metres, so RB = (20 - x) metres. AP is a vertical pole of height 16 m at A, and BQ is a vertical pole of height 22 m at B. Since AP is perpendicular to the ground line AB, triangle ARP is right-angled at A. Similarly triangle BRQ is right-angled at B. Using the Pythagoras theorem we can express both \( RP^2 \) and \( RQ^2 \) in terms of x. Their sum becomes a function of x, and we use the technique of maxima and minima from Application of Derivatives: find where the first derivative is zero, then confirm it is a minimum using the second derivative test.
Formula Used
Pythagoras: \( RP^2 = AP^2 + AR^2 \) and \( RQ^2 = BQ^2 + RB^2 \). For minima: set \( \frac{dS}{dx} = 0 \) and check \( \frac{d^2S}{dx^2} > 0 \).
Solution
- Step 1: Set up the variable: Let R be a point on AB with \( AR = x \) metres. Then the remaining distance is \( RB = (20 - x) \) metres, exactly as shown in Fig 6.16.
- Step 2: Express RP² using Pythagoras: Triangle ARP is right-angled at A because pole AP is vertical and AR lies along the ground. So \[ RP^2 = AP^2 + AR^2 = 16^2 + x^2 = 256 + x^2 \]
- Step 3: Express RQ² using Pythagoras: Triangle BRQ is right-angled at B because pole BQ is vertical. So \[ RQ^2 = BQ^2 + RB^2 = 22^2 + (20 - x)^2 = 484 + (20 - x)^2 \]
- Step 4: Form the function to minimise: Let \( S \) be the quantity we want to minimise. \[ S = RP^2 + RQ^2 = 256 + x^2 + 484 + (20 - x)^2 \] Expanding \( (20 - x)^2 = 400 - 40x + x^2 \): \[ S = 256 + x^2 + 484 + 400 - 40x + x^2 \] \[ S = 2x^2 - 40x + 1140 \]
- Step 5: Differentiate and set to zero: Differentiate S with respect to x. \[ \frac{dS}{dx} = 4x - 40 \] For a critical point, set the derivative equal to zero. \[ 4x - 40 = 0 \] \[ x = 10 \]
- Step 6: Confirm it is a minimum: Differentiate again to apply the second derivative test. \[ \frac{d^2S}{dx^2} = 4 \] Since \( \frac{d^2S}{dx^2} = 4 > 0 \), the value \( x = 10 \) gives a minimum of S.
- Step 7: State the distance: The distance of R from A is \( x = 10 \) m. Note that this also means RB = 20 - 10 = 10 m, so R is the midpoint of AB.
Final Answer
The point R must be at a distance \( AR = 10 \) m from A (the midpoint of AB), which makes \( RP^2 + RQ^2 \) minimum.
Common Mistake
A common mistake is to forget the vertical pole heights and treat \( RP \) and \( RQ \) as horizontal distances, writing \( RP = x \) instead of \( RP^2 = 16^2 + x^2 \). You must apply Pythagoras because P and Q are at the tops of vertical poles, not on the ground line AB.