Detailed Explanation
This is a maxima and minima problem from Application of Derivatives. We want the largest cylinder that fits inside a cone. The key idea is to express the volume of the cylinder in terms of ONE variable using the geometry of the cone, then use the derivative to find the value that maximises the volume. Consider a right circular cone of height \( h \) and semi-vertical angle \( \alpha \). Its base radius is \( R = h\tan\alpha \). Place a cylinder inside it, standing on the base of the cone. If the cylinder has height \( x \), then the part of the cone above the cylinder is a smaller cone of height \( (h - x) \), and by similar triangles the radius of the cylinder equals the radius of the cone at that height. Using the relationship between the two similar triangles, we get the cylinder radius \( r \) in terms of \( x \), substitute into the volume formula, and maximise.
Formula Used
Volume of cylinder: \( V = \pi r^2 x \), where \( r \) is the radius and \( x \) is the height. Base radius of cone: \( R = h\tan\alpha \). Maxima condition: \( \dfrac{dV}{dx} = 0 \) and \( \dfrac{d^2V}{dx^2} < 0 \).
Solution
- Step 1: Set up the geometry. The cone has height \( h \) and semi-vertical angle \( \alpha \), so its base radius is \( R = h\tan\alpha \). Let the inscribed cylinder have height \( x \) and radius \( r \). The cylinder stands on the base of the cone, so above the cylinder there is a smaller cone of height \( (h - x) \).
- Step 2: Find the radius of the cylinder using similar triangles. The radius of the original cone at its base corresponds to full height \( h \), and the radius of the cone at the top of the cylinder corresponds to height \( (h - x) \). By similar triangles, the radius at height \( (h - x) \) from the apex is proportional. This top radius equals the cylinder radius \( r \), giving \[ \frac{r}{h - x} = \tan\alpha \] so \[ r = (h - x)\tan\alpha \]
- Step 3: Express the volume as a function of \( x \). Substitute \( r = (h - x)\tan\alpha \) into \( V = \pi r^2 x \): \[ V = \pi (h - x)^2 \tan^2\alpha \cdot x \] So \[ V = \pi \tan^2\alpha \, x (h - x)^2 \]
- Step 4: Differentiate \( V \) with respect to \( x \). Treat \( \pi\tan^2\alpha \) as a constant. Using the product rule on \( x(h - x)^2 \): \[ \frac{dV}{dx} = \pi\tan^2\alpha \left[ (h - x)^2 + x \cdot 2(h - x)(-1) \right] \] Simplify inside the bracket: \[ (h - x)^2 - 2x(h - x) = (h - x)\left[(h - x) - 2x\right] = (h - x)(h - 3x) \] Therefore \[ \frac{dV}{dx} = \pi\tan^2\alpha \,(h - x)(h - 3x) \]
- Step 5: Set the derivative to zero to find critical points. \[ \pi\tan^2\alpha \,(h - x)(h - 3x) = 0 \] This gives \( x = h \) or \( x = \dfrac{h}{3} \). Since \( x = h \) makes the radius zero (no cylinder), we take \[ x = \frac{h}{3} \]
- Step 6: Confirm it is a maximum using the second derivative test. Expand \( \frac{dV}{dx} = \pi\tan^2\alpha (h^2 - 4hx + 3x^2) \). Differentiating again: \[ \frac{d^2V}{dx^2} = \pi\tan^2\alpha (-4h + 6x) \] At \( x = \dfrac{h}{3} \): \[ \frac{d^2V}{dx^2} = \pi\tan^2\alpha \left(-4h + 2h\right) = -2\pi h\tan^2\alpha < 0 \] Since the second derivative is negative, \( x = \dfrac{h}{3} \) gives a maximum. This proves the height of the greatest cylinder is one-third the height of the cone.
- Step 7: Find the greatest volume by substituting \( x = \dfrac{h}{3} \) into \( V = \pi\tan^2\alpha \, x(h - x)^2 \). Here \( h - x = h - \dfrac{h}{3} = \dfrac{2h}{3} \), so \[ V = \pi\tan^2\alpha \cdot \frac{h}{3} \cdot \left(\frac{2h}{3}\right)^2 \] \[ V = \pi\tan^2\alpha \cdot \frac{h}{3} \cdot \frac{4h^2}{9} = \frac{4}{27}\pi h^3 \tan^2\alpha \]
Final Answer
The height of the cylinder of greatest volume is \( x = \dfrac{h}{3} \), which is one-third the height of the cone, and the greatest volume is \[ V = \frac{4}{27}\pi h^3 \tan^2\alpha \]
Common Mistake
A common mistake is writing the cylinder radius as \( r = x\tan\alpha \) using the cylinder's own height instead of using the smaller cone of height \( (h - x) \). The correct relation from similar triangles is \( r = (h - x)\tan\alpha \), because the radius depends on the height of the cone remaining above the cylinder, not on the cylinder's height directly.