Detailed Explanation
This is an optimization (maxima and minima) problem. The total wire length is fixed at 28 m, so if one piece has length \( x \), the other must have length \( 28 - x \). We form one piece into a square and the other into a circle, then express the TOTAL area as a function of a single variable \( x \). To find the minimum, we differentiate this area function, set the first derivative equal to zero to get the critical point, and use the second derivative test to confirm it gives a minimum. This is the standard CBSE method for finding the extreme value of a quantity subject to a constraint.
Formula Used
Perimeter of square \( = 4a \), so side \( a = \dfrac{\text{length}}{4} \), and area \( = a^2 \). Circumference of circle \( = 2\pi r \), so radius \( r = \dfrac{\text{length}}{2\pi} \), and area \( = \pi r^2 \). Second derivative test: minimum when \( A'(x) = 0 \) and \( A''(x) > 0 \).
Solution
- Step 1: Let the piece used to make the square have length \( x \) metres. Then the piece used for the circle has length \( 28 - x \) metres, since the total wire is 28 m.
- Step 2: The square is formed from length \( x \), so its perimeter is \( x \) and its side is \( \dfrac{x}{4} \). Its area is \[ \left( \dfrac{x}{4} \right)^2 = \dfrac{x^2}{16}. \]
- Step 3: The circle is formed from length \( 28 - x \), which is its circumference. So \( 2\pi r = 28 - x \), giving \( r = \dfrac{28 - x}{2\pi} \). Its area is \[ \pi r^2 = \pi \left( \dfrac{28 - x}{2\pi} \right)^2 = \dfrac{(28 - x)^2}{4\pi}. \]
- Step 4: The combined area as a function of \( x \) is \[ A(x) = \dfrac{x^2}{16} + \dfrac{(28 - x)^2}{4\pi}. \] We must minimize this for \( 0 \le x \le 28 \).
- Step 5: Differentiate with respect to \( x \): \[ A'(x) = \dfrac{2x}{16} + \dfrac{2(28 - x)(-1)}{4\pi} = \dfrac{x}{8} - \dfrac{(28 - x)}{2\pi}. \]
- Step 6: Set \( A'(x) = 0 \) to find the critical point: \[ \dfrac{x}{8} = \dfrac{28 - x}{2\pi}. \] Cross-multiplying gives \[ 2\pi x = 8(28 - x). \] So \( 2\pi x = 224 - 8x \), which gives \( 2\pi x + 8x = 224 \), hence \[ x(2\pi + 8) = 224. \] Therefore \[ x = \dfrac{224}{2\pi + 8} = \dfrac{112}{\pi + 4}. \]
- Step 7: Apply the second derivative test. Differentiating again: \[ A''(x) = \dfrac{1}{8} + \dfrac{1}{2\pi}. \] Since both terms are positive, \( A''(x) > 0 \) for all \( x \). Hence \( x = \dfrac{112}{\pi + 4} \) gives a minimum.
- Step 8: The length of the second piece is \[ 28 - x = 28 - \dfrac{112}{\pi + 4} = \dfrac{28(\pi + 4) - 112}{\pi + 4} = \dfrac{28\pi + 112 - 112}{\pi + 4} = \dfrac{28\pi}{\pi + 4}. \]
Final Answer
The wire should be cut so that the piece for the square is \( \dfrac{112}{\pi + 4} \) m and the piece for the circle is \( \dfrac{28\pi}{\pi + 4} \) m. These lengths give the minimum combined area.
Common Mistake
A common mistake is confusing which length becomes the perimeter of the square versus the circumference of the circle, or forgetting to apply the constraint \( x + (28 - x) = 28 \). Students also often skip the second derivative test and simply assume the critical point is a minimum without verifying \( A''(x) > 0 \).