SOLVER7 Study. Nothing Else.
Miscellaneous Exercise Chapter 2 Q9(iii)

Let \(R\) be a relation from \(N\) to \(N\) defined by \(R=\{(a, b): a,b \in N\) and \(a=b^2\}\) Are the following true?
\((a,b)\in R ,(b,c)\in R \) implies \((a,c) \in R\) Justify your answer in each case.

CBSE Class 11 Maths · Relations and Functions

Solution

👶 Simple Explanation

Simple Explanation

Imagine a rule: one number is the square of another. So 16 is connected to 4, because \( 16 = 4^2 \). Also, 4 is connected to 2, because \( 4 = 2^2 \). A transitive rule means if A connects to B, and B connects to C, then A must connect to C too. But does 16 connect to 2? That would need \( 16 = 2^2 \), which means 16 = 4. That is wrong! So the rule breaks down, and the relation is NOT transitive.

Answer: The statement is FALSE. The relation is not transitive. Counterexample: \( (16, 4) \in R \) and \( (4, 2) \in R \), but \( (16, 2) \notin R \) because \( 16 \ne 2^2 \).

📖 Checking Transitivity of the Relation a = b²

Detailed Explanation

A relation \( R \) on a set is called transitive if whenever \( (a, b) \in R \) and \( (b, c) \in R \), it is also true that \( (a, c) \in R \). Here the relation from \( \mathbb{N} \) to \( \mathbb{N} \) is \( R = \{(a, b) : a, b \in \mathbb{N}, \ a = b^2\} \). This means the first element must equal the square of the second element. To check transitivity, we assume the two given conditions hold and see whether the conclusion \( a = c^2 \) must follow. The easiest way to disprove a general claim is to find one counterexample.

Formula Used

\( (a, b) \in R \iff a = b^2 \); Transitive means \( (a, b) \in R \) and \( (b, c) \in R \Rightarrow (a, c) \in R \).

Solution

  1. Step 1: Write down what each membership means. If \( (a, b) \in R \), then \( a = b^2 \). If \( (b, c) \in R \), then \( b = c^2 \).
  2. Step 2: Combine the two relations. Substituting \( b = c^2 \) into \( a = b^2 \) gives \[ a = (c^2)^2 = c^4. \] So the two given conditions force \( a = c^4 \).
  3. Step 3: Check what transitivity requires. For \( (a, c) \in R \) we would need \( a = c^2 \). But we found \( a = c^4 \). These agree only if \( c^4 = c^2 \), which is generally false for natural numbers greater than 1.
  4. Step 4: Construct a counterexample. Take \( c = 2 \). Then \( b = c^2 = 4 \) and \( a = b^2 = 16 \). So \( (16, 4) \in R \) since \( 16 = 4^2 \), and \( (4, 2) \in R \) since \( 4 = 2^2 \).
  5. Step 5: Test the required pair \( (a, c) = (16, 2) \). For this to belong to \( R \) we need \( 16 = 2^2 = 4 \), which is false. Hence \( (16, 2) \notin R \).

Final Answer

The statement is FALSE. The relation is not transitive. Counterexample: \( (16, 4) \in R \) and \( (4, 2) \in R \), but \( (16, 2) \notin R \) because \( 16 \ne 2^2 \).

Common Mistake

Students often assume that combining two valid pairs automatically gives a valid pair, without substituting carefully. Substituting gives \( a = c^4 \), not \( a = c^2 \), so the required condition fails — a single counterexample is enough to prove it is not transitive.

🪜 Step-by-step Solution

Step-by-step Solution

  1. Step 1: Decode what membership in R actually says. If \( (a, b) \in R \), then \( a = b^2 \). Similarly, if \( (b, c) \in R \), then \( b = c^2 \). — Reason: Before testing any property, you must clearly spell out what the relation's rule means for each ordered pair.
  2. Step 2: Combine the two conditions by substitution. Since \( b = c^2 \), substitute into \( a = b^2 \): \[ a = (c^2)^2 = c^4. \] So the two memberships together force \( a = c^4 \). — Reason: Substitution lets us express a directly in terms of c, which is exactly what we need to compare with the requirement for \( (a, c) \in R \).
  3. Step 3: State what transitivity would require and compare. For \( (a, c) \in R \) we would need \( a = c^2 \). But Step 2 gives \( a = c^4 \). These are equal only when \( c^4 = c^2 \), i.e., \( c^2(c^2 - 1) = 0 \), which has no solution for \( c \in \mathbb{N} \) with \( c > 1 \). — Reason: Comparing \( c^4 \) with \( c^2 \) exposes the gap: the two conditions overshoot the target, so transitivity cannot hold in general.
  4. Step 4: Choose a specific natural number to build a counterexample. Let \( c = 2 \). Then \( b = c^2 = 4 \) and \( a = b^2 = 16 \). Check: \( (16, 4) \in R \) because \( 16 = 4^2 \), and \( (4, 2) \in R \) because \( 4 = 2^2 \). — Reason: Picking the smallest integer greater than 1 gives the simplest, cleanest numbers to verify.
  5. Step 5: Test whether the pair \( (16, 2) \) belongs to R. For \( (16, 2) \in R \) we would need \( 16 = 2^2 = 4 \), which is false. Therefore \( (16, 2) \notin R \). — Reason: This single failure is sufficient to conclude the relation is NOT transitive; no further cases need to be checked once a counterexample is found.

Final Answer

The statement is FALSE. The relation is not transitive. Counterexample: \( (16, 4) \in R \) and \( (4, 2) \in R \), but \( (16, 2) \notin R \) because \( 16 \ne 2^2 \).

Common Mistake

One common mistake: students confuse the condition \( a = b^2 \) with \( b = a^2 \) (reversing the roles of the two elements), which leads to incorrect pair checking and a wrong conclusion about transitivity.

✍️ Exam-ready Answer

Exam-ready Answer

  1. Step 1: Assume \( (a,b) \in R \) and \( (b,c) \in R \), so \( a = b^2 \) and \( b = c^2 \).
  2. Step 2: Substituting: \( a = (c^2)^2 = c^4 \). Transitivity needs \( a = c^2 \), but \( c^4 \ne c^2 \) in general.
  3. Step 3: Counterexample: \( c = 2 \), \( b = 4 \), \( a = 16 \). Then \( (16,4) \in R \) and \( (4,2) \in R \), but \( 16 \ne 2^2 \), so \( (16,2) \notin R \).

Answer: The statement is FALSE. The relation is not transitive. Counterexample: \( (16, 4) \in R \) and \( (4, 2) \in R \), but \( (16, 2) \notin R \) because \( 16 \ne 2^2 \).

➕ More Examples

More Examples

Example 1

Question: Let R be a relation from \( \mathbb{N} \) to \( \mathbb{N} \) defined by \( R = \{(a, b) : a, b \in \mathbb{N} \text{ and } a = b^3\} \). Is the following true? If \( (a, b) \in R \) and \( (b, c) \in R \), then \( (a, c) \in R \). Justify your answer.

Solution: We need to check: whenever \( (a, b) \in R \) and \( (b, c) \in R \), does it follow that \( (a, c) \in R \)? By definition of R: \( (a, b) \in R \) means \( a = b^3 \) \( (b, c) \in R \) means \( b = c^3 \) For \( (a, c) \in R \), we would need \( a = c^3 \). Substituting \( b = c^3 \) into \( a = b^3 \): \[ a = (c^3)^3 = c^9 \] So \( a = c^9 \), but for \( (a, c) \in R \) we need \( a = c^3 \). These are equal only when \( c^9 = c^3 \), i.e., \( c^3(c^6 - 1) = 0 \), which holds only for \( c = 0 \) or \( c = 1 \) in \( \mathbb{N} \). This is not true in general. Counterexample: Let \( c = 2 \). Then \( b = c^3 = 8 \) and \( a = b^3 = 512 \). So \( (512, 8) \in R \) and \( (8, 2) \in R \). For \( (a, c) = (512, 2) \) to be in R, we need \( 512 = 2^3 = 8 \), which is false. Therefore \( (512, 2) \notin R \). Hence the given statement is NOT true.

Answer: False. Counterexample: \( (512, 8) \in R \) and \( (8, 2) \in R \), but \( (512, 2) \notin R \) since \( 512 \ne 2^3 \).

Example 2

Question: Let R be a relation from \( \mathbb{N} \) to \( \mathbb{N} \) defined by \( R = \{(a, b) : a, b \in \mathbb{N} \text{ and } b = a^2 + 1\} \). Is the following true? If \( (a, b) \in R \) and \( (b, c) \in R \), then \( (a, c) \in R \). Justify your answer.

Solution: We need to check: whenever \( (a, b) \in R \) and \( (b, c) \in R \), does it follow that \( (a, c) \in R \)? By definition of R: \( (a, b) \in R \) means \( b = a^2 + 1 \) \( (b, c) \in R \) means \( c = b^2 + 1 \) For \( (a, c) \in R \), we would need \( c = a^2 + 1 \). Substituting \( b = a^2 + 1 \) into \( c = b^2 + 1 \): \[ c = (a^2 + 1)^2 + 1 = a^4 + 2a^2 + 1 + 1 = a^4 + 2a^2 + 2 \] For \( (a, c) \in R \), we need \( c = a^2 + 1 \), but we obtained \( c = a^4 + 2a^2 + 2 \). These are equal only if \( a^4 + 2a^2 + 2 = a^2 + 1 \), i.e., \( a^4 + a^2 + 1 = 0 \), which has no solution in \( \mathbb{N} \). Counterexample: Let \( a = 2 \). Then \( b = 2^2 + 1 = 5 \) and \( c = 5^2 + 1 = 26 \). So \( (2, 5) \in R \) and \( (5, 26) \in R \). For \( (a, c) = (2, 26) \) to be in R, we need \( 26 = 2^2 + 1 = 5 \), which is false. Therefore \( (2, 26) \notin R \). Hence the given statement is NOT true.

Answer: False. Counterexample: \( (2, 5) \in R \) and \( (5, 26) \in R \), but \( (2, 26) \notin R \) since \( 26 \ne 2^2 + 1 \).

🎯 Try a Similar Question

Try a Similar Question

Question: Let \( R \) be a relation from \( \mathbb{N} \) to \( \mathbb{N} \) defined by \( R = \{(a, b) : a, b \in \mathbb{N} \text{ and } b = a^2\} \). Determine whether the following statement is true or false, and justify your answer: If \( (a, b) \in R \) and \( (b, c) \in R \), then \( (a, c) \in R \).

Solution

  1. Step 1: Understand the relation: The relation is defined as \( R = \{(a, b) : b = a^2,\; a, b \in \mathbb{N}\} \). So \( (a, b) \in R \) means \( b = a^2 \), and \( (b, c) \in R \) means \( c = b^2 \).
  2. Step 2: Set up what transitivity would require: For the relation to be transitive, whenever \( (a, b) \in R \) and \( (b, c) \in R \), we would need \( (a, c) \in R \), which means \( c = a^2 \).
  3. Step 3: Express c in terms of a: From \( (a, b) \in R \) we get \( b = a^2 \). From \( (b, c) \in R \) we get \( c = b^2 \). Substituting: \( c = \left(a^2\right)^2 = a^4 \). So transitivity would require \( a^4 = a^2 \), which is NOT generally true for all \( a \in \mathbb{N} \).
  4. Step 4: Find a specific counterexample: Take \( a = 2 \). Then \( b = 2^2 = 4 \), so \( (2, 4) \in R \). Next, \( c = 4^2 = 16 \), so \( (4, 16) \in R \). Now check whether \( (2, 16) \in R \): this requires \( 16 = 2^2 = 4 \), which is FALSE. So \( (2, 16) \notin R \).
  5. Step 5: Conclusion: Since \( (2, 4) \in R \) and \( (4, 16) \in R \), but \( (2, 16) \notin R \), the statement is FALSE. The relation \( R \) is NOT transitive.

Answer: The statement is TRUE only if \( a = 1 \); in general it is FALSE. The relation is NOT transitive. Counterexample: \( (2, 4) \in R \) and \( (4, 16) \in R \), but \( (2, 16) \notin R \) because \( 16 \ne 2^2 \).

Everything you get with Solver7

More questions in Relations and Functions