SOLVER7 Study. Nothing Else.
Chapter 2 Examples Q2

If \(P=\{a, b, c\}\) and \(Q=\{r\},\) form the sets \(P\times Q\) and \(Q\times P.\) Are these two products equal \(\ ?\)

CBSE Class 11 Maths · Relations and Functions

Solution

👶 Simple Explanation

Simple Explanation

Imagine you have three friends named a, b, and c, and one game called r. Pairing each friend with that game gives you (a, r), (b, r), and (c, r). Now flip it around — the game goes first and each friend comes second. That gives (r, a), (r, b), and (r, c). These two groups look different because order matters — just like how "cat" and "tac" are not the same word even though they share the same letters.

Answer: \[ P \times Q = \{ (a, r),\ (b, r),\ (c, r) \} \] \[ Q \times P = \{ (r, a),\ (r, b),\ (r, c) \} \] No, the two products are not equal, since \( P \times Q \ne Q \times P \).

📖 Cartesian Products P×Q and Q×P

Detailed Explanation

The Cartesian product of two sets \( A \) and \( B \), written \( A \times B \), is the set of all ordered pairs \( (a, b) \) where the first element comes from \( A \) and the second element comes from \( B \). The key word is 'ordered' — in an ordered pair \( (a, b) \), the position matters, so \( (a, b) \) is generally not the same as \( (b, a) \). Because of this, \( P \times Q \) and \( Q \times P \) usually give different sets, since in \( P \times Q \) the first coordinate is from \( P \), while in \( Q \times P \) the first coordinate is from \( Q \).

Formula Used

\[ A \times B = \{ (a, b) : a \in A,\ b \in B \} \]

Solution

  1. Step 1: Write down the given sets. Here \( P = \{a, b, c\} \) and \( Q = \{r\} \). So \( P \) has 3 elements and \( Q \) has 1 element.
  2. Step 2: Form \( P \times Q \). Take each element of \( P \) as the first coordinate and pair it with each element of \( Q \) as the second coordinate: \[ P \times Q = \{ (a, r),\ (b, r),\ (c, r) \} \]
  3. Step 3: Form \( Q \times P \). Now take each element of \( Q \) as the first coordinate and pair it with each element of \( P \) as the second coordinate: \[ Q \times P = \{ (r, a),\ (r, b),\ (r, c) \} \]
  4. Step 4: Compare the two products. In \( P \times Q \) each pair has the letter first, like \( (a, r) \). In \( Q \times P \) each pair has \( r \) first, like \( (r, a) \). Since \( (a, r) \ne (r, a) \), the ordered pairs are different.
  5. Step 5: Conclude. Both sets have the same number of elements, that is \( 3 \times 1 = 3 \), but they are not equal because their ordered pairs differ. Hence \( P \times Q \ne Q \times P \).

Final Answer

\[ P \times Q = \{ (a, r),\ (b, r),\ (c, r) \} \] \[ Q \times P = \{ (r, a),\ (r, b),\ (r, c) \} \] No, the two products are not equal, since \( P \times Q \ne Q \times P \).

Common Mistake

A common mistake is to think \( P \times Q = Q \times P \) because both have the same number of elements. But Cartesian product uses ordered pairs, so the order of coordinates matters and the two sets are different unless \( P = Q \).

🪜 Step-by-step Solution

Step-by-step Solution

  1. Step 1: Identify the given sets: \( P = \{a, b, c\} \) and \( Q = \{r\} \). — Reason: Listing the sets clearly shows us that \( P \) contains 3 elements while \( Q \) contains only 1 element, which tells us each product will have \( 3 \times 1 = 3 \) ordered pairs.
  2. Step 2: Form \( P \times Q \) by pairing every element of \( P \) (as the first coordinate) with every element of \( Q \) (as the second coordinate): \[ P \times Q = \{ (a, r),\ (b, r),\ (c, r) \} \] — Reason: By definition, in \( P \times Q \) the first position always belongs to a member of \( P \) and the second position to a member of \( Q \).
  3. Step 3: Form \( Q \times P \) by now placing the single element of \( Q \) in the first position and pairing it with each element of \( P \) in the second position: \[ Q \times P = \{ (r, a),\ (r, b),\ (r, c) \} \] — Reason: Here the roles of the two sets are reversed, so \( r \) leads every pair instead of following it.
  4. Step 4: Compare a typical pair from each product. Take \( (a, r) \in P \times Q \) and \( (r, a) \in Q \times P \). Since ordered pairs are position-sensitive, \( (a, r) \ne (r, a) \). — Reason: Two ordered pairs are equal only when both the first coordinates match AND the second coordinates match; here the coordinates are swapped, so they differ.
  5. Step 5: Conclude the comparison. Every element of \( P \times Q \) has a letter from \( \{a, b, c\} \) in front, whereas every element of \( Q \times P \) has \( r \) in front. No pair from one set can equal any pair from the other, so \( P \times Q \ne Q \times P \). — Reason: This confirms the general rule that Cartesian products are not commutative when the two sets are distinct.

Final Answer

\[ P \times Q = \{ (a, r),\ (b, r),\ (c, r) \} \] \[ Q \times P = \{ (r, a),\ (r, b),\ (r, c) \} \] No, the two products are not equal, since \( P \times Q \ne Q \times P \).

Common Mistake

One common mistake: students assume \( P \times Q = Q \times P \) because both products contain the same three letters. Remember that in an ordered pair the position of each element matters, so \( (a, r) \) and \( (r, a) \) are completely different pairs.

✍️ Exam-ready Answer

Exam-ready Answer

  1. Step 1: Given: \( P = \{a, b, c\} \), \( Q = \{r\} \)
  2. Step 2: Form \( P \times Q \): pair each element of \( P \) with \( r \). \[ P \times Q = \{ (a, r),\ (b, r),\ (c, r) \} \]
  3. Step 3: Form \( Q \times P \): pair \( r \) with each element of \( P \). \[ Q \times P = \{ (r, a),\ (r, b),\ (r, c) \} \]
  4. Step 4: Since \( (a, r) \ne (r, a) \), the ordered pairs differ, so \( P \times Q \ne Q \times P \).

Answer: \[ P \times Q = \{ (a, r),\ (b, r),\ (c, r) \} \] \[ Q \times P = \{ (r, a),\ (r, b),\ (r, c) \} \] No, the two products are not equal, since \( P \times Q \ne Q \times P \).

➕ More Examples

More Examples

Example 1

Question: Let \( X = \{1, 2, 3\} \) and \( Y = \{m, n\} \). Form the sets \( X \times Y \) and \( Y \times X \). Are the two Cartesian products equal? Justify your answer.

Solution: Step 1 — Form \( X \times Y \). We pair every element of \( X \) with every element of \( Y \): \[ X \times Y = \{(1, m),\ (1, n),\ (2, m),\ (2, n),\ (3, m),\ (3, n)\} \] Step 2 — Form \( Y \times X \). We pair every element of \( Y \) with every element of \( X \): \[ Y \times X = \{(m, 1),\ (m, 2),\ (m, 3),\ (n, 1),\ (n, 2),\ (n, 3)\} \] Step 3 — Compare the two sets. An ordered pair \( (1, m) \in X \times Y \) has its first component from \( X \) and second from \( Y \). The corresponding pair in \( Y \times X \) would be \( (m, 1) \), which is a different ordered pair because \( (1, m) \ne (m, 1) \) (their components are interchanged). Since the sets contain different ordered pairs, we conclude that \( X \times Y \ne Y \times X \). Step 4 — Verify cardinality. Number of elements in \( X \times Y \): \( 3 \times 2 = 6 \). Number of elements in \( Y \times X \): \( 2 \times 3 = 6 \). Both sets have 6 elements, but the elements (ordered pairs) themselves are different, confirming \( X \times Y \ne Y \times X \).

Answer: \( X \times Y = \{(1, m),\ (1, n),\ (2, m),\ (2, n),\ (3, m),\ (3, n)\} \) and \( Y \times X = \{(m, 1),\ (m, 2),\ (m, 3),\ (n, 1),\ (n, 2),\ (n, 3)\} \). They are NOT equal because the ordered pairs have their components reversed.

Example 2

Question: Let \( A = \{p, q\} \) and \( B = \{4, 5, 6\} \). Find \( A \times B \) and \( B \times A \). Is \( A \times B = B \times A \)? Give a reason. Also find the number of elements in each product set.

Solution: Step 1 — Form \( A \times B \). Pairing each element of \( A \) with each element of \( B \): \[ A \times B = \{(p, 4),\ (p, 5),\ (p, 6),\ (q, 4),\ (q, 5),\ (q, 6)\} \] Step 2 — Form \( B \times A \). Pairing each element of \( B \) with each element of \( A \): \[ B \times A = \{(4, p),\ (4, q),\ (5, p),\ (5, q),\ (6, p),\ (6, q)\} \] Step 3 — Count the elements. Number of elements in \( A \times B \): \( n(A) \times n(B) = 2 \times 3 = 6 \). Number of elements in \( B \times A \): \( n(B) \times n(A) = 3 \times 2 = 6 \). Step 4 — Check equality. For two sets to be equal, every element of one must belong to the other. Consider the pair \( (p, 4) \in A \times B \). Its first component is \( p \), which is not a number, so \( (p, 4) \notin B \times A \) (since every first component in \( B \times A \) is a number). Therefore \( A \times B \ne B \times A \). In general, \( A \times B = B \times A \) only when \( A = B \), which is clearly not the case here since \( A \) and \( B \) have completely different elements.

Answer: \( A \times B = \{(p, 4),\ (p, 5),\ (p, 6),\ (q, 4),\ (q, 5),\ (q, 6)\} \) and \( B \times A = \{(4, p),\ (4, q),\ (5, p),\ (5, q),\ (6, p),\ (6, q)\} \). Each set has 6 elements. \( A \times B \ne B \times A \) because the ordered pairs in the two products have their components interchanged.

🎯 Try a Similar Question

Try a Similar Question

Question: Let \( X = \{1, 2\} \) and \( Y = \{p, q, r\} \). Form the sets \( X \times Y \) and \( Y \times X \). Are the two Cartesian products equal? Give a reason for your answer.

Solution

  1. Step 1: Recall the definition of Cartesian product: The Cartesian product \( X \times Y \) consists of all ordered pairs \( (x, y) \) where \( x \in X \) and \( y \in Y \). Similarly, \( Y \times X \) consists of all ordered pairs \( (y, x) \) where \( y \in Y \) and \( x \in X \).
  2. Step 2: Form X × Y: Take each element of \( X = \{1, 2\} \) in turn and pair it with every element of \( Y = \{p, q, r\} \).
  3. Step 3: List all elements of X × Y: Pairing 1 with each element of Y gives \( (1, p),\ (1, q),\ (1, r) \). Pairing 2 with each element of Y gives \( (2, p),\ (2, q),\ (2, r) \). Therefore, \[ X \times Y = \{ (1, p),\ (1, q),\ (1, r),\ (2, p),\ (2, q),\ (2, r) \} \]
  4. Step 4: Form Y × X: Now pair each element of \( Y = \{p, q, r\} \) with every element of \( X = \{1, 2\} \).
  5. Step 5: List all elements of Y × X: Pairing p with each element of X gives \( (p, 1),\ (p, 2) \). Pairing q gives \( (q, 1),\ (q, 2) \). Pairing r gives \( (r, 1),\ (r, 2) \). Therefore, \[ Y \times X = \{ (p, 1),\ (p, 2),\ (q, 1),\ (q, 2),\ (r, 1),\ (r, 2) \} \]
  6. Step 6: Compare the two products: \( X \times Y \) has 6 elements of the form (number, letter), while \( Y \times X \) has 6 elements of the form (letter, number). The ordered pairs in \( X \times Y \) and \( Y \times X \) are completely different (e.g. \( (1, p) \in X \times Y \) but \( (1, p) \notin Y \times X \)). Hence \( X \times Y \ne Y \times X \).

Answer: \[ X \times Y = \{ (1, p),\ (1, q),\ (1, r),\ (2, p),\ (2, q),\ (2, r) \} \] \[ Y \times X = \{ (p, 1),\ (p, 2),\ (q, 1),\ (q, 2),\ (r, 1),\ (r, 2) \} \] No, the two Cartesian products are NOT equal, since \( X \times Y \ne Y \times X \). The first components and second components of the ordered pairs are interchanged, making the two sets entirely different.

Everything you get with Solver7

More questions in Relations and Functions