Detailed Explanation
A trigonometric identity is an equation involving trigonometric ratios that is true for all valid values of the angle. To prove an identity, we typically simplify one side (usually the more complex side) until it matches the other side. Here, we work with the Left Hand Side (LHS) and use the identity cosec²A = 1 + cot²A, which means cot²A - cosec²A = -1. This substitution is the key trick: whenever we see a '1' in the expression, we can replace it with cosec²A - cot²A. This allows us to factor and simplify the expression in terms of cosec A and cot A.
Formula Used
Key identity used: \( \cosec^2 A = 1 + \cot^2 A \), which gives us \( 1 = \cosec^2 A - \cot^2 A \).
Also recall: \( \cosec A = \frac{1}{\sin A} \) and \( \cot A = \frac{\cos A}{\sin A} \).
Factor identity: \( a^2 - b^2 = (a-b)(a+b) \).
Solution
- Step 1: Write the LHS: We start with the Left Hand Side (LHS): \[ \text{LHS} = \frac{\cos A - \sin A + 1}{\cos A + \sin A - 1} \]
Our goal is to show this equals \( \cosec A + \cot A \).
- Step 2: Divide numerator and denominator by sin A: Divide every term in the numerator and denominator by \( \sin A \) (valid since A is acute, so \( \sin A \ne 0 \)): \[ \text{LHS} = \frac{\frac{\cos A}{\sin A} - \frac{\sin A}{\sin A} + \frac{1}{\sin A}}{\frac{\cos A}{\sin A} + \frac{\sin A}{\sin A} - \frac{1}{\sin A}} \]
Using \( \frac{\cos A}{\sin A} = \cot A \) and \( \frac{1}{\sin A} = \cosec A \), this becomes: \[ = \frac{\cot A - 1 + \cosec A}{\cot A + 1 - \cosec A} \]
- Step 3: Replace 1 using the Pythagorean identity: Now we use the key substitution. Since \( \cosec^2 A = 1 + \cot^2 A \), we have \( 1 = \cosec^2 A - \cot^2 A \).
Replace the '1' in the numerator with \( \cosec^2 A - \cot^2 A \): \[ = \frac{\cot A + \cosec A - (\cosec^2 A - \cot^2 A)}{\cot A - \cosec A + 1} \]
Note: we write \( (\cosec^2 A - \cot^2 A) \) in place of 1 in the numerator.
- Step 4: Factor the numerator: Expand and factor the numerator. We have: \[ \text{Numerator} = \cot A + \cosec A - \cosec^2 A + \cot^2 A \]
Rearranging: \[ = (\cot A + \cosec A) - (\cosec^2 A - \cot^2 A) \]
Using the difference of squares \( a^2 - b^2 = (a-b)(a+b) \), we get \( \cosec^2 A - \cot^2 A = (\cosec A - \cot A)(\cosec A + \cot A) \).
So the numerator becomes: \[ (\cosec A + \cot A) - (\cosec A - \cot A)(\cosec A + \cot A) \]
Factor out \( (\cosec A + \cot A) \): \[ = (\cosec A + \cot A)\bigl[1 - (\cosec A - \cot A)\bigr] \]
Which equals: \[ = (\cosec A + \cot A)(1 - \cosec A + \cot A) \]
- Step 5: Simplify the full fraction: Now substitute back into the fraction. The denominator is \( \cot A - \cosec A + 1 = 1 - \cosec A + \cot A \).
So the expression becomes: \[ \frac{(\cosec A + \cot A)(1 - \cosec A + \cot A)}{(1 - \cosec A + \cot A)} \]
Cancel the common factor \( (1 - \cosec A + \cot A) \) from numerator and denominator (it is non-zero for acute angles): \[ = \cosec A + \cot A \]
- Step 6: Conclude the proof: We have shown that: \[ \text{LHS} = \cosec A + \cot A = \text{RHS} \]
Hence the identity is proved.
Final Answer
Starting from the LHS \( \frac{\cos A - \sin A + 1}{\cos A + \sin A - 1} \), dividing numerator and denominator by \( \sin A \) gives \( \frac{\cot A - 1 + \cosec A}{\cot A + 1 - \cosec A} \). Replacing 1 with \( \cosec^2 A - \cot^2 A \) in the numerator and factoring yields \( \frac{(\cosec A + \cot A)(1 - \cosec A + \cot A)}{1 - \cosec A + \cot A} = \cosec A + \cot A \) = RHS. Hence proved.
Common Mistake
A common mistake is forgetting to replace '1' in the numerator using the identity \( 1 = \cosec^2 A - \cot^2 A \). Many students try to manipulate the expression without this substitution and get stuck. The whole key to this proof is recognising that replacing 1 with \( \cosec^2 A - \cot^2 A \) allows the numerator to be factored nicely so that cancellation with the denominator becomes possible.