If \(\angle\) A and \(\angle\) B are acute angles such that cos A = cos B, then show that \(\angle\) A = \(\angle\) B.
CBSE Class 10 Maths · Introduction To Trignometry
CBSE Class 10 Maths · Introduction To Trignometry
Imagine two friends sharing the same ruler to measure their own pencils. If both pencils measure the same length compared to the ruler, the pencils are equal. In a right triangle, cosine compares a side to the longest side. When two angles have the same cosine, their nearby sides must be exactly the same length. A triangle with two equal sides also has two equal angles sitting at its base.
Answer: Since cos A = cos B implies AC = BC in the right triangle, the triangle is isosceles, and the base angles are equal. Therefore, ∠A = ∠B.
In a right triangle, the cosine of an acute angle is the ratio of the adjacent side to the hypotenuse. If two acute angles \( \angle A \) and \( \angle B \) have the same cosine value, it means their respective adjacent sides are equal (since the hypotenuse is shared). This makes the triangle isosceles, and in an isosceles triangle, the angles opposite to equal sides are equal — which proves \(\angle A = \angle B\).
For any acute angle \( \theta \) in a right triangle:
\[\cos \theta = \dfrac{\text{Adjacent Side}}{\text{Hypotenuse}}\]
Since \(\cos A = \cos B\) gives us \(AC = BC\) in triangle \( ABC \), the triangle is isosceles. Therefore, the angles opposite to these equal sides are equal, which proves that \(\angle A = \angle B\). ✓
Many students simply write "cosines are equal, so angles are equal" without giving a proper justification. Always use the definition of cosine and the isosceles triangle theorem to build a complete and valid proof.
Since cos A = cos B implies AC = BC in the right triangle, the triangle is isosceles, and the base angles are equal. Therefore, ∠A = ∠B.
One common mistake: Students sometimes assume that because \( \angle A \) and \( \angle B \) are both acute angles in a right triangle they must automatically be equal — but that is only true when their cosines (or equivalently their adjacent sides) are proven to be equal. Always derive \(AC = BC\) from the given condition before concluding \(\angle A = \angle B\).
Answer: Since cos A = cos B implies AC = BC in the right triangle, the triangle is isosceles, and the base angles are equal. Therefore, ∠A = ∠B.
Question: If \( \angle P \) and \( \angle Q \) are acute angles such that \( \sin P = \sin Q \), show that \( \angle P = \angle Q \).
Solution: Consider two right triangles: triangle \( ABC \) with the right angle at \( C \), where \( \angle A = P \); and triangle \( DEF \) with the right angle at \( F \), where \( \angle D = Q \).
By definition of sine: \[ \sin P = \frac{BC}{AB} \] and \[ \sin Q = \frac{EF}{DE} \]
Since \( \sin P = \sin Q \), we have: \[ \frac{BC}{AB} = \frac{EF}{DE} \]
Let this common ratio be \( k \), so \( BC = k \cdot AB \) and \( EF = k \cdot DE \).
Using the Pythagorean theorem in triangle \( ABC \): \[ AC = \sqrt{AB^2 - BC^2} = \sqrt{AB^2 - k^2 AB^2} = AB\sqrt{1 - k^2} \]
Using the Pythagorean theorem in triangle \( DEF \): \[ DF = \sqrt{DE^2 - EF^2} = \sqrt{DE^2 - k^2 DE^2} = DE\sqrt{1 - k^2} \]
Now compare the ratios of corresponding sides: \[ \frac{BC}{EF} = \frac{k \cdot AB}{k \cdot DE} = \frac{AB}{DE} \]
Also: \[ \frac{AC}{DF} = \frac{AB\sqrt{1-k^2}}{DE\sqrt{1-k^2}} = \frac{AB}{DE} \]
So all three ratios are equal: \[ \frac{AB}{DE} = \frac{BC}{EF} = \frac{AC}{DF} \]
By the SSS similarity criterion, triangle \( ABC \sim \) triangle \( DEF \).
Therefore, corresponding angles are equal, and in particular: \[ \angle A = \angle D \]
Hence \( \angle P = \angle Q \).
Answer: Since \( \sin P = \sin Q \) and both are acute, the two right triangles are similar by SSS, so \( \angle P = \angle Q \).
Question: If \( \angle X \) and \( \angle Y \) are acute angles such that \( \tan X = \tan Y \), show that \( \angle X = \angle Y \).
Solution: Consider two right triangles: triangle \( PQR \) with the right angle at \( R \), where \( \angle P = X \); and triangle \( LMN \) with the right angle at \( N \), where \( \angle L = Y \).
By definition of tangent: \[ \tan X = \frac{QR}{PR} \] and \[ \tan Y = \frac{MN}{LN} \]
Since \( \tan X = \tan Y \), we have: \[ \frac{QR}{PR} = \frac{MN}{LN} \]
Let this common ratio be \( m \), so \( QR = m \cdot PR \) and \( MN = m \cdot LN \).
Using the Pythagorean theorem in triangle \( PQR \): \[ PQ = \sqrt{PR^2 + QR^2} = \sqrt{PR^2 + m^2 PR^2} = PR\sqrt{1 + m^2} \]
Using the Pythagorean theorem in triangle \( LMN \): \[ LM = \sqrt{LN^2 + MN^2} = \sqrt{LN^2 + m^2 LN^2} = LN\sqrt{1 + m^2} \]
Now compare the ratios of all corresponding sides: \[ \frac{PR}{LN} = \frac{PR}{LN} \] \[ \frac{QR}{MN} = \frac{m \cdot PR}{m \cdot LN} = \frac{PR}{LN} \] \[ \frac{PQ}{LM} = \frac{PR\sqrt{1+m^2}}{LN\sqrt{1+m^2}} = \frac{PR}{LN} \]
All three ratios are equal: \[ \frac{PR}{LN} = \frac{QR}{MN} = \frac{PQ}{LM} \]
By the SSS similarity criterion, triangle \( PQR \sim \) triangle \( LMN \).
Therefore, corresponding angles are equal: \[ \angle P = \angle L \]
Hence \( \angle X = \angle Y \).
Answer: Since \( \tan X = \tan Y \) and both are acute, the two right triangles are similar by SSS, so \( \angle X = \angle Y \).
Question: If \( \angle A \) and \( \angle B \) are acute angles in a right triangle \( ABC \) right-angled at \( C \), such that \(\sin A = \sin B\), then show that \(\angle A = \angle B\).
Answer: Since \(\sin A = \sin B\) implies \(BC = AC\), triangle \( ABC \) is isosceles. The angles opposite equal sides are equal, therefore \(\angle A = \angle B\). Hence proved.