State whether the following are true or false. Justify your answer. The value of tan A is always less than 1.
CBSE Class 10 Maths · Introduction To Trignometry
CBSE Class 10 Maths · Introduction To Trignometry
Think of tan like a ramp. A gentle ramp has a small tan value, less than 1. But a steep ramp has a big tan value, greater than 1. The angle decides how steep the ramp is. At \ 60\(^\circ\), the ramp is very steep, and tan gives us \ \(\sqrt{3}\), which is about 1.732. So tan can be small, equal to 1, or even bigger than 1. It all depends on the angle we pick.
Answer: FALSE. The value of tan A is NOT always less than 1. For example, tan 60° = √3 > 1.
The statement says: "The value of tan A is always less than 1."
Let us think about what tan A actually means. In a right-angled triangle, for an acute angle A:
\[\tan A = \dfrac{\text{Opposite side}}{\text{Adjacent side}}\]
This ratio can be any positive value depending on the lengths of the sides. It can be less than 1, equal to 1, or greater than 1.
\[\tan A = \dfrac{\text{Opposite side}}{\text{Adjacent side}}\]
Key standard values to remember:
| Angle A | tan A | Value |
|---|---|---|
| \(30°\) | \(\dfrac{1}{\sqrt{3}}\) | ≈ 0.577 (less than 1) |
| \(45°\) | \(1\) | = 1 (equal to 1) |
| \(60°\) | \(\sqrt{3}\) | ≈ 1.732 (greater than 1) |
FALSE. The value of tan A is not always less than 1.
A counterexample: \(\tan 60° = \sqrt{3} \approx 1.732\), which is greater than 1.
In fact, for acute angles, \(\tan A < 1\) only when \(A < 45°\), and \(\tan A \geq 1\) when \(A \geq 45°\).
Many students confuse tan A with sin A or cos A. For acute angles, sin A and cos A always lie between 0 and 1. However, tan A has no such restriction — it can be greater than 1 for angles like 60°. Never assume the same range for tan A as for sin A or cos A.
FALSE. The value of tan A is NOT always less than 1. For example, tan 60° = √3 > 1.
One common mistake: Students often confuse sin A with tan A — since sin A is always between 0 and 1 for acute angles, they wrongly assume tan A must also stay below 1. Remember, tan A has no upper limit for acute angles approaching 90°.
Statement: "tan A is always less than 1" — check validity.
\[\tan A = \dfrac{\text{Opposite}}{\text{Adjacent}}\]
Counter-example: \(\tan 60° = \sqrt{3} \approx 1.732 > 1\)
\(\tan 30° < 1, \quad \tan 45° = 1, \quad \tan 60° > 1\)
Answer: FALSE. The value of tan A is NOT always less than 1. For example, tan 60° = √3 > 1.
Question: State whether the following is true or false and justify your answer: The value of tan A is always less than 1 for any acute angle A in a right triangle.
Solution:
Justification: The tangent ratio is the ratio of the opposite to the adjacent side. When the opposite side is longer than the adjacent side, \(\tan A > 1\). There is no upper bound on for acute angles — it increases as the angle approaches \(90°\).
Answer: FALSE — can be greater than 1 (e.g., \(\tan A = \dfrac{5}{3} > 1\)).
Question: State whether the following is true or false and justify your answer: tan A can never be greater than 1 for an acute angle A.
Solution:
Justification: \(\tan A = 1\) only when \(A = 45°\). For angles greater than \(45°\) (but less than \(90°\)), \(\tan A > 1\). For example, \(\tan 60° = \sqrt{3} > 1\).
Answer: FALSE — \(\tan A\) can be greater than 1 (e.g., \(\tan 60° = \sqrt{3} \approx 1.732\)).
Question: State whether the following is true or false. Justify your answer: The value of \( \sin A \) can be greater than 1 for some angle A in a right triangle.
Answer: FALSE. The value of \( \sin A \) can NEVER be greater than 1, because the opposite side is always less than or equal to the hypotenuse in a right-angled triangle. For all angles A, \( 0 \leq \sin A \leq 1 \).