In a parallelogram \(ABCD,\) \(E\) and \(F\) are the mid-points of sides \(AB\) and \(CD\) respectively (see Fig. 8.22). Show that the line segments \(AF\) and \(EC\) trisect the diagonal \(BD.\)
CBSE Class 9 Maths · Quadrilaterals
CBSE Class 9 Maths · Quadrilaterals
Imagine folding a rectangle into three equal parts. Here, a parallelogram is like a tilted rectangle. Two special lines are drawn inside it, cutting the long diagonal into pieces. Because of the way mid-points work, like splitting a chocolate bar evenly, each piece turns out identical. The two lines act like fair cutters, making sure no piece is bigger or smaller than another.
Answer: Since \(DP = PQ = QB\), the points \(P\) and \(Q\) divide the diagonal \(BD\) into three equal parts. Hence the line segments \(AF\) and \(EC\) trisect the diagonal \(BD\).
This question is based on two key ideas from the Quadrilaterals chapter: the properties of a parallelogram and the Mid-point Theorem. In a parallelogram, opposite sides are equal and parallel. So \(AB \parallel DC\) and \(AB = DC\). Since \(E\) and \(F\) are mid-points of \(AB\) and \(DC\), the segments \(AE\) and \(FC\) turn out to be equal and parallel, which makes \(AECF\) a parallelogram. This gives us two parallel lines \(AF\) and \(EC\). From the figure, \(AF\) meets the diagonal \(BD\) at \(P\) and \(EC\) meets \(BD\) at \(Q\). The converse of the Mid-point Theorem says that a line drawn through the mid-point of one side of a triangle, parallel to another side, bisects the third side. Applying this in two triangles formed by the diagonal, we prove that \(P\) and \(Q\) divide \(BD\) into three equal parts, that is, they trisect \(BD\).
Converse of the Mid-point Theorem: In a triangle, the line through the mid-point of one side and parallel to another side bisects the third side. Also, opposite sides of a parallelogram satisfy \( AB = DC \) and \( AB \parallel DC \).
Since \(DP = PQ = QB\), the points \(P\) and \(Q\) divide the diagonal \(BD\) into three equal parts. Hence the line segments \(AF\) and \(EC\) trisect the diagonal \(BD\).
A common mistake is to assume \(P\) and \(Q\) trisect \(BD\) just because there are two intersection points, without proving it. You must first prove that \(AECF\) is a parallelogram to get \(AF \parallel EC\), and then correctly apply the converse of the Mid-point Theorem in the right triangles. Choosing the wrong triangle or forgetting to justify the parallel lines leads to an incomplete proof.
Since \(DP = PQ = QB\), the points \(P\) and \(Q\) divide the diagonal \(BD\) into three equal parts. Hence the line segments \(AF\) and \(EC\) trisect the diagonal \(BD\).
One common mistake: Students sometimes forget to first establish that AEFD and EBCF are parallelograms before applying the Converse of the Mid-point Theorem. Without proving that AF is parallel to a side of the triangle (which comes from the parallelogram property), the theorem cannot be applied and the proof breaks down.
Answer: Since \(DP = PQ = QB\), the points \(P\) and \(Q\) divide the diagonal \(BD\) into three equal parts. Hence the line segments \(AF\) and \(EC\) trisect the diagonal \(BD\).
Question: In parallelogram PQRS, X and Y are the midpoints of sides PQ and RS respectively. Show that the line segments PY and XS trisect the diagonal QR.
Solution: Let the diagonal QR be intersected by XS at point M and by PY at point N, so that we need to show QM = MN = NR. Given: PQRS is a parallelogram with PQ ∥ SR and PQ = SR. X is the midpoint of PQ and Y is the midpoint of RS. Since X is the midpoint of PQ: \[XQ = \frac{1}{2}PQ\] Since Y is the midpoint of RS: \[RY = \frac{1}{2}RS\] Since PQRS is a parallelogram, PQ = SR and PQ ∥ SR. Therefore XQ = RY and XQ ∥ RY (since XQ is part of PQ and RY is part of SR, which are parallel). Thus XQRY is a parallelogram (one pair of opposite sides equal and parallel). In parallelogram XQRY, the diagonal QR and side XY are both present. Consider triangle QRM where M is the intersection of XS (extended through the parallelogram) and QR. Let us use a coordinate approach to confirm. Place P at the origin, Q at (2a, 0), R at (2a + 2b, 2c), and S at (2b, 2c) so that PQRS is a parallelogram. Then X, the midpoint of PQ, is at: \[X = \left(a,\ 0\right)\] Y, the midpoint of RS, is at: \[Y = \left(a + 2b,\ 2c\right)\] Diagonal QR goes from Q = (2a, 0) to R = (2a + 2b, 2c). A point on QR can be written as: \[\left(2a + 2bt,\ 2ct\right) \text{ for } t \in [0,1]\] Line XS: X = (a, 0) and S = (2b, 2c). The parametric form is: \[\left(a + (2b - a)\lambda,\ 2c\lambda\right)\] Setting equal to the point on QR: From the y-coordinate: \(2ct = 2c\lambda\) so \(t = \lambda\). From the x-coordinate: \[2a + 2bt = a + (2b - a)t\] Simplifying: \[2a + 2bt = a + 2bt - at\] \[2a = a - at\] \[a = -at\] \[t = -1\] This shows XS (not its extension) does not intersect QR inside the figure as I set it up. Let me use the standard parallelogram orientation: P = (0, 0), Q = (2a, 0), R = (2a + 2b, 2c), S = (2b, 2c) and instead use sides PQ and SR correctly. Actually, let us use a clean approach with the Midpoint Theorem directly. In parallelogram PQRS: PQ ∥ RS and PQ = RS. X is the midpoint of PQ, Y is the midpoint of RS. Therefore: XQ = YS = \[\frac{1}{2}PQ = \frac{1}{2}RS\] and XQ ∥ YS. So XQSY is a parallelogram... wait, we need to check which vertices align. Since PQ ∥ SR (not RS), let us re-label: in PQRS, sides are PQ, QR, RS, SP. PQ ∥ SR and PS ∥ QR. X is midpoint of PQ, Y is midpoint of SR. So XQ = YR = half of PQ = half of SR, and XQ ∥ YR. Hence XQRY is a parallelogram. Consider triangle QRS with the segment XM where M lies on QR (X is on PQ extended — actually X is on PQ, not on a side of triangle QRS). Let us instead consider triangles formed by the diagonal. Consider triangle QRS. The line from Y (midpoint of SR) parallel to QS meets QR at its midpoint — that is the Midpoint Theorem applied to triangle QRS. Instead, use the following argument (standard NCERT approach adapted): In triangle QMX (where M is the point where line from X meets QR), since XQ ∥ YR, by similar logic consider the trapezium. Final clean proof: Since PQRS is a parallelogram, PQ ∥ SR. X and Y are midpoints of PQ and SR respectively. Step 1: XY ∥ PQ ∥ SR and XY = PQ = SR (from midpoint properties in parallelogram — actually XY joins midpoints of the two parallel sides, so XQRY and PXYS are both parallelograms). Step 2: Consider diagonal QS of parallelogram PQRS (we now work with diagonal QS for this example — but the question says diagonal QR). Let us reconsider with diagonal PR. For clarity, let us restart with diagonal PR. Diagonal PR: goes from P to R. Line segment XS: X is midpoint of PQ, S is a vertex. Line segment QY: Q is a vertex, Y is midpoint of SR. In triangle PQR, X is the midpoint of PQ. The line through X parallel to QR meets PR at its midpoint, say M (Midpoint Theorem). But here we want to use XS. Let M be the intersection of XS with PR and N be the intersection of QY with PR. In triangle PSR, Y is the midpoint of SR. The line through Y parallel to PS meets PR at its midpoint N (Midpoint Theorem in triangle PSR with line YN ∥ PS). So N is the midpoint of PR, meaning PN = NR. In triangle PQR, X is the midpoint of PQ. The line through X parallel to PQ... let us use XS. Since PQRS is a parallelogram, QR ∥ PS. In triangle PQR, XM (where XM ∥ QR since XS direction... ). This is getting complex. Let us use coordinates cleanly. Place P = (0, 0), Q = (4, 0), R = (6, 4), S = (2, 4). This is a valid parallelogram (PQ ∥ SR, PS ∥ QR). X = midpoint of PQ = \[(2,\ 0)\] Y = midpoint of SR = midpoint of S(2,4) and R(6,4) = \[(4,\ 4)\] Diagonal QR: from Q(4, 0) to R(6, 4). Parametric form of QR: \[(4 + 2t,\ 4t),\ t \in [0, 1]\] Line XS: from X(2, 0) to S(2, 4) — this is the vertical line x = 2. This does not intersect QR (which goes from x=4 to x=6). So this example needs adjustment. Let us use a standard parallelogram: P=(0,0), Q=(6,0), R=(8,4), S=(2,4). Then PQ ∥ SR (both horizontal), PS ∥ QR. X = midpoint of PQ = (3, 0). Y = midpoint of SR = midpoint of (2,4) and (8,4) = (5, 4). Line XY connects (3,0) to (5,4): parametric form (3+2t, 4t). Diagonal QR from (6,0) to (8,4): parametric form (6+2t, 4t). The diagonals of PQRS are PR and QS. Diagonal QS: from Q(6,0) to S(2,4). Parametric: (6-4t, 4t), t in [0,1]. Intersection of XY with QS: 3+2t = 6-4u and 4t = 4u so t=u. Then 3+2t = 6-4t, so 6t=3, t=1/2. Point: (4, 2). This is the midpoint of QS — not a trisection point. Let me go back to the original problem's spirit: E and F are midpoints of AB and CD (opposite sides), and AF, EC trisect diagonal BD. Let me create an analogous but clearly different example. Example 1 restated cleanly: In parallelogram ABCD, P is the midpoint of AB and Q is the midpoint of CD. Prove that DP and BQ trisect the diagonal AC. Proof: Let ABCD be a parallelogram with AB ∥ DC and AB = DC. P is the midpoint of AB and Q is the midpoint of DC. Let DP meet AC at point X and BQ meet AC at point Y. We need to show AX = XY = YC, i.e., X and Y trisect AC. Since ABCD is a parallelogram: AB ∥ DC and AB = DC. Since P is the midpoint of AB: AP = PB = \[\frac{1}{2}AB\] Since Q is the midpoint of DC: DQ = QC = \[\frac{1}{2}DC\] So AP = DQ (both equal half of equal lengths) and AP ∥ DQ (since AB ∥ DC). Hence APQD is a parallelogram (AP ∥ DQ and AP = DQ). In triangle ACD: Q is the midpoint of DC. Line QX where X lies on AC — we use the fact that DX passes through X on AC. Consider triangle ACD. D is a vertex, C is a vertex, A is a vertex. Q is the midpoint of DC. The line from A through... let us think differently. In triangle DAC: D, A, C are vertices. X is the intersection of DP with AC. P is on AB (outside triangle DAC). Since APQD is a parallelogram, DP ∥ AQ... wait, AQ is not defined. Using vectors: Let position vector of A = vector a, B = vector b, C = vector c, D = vector d. Since ABCD is a parallelogram: d = a + (d - a), c = b + (d - a) = d + b - a. Let's set A as origin: A = 0, B = b, D = d, C = b + d. P = midpoint of AB = \[\frac{\vec{b}}{2}\] Q = midpoint of DC. D = d, C = b+d, so Q = \[\frac{d + (b+d)}{2} = \frac{b + 2d}{2}\] AC goes from A=0 to C=b+d: points on AC are of the form t(b+d) for t in [0,1]. Line DP: D=d, P=b/2. Parametric: d + s(b/2 - d) = d(1-s) + sb/2. Intersection with AC: t(b+d) = d(1-s) + sb/2. Comparing coefficients of b: t = s/2, so s = 2t. Comparing coefficients of d: t = 1-s = 1-2t, so 3t = 1, t = 1/3. So X divides AC such that AX = \[\frac{1}{3}AC\] Line BQ: B=b, Q=(b+2d)/2. Parametric: b + r((b+2d)/2 - b) = b + r(2d-b)/2 = b(1 - r/2) + rd. Intersection with AC: t(b+d) = b(1-r/2) + rd. Comparing coefficients of b: t = 1 - r/2. Comparing coefficients of d: t = r. So r = t and t = 1 - t/2, giving 3t/2 = 1, t = 2/3. So Y divides AC such that AY = \[\frac{2}{3}AC\] Therefore: \[AX = \frac{1}{3}AC,\quad XY = \frac{2}{3}AC - \frac{1}{3}AC = \frac{1}{3}AC,\quad YC = AC - \frac{2}{3}AC = \frac{1}{3}AC\] Hence AX = XY = YC, which means DP and BQ trisect diagonal AC.
Answer: DP and BQ trisect the diagonal AC, i.e., AX = XY = YC where X and Y are the intersections of DP and BQ with AC respectively. This follows because the intersection points divide AC at parameters t = 1/3 and t = 2/3 along AC.
Question: WXYZ is a parallelogram. M is the midpoint of WX and N is the midpoint of YZ. Show that WN and MY trisect the diagonal XZ.
Solution: Let WXYZ be a parallelogram with WX ∥ ZY and WX = ZY. M is the midpoint of WX, N is the midpoint of YZ. Let WN meet XZ at point P, and let MY meet XZ at point Q. We need to prove XP = PQ = QZ, i.e., P and Q trisect diagonal XZ. Set up position vectors with W as origin. Let W = 0 (origin), X = vector x, Z = vector z, Y = x + z (since WXYZ is a parallelogram, WX ∥ ZY and WZ ∥ XY). Note: In parallelogram WXYZ, vertices go in order, so WY = WX + WZ. Let us set: \[W = \vec{0},\ X = \vec{x},\ Y = \vec{x} + \vec{z},\ Z = \vec{z}\] M = midpoint of WX: \[M = \frac{\vec{x}}{2}\] N = midpoint of YZ. Y = x+z, Z = z, so: \[N = \frac{(\vec{x}+\vec{z})+\vec{z}}{2} = \frac{\vec{x} + 2\vec{z}}{2}\] Diagonal XZ: from X = x to Z = z. Points on XZ are: \[\vec{x} + t(\vec{z} - \vec{x}) = (1-t)\vec{x} + t\vec{z},\ t \in [0,1]\] When t = 0, we are at X; when t = 1, we are at Z. Finding P — intersection of WN with XZ: Line WN: from W = 0 to N = (x + 2z)/2. Parametric form: \[s \cdot \frac{\vec{x} + 2\vec{z}}{2},\ s \in \mathbb{R}\] Setting equal to a point on XZ: \[\frac{s}{2}\vec{x} + s\vec{z} = (1-t)\vec{x} + t\vec{z}\] Comparing coefficients of x and z (since x and z are independent as non-parallel, non-zero vectors): Coefficient of x: s/2 = 1 - t, so s = 2(1-t). Coefficient of z: s = t. Substituting s = t into s = 2(1-t): \[t = 2(1-t) = 2 - 2t\] \[3t = 2\] \[t = \frac{2}{3}\] So P lies at t = 2/3 along XZ from X, meaning: \[XP = \frac{2}{3}XZ\] Wait, this means WN meets XZ at 2/3 of the way from X to Z. Let us check MY. Finding Q — intersection of MY with XZ: Line MY: from M = x/2 to Y = x + z. Parametric form: \[\frac{\vec{x}}{2} + r\left((\vec{x}+\vec{z}) - \frac{\vec{x}}{2}\right) = \frac{\vec{x}}{2} + r\left(\frac{\vec{x}}{2}+\vec{z}\right)\] \[= \frac{\vec{x}}{2}\left(1+r\right) + r\vec{z}\] Setting equal to (1-t)x + tz: Coefficient of x: (1+r)/2 = 1-t. Coefficient of z: r = t. Substituting r = t: \[\frac{1+t}{2} = 1-t\] \[1+t = 2-2t\] \[3t = 1\] \[t = \frac{1}{3}\] So Q lies at t = 1/3 along XZ from X, meaning: \[XQ = \frac{1}{3}XZ\] Summary of positions along XZ (measured from X): Q is at t = 1/3 (from MY), P is at t = 2/3 (from WN). Therefore: \[XQ = \frac{1}{3}XZ\] \[QP = \frac{2}{3}XZ - \frac{1}{3}XZ = \frac{1}{3}XZ\] \[PZ = XZ - \frac{2}{3}XZ = \frac{1}{3}XZ\] Hence XQ = QP = PZ, which proves that MY and WN trisect diagonal XZ at points Q and P respectively.
Answer: MY meets XZ at Q with XQ = (1/3)XZ, and WN meets XZ at P with XP = (2/3)XZ, giving XQ = QP = PZ. Thus WN and MY trisect diagonal XZ.
Question: In a parallelogram \( PQRS \), \( M \) is the mid-point of side \( PQ \) and \( N \) is the mid-point of side \( RS \). The line segments \( PN \) and \( MR \) intersect the diagonal \( QS \) at points \( X \) and \( Y \) respectively. Prove that \( X \) and \( Y \) trisect the diagonal \( QS \), i.e., \( QX = XY = YS \).
Answer: Since \( QY = YX = XS \), the points \( Y \) and \( X \) divide the diagonal \( QS \) into three equal parts. Hence the line segments \( MR \) and \( PN \) trisect the diagonal \( QS \).