Example 1
Question: A student claims: 'Any quadrilateral whose opposite sides are equal must be a rectangle.' Is this claim correct? Justify your answer with an example.
Solution: Step 1: Recall the properties needed. A rectangle has (i) opposite sides equal and parallel, and (ii) all four angles equal to \( 90^\circ \). Having opposite sides equal alone is not enough to guarantee a rectangle. Step 2: Construct a counter-example. Consider a parallelogram PQRS where \( PQ = RS = 7 \) cm and \( QR = SP = 4 \) cm, but none of its angles is \( 90^\circ \). For instance, let \( \angle P = 60^\circ \). Then the angle sum gives: Since opposite angles of a parallelogram are equal and consecutive angles are supplementary: \[ \angle P = \angle R = 60^\circ \quad \text{and} \quad \angle Q = \angle S = 120^\circ \] Checking the angle sum: \[ 60^\circ + 120^\circ + 60^\circ + 120^\circ = 360^\circ \] This confirms it is a valid quadrilateral. Step 3: Verify opposite sides are equal. In PQRS, \( PQ = RS = 7 \) cm and \( QR = SP = 4 \) cm, so opposite sides are equal. Yet \( \angle P = 60^\circ \ne 90^\circ \), so PQRS is NOT a rectangle — it is just a parallelogram. Step 4: Conclude. The student's claim is incorrect. A quadrilateral with opposite sides equal is a parallelogram, but it need not be a rectangle unless all its angles are also \( 90^\circ \).
Answer: The claim is incorrect. A parallelogram with sides 7 cm and 4 cm and angles 60° and 120° has equal opposite sides but is not a rectangle, since its angles are not 90°.
Example 2
Question: Rahul says: 'I drew a quadrilateral ABCD in which \( AB \parallel CD \), \( AD \parallel BC \), \( AB = CD = 5 \) cm, and \( AD = BC = 3 \) cm. So ABCD must be a rectangle.' Is Rahul correct? What extra condition would make ABCD a rectangle?
Solution: Step 1: Identify what Rahul has described. A quadrilateral with both pairs of opposite sides parallel and equal is, by definition, a parallelogram. So ABCD is certainly a parallelogram. Step 2: Check whether every parallelogram is a rectangle. A parallelogram becomes a rectangle only if its angles are all \( 90^\circ \). In a general parallelogram, consecutive angles are supplementary: \[ \angle A + \angle B = 180^\circ \] This means \( \angle A \) can be any value between \( 0^\circ \) and \( 180^\circ \). For example, if \( \angle A = 70^\circ \), then \( \angle B = 110^\circ \), \( \angle C = 70^\circ \), \( \angle D = 110^\circ \), and the angle sum is: \[ 70^\circ + 110^\circ + 70^\circ + 110^\circ = 360^\circ \] All conditions Rahul stated are satisfied, yet no angle equals \( 90^\circ \), so ABCD is not a rectangle. Step 3: State the extra condition. For ABCD to be a rectangle, we additionally need \( \angle A = \angle B = \angle C = \angle D = 90^\circ \), i.e., at least one angle must be a right angle (since in a parallelogram, if one angle is \( 90^\circ \), all four automatically become \( 90^\circ \)). Step 4: Conclude. Rahul is incorrect. Having opposite sides parallel and equal makes ABCD a parallelogram, not necessarily a rectangle. The extra condition required is that one (and hence all) of its interior angles equals \( 90^\circ \).
Answer: Rahul is incorrect. ABCD is a parallelogram, not necessarily a rectangle. The extra condition needed is that at least one interior angle equals 90°, which would force all four angles to be 90°, making it a rectangle.