Detailed Explanation
To prove a trigonometric identity, we simplify one side (usually the more complex LHS) using known identities until it matches the other side (RHS). Here we use the Pythagorean identity \( \sin^2\theta + \cos^2\theta = 1 \), which can be rewritten as \( \sin^2\theta = 1 - \cos^2\theta \) or as \( \sec^2\theta - \tan^2\theta = 1 \). A useful trick is to multiply the numerator and denominator by a chosen expression so that the Pythagorean identity can be applied to simplify.
Formula Used
Key identities used: \( \sin^2\theta + \cos^2\theta = 1 \), \( \sec^2\theta - \tan^2\theta = 1 \), \( \sec\theta = \dfrac{1}{\cos\theta} \), \( \tan\theta = \dfrac{\sin\theta}{\cos\theta} \), and the algebraic identity \( (a+b)(a-b) = a^2 - b^2 \).
Solution
- Step 1: Start with the LHS: \[ \text{LHS} = \dfrac{\sin\theta - \cos\theta + 1}{\sin\theta + \cos\theta - 1} \] Divide the numerator and denominator by \( \cos\theta \) so that \( \tan\theta \) and \( \sec\theta \) appear.
- Step 2: After dividing every term by \( \cos\theta \): \[ \text{LHS} = \dfrac{\tan\theta - 1 + \sec\theta}{\tan\theta + 1 - \sec\theta} \] Rearranging the terms neatly: \[ \text{LHS} = \dfrac{(\tan\theta + \sec\theta) - 1}{(\tan\theta - \sec\theta) + 1} \]
- Step 3: Use the identity \( \sec^2\theta - \tan^2\theta = 1 \), which means \( 1 = (\sec\theta - \tan\theta)(\sec\theta + \tan\theta) \). Replace the \( 1 \) in the numerator: \[ (\tan\theta + \sec\theta) - (\sec\theta - \tan\theta)(\sec\theta + \tan\theta) \] Take \( (\tan\theta + \sec\theta) \) common: \[ = (\tan\theta + \sec\theta)\big[1 - (\sec\theta - \tan\theta)\big] \]
- Step 4: So the numerator becomes \( (\tan\theta + \sec\theta)(1 - \sec\theta + \tan\theta) \). Notice the denominator is \( (\tan\theta - \sec\theta) + 1 = 1 + \tan\theta - \sec\theta \), which is the same as \( 1 - \sec\theta + \tan\theta \). Therefore: \[ \text{LHS} = \dfrac{(\tan\theta + \sec\theta)(1 - \sec\theta + \tan\theta)}{1 - \sec\theta + \tan\theta} \]
- Step 5: Cancel the common factor \( (1 - \sec\theta + \tan\theta) \): \[ \text{LHS} = \sec\theta + \tan\theta \] Now rationalise by multiplying numerator and denominator by \( (\sec\theta - \tan\theta) \): \[ \sec\theta + \tan\theta = \dfrac{(\sec\theta + \tan\theta)(\sec\theta - \tan\theta)}{\sec\theta - \tan\theta} = \dfrac{\sec^2\theta - \tan^2\theta}{\sec\theta - \tan\theta} \]
- Step 6: Since \( \sec^2\theta - \tan^2\theta = 1 \): \[ \text{LHS} = \dfrac{1}{\sec\theta - \tan\theta} = \text{RHS} \] Hence proved.
Final Answer
\( \dfrac{\sin\theta - \cos\theta + 1}{\sin\theta + \cos\theta - 1} = \dfrac{1}{\sec\theta - \tan\theta} \) is proved.
Common Mistake
A common mistake is forgetting to replace \( 1 \) with \( \sec^2\theta - \tan^2\theta \) (which factors as \( (\sec\theta - \tan\theta)(\sec\theta + \tan\theta) \)). Without this substitution, the common factor between numerator and denominator cannot be seen, and students get stuck.