Detailed Explanation
When two objects move towards each other, their relative speed is the sum of their individual speeds. When they move in the same direction, the relative speed is the difference of their speeds (faster minus slower). Using distance = speed \(\times\) time, we can form two linear equations in two unknowns (the two speeds) and solve them simultaneously.
Formula Used
\[ \text{Distance} = \text{Speed} \times \text{Time} \] Relative speed (opposite directions, moving towards each other) = sum of speeds. Relative speed (same direction) = difference of speeds.
Solution
- Step 1: Let Hamid's speed be \(x\) km/h and Joseph's speed be \(y\) km/h. Assume \(x > y\) so that Hamid can catch Joseph in the second case.
- Step 2: Case 1: They start from A and B (30 km apart) and move towards each other. They meet after 20 minutes, i.e. \( \dfrac{20}{60} = \dfrac{1}{3} \) hour. Since they move towards each other, relative speed = \(x + y\). Distance covered together = 30 km. So, \[ (x + y) \times \dfrac{1}{3} = 30 \] which gives \[ x + y = 90 \]
- Step 3: Case 2: Joseph starts from B but moves in the opposite direction (away from A). Hamid also starts from A towards B (same direction as Joseph now). So Hamid chases Joseph. Relative speed = \(x - y\). Initial gap between them = 30 km. Hamid catches Joseph after 3 hours, so \[ (x - y) \times 3 = 30 \] which gives \[ x - y = 10 \]
- Step 4: Solve the two equations: \[ x + y = 90 \] \[ x - y = 10 \] Adding: \[ 2x = 100 \Rightarrow x = 50 \] Substituting in \(x + y = 90\): \[ 50 + y = 90 \Rightarrow y = 40 \]
- Step 5: So Hamid's speed \(= 50\) km/h and Joseph's speed \(= 40\) km/h. Verification: In 1/3 hour they together cover \( (50+40)\times \dfrac{1}{3} = 30 \) km. In 3 hours the gap closes by \( (50-40)\times 3 = 30 \) km. Both conditions match.
Final Answer
Hamid's speed = 50 km/h and Joseph's speed = 40 km/h.
Common Mistake
A common mistake is to forget to convert 20 minutes into hours (using 20 directly instead of \( \dfrac{1}{3} \) hour), which gives a wrong equation. Also, students sometimes add the speeds in the second case too, forgetting that when they move in the same direction the relative speed is the difference \(x - y\), not the sum.