SOLVER7 Study. Nothing Else.
Problem Set 4B Q7

Market value of shares and dividend declared by the two companies is given below. Face Value is same and it is ₹\(100\) for both the shares. Investment in which company is more profitable\(?\)
(i) Company \(A -\) ₹\(132 ,\ 12\%\) (ii) Company \(B -\) ₹ \(144,\ 16\%\)

MAH STATE BOARD Mah SB Class 10 Maths · Financial Planning

Solution

👶 Simple Explanation

Simple Explanation

Imagine two shops selling magical money-trees. Both trees grow the same sized fruit, worth 100 rupees each. Company A's tree costs 132 rupees and gives back 12 rupees every year. Company B's tree costs 144 rupees but gives back 16 rupees every year. The real question is: which tree gives more money back compared to what you paid? Company B gives back a bigger share of what you spent. So even though it costs more, it is the smarter buy.

Answer: Investment in Company B is more profitable, as it gives a higher rate of return (approximately \( 11.11\% \)) compared to Company A (approximately \( 9.09\% \)).

📖 Comparing Profitability of Two Company Shares

Detailed Explanation

When we buy a share, we pay its market value (MV), but the dividend is always calculated on the face value (FV). To decide which investment is more profitable, we cannot simply compare the dividend percentages, because those percentages are on the face value, not on what we actually spent. Instead, we calculate the rate of return (also called yield), which tells us how much income we earn for every rupee invested. The company giving a higher rate of return is the more profitable investment.

Formula Used

\[ \text{Dividend} = \frac{\text{Rate of dividend} \times \text{Face Value}}{100} \] \[ \text{Rate of Return} = \frac{\text{Dividend}}{\text{Market Value}} \times 100\% \]

Solution

  1. Step 1: Write down the given information. Face Value (FV) = \( \rupee 100 \) for both companies. Company A: Market Value = \( \rupee 132 \), Dividend rate = \( 12\% \). Company B: Market Value = \( \rupee 144 \), Dividend rate = \( 16\% \).
  2. Step 2: Calculate the dividend on one share of Company A. Dividend is calculated on face value: \[ \text{Dividend}_A = \frac{12 \times 100}{100} = \rupee 12 \] So an investor gets \( \rupee 12 \) per share of Company A.
  3. Step 3: Find the rate of return for Company A. The investor actually spent \( \rupee 132 \) (market value) to earn \( \rupee 12 \): \[ \text{Rate of Return}_A = \frac{12}{132} \times 100 = \frac{1200}{132} \approx 9.09\% \]
  4. Step 4: Calculate the dividend on one share of Company B: \[ \text{Dividend}_B = \frac{16 \times 100}{100} = \rupee 16 \] So an investor gets \( \rupee 16 \) per share of Company B.
  5. Step 5: Find the rate of return for Company B. The investor spent \( \rupee 144 \) to earn \( \rupee 16 \): \[ \text{Rate of Return}_B = \frac{16}{144} \times 100 = \frac{1600}{144} \approx 11.11\% \]
  6. Step 6: Compare the two rates of return. Company A gives about \( 9.09\% \) while Company B gives about \( 11.11\% \). Since \( 11.11\% > 9.09\% \), Company B gives a higher return per rupee invested.

Final Answer

Investment in Company B is more profitable, as it gives a higher rate of return (approximately \( 11.11\% \)) compared to Company A (approximately \( 9.09\% \)).

Common Mistake

A common mistake is to directly compare the dividend rates (12% vs 16%) and conclude Company B is better without checking. Although B is indeed better here, this reasoning is wrong because dividend rates are based on face value, not on the actual market price paid. Always compute the rate of return using the market value to make a fair comparison.

🪜 Step-by-step Solution

Step-by-step Solution

  1. Step 1: List all the given data clearly. Both companies have a Face Value (FV) of \( \rupee 100 \). Company A: Market Value \( = \rupee 132 \), Dividend Rate \( = 12\% \). Company B: Market Value \( = \rupee 144 \), Dividend Rate \( = 16\% \). — Reason: Organising the given information first prevents confusion and makes the calculations easier to follow.
  2. Step 2: Calculate the annual dividend earned from one share of Company A. Dividend is always computed on the face value, not the market value: \[ \text{Dividend}_A = \frac{12 \times 100}{100} = \rupee 12 \] — Reason: Even though you buy the share at \( \rupee 132 \), the company declares dividends as a percentage of the face value \( \rupee 100 \), so we use FV here.
  3. Step 3: Find the rate of return for Company A. You spend \( \rupee 132 \) (market value) to earn \( \rupee 12 \) (dividend): \[ \text{Rate of Return}_A = \frac{12}{132} \times 100 \] Simplifying: \[ \text{Rate of Return}_A = \frac{1200}{132} \approx 9.09\% \] — Reason: The rate of return tells us how much income we actually earn per \( \rupee 100 \) invested, making different investments directly comparable.
  4. Step 4: Calculate the annual dividend earned from one share of Company B. Again, dividend is based on the face value of \( \rupee 100 \): \[ \text{Dividend}_B = \frac{16 \times 100}{100} = \rupee 16 \] — Reason: The dividend rate of \( 16\% \) applies to the face value \( \rupee 100 \), giving us \( \rupee 16 \) income per share of Company B.
  5. Step 5: Find the rate of return for Company B. You spend \( \rupee 144 \) (market value) to earn \( \rupee 16 \) (dividend): \[ \text{Rate of Return}_B = \frac{16}{144} \times 100 \] Simplifying: \[ \text{Rate of Return}_B = \frac{1600}{144} \approx 11.11\% \] — Reason: Just as in Step 3, we divide the actual income by the actual amount spent and multiply by 100 to get a comparable percentage.
  6. Step 6: Compare the two rates of return side by side. Rate of Return for Company A \( \approx 9.09\% \). Rate of Return for Company B \( \approx 11.11\% \). Since \( 11.11\% > 9.09\% \), Company B offers a higher yield. — Reason: A higher rate of return means you earn more income for every rupee you invest, so Company B is the better investment despite its higher market price.

Final Answer

Investment in Company B is more profitable, as it gives a higher rate of return (approximately \( 11.11\% \)) compared to Company A (approximately \( 9.09\% \)).

Common Mistake

One common mistake: Students often compare only the dividend rates (12% vs 16%) and conclude Company B is better without checking whether the higher market price reduces the actual return — always calculate the rate of return using the market value, not just the dividend percentage on face value.

✍️ Exam-ready Answer

Exam-ready Answer

  1. Step 1: Given: FV = \( \rupee 100 \) for both. Company A: MV = \( \rupee 132 \), Dividend rate = \( 12\% \). Company B: MV = \( \rupee 144 \), Dividend rate = \( 16\% \).
  2. Step 2: Dividend per share — Company A: \[ \text{Dividend}_A = \frac{12 \times 100}{100} = \rupee 12 \] Company B: \[ \text{Dividend}_B = \frac{16 \times 100}{100} = \rupee 16 \]
  3. Step 3: Rate of return — Company A: \[ \text{Rate}_A = \frac{12}{132} \times 100 \approx 9.09\% \] Company B: \[ \text{Rate}_B = \frac{16}{144} \times 100 \approx 11.11\% \]

Answer: Investment in Company B is more profitable, as it gives a higher rate of return (approximately \( 11.11\% \)) compared to Company A (approximately \( 9.09\% \)).

➕ More Examples

More Examples

Example 1

Question: The market value of shares and dividend declared by two companies are given below. The face value of each share is ₹100 for both companies. In which company is the investment more profitable? (i) Company P — Market Value ₹120, Dividend 15% (ii) Company Q — Market Value ₹175, Dividend 24%

Solution: The face value of each share for both companies is ₹100. \nFor Company P:\nDividend per share \[ = \frac{15}{100} \times 100 = ₹15 \]\nReturn on Investment for Company P \[ = \frac{15}{120} \times 100 = 12.5\% \] \nFor Company Q:\nDividend per share \[ = \frac{24}{100} \times 100 = ₹24 \]\nReturn on Investment for Company Q \[ = \frac{24}{175} \times 100 \approx 13.71\% \] \nSince \( 13.71\% > 12.5\% \), Company Q gives a higher return on investment.

Answer: Investment in Company Q is more profitable.

Example 2

Question: Ramesh wants to invest in shares. He has two options. Both shares have a face value of ₹100. Which investment gives better returns? (i) Company X — Market Value ₹150, Dividend 18% (ii) Company Y — Market Value ₹110, Dividend 11%

Solution: The face value of each share for both companies is ₹100. \nFor Company X:\nDividend per share \[ = \frac{18}{100} \times 100 = ₹18 \]\nReturn on Investment for Company X \[ = \frac{18}{150} \times 100 = 12\% \] \nFor Company Y:\nDividend per share \[ = \frac{11}{100} \times 100 = ₹11 \]\nReturn on Investment for Company Y \[ = \frac{11}{110} \times 100 = 10\% \] \nSince \( 12\% > 10\% \), Company X gives a higher return on investment.

Answer: Investment in Company X is more profitable.

🎯 Try a Similar Question

Try a Similar Question

Question: The market value and dividend declared by two companies are given below. The face value of shares of both companies is ₹100. In which company is the investment more profitable? (i) Company P — Market Price: ₹120, Dividend: 15% (ii) Company Q — Market Price: ₹175, Dividend: 24%

Solution

  1. Step 1: Find the dividend per share for each company: Since the face value is ₹100 for both companies: \nDividend per share for Company P: \( 15\% \times 100 = \text{₹}15 \) \nDividend per share for Company Q: \( 24\% \times 100 = \text{₹}24 \)
  2. Step 2: Calculate the rate of return for Company P: The market price of Company P is ₹120 and the dividend earned is ₹15. Rate of return for Company P: \[ \frac{15}{120} \times 100 = 12.5\% \]
  3. Step 3: Calculate the rate of return for Company Q: The market price of Company Q is ₹175 and the dividend earned is ₹24. Rate of return for Company Q: \[ \frac{24}{175} \times 100 \approx 13.71\% \]
  4. Step 4: Compare the two rates of return: Rate of return of Company P \( = 12.5\% \) \nRate of return of Company Q \( \approx 13.71\% \) \nSince \( 13.71\% > 12.5\% \), investment in Company Q is more profitable.

Answer: Investment in Company P is more profitable — wait, comparing correctly: Company Q gives approximately \( 13.71\% \) return while Company P gives \( 12.5\% \). Therefore, investment in Company Q is more profitable.

Everything you get with Solver7

More questions in Financial Planning

Chapter 4 Examples Q1 Practice Set 4.1 Q1 Practice Set 4.2 Q1 Practice Set 4.3 Q1 Practice Set 4.4 Q1 Problem Set 4A Q1 (i) Problem Set 4B Q1 (i) 04/2019 2019 / Question 3 QA (i) N362 2020 / Question 1 QA (i) N384 2024 / Question 3 QA (i) N384 2026 / Question 3 QA (i) N819 2025 / Question 3 QA (i) N919 2026 / Question 1 QA (i) N919 2026 / Question 3 QA (i) Chapter 4 Examples Q2 Practice Set 4.1 Q2 Practice Set 4.2 Q2 Practice Set 4.3 Q2 Practice Set 4.4 Q2 Problem Set 4A Q1 (ii) Problem Set 4B Q1 (ii) N362 2020 / Question 3 QA (ii) N384 2026 / Question 2 QA (ii) N619 2024 / Question 3 QA (ii) N684 2025 / Question 2 QA (ii) N919 2026 / Question 4 Q2 (i) Chapter 4 Examples Q3 Practice Set 4.1 Q3 Practice Set 4.2 Q3 Practice Set 4.3 Q3 Practice Set 4.4 Q3 Problem Set 4A Q1 (iii) Problem Set 4B Q1 (iii) 04/2019 2019 / Question 4 Q3 N384 2024 / Question 2 QA (iii) N384 2026 / Question 1 QA (iii) N819 2025 / Question 2 QA (iii) N913 2023 / Question 2 QA (iii) N919 2026 / Question 4 Q2 (ii) Practice Set 4.1 Q4 Chapter 4 Examples Q4 (i) Practice Set 4.2 Q4 Practice Set 4.3 Q4 Practice Set 4.4 Q4 Problem Set 4A Q1 (iv) Problem Set 4B Q1 (iv) 04/2019 2019 / Question 2 QA (iii) N619 2024 / Question 1 QA (iv) N684 2025 / Question 3 QB (ii) N919 2026 / Question 4 Q2 (iii) Practice Set 4.1 Q5 Chapter 4 Examples Q4 (ii) Practice Set 4.2 Q5 Practice Set 4.3 Q5 Practice Set 4.4 Q5 Problem Set 4A Q1 (v) Problem Set 4B Q1 (v) N619 2024 / Question 3 QB(iii)i N919 2026 / Question 1 QB (i) N919 2026 / Question 4 Q2 (iv)