Detailed Explanation
When we buy a share, we pay its market value (MV), but the dividend is always calculated on the face value (FV). To decide which investment is more profitable, we cannot simply compare the dividend percentages, because those percentages are on the face value, not on what we actually spent. Instead, we calculate the rate of return (also called yield), which tells us how much income we earn for every rupee invested. The company giving a higher rate of return is the more profitable investment.
Formula Used
\[ \text{Dividend} = \frac{\text{Rate of dividend} \times \text{Face Value}}{100} \] \[ \text{Rate of Return} = \frac{\text{Dividend}}{\text{Market Value}} \times 100\% \]
Solution
- Step 1: Write down the given information. Face Value (FV) = \( \rupee 100 \) for both companies. Company A: Market Value = \( \rupee 132 \), Dividend rate = \( 12\% \). Company B: Market Value = \( \rupee 144 \), Dividend rate = \( 16\% \).
- Step 2: Calculate the dividend on one share of Company A. Dividend is calculated on face value: \[ \text{Dividend}_A = \frac{12 \times 100}{100} = \rupee 12 \] So an investor gets \( \rupee 12 \) per share of Company A.
- Step 3: Find the rate of return for Company A. The investor actually spent \( \rupee 132 \) (market value) to earn \( \rupee 12 \): \[ \text{Rate of Return}_A = \frac{12}{132} \times 100 = \frac{1200}{132} \approx 9.09\% \]
- Step 4: Calculate the dividend on one share of Company B: \[ \text{Dividend}_B = \frac{16 \times 100}{100} = \rupee 16 \] So an investor gets \( \rupee 16 \) per share of Company B.
- Step 5: Find the rate of return for Company B. The investor spent \( \rupee 144 \) to earn \( \rupee 16 \): \[ \text{Rate of Return}_B = \frac{16}{144} \times 100 = \frac{1600}{144} \approx 11.11\% \]
- Step 6: Compare the two rates of return. Company A gives about \( 9.09\% \) while Company B gives about \( 11.11\% \). Since \( 11.11\% > 9.09\% \), Company B gives a higher return per rupee invested.
Final Answer
Investment in Company B is more profitable, as it gives a higher rate of return (approximately \( 11.11\% \)) compared to Company A (approximately \( 9.09\% \)).
Common Mistake
A common mistake is to directly compare the dividend rates (12% vs 16%) and conclude Company B is better without checking. Although B is indeed better here, this reasoning is wrong because dividend rates are based on face value, not on the actual market price paid. Always compute the rate of return using the market value to make a fair comparison.